Which wich is which? Which wich did the witch wish was her wich? Which? With over 50 options you're gonna be asking which wich? This was my first visit to Which Wich and I was a little overwhelmed by the bags on the wall (you're supposed to mark which wich you choose with a sharpie). Instead I went up to the register and was walked back to the bags. Too many choices so I selected a tuna wich and fries. I waited quite some time. I was expecting a quick turnaround like at Subway or Potbelly's. No, your food is prepared behind a barrier and you were supposed to mark the toppings you wanted on the bag. It was about 20 minutes at which time I decided to take my food to go. I had a dr appointment so I took my wich into the office with me (didnt wanna leave a tuna wich in a 100 degree car). I carried my bright yellow which wich bag into the waiting room. The wich was ok, nothing spectacular. I prefer the tuna sandwich at other establishments. I wouldn't order the fries again. Next time I would examine the menu in advance so I could select which wich. read more

See all

Which Wich was my sister's go to sandwich spot when she was at the University of Iowa. So, when a Which Wich opened near me, I wanted to try it. When I entered Which Wich I grabbed a sandwich bag and filled in my order. This was new to me but I was able to figure it out and ordered successfully. An employee also explained this to me. Because I wanted to try everything I could, I ordered a French Dip sandwich, French fries, milkshake, and cookie. The sandwich was fine, a little better than your average sandwich shop sandwich but not super memorable. The French fries were really good and I enjoyed the skinnier fries. The milkshake was again ok but not great. The cookie, I thought, was the best thing I had from Which Wich. The food was average but what was really shocking was the price. This meal was $25.02. This was really expensive. A dinner for two would cost over $50! This caused me not to want to go back. It makes it really difficult to take a family here for food. For adequate food and really high prices, I cannot recommend Which Wich! read more

See all

Second time visiting Which Wich and honestly from the first visit I was hooked. I like that you can customize your sandwich and they have options that you don't get at other sandwiches shops. Everyone is very nice and never a long wait. If you're looking for yummy sandwiches this is for sure I place you need to try out. You won't regret it i promise. read more

Incredible sandwich! Egg bacon cheese yum! My daughter had egg salad pesto and cheddar. Yum . Best qsr sandwich I've had!

The food is pretty good. The people working there are very nice. HOWEVER, make sure you check your order before you leave. I've ordered 3 times, once on Door Dash, twice as a walk in. 2 out of three times they forgot something. Through Door Dash, they refunded me for not getting the avocado I paid extra for. That was okay, except I really do enjoy avocado on my sandwich. Last time I went there, yesterday, I ordered a French Dip for my husband. When I got home, I got the French, but not the Dip. Not cool. I don't live very close, so I didn't bother to call and complain. I wasn't driving back to get the Dip. So make sure you check it before you leave. read more

Good sandwich's about $10.00 each Had the Italian club and pesto chicken both were quite tasty. Service was quick

I purchased a package of discount coupons through the Appreciation Perks program in June 2024 with coupons valid for one year. On Saturday March 1, 2025, I visited the Arlington Heights location to place an order for two sandwiches. I was told that they would no longer honor the discount coupons. I spent over $20.00 money for this discount program and apparently this franchise believes they don't have to live up to their commitments. I won't be patronizing this location ever again and they just lost a customer. I intend to complain to Which Wich headquarters and the BBB as well. read more

Honestly, the manager guy was super nice-he gets a 5 star rating, but overall experience gets like 2 stars. I did an online order, went to get it at the time it specified, and he said their system never printed the order so they didn't make it. He apologized, explained everything, asked to see the order on my phone-wrote it, then said it would be two minutes for the sandwiches I ordered. I was very understanding, I wasn't in any rush. He said I could take chips to make up for it, again he was very nice. I waited probably 7-10 minutes, got my two sandwiches and chips, and went home happy. I opened my sandwich and was honestly pretty disappointed. I had never been here before-for the price-I expected a lot more. It had almost all the meat on one side, didn't have any noticeable cheese, the onion strings were very hard, and the bread was overcooked so it was hard and falling apart. Overall, the food is pretty bad, but it really wasn't a totally unenjoyable experience. read more

Which Wich - philly cheese steak with onion strings - A sandwich with onions and meat, partially eaten, on crumpled paper with a business logo, on a wooden surface. - Sandwiches Near Me - Arlington Heights, Illinois

It was my very first time at Which Wich. I decided to choose the ingredients of my sandwich. I chose ham, cheddar cheese, oil & vinegar dressing and oregano. I did not realize they put the sandwich through an oven on a conveyor. It turned out to be a very tasty sandwich. It was warm and on fresh baked bread. I really enjoyed the experience and I can't wait to return. read more

See all

I ordered the tomato avocado sandwich. The avocado was brown. BROWN. Which is a sign of them using old food from a prior day. I would never recommend them as this is a food safety and food quality issue. read more

Which Wich - Tomato avocado sandwich. To the manager or owner of this franchise...would YOU eat this? - Sandwiches Near Me - Arlington Heights, Illinois

Used to come here a couple years ago and it was just ok. I guess they're under new management or somthething but this was a fantastic experience. Way more menu options. Food was excellent. Staff was so polite. And the owner introduced himself in a very respectful nice way. Very genuine guy. Much better than it used to be read more

Superb taste. Very soft and crunchy filling, very fresh, try there bean patties if you vegetarian. Multiple items for filling, addictive , give better discount and coupon, read more

Don't even bother. Seriously. Friend and I stopped in for sandwiches and shakes, because I Doordashed from Which Wich before & it was ok. I got a muffuletta which says in the description has olive salad on it. Friend got the buffalo chicken but chose provolone instead of blue cheese. He also asked if their jalapeños were pickled or fresh, the girl said fresh. I didn't check olive salad as a topping because it's supposed to come with it. I also checked oil & vinegar. Mine didn't have olive salad or oil and vinegar. My friend got blue cheese AND provolone (eww), and the jalapeños were pickled. We took it to go (about a 5 min car ride) and weren't about to go back to complain (both hungry and a but tired). But neither of us finished our food. I don't think any of them knew what they were doing at all, at one point the little order bag you write on got slingshotted to the floor somehow. Comical but should have seen that red flag. And it seemed like the three of them were trying to figure out how to make sandwiches? Oh, nearly forgot about the fries! My friend got fries. They were old, like had been sitting there for hours old. Stale tasting and just gross. Shakes were meh, but probably best part of our meal. Don't waste your time with this place. read more

First time at WW? tonight. I was really looking forward to it, but to be honest, I was a little disappointed. I had the Wicked Lettucewich, which is comparable with Jimmy John's unwich, (wrapped in lettuce instead of bread). The unwich is a superior lettuce wrap and the contents are better too. WW? is not what I hoped for, but it is probably worth another try. To be continued.., read more

This location has an amazing selection of sandwiches and the employees here are truly hard workers. The 2 ladies that are here today are knocking the orders out. I would highly recommend coming to this location here in Arlington Heights and support this business. read more

Which Wich - The menu area. You pick between BYO WICH OR FAVS Then bring it to the cashier. - Sandwiches Near Me - Arlington Heights, Illinois

I've always loved this chain so I was so excited when the Arlington Heights location opened up. Great service, same quality food and excellent menu variety. One of my favorite chain sandwich places in the area! read more

Which Wich is a fantastic sandwich restaurant. The restaurant is beautiful. The sandwiches are amazing. The fries are delicious. Staff is wonderful. My ONLY complaint (and this is very minor), is the smell. I don't know what it is, but the smell of this place doesn't smell good at all. And I can't wrap my head around what this place smells like. When you walk into Subway, you can smell the bread. When you walk into Jimmy John's, you can smell the bread. When you walk into Potbelly, you can smell the hot sandwiches. At Which Wich, you don't smell any of that. It's like a metallic kitchen? It's hard to explain. I guess all I'm saying is, please do something about the smell inside. I don't care if it smells like fruit or Lysol when I walk in. I just would love if the smell inside was just a little better. Overall I like this restaurant and I hope the very best for them. Just please do something about the smell. Thank you! read more

It's 750pm, open sign is lit, hours sign says open until 9pm. Why are you closed? Don't you want our business? read more

Fast healthy and overall pretty good! The bread is really nice and I really like the Cali sandwich

We often choose to go to Which Wich. They offer discounts for goldfish members and have a good rewards programs. We're a family of diabetics and the cloud which offering is tremendous. The sandwich offering is diverse and tasty. They've also had some great employees, Victoria today was awesome, so helpful!! read more

I like the food but the service here is ungodly slow. Entering more words so I can finish this review.

As a representative of Hersey Football, I have been dissatisfied by this poo poo customer service. The food was very too too which means it was good! On the other hand, I waited 50 fricking minutes for my damn sandy ferda! Me and my husband Colton Gumino did not have much fun here! What the fluff!!! read more

I've been waiting 50 minutes for a damn sandwich. I can't believe this experience. Thank goodness the sandwich was good. James Erickson really didn't like his Philly cheesesteak though. read more

If you have things to do I wouldn't recommend drags crazy balls fuck which wich. I have been here for 37 minutes and still don't have my food. It's a sandwich wtf. read more

The worst service I have ever experienced at any restaurant establishment. I spent $19.78 and tipped generously and it took 56 minutes to get my foodThis is absurd!!! I have places to be! read more

How terribly below average the food is here! Corned beef sandwich was more bread than beef. And they charge too much. I regretfully had food delivered. It was $47 for 2 sandwiches and a completely melted chocolate shake. Ridiculous! I originally put up a 2-star rating, but it really was bad, and the food made me ill. Never ordering a thing from this place ever again. read more

Cool concept, nice menu.... horrible execution. You fill out brown lunch bags with your order, which are hung on a clothesline type contraption and go down the line. Sounds simple in concept but is not, apparently. Waited 22 minutes for a simple deli sub, which came with only 4 of the 8 toppings I chose. Also ordered fries, then watched as 3 people behind me in line got theirs. Also saw 3 separate families wait 20+ minutes for kids meals. We're talking a pb&j, folks, with apples on the side. Spare yourself the hassle, unless you like standing in line watching the world burn down around you read more

Just tried the Philly Sandwich and it was absolutely amazing. The bread is awesome, the protein was amazing! Definitely going to be going to Which Wich for my subs! Also the management team there corrected a delivery issue with a third party in a heartbeat. You can't buy good customer services like that any more. But they went above and beyond to correct a mistake that wasn't even theirs. The bottom line though is the food here is great! Can't wait for the next time when my family is home to orders from here! read more

Love the veggie sandwiches. Build your own. Black bean burger is yummy. Some nice tunes in the evening hours. Family friendly read more

I order from here because it's close to my house. The staff is nice but it takes too long to make the sandwiches and the ingredients are C+. You have to write your order on a bag and give it to the register person which is just a quirky way to order. read more

The quality of their food has not declined one bit due to the pandemic. The sandwiches are fresh and they are generous with fillings. Their grilled chicken sub is my go to. They have consistent service and they never leave you hungry. read more

Which Wich - Chicken with avocado, hot peppers, olives and spinach. - A sandwich with visible vegetables and bread, partially unwrapped from paper and foil, placed on a speckled countertop. - Sandwiches Near Me - Arlington Heights, Illinois

Hungry for a great sandwich - come to Which Wich! Create your own or pick a favorite. If you like Thanksgiving try the Thank You Turkey, it's like thanksgiving dinner in a sandwich. Help support this local shop which opened in January. read more

Which Wich - a restaurant counter with stools in front of it - Sandwiches Near Me - Arlington Heights, Illinois

Love which which but this location is poorly run. Had to cancel an order because they did but have it ready, issues w the app. Called a few days later to see why the refund was not issued and the employee was not very helpful so I asked to speak to a manager. Both owners called me back the man explained the situation and lady owner, not so much. Sandwiches are good but not that good lol, Gatsby's right across the street read more

I was excited to finally try Which Wich, but was left terribly disappointed. The scraps of steak had absolutely no seasoning. Despite requesting salt & vinegar the sandwich had zero flavor, it has to be the most flavorless sandwich I've ever eaten. There's far too little meat for the amount of bread, every bite of a sandwich should include meat, but this one certainly did not. The fries & wich sauce were good. The restaurant was clean. Can't say the staff was friendly since no one uttered a word when I walked through the door to pick up my order. read more

Fantastic food and great service. Our which Wich closed and I've tried a few of them. This was the cleanest and friendliest I've been to and I'll be back. Don't change a thing. Worth the drive if your looking for a great sandwich and a great place. read more

I'm a huge fan of this place! Everything is super customizable, and the staff are a delight. Can't wait to go back!

I'm really surprised to read some of these negative experiences! We visited them a couple times before the COVID quarantine and again during the lock down by ordering in advance through the mobile app. Every time our sandwiches have been made right and are delicious! I love the variety of options they have, though I usually end up building my own. My favorite is anything with grilled chicken. Some places have gamey chicken but Which Wich has nice flavorful pieces. read more

I was hungry so I gave this new concept sandwich shop a try. I had the ultimate BLT sandwich, regular size. There is also a large size but the regular size was plenty big enough. And oh boy was it good. The best sandwich I have eaten in a long, long time. Maybe ever. The next day I went back and had the Brunchwich. The Brunchwich came with a sunny side up cooked egg on top so it was a little messy. And after that BLT any other sandwich might struggle. The Brunchwich was good. I plan to work my way through their list of sandwiches. The sandwiches are not cheap but the quality is so high that it's a good value. The service is good and the staff is friendly. They also do catering. This will be my favorite lunch time go to place. Great sandwiches, made with fresh ingredients, at a fair price for such a quality product. read more

Great new place for a sandwich. I really liked the meatball as it's different from the usual around here. Using a pesto sauce. Plus large cuts of mozzarella. Very nice. Also had the Philly cheesesteak. Yummy. New place with new crew so it's a little expected that the time it takes is a few minutes longer. I'm sure they will get that all worked out. Still worth it though. read more

Which Wich is awesome! The sandwiches are awesome as is the salad. And don't get me started on the shakes. Yummy!! Service was fantastic. This new store in Arlington Heights is sure to be a hit. read more