On the way home from a recent trip to the Cincinnati area, we stopped at Handel's for a sweet…read moretreat. We used to have a location closer to us in Pittsburgh, and we very much miss it, so we make sure to stop anytime we are on a trip and come near one! This specific Handel's Ice Cream location is on Feder Road, just down from the Feder and Hilliard Rome intersection. It is close to the business district on Hilliard Rome, but just far enough off that it is not too loud or busy. The building sits by itself, and can be accessed via Hartford Village Boulevard, or an unnamed road to the right of the store. There is a large sign that sits near Feder Road, so you will know exactly where to go. Since the building sits by itself, there is dedicated parking on both the right side and in the rear. I can see potentially at peak times this being full, but there are other parking lots adjacent to Handel's that potentially could be utilized. Some Handel's locations have an inside, but like most in Ohio, this location is completely outdoors. So, to place your order you simply walk up to the windows, and can then enjoy their bench seating or take your items to-go. When you approach the windows, you will see all of the signage, menu items, and flavors. The overall ambiance here is nice. There is a lot of bench seating and grass area to socialize and enjoy your ice cream at. There is also a fence at the front of the property to prevent anyone getting too close to Feder Road. The building itself is a classic, older Handel's design, that is very recognizable if you are familiar with the brand. They have a very nice, bright mural painted on the right side of the building that brings a lot to the space. Our visit was on a Sunday evening in September, around 6:30 PM. It was not too busy, as it was lightly raining when we stopped. We briefly waited for the few groups ahead of us to order, but then got waited on less than 5 minutes after arriving (including the time we took to look at the menu). The menu had a lot of different flavors to choose from. There were some fall options being that is was mid-to-late September, including Pumpkin flavors! Like all locations, they had cones, cups, milkshakes, sundaes, novelty items, cakes, pies, and much more. My typical order at Handel's is a 4 Scoop Sampler. This is a takeout-like container with four singular scoops of up to four different flavors. It is a great way to try several different kinds of ice cream, or simply when you cannot decide what you want to have. It is a good size if you are wanting a large sweet treat, or to split with someone else. You are able to get anything that is scooped in the 4 Scoop, which includes the sherbets, ices, and other non-traditional flavors. We were not super hungry when we stopped, so my mom, sister, and I shared the 4 Scoop Sampler. For the flavors, we chose Confetti Brownie Batter, Frosted Animal Cookie, Knot Your Average Dough, and Blueberry Cobbler. I had never tried the Knot Your Average Dough before, so I was excited to taste it. The Confetti Brownie Batter and Frosted Animal Cookie were new to my mom and sister, and then the Blueberry Cobbler is a personal favorite for my sister. I really enjoyed Knot Your Average Dough! It is a Cookie Dough-flavored ice cream with a Salted Pretzel Ripple and Cookie Dough Pieces. The ripple was my favorite part, and I would definitely order it again. I am not a huge fan personally of Confetti Brownie Batter (nothing wrong with this one, I just believe there are much better flavors Handel's makes) and Frosted Animal Cookie (in my opinion, does not taste like Frosted Animal Cookies except for the actual cookie inclusions), but both were made well. Blueberry Cobbler had a ton of Blueberry Ripple, and was great. No complaints about the quality or taste of the ice creams! We all enjoyed getting to try some new-to-us flavors. Since it was raining, and were were trying to get back to Pittsburgh, we took our ice cream to-go. Though, I would love to come back and enjoy the outdoor area on another visit. Pricing here was fair. A small scoop will run about $5 after tax. Our 4 Scoop Sampler was around $7 after tax. Most single-serve items are less than $10, so very normal as far as ice cream is concerned. Considering they make all of the ice creams in-house and with high-quality ingredients, I definitely believe the value is there. All of the staff we interacted with were friendly and helpful. As stated, our service was very prompt and quick. I have no complaints about anything relating to the staff or the overall customer service here. Had a great visit to this Handel's location! Service was excellent, the ice cream was all very well-made, the location is clean, and the overall atmosphere is great. Glad that I got to have some delicious ice cream, and check out a different Handel's location. I highly recommend stopping at Handel's if you have never been, or are simply in the mood for some incredible ice cream!

Personally I think the best ice cream place around! Great service with a friendly staff.read more

I really liked my ice cream flavor which was coffee with some chocolate like pieces. It was…read moredelicious. Service was quick except the cash register broke down and there was a line of people who were waiting to pay. There is some outside seating but it is rather limited inside. There were some funky flavors. Very ice cream parlor like atmosphere.

The woman helping us was knowledgeable and patient with us since it was our first time. My husband…read morewanted a super thick shake that's almost like blizzard, and she was able to make it for him. Everything was delicious! We will definitely be back some time

Nice people, decent food, delicious ice cream, as of 2025 open year round! I enjoyed my grill…read morecheese and ham on a ciabatta roll. Everything was fresh and they wrapped the giant sandwich in two halves. Nice touch.

Nice treat today in this hot Ohio heat. Grand daughter had Rainbow Sherbert with a chocolate…read moresprinkle cone. The cone looked yummy, the ice cream was a very hefty scoop. She loved it. We also took a cute pic outside.

Upon entering this hidden gem, I felt a rush of excitement like a kid in an ice cream shop! The…read morewalls are painted vibrant, bright colors giving off a cool atmospheric vibe! Each time I have visited it is always super clean, even the bathrooms! The selections are plentiful; something for everyone! The food and ice cream that I have tried are all delicious, however, my funnel cake was a little too well done, yet kind of tasted like it was pre made, waiting for someone to order, and then heated up, yet still edible! The elotes was not what I expected, having only tried Mexican Street Corn from Local Cantina. Unfortunately, I did not care for the Elotes, that is just my taste buds, however, it was beautiful to look at for sure! This dive is a hidden gem in my eyes and my family will definitely frequent this location!

An ice cream place that you can't get a sample is a turnoff. Won't go back. Any high quality…read moreplace with good service allows a sample!! Take graders for example!!!!!

Finally made it to Double Happy! Everytime I have decided I wanted to go they seemed to be closed…read more This little walk-up ice cream shop had a line of people when we went. They offer a variety of milkshakes. The best part is they offer dairy-free shake options at no extra cost! I got the peanut butter cup dairy-free. It was really tasty. The gentleman behind the window asked for feedback as they are trying a new vendor. I told him it was creamy and had a ton of flavor. I could barely taste that it was dairy-free. They also offer a few food items and sundaes. The brownie sundae is mind blowing. The brownie was mouthwatering. It comes in a large sundae bowl that is easily shareable if you're feeling generous. This is a nice spot to visit on a summer day. We will definitely go back and try some other things out.

Super friendly service…read more Good ice cream and a cute spot to bring the kids! Would be awesome if the sitting area was a little more put together there's only just a picnic table and a gazebo with no seats Good selection of ice cream goodies and milkshakes and prices are great

We had Sweet Tooth Ice Cream visit us for a corporate event, and everyone enjoyed the ice cream…read more The staff was friendly, and there were multiple unique flavor options. If you look them up online, you can find a list of their upcoming events. You can also book them for your own events! I enjoyed their non-dairy option, but they had wonderful dairy options as well.

After a long day in the sun, a scoop of ice cream sounded refreshing. This food truck has a small…read morebut flavor packed menu. I was in the mood for a light fruity flavor, so I chose strawberry. For food truck prices, I gotta say, I think the value is pretty good for what you get! I was very pleased with my ice cream. I got a hefty amount and it was thick and delicious! I like that there's a Hispanic twist with some of the menu items, such as one item having tajin sprinkled on top. The woman taking orders was super nice and helped me out with which flavor to get. I would absolutely order from this truck again!

This location keeps their ice cream frozen enough to not be running down your cone from melting…read moreright away and they receive daily deliveries from Krispy Kreme so the donuts are always fresh with a great range of flavor options on both ice cream and donuts. They keep their store well stocked with pretty much all items and most employees there are very friendly and helpful. They stick to the "No I.D. No tobacco or alcohol sales" rule tho with NO EXCEPTIONS so even if your 70+ years old, bring your I.D. or they will NOT sell these items to you! They keep the store very clean as well.

I was just in there about 2030 minutes ago a guy stole 2 packs of soda and thought he was just…read moregoing to casually, walk out well dim women that women that were working there. Man, they are f****** awesome date. They went after that dude and showed him that he's not gonna just walk all over them. And I am so proud to see that and then I chased the guy around for like. Probably 30 minutes trying to catch him, but he went into 488 South Hague Avenue.And traded the soda for some drugs.Cause I caught him in the back alley.But then when I got out of the car he took off running, they whoever owns that f****** united dairy farmers needs to give them girls a raised.They're fucking awesome

Hands down the best ice cream in Columbus. The out of the box flavors are out of this world and…read morestaff is so friendly! The piffle is an absolute must especially if it is your first time. Honestly the ice cream is so fantastic that the toppings aren't even needed (but why not go crazy right!!!) Love it so much we always have to take a couple pints to go when we make a trip. Highly recommend the coffee flavor, biscoff cookie (try it mixed with coffee!) or if your really up for having your taste buds go wild go for the fruity pebbles flavor (thank me later!).

Honestly was kind of throne off with how empty this location was, no tables or chairs but a lot of…read moreopen space. I got the matcha ice cream in a waffle cone and it was a really subtle matcha taste, but perfectly balanced. I'd definitely try more flavors!

I got the lavender ice cream and the blueberry cornmeal ice creams. They went together really well…read moreand were so tasty!

Cute little candy store on the corner of some shops in downtown Grove City. It has unique soda…read moreflavors, icecream, homemade candy & some random knicknacks inside for purchase. There was one worker inside, but it never seems to be busy when I drive by so there was no issue with service.

3.5 stars Shakes are…read moreawesome, presentation was great, and staff was friendly and helpful. This place needs a super deep clean. I added a few photos but it doesn't do it justice how dirty it is in the business and bathrooms. The stickiness on my shoes was disturbing. Expect a bit of a wait if there's a line, decor is a bit cheap, but again, shakes were wonderful! You also get to keep the yard cup and there's a cleaning area so that was cool.

Classic Oreo milkshake. The shake was good but the service wasn't the greatest. There was no line…read moreas I was the only customer in the store but I had a long wait. Also, the two associates working that day weren't very friendly. I would try The Yard again but not this location.