Goodfello's is exactly what a neighborhood pizza place should be. Great food, generous portions,…read moreand staff that actually makes you feel welcome. Three local guys running a scratch kitchen and it shows in every bite. Whether you're dining in or grabbing takeout, this place never disappoints. Easily the best pizza in Zelie.

For a busy night during Miracle on Main, this place pushed out good food quickly! I had the Cajun…read morechicken sandwich and it was excellent. I loved the spice, and the bread was so fresh. I really enjoyed the flavors. My wife got a chicken salad. It was a large portion with lots of fixings. The pizza was good and hot! Just a heads up - they don't do call ahead, so expect a little bit of a wait. But a wait is a good thing - it must mean they're doing something right if people are willing to wait in Zeli... a place with multiple other great restaurants!

Stopped in here on a Saturday afternoon for the first time since this location opened. Were…read morepleasantly surprised to find a band setting up to play outside! We found a table in the shade and had a great late day meal. Started with the spinach/artichoke dip which was hot and tasty and then shared a white pizza. With the live entertainment it was busy inside and out but the service was great! At one point someone came out and passed around garlic knots to everyone which was a nice surprise! They have several local beer varieties on tap to choose from. Looking forward to our next visit!

Four of us dined here for a late lunch a week ago. The food was OK We did not care for the beans…read moreand greens made with kale as we are used to escarole Other than that the food was ok. Service was good, my fav bartender Dee was off that day unfortunately

We enjoyed our experience here on a warm Sunday evening. It was surprisingly busy so we sat at the…read morebar and were promptly greeted by our bartender. It was a nice atmosphere inside. We made it just in time for happy hour so ordered the Iris drink and a beer. For food we had the meatballs, fried artichokes and a mini mortadella pizza all on special for happy hour. It was fun to watch the pizza being cooked on the wood fired oven. Everything was very good though the meatballs could have been served warmer. The fried artichokes were really delicious. We enjoyed our evening and round definitely return.

Let's keep this short! Restaurant is in an old Mellon bank…read morebuilding. Food was excellent. Definitely order the fried artichoke, greens and beans appetizer. Unfortunately, the service didn't match the food. The waitress took our order and the service slowed after that. After dinner, she cleared only a few dinner plates and asked if we wanted dessert, brought the dessert menu _. but still left the remaining dinner/salad plates on the table.

AMAZING Place. Great Food Great Drinks Great Service. Hannnah, Vanessa and Justin made it a evening…read moreto remember. The service is second to none....just a top notch experience

We came because it's advertised as dog friendly. They have a couple of tables on the sidewalk out…read morefront you can occupy but doesn't give you a lot of room so beware if you have large animals. The burgers are well worth it on burger night and the fries are good. The Mac 'n cheese was not as good nor the Mexican street corn. We will be back but will stick with the burgers. 2 smash patties that taste great.

Took the recommendations from Yelp and ordered to-go after a long day of travel. So glad we…read morelistened!! Two pizzas and a focaccia bread were amazing. Great crust, great flavor, fresh topping and wood fired. Staff was friendly when we picked up as well!

Credit where credit is due. After my second visit, all of the kinks have been ironed out and they…read moredelivered some of the best neopolitan pizza (and desserts) I've had in a LONG time. Each was perfectly seasoned and cooked, and I especially loved the "The White Buffalo" pie. And to top it off, friendly service again. Feel flvery lucky to have this spot close to home.

Online ordering was easy. Was ready in the time frame provided. Pizzas were made just as ordered…read more Fantastic, delicious pizza!

Friendly service, the food is good. I just wish the appetizers came out before the pizza. The…read morerestaurant is always clean.

I went for lunch with my husband and this place did not disappoint…read more We ordered the lunch combo that comes with a personal pizza and a salad of your choice. The pizza was crunchy but not stiff, I ordered the Margherita one and it was so good. The pizza was a but oily but that didn't bother me at all. I enjoyed the sauce, basil and cheese quality so much. The portion sizes were perfect. I was not a fan of the salad dressing however as it was too oily. The service and ambiance were good as well; Just an Italian restaurant vibe. I think this will be a regular place for me.

Correcting my review, place is a staple been a lot since my 3 star and it's very goodread more