Pizza is delicious. The cheesy garlic bread and fried mushrooms are my favorite appetizers. The service is excellent.

Unfortunately this is some of the worst pizza I've ever had. Sweet sauce. Gross wings. Oh well.

Haven't been here in a while so I ended up ordering a few different things to try! The salads look great and are really fresh! The pizza is decent as well! They have a thin and regular crust option. The pizza sauce is definitely in the sweeter side! I got the regular crust and it was nice. I also ordered some spaghetti and chicken Alfredo which were good. The meatball sub and fries however were the best I have had in a long time! The meatballs taste fresh and homemade and the fries they come with are a perfect pairing! Support local! read more

Had Starlite pizza tonight for the first time. We ordered the Starlite special, and dang is it good! The sauce is a little on the sweeter side, but it's so yummy. Will definitely order again. read more

Starlite Pizza - Starlite Special Pizza - Pizza Near Me - South Bend, Indiana

This is a must-stop restaurant when we visit South Bend. The pierogis are made like my grandmother's. Nice family-owned joint with great customer service! read more

Yuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuckyyy This is the worse pizza I've ever had in my entire life. Torinos is better and less expensive. I mean Jesus- my son could create pizza better than this and he's 6. This has to be some sort of joke If it isn't Please turn in your pizza license immediately. Ewwwwwwwwww ! read more

Excellent food, and great service! We will definitely be back bringing friends along next time.​

It was on the west side of South Bend, but it is closed permanently. For pizza wasn't close to the original greasy jeans pizza from starlight that was on Western Avenue, but the pierogies were pretty good. read more

Purchased two large pizzas 1 Hawaiian and the other supreme. They used bacon bits instead of just bacon which alters taste. They used to make pizza right but not anymore. After spending 40$ on two pizzas they did not even bother to cut the pizza. read more

Starlite Pizza - a hand holding a piece of bread - Pizza Near Me - South Bend, Indiana

See all

we went there for the 1st time tonight. we ordered from the menu and when we got the bill the prices for the meatball sandwich and the spaghetti was 14.56 instead of 11.00. we asked the server and he said oh these are old menus. I asked if it would be fixed and he said no we just haven't gotten around to getting new menus. if you go there check the menu prices. We won't be back. Food was not that great wither. read more

Absolutely love Starlite Pizza! The thin crust with the slightly sweet sauce is their signature. We ordered pizza on a busy Sunday night and when I got there to pick up our to go pizza they had a full house. It looked like two large parties celebrating inside the restaurant seating area. I ask if they could make up two side salads, which I hadn't ordered over the phone with the pizza and they were so accommodating. They made the salads up right away while I waited and were sure to put our pizza back on the warmer. Can't say enough good about the fantastic ambiance, food and customer service. We are fortunate to have this restaurant on the south side of South Bend! read more

Try their Philly Steak sandwich is the best around. My husband loves their mushroom pierogi.

Amazing food! Had the Italian combo, all of the items tasted great. The pizza was also fresh and flavorful! Not very talkative, but hey I'm ok with that! I highly recommend giving them a try! Had to edit the review to say, I just saw them kneading fresh dough! Wow! read more

Starlite Pizza - Pepperoni, ham, bacon pizza - Pizza Near Me - South Bend, Indiana

Best Pizza this side of Chicago! The little bit of sweetness in the sauce makes it different (better) than anywhere around! Definitely worth trying if you haven't already. It's a Sunday night must at our house. Try the bread sticks with cheese or deep fried ravioli as an appetizer! You'll thank me later read more

Its, okay. Usually get the shits but kinda worth it. Granger one is better but its still pretty good.

Pierogi was amazing! The people were so kind and the service was quick! We will be back that's for sure! We were here many years ago one time but never went back till now! We will be back that's a promise! This trip made up for the past visit by far!!!! Thank you! read more

Starlite Pizza - a half eaten piece of pizza on a black plate - Pizza Near Me - South Bend, Indiana

All I can say is you need to bring this up to Grand Rapids, please! We stopped by on our way home from vacation. Best pizza I have ever had. Beside the chain restaurants; I have tried all the pizzas shops in and around west Michigan. Star lite is the very best 10 s the crust is thin and crispy. The sauce mwah the best tangy and sweet with just enough spice.Loaded with the best cheese!! It's a 2 hour drive, I'll be back!! read more

I would have given 5 stars but we had a delivery and asked for sauce on the side for the wings. sauce was on the wings. the wings were cooked well and the mild buffalo sauce was good. just wish it had been on the side. the pizza was excellent. nice thin crust and the ingredients were so good. ham, bacon and pineapple that was so tasty. we will definitely order from starlet again. read more

I grew up eating this pizza at the orginal location on Western Avenue. I love this pizza. The crust's thin and just the right crisp. The sauce... where to begin it does have a hint of sweetness. I love it. Can't wait for my next trip to South Bend! read more

Update your YELP account. Delivery is advertised, and when I called they mentioned they dont do delivery. Anything on any APP or advertisement should be upto date. So moving to a more reliable pizzeria like Papa John's or Pizza Hut, at least with them you know what you can expect. read more

Absolutely best pizza place I have ever been to. The ownernis absolutely fabulous. He always waits on us when we come in and is on top of everything. We never have to wait long periods of time and we have never had an issue with our order. Definitely recommend this place. read more

Eat here whenever we are in the area. We've never been disappointed. Great pizza, great sauce, great service. Must try the breadsticks. We've heard the perogi's are great, we will need to try them soon. Buy a large pizza and take some home!! read more

Starlite Pizza - We love this place after a baseball game. - Pizza Near Me - South Bend, Indiana

Great, locally owned pizza place on the South Side of South Bend. The crust which is freshly made, is thin and soft. The Pizza sauce is more on the sweet side. Offers a variety of different dining options including pasta dishes. The Cheese Pierogi, which is a meal in itself, also has a sweet taste.The service is pretty good and there is a selection of beers as well as typical domestics. read more

Just ok pizza. The sauce is really sweet, so know that up front. The crust is on the bland side. The amount of onions they put on is wayyy too much. The sausage is flavorless. The cheese was just ok. I more than likely will go somewhere else for our next pizza. read more

Wife hates it I love it, the sauce is what gets me the sweetness with the greasy crisp crust all that good stuff just dripping from it it. I love it reminds me of home back in St. Louis. Give it a try you'll either love it or hate it no in between. read more

This Ian the second time I have called in over an hour before closing only to be told that they were done taking orders for the night. Good pizza but really poor service. read more

Great pizza but over priced for what you get. Lack of toppings is the biggest issue. I shouldn't be able to count my pepperoni slices with both hands. read more

Starlite is yummy. This joint had unique pizza. Sauce is sweeter than most and crust is thin but still almost spongy, not crispy. Good toppings and overall it is pretty tasty. We recently tried to Buffalo chicken pizza and thought that was great too. read more

It's OKay pizza. Haven't had a bad experience, but nothing spectacular. Their sauce is sweet, which I like but not every time I eat pizza. Also, be warned not to order a pizza with onions. I like onions, but they put it on like cheese! Way too much!! read more

I have been eating Starlite pizza since I was a child and am happy to pass the tradition on with my wife and son at this location. If we are ordering pizza, I would estimate that 4 out of 5 times, we are ordering Starlite. The pizza is incredibly unique and delicious. The sauce can definitely be described as "sweet" but is very good with toppings that always taste fresh. I have never had a bad experience nor have I ever had an order be incorrect. The staff are very curteous and friendly. Pizza's ordered for pick-up are ALWAYS ready before their estimated time. Although it is a small location, dining in is a fun experience as well. It is quiet with very attentive staff. Perfect for a family outing or group of friends getting together for dinner. Highly recommend. This place is one of South Bend's best local pizza establishments. read more

I loved Starlite on western ave. we thought we would try the one on Ireland rd. It is disgusting. nothing like the original. The sauce is so sweet it is sickening(even sweeter than the original), barely had cheese on it and the crust was like something sold at the grocery store wrapped in plastic. The peirogie was ok. Will never go back! read more

Best pizza and wings in town! This is a family owned business and they always remember our names! The pizza has a sweet taste with a thin crust and just the right amount of grease:) My husband raves about the hot sauce on the wings.. We don't get pizza from anywhere else! read more

Don't know how to rate this pizza place but I hear they have good pizza. But everytime I go by it's always closed

I tried the pizza a bit ago - pizza was good - my only issue was how sweet the sauce was - weird

The service was excellent, but I was not a huge fan of the sauce. That's just my preference, my husband liked it.

Delicious pizza! Much better than you could get at a chain! Love supporting a local business!

Love that pie! Thin crust is super thin, while the thick crust is more like New York style rather than deep dish. Sauce is sweet. I usually go for meat toppings because they overdo the veggies. read more

Food was ok, manager/waitress was more involved with her cell than the customers. Not impressed with the service.