Did carry out pizza. Probably the best pizza I have had in ages. Friendly people on phone & at pickup. Will definitely be going back. Toppings were tasty. Had sausage & black olives. Plenty of cheeses tangy sauce & a crust that tasted good. Not to think but not too thin read more

Love their combo pizza definitely the best in town! The portions are huge, even an extra small easily feeds two or more. It's a long standing, family run Italian spot, and while the owner can be a bit gruff, he's clearly dedicated and keeps things running smoothly with his family team. read more

Milano’s Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Elkhart, Indiana

Delicious, homemade style food and a relaxing atmosphere! I had the lasagna and my wife had a calzone both with homemade noodles. So good! read more

Milano’s Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Elkhart, Indiana

Great food especially the pizzas always hot and they use quality cheese not the waxy cheap stuff.

The food is GREAT . Everything is really good. Thanks Ernie, Scott A-1 Commercial Roofing.

Was up to try a new pizza place so we decided on Milano's since it had decent reviews. Ordered the 18" large Combination with regular crust. When I got it home opened up the box and the pizza looked and smelled great. Went to get a piece out of the box and the dough was extremely wet and mushy. Looked underneath the dough to find foil as the pizza insert. Foil does not osborb juices so instead of an insert obsorbing the moisture the dough did. The business is cutting cost in not paying for pizza inserts but the customer pays the price with a soggy dough. Not bad flavoring in the pizza but nothing sets it apart from any Dominos or Pizza Hut and they are much cheaper. Could not give a review on the dough because it was mushy from the pizza. 2 stars because I could not even get a piece of pizza out of the box with good crust. Was like eating a lunch meat sandwich with soggy bread. Not Good !! read more

I love their pizzas, but I don't love getting charged for an item. I asked for on it like garlic.. three months ago I ordered one with garlic. It had none on it. I started getting my pizzas from Paesello's pizzeria in Goshen and when I ordered garlic, it was like eating garlic bread like I used to get from Milano's. I Loved. Milano's pizza and I thought I'd give them another chance when I ordered my pizza again and asked for garlic on it. I was charged for it, but there was no garlic on the pizza this second time.. I would've given one star, but I gave two more stars because I love their pizza. I am tired of being disappointed on my pizza order so I guess I will go back to getting my pizzas in Goshen, Indiana again. read more

Called for pizza delivery. They don't deliver to the address we were at....we were 6 miles from them. Their website says they deliver Elkhart and Goshen..they don't! read more

Milano’s Pizza - Their delivery cities - Pizza Near Me - Elkhart, Indiana

Best pizza place in the world they always make it right for me hot and that xtra cheese is so good and halopenos can't spell service is amazing read more

Love their pizza. One of the best in Elkhart. Sausage , Pepperoni, and Jalapeno is the way.

Ordered over $100 worth of assorted pizzas. Don't know if they were baked correctly or not but these were by far the worst pizzas I've ever had. The first bite the whole topping came off. What a mess. Every pizza was like this. Soft and chewy and read more

Good lasagna, ordered small size that does not include a salad, does come with a baked fresh loaf of excellent bread and real salted butter. Service was good on a slow night. Merlot came a tab more chilled than usual. read more

Milano’s Pizza - Interior - Pizza Near Me - Elkhart, Indiana

See all

Love,love,love their pizza. Moved out of the area and wish I could have the pizza shipped. It's is always cheesy, loaded with toppings and cooked to perfection. read more

Y'all missing out if you never had them! There huge for a large pizza and the sauce is excellent it ain't sweet

Ordered a carry out pizza. Hot and ready when I picked it up and more costly than their website advertised (my biggest gripe). Dough wasn't too thick, sauce tasty and a good ratio of cheese to toppings. Much like all the other relatives who have pizza places in town a very nice pizza. read more

The pizza was delicious! The app sampler was great too. Pitcher of beer for 8 bucks, couldn't go wrong. Good place to go! read more

Great food! My only complaint is every time I am ordering over the phone the man taking the order does not have good customer service qualities. He makes me uncomfortable to the point I don't order from them as much as I would like. read more

Enjoyed a delicious and huge calzone this evening (I always forget to take pictures). Milano's food is always so good. The kids menu items are completely worth checking out. It is a good place to go for a quiet meal with good service! read more

The best pizza! The baked mostaccioli is delicious and the portions are huge! Great homemade food. read more

Milano’s Pizza - the outside of a restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Elkhart, Indiana

Overpriced=Italian Italian=Overpriced. That seems to be the theme with Italian restaurants. Food is okay, it's not bad but seems like your not getting what you paid for. Simply overpaying because it's Italian. read more

Amazing pizza, wonderful employees, great atmosphere, and authentic italian cuisine! The first time I was there was two days ago, and it was amazing! We ordered breadsticks for a starter, and they came out immediately, nice and warm! Then, we ordered a regular cheese pizza, and I must say, the best cheese pizza I ever had! The service was great, and the food, delicious! read more

By far one of the best Italian pizzas around. Hands down. Haven't tried many other things like sandwiches or pastas but the pizza has to be one of the best in Elkhart. read more

In Elkhart, Indiana...you have to eat here! It is a small family owned restaurant that the owners are originally from Italy, grandma makes the sauce. The pizza is delicious...and their size small pizza is a "typical" chain pizza restaurant size large. We've been going to this place for years! My family's favorite is the pepperoni with shaved beef. The have spaghetti, calzones, etc. It's very friendly and laid back. Btw..their sausage is on the spicier side. read more

Pizza is the only thing we will ever get from here. We've tried dining in the restaurant twice and it somehow managed to get even worse the second time! Service was HORRID, which matched the food (I've honestly had better frozen entrees.), and the whole place is super outdated. I am surprised the pizza is as delicious as it is, but I can't lie....these people make an exceptional pie! read more

Pizza is great and they deliver! I haven't been inside in over a decade, but the foods good, especially for the price!

Amazing place! Ordered a manicotti and an Alfredo pasta along with an extra large two topping pizza. The food was very amazing. As a New Jersey resident who tries lots of pizza, I was impressed by the quality of the pizza. It was thick, cheesy, and well cooked! The manicotti was delicious, especially the sauce. And the Alfredo pasta was amazing also. The sauce was light and not that oily compared to places like red lobsters. My family and I were very pleased with the food. The server was kind and the service was rapid. Decor from outside and inside is a little tacky, but the food is worth going in for! read more

This is the best pizza in town. If you are some today it will taste the same years from now. The owner will do all he can to keep it tasting the same year after year. That is a great incentive to keep coming back. They also have great pasta too! Try this place if you never have. You will find your new favorite spot! read more

Very disappointing experience from start to finish. There were 3 ladies working but yet only one was running around taking orders, bringing food out and giving checks. The other 2 were mostly walking around aimlessly. We didn't want pizza so we ordered fettuccine Alfredo and a manicotti, plus an appetizer. Our salads came drowning in ranch but under the dressing was wilted/dying lettuce. Our appetizer came about 5 minutes before our meal, we wouldn't have ordered it if we knew it was basically coming with our dinner. The manicotti was good. The fettuccine was a mess. We had paid extra for 6 flavorless shrimp to be added on top. The noodles were crunchy, and stuck to each other as if someone tossed them into a pot to cook and never stirred. My husband ate the shrimp but couldn't eat the crunchy pasta. Waitress came at the end and asked if we wanted a box. We told her no which prompted her to ask why. We told her the pasta was crunchy. The waitress then proceeded to lecture us, loudly so other tables could hear and stare, that this is an Italian restaurant and Italians like their pasta AL dente and Americans like theirs soft and we just didn't know what we're talking about. No apologies, no offer of a discount. My husband had a plate full of pasta that he tried 2 bites of and didn't want to take it home, obviously he didn't like it. The dish was $20 which included the extra $4 for the flavorless shrimp. We had to ask a couple times for the check and when it was brought out we waited about 10 minutes before we finally just got up and tracked down a waitress to finally ring us up. read more

Milanos is always great and they're one of the only places open on Mondays but when I went to get a pizza tonight at 840 they had already told me they were closed and they usually close at 9 and it was extremely disappointing read more

Pizza is excellent. Customer service is bad. When mistakes are made, the manager gets real snippy and tries to justify mistakes. A few months ago I ordered pizzas and the arrived an hour and a half late, so 2 and a half hours AFTER I originally ordered. They were also cold, so I called and was told I could get a free pizza next time I ordered. Well 2 weeks later I call to redeem my free pizza and I was acussed of lying by the manager because my name wasn't written on a board. 15 minutes into a very unprofessional conversation with the manager he agree to give me a pizza for $10 but I had to come get it. I stayed away for a couple months after that experience. Well today I ordered pizza and bread sticks, they forgot my bread sticks, no biggie.. the driver says he'll bring them right back. So here we are over an hour later waiting on bread sticks. I call and the manager says "well the driver is busy, he'll get there when he gets there". They really need to practice better customer service. After these experiences I will no longer order from here, which sucks because the pizza is great but the hassle and attitude isn't worth it. read more