Wow!!! We're wishing we woukd have checked this place outt sooner. The owner treated us like royalty with special made pizzas for each of us. Also treated us to bread sticks. It felt like a pizza bar. We will be back for sure! read more

See all

Great pizza! We love the red sauce and how flavorful the crust is. All in all we will b back. PLUS don't forget to get the Freshieez app. read more

Freshieez - Sausage mushroom with extra sauce - Pizza Near Me - Elkhart, Indiana

First time eating at Freshieez. We were welcomed by owners Steve and Brooke who were very friendly and explained the menu to us to ensure we got the very best pizza and experience. The pizza was amazing! We also loved the ties to other community businesses and the community "buy a meal, take a meal" program for those in need. We'll be back! read more

Ordered delivery for a taco pizza and bread sticks! And it was so good! So many toppings and tasted so fresh! Loved all of it! -Carly read more

WOW is all I can say. This might be the best pizza I have ever eaten. Thanks Freshieez!! read more

Freshieez - Pizza Near Me - Elkhart, Indiana

Got our first carryout order last night. Loaded chicken bites, bread sticks, a thin and crispy meat lovers (Roof Monkey pizza), and a deep dish. So let's start from the top. Chicken bites were fantastic. A nice bite from the jalapeños. The bread sticks were tasty. Tried a variety of dipping sauces. Pro tip - skip everything else and get the honey sriracha. That stuff ROCKS. I may go sometime and just get 5 servings of that, go somewhere else and get some sweet potato fries, and go to town. The thin and crispy was thin, but not overly crispy. Great flavor, though. 9/10. But the star of the show was the deep dish, which was cooked in a cast iron pan. 3 different cheeses, pepperoni, sausage, bacon, onion, mushrooms. Holy CRAP, that thing is a beast. In a good way. Leftovers for days. I suggest re-cutting each piece as you take it out, because the molten cheese will re-fuse and you'll destroy the piece getting it out. The only negative thing I can really say is that their Alfredo dipping sauce is meh at best. Pretty bland and flavorless. But honestly, that's pretty nitpicking. And the wrap up? If for no other reason, support Freshieez for their involvement in the community. Yeah, you can get pizza for cheaper at some soulless chain. But Papa John's isn't going to sponsor your kid's little league team. If you want pizza made with love from people involved in their community, this is your new to-go spot. read more

Freshieez - Pizza Near Me - Elkhart, Indiana

It was a great pizza. Will order from them again it was great. Will order again. First time ever that I have had your pizza. read more

Freshieez - The Freesia Pizza 12" - Pizza Near Me - Elkhart, Indiana

The food is amazing. Everything is fresh and you can definitely taste it. Very large portions too. I got the crust less pizza and a salad. It was 3 meals for me. The lady that helped us (I think she was the owner) was so friendly and personable. We talked the whole time while she made our lunches to perfection. Two thumbs up! We will definitely be back!! read more

Freshieez - Crust less pizza - Pizza Near Me - Elkhart, Indiana

Everything they have is amazing they have an amazing staff all friendly the ice cream area is fantastic the pizza is nice and very filling for the price and they let people sing outside sometimes it's the best pizza place I've ever went to read more

Excellent taste and very pleasant staff. We'll definitely return. The stuffed crust is unlike any before.

I've seen some pretty delicious looking pictures online showing off all of Freshieez yummy eats, so I thought it was high-time I gave them a whirl. Ordered via DoorDash last night three pizzas.. one pepperoni, one Hawaiian, and one custom (sausage, bacon, onion, black olives). Also picked up a side of breadsticks as an accompaniment. Everything was delicious! We tried a few of their sauce offerings, the mango habinero sauce was our favorite! Only thing I didn't particularly care for was the garlic butter dip & the Freshieez spread, both I thought to be lacking a tad in flavor. But that's definitely not enough to deter a future visit, we will for sure be back! read more

My first time here. I. WILL. BE. BACK!!! I met Steve and Adrian. Good guys who are proud of each and every item they make. Their secret...everything fresh and made with love. You can't go wrong with anything and everything you order. I tried the meatball "sandwich". OMG! This Chicago Italian heard the angels sing with each bite. Thanks guys. Great job on very tasty food. See you soon! read more

I do not understand the "hype". Waited almost 2 hours for a carry out order of at $150. Upon arrival they said "we are running behind, it'll be another 20 minutes. Do you still want your order?" (We already paid...) Fast forward to waiting IN SHOP for another hour... They don't have a pizza warmer, so alllll the pizza and desserts we ordered were getting cold. Finally ask about it, and she sets them on top of the oven. One girl said "your pizza is all ready, just needs to be cut". Then 10 minutes later another one said "your pizza is all in the oven". Very unorganized. Management needs to be addressing these issues and training appropriately if they want to be a successful business. ***I wrote this review on the FB page. The owner responded "I will be definitely looking into all comments of your review from times ordered and through the cameras and process. This is very alarming to me and all aspects. Thank you for your review." And I have never heard from the again. read more

The crust is flavorful and crisp. They do not skimp on toppings at all. It seems like just the right amount of cheese and the sauce tastes fresh and definitely not from some can in the back. The bread chips were flavorful however they were nothing too special. Overall I think this is one of the better pizzas in Elkhart and you should give it a try. read more

See all

I ordered a pizza online they sent a message saying thank you for ordering and when the pizza would be delivered. I downloaded the slice app to track my pizza. It said it was done and out for delivery. I waited another 15 before calling nobody answered. Then I get a notice from slice saying they had to cancel my order because they were no longer open. What happened to the pizza they made me and charged me for. Supposedly I will be getting a refund on two days. I will never try to order from them again. read more

It was OK. The staff were some of nicest people we have met. Went there on a Monday night. The pizza was so-so. It is a thin crust. The one thing I did not care for was the sausage and some of the other toppings were crumbled up very very small. You really couldn't taste them much. I like to be able to taste the sausage, green peppers, ham, etc. It was pizza, had better, had worse.​ read more

First-time customers today and we'll definitely be back. Friendly, clean business with the best pizza we've had in forever. Definitely worth the drive from Goshen to pick up! (Husband kept it toasty warm with the seat heater.) Bread chips with garlic sauce and apple/blueberry chips with cinnamon dip nicely rounded out the meal. Can't wait to work our way through the rest of your menu! read more

Heard about them for months. Drive by all the time. Was short on time so I stopped by. Got a sub (think calzone) and the bread chips. Both were absolutely outstanding. I ordered for my office tomorrow. It's fantastic and I am completely impressed. They are obviously making dough daily onsite. Talked with one of the owners for 30 minutes and was very impressed by her and one of her employees attentiveness. I have high hopes they will be hanging out a long time! read more

I ordered several pizzas recently. The price was very reasonable. They were on time and the pizzas were absolutely delicious! We were very impressed! We will be ordering from them again! read more

Really nice people and great pizza! Highly recommend the cream cheese garlic sauce, the garlic bread, and the pizza was awesome!

a lot of people on facebook recommended this new pizza restaurant, raving with the claim it was the best pizza in this area. i have worked in a pizza restaurant for over 15 years, in another state, so, i kind of know what a good pizza should taste like. so, i tried this place, i will not be returning. the pizza i ordered was a simple sausage pepperoni pizza, but the sausage tasted like it was breakfast sausage instead of italian sausage. if the locals think this is the best pizza available in the area, i guess i need to remove pizza from my diet. read more