Too much cheese and sliced in a very impractical fashion. Sausage was cheap and questionable in flavor. Not a pleasant eating experience. It is not authenticate Italian. We will not give it a second chance. read more

Pizzas are great, albeit on the small side. Breadsticks and sauce are out of this world! Check out their wide selection of sandwiches. Great prices and you can even order a half if you aren't that hungry. My favorites are the Meatball and Cheese (careful, it will ruin any other meatball sub for ever) and the Hot Ham and Cheese...Stop in, give them a try! If I were to have any criticism, it would be Soda is served in cans (Mice have sex on cans (in general)) and they don't take Debit/Credit last I knew. read more

Tasty pizza that was delivered piping hot! We wished the delivery on a Sunday night didn't take an hour. We would order from them again, though. read more

Oh Volcano Pizza, I think I'll miss you most of all. So incredibly delicious. And please, don't discount their pasta. We ordered Spaghetti for 2 with breadsticks - got enough for several meals out of it. The sauce is delicious. read more

Just found their outdoor grill location off Jackson Street in Elkhart. They grill a Italian Saugage patti with onions & peppers on a home made bun...Killer! read more

Volcano Pizza - Italian Saugage patties Grilling ! - Italian Near Me - Elkhart, Indiana

I grew up (age 59) on this pizza so of course I love it. My favorite is a large with PP, SS, ON, GP, BO, MR. The sausage is unique in it's flavor and is what makes the pie. The dough doesn't have a large crust, al dente, toothsome taste/texture like a New York pizza but it is fold-able. Instead of being sliced into wedges it is cut into rectangles which make for easy pick. I prefer the cruncy 'corners' myself. The sausage sandwich is great too, sauce is unique also, a good tomato flavor. All locations are tiny but do have a few table and chairs if you can't wait to get one home! I now live in the Carolinas and I swear each time I come back to visit and reach the town limits, I have Volcano on the phone placing my order! read more

Thanks for being a tried and true place for me to come home to. A trip home to Elkhart is not complete until I've had Volcano's.

Most excellent pizza! Crust, cheese, onions, sausage and mushrooms in perfect balance. Hot and ready when promised, friendly staff, I'm a fan. read more

I've been coming here since I was a kid, been all over the country and in between and you won't find a better pizza anywhere in my opinion.

The best pizza in Elkhart. Great toppings. Lots of cheese. Good flavor. It is a bit high on the grease scale...so if you are looking for low fat pizza...this isn't it. But...if you wanted low fat. Don't order pizza. Also try breadsticks. Very good with the red sauce. read more

Where to begin. Hunger can make you look past even something like an employee tickling another employee's armpit, and then cut a pizza with his one good hand (without washing it mind you). But calling this pizza is like calling Alpo ground beef. The box had more flavor than the crust, the sauce was like ketchup, and you would think bacon on a pizza would mean spread around the whole pie, not two pieces with one whole strip of bacon each. They've been in business for over 50 years... how they got past 50 minutes is beyond me. Elkhart, you are being bamboozled read more

Volcano Pizza - Italian Near Me - Elkhart, Indiana

As a lifetime customer of Volcanos, I can't tell you how upset I was about my interaction with them. This rating is for the terrible service from the manager on Friday 11/12/2021. We called to order delivery, which we have done countless times over the years since we only live 1.1 mile away from this location. The employee I spoke too was very short with me and refused to process my order for delivery. Her only response was "The manager says no", without further explanation. Confused about why they suddenly wouldn't deliver (which they've done tons of times before) I asked to speak with the manager, who became unnecessarily and extremely rude to me. The more polite I tried to be, the more rude he became with me. His responses were rude, abrupt, and dismissive. He actually told me that he didn't care if I took my business elsewhere and that it didn't matter to him. I completely understand that places are very short-staffed right now. I didn't even mind that they were unable to deliver to my house, but the way the manager spoke to me was completely uncalled for. Gave one star because it's required. read more

Good pizza - good cheese, good crust, etc. Pretty good salad too (for people that like "normal" salads with iceberg lettuce. The do put the pepperoni under the cheese, which I never understand, but it still tasted very good. The reason I didn't give a 5 star is that they don't seem to understand that a pizza is supposed to be cut into slices ... instead they cut it into awkward, differently shaped & sized strips, which was incredibly annoying (80% of crust on 4 "strips", major difference in size of each strip, etc.).. The rest of the world seems to understand that cutting circular pizzas into slices is the right way to do it, but I've now seen this pizza strips idiocy in both Ohio and Indiana. ... am I missing something here? read more

TERRIBLE! Very very greasy. Had 1 slice and lets just say my stomach was upset for hours!! A few of my co-workers have the same problem. Just moving here they informed me that Volcano's uses cheese made with goat milk. Not sure if that was the issue but I would NOT recommend. Stick with a pizza chain. read more

So the meatball sandwich is not a meatball it's more of a meat patty. With the works the green peppers are raw, who does that? The Italian beef is not what you expect if your from Chicagoland so be aware. Oh, if you want a delivery you HAVE to order a pizza, lame! So we ordered a small sausage which was more like ground beef and the pizza was cut like cheese sticks from Little Caesar's. Good luck if you call this the best pizza joint in Elkhart. read more

I've lived in multiple states over the years and this is my favorite pizza of all time. The crumbled sausage is excellent, small pepperonis, quality cheese, cross cut slices, and great sauce. The cheese can get greasy on top, but just blot it with paper towel and get over it. They also have an amazing hot ham and cheese sub and the bread sticks are awesome. Whenever I return to Elkhart I must eat here within the first day or so. Until then I can only daydream about that wonderful unique bready smell when you first walk in to pick up your take out order. MMMM! read more

New to the area so yesterday was my first time ever having Volcano Pizza. My boyfriend is from here and has always loved them. It was the best pizza I have ever had. I usually HATE pepperoni and will just eat a cheese pizza but their pepperoni pizza was to die for. We also got breadsticks with extra sauce and thank god we did. I've been dipping my pizza in the extra sauce because it's so good. The best part is how amazing the pizza still is the next day. I can't imagine eating pizza anywhere else. Also the staff was very friendly and helpful! I will definitely be back this Friday! read more

Volcano makes a good pie. The crust is decent, the ingredients seem average, and the taste is pretty good. I can't see anything great about this pizza, but it is better than some I've tried. The service is excellent...probably the strongest quality in my opinion. By no means is this a cheap pie, yes it is on the small side, but I feel it is worth the money you pay. I have yet to find a better pie in this community. So, for my money I will endorse Volcano and their pizza. read more

Good pizza, great sanwiches and breadsticks. If you're looking for a place that does it all hand/ home made. This is the place. My biggest dissapointment is that I don't live conveniently to any of the 3 stores. read more

If you are looking for a good thin crust greasy pizza, this place has it. The spaghetti is great, and if you want a good grinder sandwich and a salad to top it off, this is the place to go! read more

Love their Hawaiian Pizza! Wish that their breadsticks were made fresh THROUGHOUT the day, instead of just every morning. Little bit pricey, but it doesn't stop me from ordering at least a couple times a month! read more

The best breadsticks ever. I could just go over there right now! Even their red yummy sauce! If your a cheese person. You would love the pizza, and even the awesome breadsticks. read more

This would be a 5 star because the pizza is fantastic (I would recommend pepperoni and banana peppers btw )the only downside is that sometimes the pizza is burnt and it can be hard to get breadsticks but I would recommend read more

Best pizza ever. We drive over here several times a year for pizza. Makes us happy yea

I would give it 5 stars if it wasn't so impossible to eat. I was in a hotel, so no utensils were handy. The toppings, sauce, crust; simply amazing. They cut the pizza in long rectangle shapes though.....yeah. ..don't reinvent the wheel. Everything came off every slice so not once did I have a "real slice of pizza". Other than that. . Loved it. read more

Not very good pizza, and they cut it in a dumb way so every slice you grab all the toppings and cheese fall off the crust. The local gas station and even little Caesar's have better quality pizza than this place. I can't understand how or why this place is still open read more

I've been going to Volcano every since 1967 so I can say I know my Volcano pizza. I've noticed that they seem to be cutting back on the quality of the ingredients and these last two we got on Sunday (1 with meatballs, onions and mushrooms and one with pepperoni with 1/2 olives from Concord Mall store) tasted watered down, like the sauce had been watered down or the cheese wasn't right. A lot of money for 2 pizzas that were no better than fast food chain pizzas at 1/3 the cost. So disappointed. There are too many other good pizza places to go, so trying to cheapen the pizza is not the way to go, I would pay a little more for the real Volcano taste if you need to raise prices. read more

Eat at the easy shopping plaza weekly for office lunch. Food quality is always consistant and tasty as always.

Since my last review, the Poplar Court location has stepped up their game and the service has improved greatly. They finally have a great crew once again. Nice job! read more

This used to be my favorite pizza place around here , I would stop in a pick up pizza once a week on the way home from work , but after the horrible experience I had here last night , I will never go in there again. So I ordered dinner before I left work so I could pick up on the way home , when I arrive to pick up my pizza there is only one customer in front of me at the register , two employees are swiping and re-swiping his debit card that is not working as they are just chit chatting amongst themselves about personal issues , as if they were alone in the room . I'm standing there waiting my turn to pay when the pizza cook asks if he can help me and then takes my pizza off the hot stove and puts it on the counter in front of me where it stayed , getting colder , for the next 10 minutes. Ok so now after standing there for what felt like forever , I just wanted to pay for my room temperature pizza and go home to my wife ' I had been roofing for 12 hours that day , and I was starving. Now here goes the employee swiping my card over and over again , not working , he punches in the digits on my card , not working. The next thing he tells me is that MY CARD is not working and I will have to go to the ATM !!! OUTRAGEOUS!!!! My card is not the problem , it's the machine JUST LIKE THE CUSTOMER BEFORE Me !!!!! So now after being in there for 2o minutes , the manager , she tells me her name is SUE , says she can't help me even tho she totally knows I'm a regular customer too !!! When I tell her I want the owners phone number she would not give it , she took my phone number and told me someone would contact me today , WELL GUESS WHAT NOBODY CALLED !! VERY POOR CUSTOMER SERVICE!! I am sorry , I'm from New York and have worked in many family pizza places I KNOW AND HAVE SEEN GOOD CUSTOMER SERVICE AND THIS PERSON "SUE " NEEDS SOME TRAINING HOW TO TALK TO AND TREAT CUSTOMERS THE PROPER WAY !! it was a problem on their end not mine , I should have been given that darn pizza and sent on my way. NEVER GOING BACK. read more

Seriously, get the breadsticks. They are to die for! The pizza is great, but the breadsticks really make the meal. I would highly recommend it! read more

BEST breadsticks in the entire world!!!! Their pizza is good as well but I go for the breasticks. They only make so many sticks a day so once they are gone thats it. Gotta get there early read more

Sandwiches are good, breadsticks are great(but they don't sell them on the weekend). Kinda dumb! Pizza was very over priced. Over $36 for a 14" sausage pep and 1/2 banana pepper and 12" with pep on half. That was carry out... Should have ordered Bruno's! read more

Love this pizza! Wish they made a gluten free crust tho. But it's always been a staple at our house. When I was able to eat wheat I also loved the meatball sandwich. I'll periodically check to see if they ever make a GF crust! read more

Best pizza EVERRRRRR!!! I drive in from Chicago for this pizza , breadsticks & sandwiches,,,,,sooooo good!,,,

I grew up on Volcanos, but on a recent visit to Elkhart, stopped by the location on Bristol street. The worst service, worst attiitude from employees I have ever encountered. Crossing them off my list for all future visits, other pizza in town, might not be as good, but there is no way the service could be as bad. read more

One of my favorite pizzas in the area. The flavor and consistency hasn't changed since i was a kid and that is something to be proud of.

I love Volcano pizza, however, I went there today and when I asked about my pizza being done as it was not done when I was told, the woman snapped at me. Don't appreciate being snapped at when I'm spending money to eat out. Not good!! This was at Poplar Court and I won't be going back to that one!! read more

I dont know what people see in this place?... Normally local pizza joints are great, but not here! VERY greasy, TOO much sauce, the crust is soggy and limp as can be and the sausage is horrible. Just save your money and go elswhere. read more

This is the best pizza I have ever had. Every time I go up north to Elkhart I make sure to have some Volcanoes pizza. I also love how the pizza is cut it's just great and makes for great leftovers. I also love how they put the toppings under the cheese. The bread sticks are great when you can get them and the sauce is very good too. read more