You will be so happy you tried this place!!! We stopped in for breakfast on a Thursday morning, so…read moreit was pretty quiet. I imagine this place is hopping on the weekends! Felt right at home and were treated so well! We ordered our drinks and then looked over the giant menu. It was so hard to decide. The staff were so warm and friendly without going overboard and the food was delicious!!! Homemade bread for toast was out of this world. Prices were great as well.

Nestled on the 4 corners of the Village of Cato intersection sits The Busted Yolk, a small,…read moreunassuming diner that you'd more than likely pass if you didn't know it was there. My wife and I recently moved to the Village and the Busted Yolk is a 30 second walk for us, so one weekend we headed over to grab some breakfast. It's a small little place, but clean and nicely decorated, and there were a good amount of people inside, but there were some open tables and we were sat relatively quickly. We were given our menus and looked 'em over. Typical stuff you'd see on diner menus. One of the cool things about the Busted Yolk though is they bake their own loaves of bread. I'm not a huge fan of eggs, so I went with ordering a bunch of sides of stuff to make my own plate, so I went with an order of bacon, sausage links, home fries and toast with their homemade Italian bread. The wife got The Big Four Breakfast along with a pancake. Food was brought quickly and everything was tasty. They had very good home fries with onions, bacon was nice and crispy, and their toast with their homemade bread was very good. Thick slices too. The wife also enjoyed hers. Service was good and all the employees were very friendly. Prices were pretty cheap and more than fair. The Busted Yolk does simple diner food, but they do it well and they do it friendly, so we'll definitely be back at some point.

Gas station, store and diner all in one place in the middle of nowhere. The sitting area has a…read morecounter and about 10 tables, modest but clean. Service was friendly and quick. I got a cheese omelette with toast and fries. The food came out pipping hot and prices were good. Nice option for a food and gas stop on your way in/out of Lake Ontario beaches.

Food is always hot delicious and made to order. Staff usually great except for one server.read more

Local family owned breakfast/lunch restaurant. Not much to look at, but the food is decent, the…read morestaff are friendly and the prices are good. They cook breakfast until close, 2/3pm. They only accept cash, NO Credit Cards or checks.

Terrific local diner -Food is very good - staff is very friendly and extremely efficient and…read moreprices are reasonable! No credit cards accepted. Open 6 AM- 2 PM M-Thurs, 6 AM- 12 pm on Sat & Sun and from 6 AM - 7 PM on Fridays. Be sure to stop in when you're traveling on Rte 104!!

Service by Laura D was very friendly and attentive. Back area of restaurant was very busy and…read moreLaura still kept checking on us. Spicy peach sauce on chicken wings was very good. Goulash special was great. Large portion. Ruby red Ruben was good. French Fries, some of the best I have had. Fresh, hot and tasty. Parking lot was packed but most people were at various events in their back room. Front of restaurant had booths , counter and tables. Worth a ride to this gem.

Great find - thank you Yelp! Fantastic spot, big menu, accessible, and family friendly. We got…read morehere late on the July 4th holiday weekend - so happy they were open. There was live music in the back room, so we opted for a booth in the front room so we could have quiet dinner conversation. Alisha was great. She explained the menu, the Mac & cheese, and the dairy bar in the adjacent bldg. We ordered dinner and it was out quickly. Hubby had the entree of brisket & pulled pork with a side of veggies and the Mac & cheese. The Mac & Cheese is so, so good. We ordered some to take home for my son! My balsamic chicken entree was delicious - I loved the side of carrots & zucchini- very fresh & unique! Great dinner, no hesitation to come back here. And, we did have to wander over to the dairy bar and check out the ice cream too! On the way, we noticed lots of outdoor seating and maybe a little stage too. There is live music regularly! Hubby got a shake & I had a dish of hard ice cream. It hit the spot! Thanks so much!

It had been many years if not decades since we had last visited the previous Jack's reef at their…read moreold location. We decided to take a road trip to check out the new Reef restaurant. The dining room was spacious and clean and bright as were the servers and the bartenders who expertly served us. They have a happy hour from 5 to 7 that varies each day so on this Thursday was half price on selected appetizers as well as $2.50 domestic select drafts. We got there about 10 after five and the bar quickly filled up, which seemed to be regulars, which was a good sign. We decided to linger a little bit over our first drinks and ordered deep fried cheese curds with a delicious margarita type tomato sauce. I had never had fried cheese curds and they were plentiful and came out steaming hot topped with a sprinkle of Parmesan cheese, unfortunately I did not take a picture as we were hungry and dove right in. When it was time for our second drink, I pondered over their wine list, but decided that with my Reuben and mac & cheese dinner a cold draft would suffice. My husband ordered the Philly cheesecake sandwich and onion rings. The mac & cheese and the onion rings were up charges of $2.50 and they were worth it. The cheesesteak sandwich was not shaved beef, but wonderfully thick pieces of beef on a perfectly toasted bun type with cheese and peppers. The onion rings were generous as well as crisp and not overly breaded. My Reuben was perfectly toasted on a delicious rye bread with just the right amount of sauce to not make it soggy. The star was their mac & cheese served in a steaming hot crock! It was creamy, not too cheesy, but cheesy enough to know that you were digging into a delicious bite of mac & cheese.. well done kitchen! All in all the meal was so large we could only eat half of it and brought it home for another day. We would certainly return as we enjoyed every bit of our evening. The patio looked invited and will be opening soon. They also have live entertainment to enjoy.

Joined some family and friends for birthday celebration. I've never been to this little hideaway…read morenear Jacks Reef. Probably because I'm not a snowmobiler, and this place had more sleds than cars parked. Place had a friendly feel, waitress was in training and did a great job, asked right off if we going to split checks and made sure the drinks kept coming. Had the special Philly Cheesesteak in a bread bowl and wasn't disappointed. If you're a snowmobiler or not looking for some comfort food in a relaxed atmosphere stop by "The Reef"!

No longer open was too expensive the spaghetti sauce was so sweet it was sickening and almost as if…read moreit had spoiled but they were still using it

Horrible, overpriced food, bad wine, tacky ambiance. Definitely won't go there again-- once was one…read moretime too many.

We had a banquet here. We had buffet style dinner of beef tenderloin, chicken "french", black and…read moreblue pasta, whipped potatoes and green beans. It was amazing! Bruschetta and spin-dip appetizers were great too! Kristen is great to work with. She made sure everything was lined up and timed right. Quaint setting made the speeches from our group easy to hear. And the room was set up 100% to our liking. We will be back!

RFH's Hideaway in Phoenix, NY. What a hidden gem, just outside of town but worth the drive…read more Nice bar seating area and large back room for seating. Nice local restaurant where not only the staff is friendly but everyone there says hello and wishes you a great day. Full bar. Private parking. Bathrooms were clean. NYS lottery available. . Food, their steak, cheese, pepper, onions etc. sandwich was amazing. Large portion and served extremely hot. Fish sandwich was excellent with great starter sauce. Portion was large and served hot with FF. Shrimp starter with Thai Asian sauce was just ok. Nice soup and salad bar for extra. Service was very good. Will return and worth our 45 minutes drive.

OK, I got to the restaurant with a bunch of friends. We sat down waitress was really nice very…read moreattentive. All the servers were very attentive. The guy across from me got a 12 ounce prime rib, which didn't look bad and he got mashed potatoes with gravy, which didn't look bad.. I got the 14 ounce prime rib and it came back hard. I ordered a medium well, but there was no paint at all and it was very tough to cut and it was dry. The side order of spaghetti that was undercooked almost raw, and the sauce was very bland like a can of tomatoes have been dumped on top.. the salad bar was about the only thing that was really good and untouchable. Would I go there again absolutely not.. but I didn't say anything to the waitress because our friends was with us and I didn't want to embarrass my friends. But that meal was horrible very second rate..

I just had one of the best burgers of my life, and definitely the best sweet potato fries. Maybe…read moreone out 20 times when I request a medium rare burger do I get it. Tonight was one of those nights. If you get here I highly recommend the Bacon Bourbon Swiss Burger. The sticky bourbon sauce makes it a bit messy, but it will be worth every napkin! Most times sweet potato fries are soft and wilted, but these were crisp, hot and perfectly cooked. As you can see, the burger is HUGE, a full 8 ounces of juicy beef goodness. Add in the ambience of a dockside restaurant on Little Sodus Bay on Lake Ontario and it's a memorable experience. My GF and I had the chicken rice bowls last week which were also very good, but these burgers are epic. You won't be disappointed. This was on a cold April day, in warmer weather you can dine outdoors and enjoy an even better experience.

We ordered chicken wings only 5b, the raspberry steak salad it was the size of side salad ($18.50)…read morewhich had maybe 3 oz of steak, and the margarita flatbread ice cold. We waited 40 minutes, the food arrived cold, and the quality was terrible. Stay away.

Delicious Italian ices and ice cream! Home made and…read moredelightful. Will be back. They have an ice cream truck for hire too!