One of my favorite places for a treat. Diamonds has an array of handcrafted Mexican ice creams. Traditional flavors like piñon, mamey, or rompompe are always available, but they also have super yummy flavors they rotate in line leche quemada (burnt milk) or fruit-forward sorbets. Don't forget their Aguas Frescas. My favorite is their Jamaica, but their Horchata is top-notch too. They also have a variety of Vaso de Frutas at their second counter where you can get mango slices topped with lime juice, chamoy, and Tajiín. This is my favorite menu item of all! If you're with some friends and feeling crazy, get a Sandía Loca to share (practice safe COVID protocols of course) If you're not sure where to start, grab a paleta (Mexican popsicle) or chocolate covered banana. In the last few years, they've added tons of Mexican candies, snacks, and trinkets which are fun. The workers are always super nice and happy to give you a sample. Definitely check out this place and support them! read more

Great Mexican ice cream! The blackberry cream cheese and queso ice cream is a must try and one of my favorites! Don't forget to get a selfie with Frida Kahlo real size mannequin! They also have a big variety of delicious Mexican snacks! read more

See all

So colorful inside. Grabbed a mango, strawberry, kiwi popsicle and one scoop of the ferrero rocher ice cream. $8.50 The mango, fresa, kiwi popsicle is yummy. The scoop of the ferrero rocher ice cream is pretty good, but not as good or memorable as the popsicle. Could have more bits of the ferrero rocher to make it berry for me. Their ice cream is home made here. read more

See all

Cute little ice cream shop featuring homemade ice cream and a variety of paletas. I had the ferrero rocher flavored ice cream and it was so creamy. Plus I got a very generous serving for a great price. Everyone there is so kind and they also have different snacks and little trinkets available as well. read more

Unique treat & ice cream store! Very friendly staff and so many flavors to choose from. I brought my after school care group here and the kids loved it! We highly recommend this ice cream store if you want to try something different than our "norm" ice cream stores around town read more

The ice cream was delicious here. The hazelnut scoop was a great mix with a scoop of the dark chocolate. The mangonada was great too! It had actual mango bits and tasted great with the tamarind and tajin seasoning. The interior of the shop could use some updating. It wasn't that great of a space inside and seemed congested without other customers there. The service was fast. read more

See all

Awesome spot! After a grocery store run next door at La Michoacána, my sister recommended we stop by Diamonds for a sweet treat. This place is massive! I really dug the purple decor and all the Mexican art. In addition to an incredible selection of ice cream in legit Mexican flavors, they offered paleta popsicles, aguas frescas, and snacks like elote. We shared a strawberry horchata which was absolutely delicious. Very refreshing and not overly sweet. A large came in at $3.75 I was too full to try another offering but will look forward to returning! Overall, a wonderful experience that brought vibes from my recent month in Baja. read more

See all

I love their ice cream, specially the mango flavor. However, this time around, I ordered the Mangoanda, and it was absolutely delicious. Just the perfect balance of sweet and sour. Can't wait to go back and order it again. read more

Diamonds Ice Cream - Mangonada - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I had a strawberry and kiwi paleta and it was delicious. They have alot of flavors to choose from.

Great place for some Mexican treats and ice cream. Nice clean and bright atmosphere. Prices seem high but quality is high also.

Diamonds Ice Cream has a huge selection of ice cream, fruit popsicles, various desserts and sides that are inspired by Mexican dishes. I particularly love the fruit popsicles!!!! read more

See all

Such a hidden gem in Columbus! I love their fruit bars! So many flavors! Such a legit ice cream place, most everything is homemade. Ignore the Frida and purple decor. read more

What a fun shop! I have been here twice, and have received great service both times! This last time, we had a large group and the staff were so very accommodating to the several ice cream samples. This place has it all!... ice-cream, ice pops, food, bottled drinks, and candy. The flavors are fresh, and original. Takes me back to the streets of Mexico! I haven't explored too much of the food, minus the elote! I LOVE ELOTE! (my stomach is growling just thinking about it). This place is nowhere near my house, or I'd some more often. read more

Pretty cool experience at Diamond's last night! I've always heard good things, so after dinner, we headed over for a birthday treat. It's a pretty decent sized ice cream shop with ice cream, paletas, and a lot of other options that I couldn't quite follow, which leads to my only real complaint - it was really hard to tell what you were looking at, or what was on offer. First case contained some cake selections. There was for sure a tres leches, and a couple of other fruit topped options, and then a snack counter that did some variations on hot cheetoes and elote. Then was the frozen dessert counter. I don't know what was in the first case, it looked like a granita, maybe? Followed by ice cream in some great looking flavors - passion fruit, guava, corn.... and then the paletas. We ordered some milkshake kind of delights, with fruit and topped with tons of whipped cream, but the price and description didn't match the menu, so my friend just pointed and said I'd like that one and she would like the strawberry kind, please. I'm sure the staff would have walked us through, but it was within an hour of closing and we were a large group, so I didn't ask too much. it took about 10 minutes to make the shakes, and I was not expecting mine to be topped with a slice of cheese cake. I asked the lady at the counter for a box and she grabbed a box and a glove and boxed that up for later for me! The shake was really good! It was not as thick and heavy as a traditional style milkshake and had a great strawberry flavor! Overall, we had a fun experience and I'd love to go back for the paletas! read more

Diamonds Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

One of my favorite sweet spots in Cbus! Mexican ice cream and paletas are some of my favorite treats and I love every visit to Diamonds. They have great selection of aguas de frescas, too. It has a lot of seating and the staff is friendly enough - maybe not "Midwest friendly" but the treats are worth a visit regardless. I'm never disappointed with the flavors they bring! read more

I've visited Diamonds twice, once I had a mangonada and the second time I had a strawberries and cream paleta. The mangonada had nice fresh fruit, flavorful sorbet, and a nice spice from the tajin. There are so many paletas to choose from, but for my first one I went with something I knew I'd like. The texture was really nice and creamy with the fruity zing from the strawberry. They also have a nice selection of agua frescas and food as well that I'd love to try in the future. read more

Diamonds Ice Cream - Strawberries and cream paleta - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Ice cream was sooo good! The lady that helps was nice and the place was really clean. read more

Diamonds Ice Cream - Mangoneada but with guava ice cream and fruit added with chamoy. Sooo good - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Both my kids had one of their 'crazy' milkshakes and it was amazing! One was strawberry cheesecake and had an entire slice of homemade cheesecake on it and the other had an entire Oreo ice cream cookie sandwich on it. All homemade and delicious! Plus the staff is super nice. read more

Diamonds has a great unique ice cream and other selections. the staff are friendly and helpful. the restaurant is large enough to ensure available seats. I really like diamonds. read more

The popsicles from Diamonds Ice Cream are outstanding! These premium popsicles are made with real fruit and are fun to eat anytime of the year. They also serve banana splits, ice cream sandwiches, milkshakes, natural juice, smoothies, ice cream, & aguas frescas. Order: Kiwi-strawberry water popsicle Strawberry milk popsicle read more

Diamonds Ice Cream - Kiwi-strawberry water popsicle & Strawberry milk popsicle - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I kept driving past this place, so I finally made plans to see what it's all about. And I'm so glad I did. I got a strawberry kiwi paleta that tasted fresh and sweet and fruity and generally delicious, so now I basically want to taste my way through the other 30-some flavors in the freezer. Dulce de leche next, I think. read more

Diamonds Ice Cream - Strawberry Kiwi Paleta - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

The mangonada is my favorite from their menu, service is okay, could be abit more friendly.

We stopped in for cones with a the three year after a busy day. We all had cones which were good but basically the typical kind of spot. Variety of flavor choices. Different cones or bowls. Area inside and out for eating. read more

We took our daughter here for the milkshakes and they were all amazing. Such a cute little Icecream shop. We will definitely be back often

Great customer service! The employee who helped us was so friendly & helpful. We enjoyed our popsicles very much. Can't wait to come back with friends! read more

This place is one of my favorite ice cream joints! They have various ice cream and popsicle flavors; they are sure to satisfy any craving. They hand make their popsicles and they're refreshing and delicious. They also have authentic Mexican desserts and savory snacks available. Their prices aren't too bad, they recently raised some of their prices though. It's about $3 for one scoop of ice cream and $3 for one popsicle. If you get more than one scoop, you can get multiple flavors. This is a good place to take groups, your family, and kids. During the week, they have deals for certain things, be sure to check out their banner! There is plenty of parking in the lot, a few benches outside to sit on, and a lot of tables inside to sit at. read more

Diamonds Ice Cream - Strawberry and Kiwi Cream popsicle - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

This place was great. It was a little local shop with what appeared to be homemade ice cream. The atmosphere was very Latin and the food was great. read more

See all

Diamond's is the best popsicle shop anywhere. It may be the only such kind of place of course. That would be in Columbus at least. It's rated high by no accident. This is seriously good authentic Mexican treats. In this area of Columbus there's a lot of ethnic businesses. It has quite a lot of Hispanic restaurants and shops to serve the huge population. The plaza at the corner of Bethel and Sawmill features a Hispanic market and the Taco Loco restaurant. In comes this concept new to the city. These are the popular dessert item called paletas . It's basically like a popsicle with real fruit. The paletas are either made with milk or water. It's about $2 for each. There's also fresh cut fruit, ice cream, and smoothies. I like going to Diamond's on a hot day and getting some great cool treats. It may be hard making a choice. The products care all good no matter how weird it sounds so you won't go wrong. read more

Diamonds Ice Cream - Coconut And Watermelon Chili Pops - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Diamonds is one of the best ice cream spots in Columbus! They have unique flavors and a wide variety. The staff is happy to answer questions and provide samples. They also have cream and non-dairy popsicles and smoothies. Next time I want to try the popsicles but the ice cream is just so good. It is thick and creamy and does not melt quickly. read more

Diamonds Ice Cream - Half coconut, half tequila! This is a one scoop serving. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

This place had amazing Mangonada. In love with this Spicy Mango Fresh Fruit + Sorbet and a tinge of Tamarind Sauce. They also have a wide variety of Fruit popsicles and My favorite is Pineapple Pop. It has the perfect mix of spicy and tangy . The only thing I would like to tell them, is a lot of people there are not able to talk in English. It's hard to understand what they are trying to say. read more

Diamonds Ice Cream - Mangonada - Mango Fruit pieces with Mango Sorbet and a tinge of tamarind sauce - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

THIS PLACE IS AMAZEBALLS. Thank you Bryant for introducing me to Diamonds Ice Cream (and also for treating me to a paleta). Walking into Diamonds for the first time was like walking into an alternate universe for me. Mariachi music on blast, in-your-face purple paint and adorably uniformed employees. The place feels distinctly ethnic and I mean that in a good way. They offer all sorts of Mexican goodies such as Mexican ice cream, flavored horchatas and of course their paletas. I sampled their strawberry horchata and cactus pear ice cream. Both were great. Bryant suggested the strawberries and cream paleta. Definitely a great recommendation. As opposed to the American popsicles that are either too icy hard or too soft, these paletas are the perfect compromise with great consistency. My paleta was packed with chunks of fruit. It was also smooth, creamy and full of flavor. I wanted to take a box home with me, but somehow managed to resist. They also have literally 30+ flavors. Anyways, I am a big fan of this place and i'll be back for sure. read more

Diamonds Ice Cream - Strawberries and cream paleta - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

You guys I finally got to try this place after all this time! I got my husband to agree to come in because he thought it was a strip club every time I was talking about it. How does strip club have anything to do with paleta or ice cream? (He must be thinking of the Diamonds in Dayton, which is a whole other place just not in this city.) What I loved coming in is that you can try almost all the flavors of the different ice creams there. I liked the caramel one at first since that was the very first one we tried, but since I had already eaten a little bad before I came in I decided to go a tad bit healthier and go with a lower in fat kiwi sorbet. To my surprise it wasn't bad at all. Next time I definitely want to try the popsicles they look divine! Especially the strawberries and cream, it reminds me of the same thing I had in the past as a little girl back in my home country. Although this was the Mexican version of it. All the treats here look so good and I was so happy my husband was willing to try something new. It's always good to get out of your comfort zone and try new things in life and experience other cultural foods. I'll definitely be back soon! read more

Diamonds Ice Cream - Kiwi ice cream is the bomb! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I have never been to a Mexican ice cream shop - it seems like a rare entity in the Midwest! But wow, I highly recommend this place. 1. So many choices!!! And I'm not just talking flavors, but types of ice cream goodness! Ice cream, Popsicles, milk shakes, plus food snacks (like the corn on the cob with cheese and spices). 2. Easily a couple dozen ice cream flavors and you won't find them elsewhere. You have your fruity options like mango or strawberry with cream, and standard options like cookies and cream, and then it gets a bit different with choices like chocolate with marshmallows (like the Lucky Charms kind) and then many quintessential Mexican flavors. 3. Dozens of Popsicles. Mango with chili is one popular option but there are SO many (check out the photos) and many of them are very Mexican-centered flavors. 4. Mexican candy! Lots of choices. Your popular and more common in the Midwest times like the mango with chili suckers but a lot more. 5. Music. When we walked in it was a lot of bachata (great on a Saturday night!) and they switched to ranchero by the time we left. 6. It was fairly busy on a Saturday night but they had a lot of workers. 7. Clean and well-lit inside. I've seen skeptical comments because a strip club is nearby and an adult entertainment store is a couple stores down in the strip mall, but it's fine. It's also across from Carriage Place, so come here before/after a movie. 8. Portions! "One scoop" of ice cream is $2.98 but was really two big scoops. I couldn't finish it. 9. Taste: very good. I enjoyed my strawberries and cream but sampled others. The mango ice cream legit tastes like mango. 10. Ingredients: a lot of fresh ingredients. Real fruit is used. For the coconut ice cream there is coconut in there...its just real darn good. read more

See all

I've been hearing about this place for a while and thought I'd drop in since I was in the neighborhood. It's every bit as great as you read in the reviews! Love the vast selection of popcicles (so creative in their combinations), drinks, and ice creams. I decided on the cactus pineapple drink and watermelon popcicle. The owner was very kind and let me sample a number of drinks. Next time I stop by, I'll try a mangonada. They look amazing. Their fruit drinks are an excellent alternative to a soda or coffee. read more

See all

We stopped in and got a few bars to go. They were delicious!! My husband had the strawberries and cream and it was so creamy. We had the strawberry, kiwi, mango. It was good to but not as good as the ice cream based ones. I was surprised to see that also had a ton of regular ice cream as well as some other Mexican specialties like flan and candy. We're from out of town but I'm sure we'll be back. read more

I'm a big fan of this place. It's vibrant and has a down to earth kind of vibe to it. Nothing pretentious. Just a good 'ole place that sells paletas, ice cream, nachos, and other mexican snacks. I've tried their ice cream and it's pretty good--especially the kiwi. I've also tried their elote in a cup (they didn't have corn on the cob when I went) and it was pretty good. Only thing was when the lady scooped up the corn she grabbed too much water with it so my elote was kind of watery. read more

Diamonds Ice Cream - Elote in a cup - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

If you want to cultural experience definitely bring the family! Very traditional Mexican ice cream parlor with a lot of extra fun snacks

I am a huge fan of this cute shop. I love the bright pink and purple scheme along with the tasty treats. The flavors are so unique. It feels like there are a million of them to try. I usually get a paleta but I sometimes get a mangonada. Keep an eye out for their daily specials, usually a mangonada was $7, but when I went there it was around $5 because of their special. read more

Diamonds Ice Cream - Strawberries and Cream, Blackberries and Cream, Paletas - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Unique treats are here. it's not necessarily my preference due to the food being around a more Hispanic style of deserts. A wide range of market to store to desert. My wife and daughter love the tamarin seasoning. While this isn't for me it doesn't mean you won't love it. read more

5 stars and moreeee for this place! It was delicious but the real treat was the worker tad. The way he promiscuously walked to the register to allow me to pay made me feel some type of way. Let's rewind a little bit! I was really feeling like I needed some cream in my mouth;) IFYKYK. I pranced my way into the ice cream shop by the name of diamonds ice cream! I felt as tho this place would fulfill my cravings so I levitated my left hand towards the cold handle. I got in line and felt overwhelmed but also pleased by the amount of flavors to chose from. That's when I saw the seductive creature waddle his way to the counter and make eye contact and say "HI THERE;)". Boy was it hot in there IFYKYK. He asked me for my order and all I could say was chocolate. With some toppings of your choice;) he said ok bbg. I galloped to register to try and lore in my future mate. I went to pay for my ice cream when tad said it's on the house for you my bountiful beauty. I blushed and began to sweat profusely:0! After that he asked me go to bingo with him that night and I could not deny such an offer. The ice cream was okay too btw! read more