This store now has a new location (in the same shopping center) and a new name: Jack's Comics &…read moreMore. Owner Jack Tolzmann has made it fully a comic book store now, devoting space that used to be shelves of used books to more graphic novels and collectibles. There's a selection of kid-friendly comic books at the back right corner and teen graphic novels to your right when you enter. New releases go up on the wall every Wednesday. This store has been helping Saint Augustine geek out since 1986.

Honestly there is no easy way to start but here goes, THIS PLACE IS AWESOME. Being my first time in…read morea comic book store this store has tons and tons and tons of comics going from old to new releases. I've been hunting MAD Magazines for the longest online doesn't help with people setting outrageous prices for them, once I collected my comics I asked the cashier if he had any MAD Magazines and once he said yes it was like the heaven sound I immediately left majority of the ones I had before and went through that box with an urge lol I found so many and took almost half since he had them for the best prices I didn't get the chance to get his name but the cashier knew his stuff me just browsing around and overhearing his conversation with someone else and him knowing so much about regardless of the topic I most certainly and definitely will be returning here no doubt it best service by far. Highly recommend

We had so much fun! Nick was AWESOME! He really seemed to care about my nephew and was so patient…read moreand kind. We highly recommend Woke Poke and will definitely be back!

Cute little card shop! They don't really have a lot there, but you can tell that the owners are…read morereally nice and genuine. They were friendly and helpful when I came in to check it out! They have good prices on wax from what I've seen and lots of room for people to play the TCG. I will surely be visiting again!

Service was really good and the guy working the counter was very knowledgeable. They have a great…read moreselection and amazing value for the retro games they have. I found a game I was looking for sometime NFS Most Wanted (2005) for the 360. Also picked up Dark for the 360 and Midnight Club 2 for the original Xbox.

Great Retro Fit Cartridges! Great Store! All the Video Games work. If you're looking for a retro…read moreVideo Game, they have it! Cool People too talk too who are up to date on the 4-1-1 of the Video Game World. Go See em and Leave your hassle at home.

I travel nearly 3 hours to shop here simply for the experience of seeing wall-to-wall toys and…read morelearning tools of all kinds. This store boasts a grand selection of unique and somewhat hard-to-find items, and I get a thrill from all there is to look at. I especially love that Old Towne carries Playmobil. Playmobil used to be more popular in Florida, as there were once a couple of Playmobil Fun Parks - one in Orlando, one in Palm Beach Gardens. The brand, behind Star Wars, was my favorite toy throughout the 80s, and somehow I just haven't been able to stop collecting them. The staff have always been welcoming and friendly, and each went out of their way to look up information about toys we've inquired about. The prices are decent. As a locally owned and operated store, I'd expect the price to be a little higher than what you'd expect from a well-known, brick-and-mortar business. There is a clearance section, which is nice, but it doesn't help me, particularly... At any rate, St. Augustine is Florida's most captivating city, and Old Towne Toys is one of its finest treasures, and my favorite part of going there.

This was such a cool store! I think I enjoyed it more than my 6 year old. The address (unsure if…read morethis is the one) I initially went to was wrong. Also the name is toytopia now. The young man working was very kind and it seemed that it was a very family friendly environment. The selection of toys ranged from baby Montessori to epic Lego kits and everything in between. We bought some small items and I felt that the price was very reasonable.

I planned to stop in during our visit to St. Augustine. Quaint little bookstore which is tucked…read moreaway. The owner was so polite and helpful when we walked in the door by explaining the prices of the books. My son spotted two books after only walking in two steps. He was so excited because they were two books he had been looking for and immediately purchased them. He normally doesn't read for pleasure. He was thrilled about finding the books and the price. So I consider this a win!

If you're visiting St. Augustine, this really cute bookshop is definitely worth a visit. We grabbed…read morea book on the sacred churches of St. Augustine, which we could not find anywhere else. Got it for a great deal as well. The store owner-operator, Susan, was quite hospitable and informative. Really nice experience.

Okay. This place is so cute. The set up is easy to maneuver, great selection, the employee that was…read morethere was helpful with all my questions for book recommendations. The three of us left happy and talked about the store a few times that weekend. 11.04.2026

Beautiful store! Lots of great books and games. So many wonderful gifts. I've come in here often…read morejust to pick up something for someone's birthday.

Excellent staff and reasonable prices!! Have been their multiple times and always find something I…read moreneed. The staff is always pleasant and helpful.

Very strange that the a staff member took 10 months to reply to this review, then attempt to insult…read moreme several times over the course of their reply. Customer service isn't that hard but it's clear from your reply that you have absolutely no idea what the term "customer service". This weird and insulting reply has insured that we will never bother stopping in again seeing as being snarky & insulting almost a year later is more important to you than learning and improving.

In response to the guy who was upset about Music Matters not holding a record for him on Record…read moreStore Day - I too called Music Matters to request that they hold a Record Store Day (RSD) single for me and then mail it, but they explained to me that their RSD contract stated that they could not hold records, and that they would lose the right to get RSD limited edition records if they did. So, as much as I wanted that single, I completely understood their policy. I know now I have to drive to St. Augustine to wait in line! I want to say something else about Music Matters. In an age where record stores are becoming extinct, and online retail overwhelms, Music Matters is not just a music "shop," it is a cool, friendly place to hang out, with people who are knowledgeable, and care about you finding that one record you have been looking for, or turning you on to new music in a favorite genre that you didn't even know about, something that you cannot experience with a computer (sorry Siri). And where else can you immediately buy the music you were jonesing for? Even Amazon hasn't come up with immediate gratification delivery! Check this store out!

Stopped in here after a disappointing visit to another record store in the area…read more We were only there for a short time but a couple of observations led to my 4 star review. 1) the staff was going through a large amount of records right near the front door. I'm not saying that's a negative, it's actually quite a positive. Even through the 3 of them were going through a big collection, they still stopped to help us. The only reason I didn't give this place 5 stars is because of how I personally shop for records. I'm not what you'd call a crate digger. If you are, then you'll love this place. I know there are many, many crate diggers out there. Just wanted to mention it not being my style in case anyone else wanted to know what to expect. We picked up a couple of records while we were there, so it was a good visit. It helped make up for the other place in town that we stopped first.