Very cute little bakery in Sterling. Makes for a great stop after a beach day at Fair Haven State…read morePark. They have a lovely outdoor seating area you can enjoy, we took our stuff to go but the area looked so cozy. I ordered a delicious strawberry refresher and a festively decorated chocolate brownie. 9 dollars and change for both. Not bad at all as the brownie was huge. The menu is rotating so they had items on the menu board that were not available when I visited. Quick service with a smile. I will stop in anytime I am in the area if they are open. The brownie was the perfect texture and I was able to eat it over a few nights due to the size. Amazing quality!

I have ordered so many things from the bakery cinnamon rolls are to die for I ordered all my pies…read morefor Christmas delicious especially the Oreo cookie one. The owner is adorable. She is number one in the region for so many awards. She has won. Nice family business definitely need to try great ambience. I will be going back. She has done pop-ups in my Salon. We absolutely love this. Bakery and Sara herself is such a wonderful young lady.

I was on vacation in Fair Haven and wanted to get in a bit of shopping. I was walking the strip…read morewhere Chelle's Bake Shop was located and walked in because I'm always in the mood for baked goods. I picked a triple ginger cookie, a lemon ricotta cookie and a blueberry/lemon scone. They were to die for! So here I am back in Rochester craving these cookies. I think there is a road trip to Oswego in my near future. I need more. I'll be back sooner than later! Must try!

I debated between 3 and 4 but overall was happy so wanted to be optimistic. Everything in the case…read morelooked delicious. I went for a slice of the spinach, cheddar tomato quiche, warmed, and a molasses cookie. First the good. The cookies was delicious. Moist, flavorful with just the right spices. The quiche was a mixed bag. Overall the flavor was pretty good...a tad bland but ok. But the crust was just awful. It was almost totally raw...and not just the wet crust under the egg but the edges too. There is no way they blind baked it at all. I was able to peel the entire crust off the egg with it breaking. There was no crumble at all. I could squeeze the edge and flatten it without it crumbling. I hate to be this critical but it was very bad. Everything else looked so good and because the egg part and the cookie were good I will definitely try again.

I tried a cupcake that was from this business…read more I'm not a huge fan of desserts so when my friend gave me a cupcake to try I wasn't expecting much. She had poo pooed magnolias cupcakes from NYC on a recent trip. Once I took a bite into the delicious cupcake I was amazed. The frosting is perfectly light, creamy, and not overly sweet. The cake part was super moist and fluffy. I have never had such Ana amazing cupcake. I cannot speak for the location but only for the cupcake since it was take out for someone's birthday but I have to say if the cupcakes are that good... Then I must make a trip out.

I first used this bakery in 1994, and it remained my only bakery for almost 30 years. It changed…read moreownership several years ago and I found that the new owner kept the recipes up that we had all come to love. But the bakery was sold again and now I will never- ever use it again and it's really sad. The new owner made a terrible mistake on an important order and wouldn't fix it. And worse, she didn't seem to care. Even though I had all the emails between us and had been specific, she was basically like, oh well... What a shame that a bakery that had built such a wonderful reputation over the past (almost) 30 years has been now reduced to nothingness. I know I'm not alone in saying- this business would have been better off going out on a high note rather than being reduced to an incompetence that might just lead to an unhappy ending.

I save five stars for someplace special. This is such a place, I mean, how can you NOT check out a…read morebusiness with a name like Fly By Night Cookies? First of all, I admire people who have an idea for a product and decide to make a business out of it. Secondly, for that person to have the chutzpah to open said business in their home! Thirdly, to trust your buyers to do the right thing. (It works in the resort town of Fair Haven but you'd never try such a thing in Chicago or LA.) The charming house has a fantasy novel feel to it with some radically hand-carved porch columns and a tea room on the front porch. A giant pointing hand indicates where to enter to find the cookies. A giant, pointing hand. (HOW could you miss it?) Prices are clearly displayed. It ain't cheap - but rich, homemade, and delicious never is. It's not Aldi or Trader Joe's, okay? Spare me the sticker shock. It's self serve. Seriously! Self serve! The instructions are clear - put on a plastic glove (supplied) and a bag (supplied) and make your selections. The cookies are all fresh baked and are homemade. Literally. They're baked in the owners' home kitchen just through that door over there. You can see the kitchen through the glass. After you've made your selections, drop your cash payment in the little tin box. Need change? Help yourself. A tip o' my hat to the owner's trust in us to do the right thing. Oh, one more thing - these confections are delicious!

Cookies are sometimes a bit dry but we still love it there. The building is so cute! The one…read moreproblem is parking...but we manage. A great addition to Fair Haven!!!

This place is a GEM! Well worth a drive into the beautiful countryside to visit. My wife and I live…read morein Washington DC, and the quality of the baked goods, sandwiches, and ice cream at this cafe would outdo most of the fancier places we could find in the city. Great seasonal fruits all summer, including you-pick strawberries. We split two chipotle Turkey and caprese chicken sandwiches and they were amazing! Cannot recommend this place enough.

Bake goods are out of this world!! Love the Cherry Almond cookies. Could not just have one bite. :)read more

I love TLJ! I saw they had some new breads and drinks and decided to try them out…read more The honey lavender matcha was a nice sweetness but I still prefer the shaken oat milk espresso. The curry bread as always is delicious. Honey melon bread was soft and airy. 10/10

Great service as always! Took my granddaughter for a special treat after her Dr. appointment. We…read moreboth love coming here! She had her favorite sugar donut twist and I had my kimchi croquette and I also tried one of their sausage pastries. She had a strawberry smoothie and I had a London Fog....an earl greytea drink. We are both fascinated by the elaborate cakes and I promised her I'd get her one for her birthday.

Jessi made the most wonderful cake to celebrate a milestone birthday. She was very flexible with…read moreflavor and design requests and was in frequent communication about the pick up time etc.

Cupcakes were very fresh. They have lots of ice cream flavors too. The salesperson was helpful and…read morepleasant

Everything was incredibly delicious - so the basics like turnovers and apple stix were already…read moreexcellent, but you're doing yourself a disservice if you don't get try their bread loafs when they're still warm - it's mindblowing

Not what it used to be, unfortunately. We purchased 2 items, were charged for 3. Manager quickly…read morecredited our account when we discovered the error and was very apologetic. The cheesecake with cherry topping was good, not great, but the cranberry orange scone was a real disappointment,