Pretty solid pizza! My friend suggested getting the extra pepperoni and I'm glad she did! It's the good pepperoni that curls up and gets crunchy! Great stuff! read more

Supremo's Pizzeria - Extra pep - Pizza Near Me - Mars, Pennsylvania

Good food Great people and good service and delivery people at Callery Store on Mars Evans City Road read more

Pizza delivered to the door is always tricky business. No longer is it 'hot from the oven' with the cheese and topping at peak perfection. Delivery pizza is judged by far different standards and for me, the leading standard is the crust. I love a yeasty crust that hasn't been worked to a point of toughness (pizza makers...stop overworking that crust!). It doesn't have to be piping hot. It does have to have good flavor. It can't be overcooked (aka burned or charred) and it absolutely cannot be soggy. We ordered four pies: a cheese with no sauce, a pepperoni and a veggie on regular crust and a ham&pineapple sicilian. The cheese and pepperoni pizzas were solid. Nice crust a tad overworked with a nice amount of cheese. The ham and pineapple had that thick crust and four corners. The dough did not knock us out though. The veggie was a bust. The crust was way undercooked and the toppings slid off as we tried to pull a slice to eat. We tried to cook it a bit more but it remained a kind of gooey mess. The toppings were good so our disappointment was high. Maybe the veggies weren't drained enough or the pizza just didn't get to stay in the oven long enough. Either way, we would not order it again. read more

Consistently good pizza and hoagies Pittsburgh style. Always on time and friendly service.

Usually this supremos is pretty good. I had just picked up an order from the callery location. Ordered a detroit style pizza and some apps. I have to say if people in Detroit eat pizza like this I feel real bad for them. First off the cheese in the center of the pizza was stuck to the lid. Then the slices are all dough. In all fairness i did not contact them because I am about half hour away when I opened the box. Just going to take this one as a loss. Edit to this review. After posting this review I recieved a call from Supremos (i apologize for not remembering name). The had apologized for quality and asssured me that they will make it right. Now that right there is something I value more then the price of the pizza itself. Caring about the customer. Thank you read more

Supremo's Pizzeria - a piece of pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Mars, Pennsylvania

See all

Just tried some Supremo's for the first time today for lunch. I am not too familiar with the pizza competition in Mars, or any restaurants in this area for that matter, so I can't say how it compares to other local spots. However, based on the other places I've eaten at near the Pittsburgh area, their pizza is just very average. Location is somewhat small and in a plaza. I decided to try out the classic cheese pizza (because if you can't nail a delicious cheese pie, you won't nail the more sophisticated pies). The prices are pretty awesome, I will say that. You can get a personal sized pie for just $6, and there is a way to order online from them directly. But, flavor-wise, the food is still pretty mediocre. They have a somewhat thick crust, cheese that's only average, and not enough tomato sauce in my opinion. Nothing stood out, but it wasn't bad. It did have a slightly stale flavor as well. There are a few interesting items I found on the menu, but didn't order this time. They have nice desserts like the Cookie Bash (tons of chocolate and Oreo) as well as a Mississippi Mudslide Pie (not offered at most pizza places). Plus, the portion for the cinnamon bites is great and it's a great deal! All in all, this is an alright option for a quick snack, cheap dinner, or event when you need tons of pizza. They are a solid choice for catering or fundraising in the area (if you want cheap pizza, that is). Really good option in terms of prices! read more

Even with the special it was overpriced and hate to say not as good as expected. For the price it'd be nice not to skimp on the cheese

Tried takeout for the first time and was really good! Simple order of Cheese pizza and buffalo wings and both were great. Pizza sauce cheese and dough were very tasty and possibly the best pizza we've had in the cranberry area. Wings were crispy and buffalo sauce very tasty with just the right amount of heat. Looking forward to trying more of their menu. read more

We've lived here for about two years and have ordered from the Mars location roughly 40 times, after trying one other local pizza place. The pizza is good. Kids love it. Salads are pretty good, the buffalo chicken dough roll is a good value if you only want to spend $5 or so. The zucchini fries are excellent! The calzones were really good. The breadsticks are great. They have a family deal with two large cheese pizzas, a large order of breadsticks, and a 2-liter for $23.99. That's the correct play here. They give quite a bit to the local community, notably when a local family had a fire about a year ago. So we're generally happy to support the place. Delivery is usually pretty fast even during dinner hours, at least from the Mars location. No issues with cold food upon delivery. Never had any issue with service or delivery drivers, they're all cool and nice. Now, the bad stuff. The wings aren't really good by any standard, especially not when delivered (they get soggy looking and I have to throw them under the broiler for a few minutes). They're really small too. It's a joke to charge $12 for a dozen of them. Hoagies are hit or miss, but I just received a huge miss -- a meatball hoagie in which the meatballs were cut in half (see photo), so it was basically a bread and sauce hoagie. That's like 2.5 or 3 full meatballs for what is basically a $9 or $10 whole hoagie. Huge disappointment, blatant ripoff. Pretty sure this is a recent change, I don't recall getting half-meatballs in the past and I'm "want to speak to the manager" mad about it. The steak they use in their hoagies and salads is just...suspect. Strangely seasoned and not really steak-like -- avoid it. Again, we order from Supremo's frequently so it can't be that bad. The pizza is a good, reliable option in a pinch or when you don't feel like cooking. As for the other stuff, you're taking a chance with a lot of it. read more

Supremo's Pizzeria - Meatballs cut in half for a hoagie? Traaaaaaaash. - Pizza Near Me - Mars, Pennsylvania

Bread sticks are really good. Didn't even use the marinara. We then ordered the Sicilian pizza which is just ok. Not bad not wonderful. What's the best is that it is steps from On The Point Brewing where we were. We walked next door to order and pay and they walk the food to you. Had pretzel bites as well. They were pretty decent. Prices aren't bad and things were decent. read more

Supremo's Pizzeria - Sicilian - Pizza Near Me - Mars, Pennsylvania

See all

This place has great pizza! We tried it out a few days ago and were very pleased with both the food and the service. Returned today with a larger order for my birthday. Can't wait to try some hoagies from here! read more

Good customer service. They called and made corrections and will try again. Thanks for the follow up! read more

Supremo's Pizzeria - French bread pizza with mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Mars, Pennsylvania

BestHoagie in Mars..... season fry's are great and don't forget the cookie. so so good. delivery is very fast as well. It's not DoorDash they have drivers. read more

I love this place! The garden veggie pizza is so good! It's been my go to pizza order since I moved to the mars area. The crust is quality and so is the cheese. I like the salted caramel cheesecake too. I forgot to take a picture of that before I started eating. Whoops. read more

Supremo's Pizzeria - Veggie pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mars, Pennsylvania

The quality is horrible and when you call them on it, they say "we made it as you asked". When you just say, hey this is bad, just give me a refund, they just say no and walk away. While communities should be supporting local business, quality and poor customer service is no excuse. You should be doing your best, not giving crap and saying ohh well. There are plenty of other great places to get pizza in Mars. read more

Worst experience of my life!!!! Pizza was 2 hours late. Driver couldnt find my location!?! Owner gets on the phone with me cursing ME out!? Dont call my store again. Omg.... This place is a train wreck. Never got food or refund. read more

Just finished eating a large pepperoni & sausage pizza, and tried a personal sized spinach feta. Both were delicious. I can't speak for the older reviews on here that complain about delivery time since I picked mine up, but this was easily the best pizza I've had in this area. I've been looking for a new main pizza spot after being disappointed elsewhere, and I think I've finally found it. read more

Supremo's Pizzeria - Cute little baby spinach feta pizza! Tasted as great as it looks. - Pizza Near Me - Mars, Pennsylvania

Consistent and delicious. Our go to pizza place in the Mars area. Calzones are top notch as well. Huge added bonus that they are always clean and strictly follow Covid-19 requirements. I would definitely dodge the Sicilian crust though! The rest of their pizza is delicious. read more

The pizza is so delicious. We love their fry pie! They have THE best buffalo chicken pizza!

My wife and I ordered the 8 cut Sicilian pizza. It was very good and the perfect amount for the two of us. The sauce on the pizza was really good and the pizza was cooked and delivered in 30 minutes. I would highly recommend this place if you're looking for some good pizza. Delivery driver was very nice as well. read more

Supremo's Pizzeria - 8 cut Sicilian pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mars, Pennsylvania

We thoroughly enjoyed the pizza we ordered from Supremo's. Saucy, the right amount of toppings. You owe it to yourself to try this pizza.

Very good pepperoni pizza. My neice loves the steak salad. The ranch dressing is delcious.

AVOID. Like many restaurants and pizza dens... good food; terrible service. It's a pity, very good pizza and sandwiches, but the delivery time and management is HORRENDOUS. The last time that I ordered they dropped the ball and it took over 1.5 hours to receive two plain. Just now, I called up asking for a discount, forgetting that the manager had already given us the discount last time and he had the audacity to tell us that the last time we ordered it only took them 29 minutes to deliver (a blatant lie). He contradicted himself, as the last time he admitted to the 1.5 hours of deliver time, yet not tonight. Plus, he gave us the discount last time, so what does that tell you? It's Posti's and Cenci's for me from now on. Skip this joint! read more

We've eaten pizza from here for the last few years. I was disappointed during a recent take out visit when I asked for a few paper plates for my kids since we were eating in the car at the dance studio across the way. He responded abruptly that they are too expensive and they won't be buying them anymore. Customer service goes a long way....a drive down the road to another pizza shop will be worth the trip for me next time! read more

The Supremo's Pizzeria in Evans City is the only delivery pizza I'll order now. New to the area and after having tried the other options I was ready to give up on delivery altogether. Their crust is light, not over baked and the toppings are fresh. My son also agrees, they're the best pizza delivery in this area. read more

This is one of the few places that delivers to my house, but my lack of delivery options is not the reason I keep coming back. I've tried a ton on their menu and the only thing I wouldn't recommend is their wings. They are quite ordinary and when it comes to wings I want extraordinary. What I can give a big standing ovation for is the Italian sub and their calzones. You really cannot go wrong with these. Their pizza is great, but it's rather hard to mess up pizza. I consider myself a buffalo chicken pizza conesseuir and I wouldn't say it's the best, but it's better than a lot of other places I've been to. I definitely recommend Supremos for your pizza delivery needs if you live in their radius. Small town chain with big flavors! read more

We were away for awhile owing to a not so great experience over a year ago. This time they absolutely hit it out of the park. Five + stars on the quality of the pie that was delivered hot fresh and a few minutes ahead of time. This beats Lucianos, Mars Pizza, Pizza Roma HANDS DOWN. excellent in every respect. We are back and look forward to many more great Pizzqs from Supremo's. read more

Supremos is a staple in Mars. Their pizza is delicious and their wings are too. Consider trying the bread as well. The owners of Supremos are good to the local students...both by hiring them and being good managers and also by participating in local fund raisers. Their service is great. Always nice and on time. Definitely choose Supremo's for your local deliveries. read more

They seem to have a hard time following directions when you're allergic to something. I ordered a hoagie (2 of them) without one or two things. I get it to see they basically took everything I just said what I didn't want on the hoagies and threw it out the window ugh! How annoying! $25 down the hole! read more

Fresh and hot by delivery. Delivery was quick as well. Driver was polite. Kids loved the pizza and it was reasonable priced. If ever around that area again, I will be sure to order from there again! read more

Average pizza in my opinion. The dough doesn't match up to the big boys, Aiello's or Fiori's.

Called them with constructive criticism on their steak hoagie with clear intent to further their business. The owner said he would not deliver to me because I didn't like his hoagie as much as others i have had. In his words "I don't need your business." Avoid places like this at all costs. They have no interest in being the best or better. read more

This is our favorite pizza place in the area! The food is always hot, fresh, and made to our specifications! Love Supremo's!

This place is absolutely ridiculous, we ordered from them at least twice a week over the past year or so. We had company at our home and we're going to put in a $70 order and the manager would not give us any kind of deal. We even asked if he would give us just a $1 off after we asked and he said NO! Absolutely insane? I am a business owner and I always take care of my good customers. Sadly we are done with Supremo's. read more

Had take out at the new location on Mars Evans City Road on September 28th. Had a thin crust pizza with pepperoni and mushrooms which was terrible. Tasted like a bad frozen pizza, tasteless with what appeared to be cheap ingredients. I usually save left over pizza for the next day but this was so bad that most of the pizza went right in the trash can. Also, there is a "service charge" when order is placed on line. I asked what it was for and counter person said it was "traditional" in the industry for take out pizza. Not true, most other establishments do not add service charge. Maybe their other location is better but this new location better step up its game! read more

Tonight was our first time eating at Supremo's Pizzeria, and I'll admit that I was lured in by the prospect of frozen yogurt for dessert at their new sister store, MangoBean, next door. Their wings are the best that I've had in town! The mild had the perfect flavor of heat and tanginess without hurting your mouth. And my son devoured the sweet, dripping with BBQ sauce wings. Our pizza was hot, fresh, and a good deal with the coupon for a large deluxe pizza which included many toppings - pepperoni, sausage, onions, green peppers, mushrooms, and extra cheese. The crust is excellent. And, Supremo's is Mars' first BYOB restaurant. My husband packed two cans of beer and I brought a little something to add to my Coke. Everyone was happy, and it didn't break our budget. We had a great meal. Thanks! read more

Supremo's came to Mars in 2010 and is the best Pizza in town! They have expanded their menu and even have a kids menu. The dining room is quaint and very friendly. You have to try it. Ed read more

The food Is fantastic but the attitude that the older guy who I think is the owner was giving people from behind the counter, I will never spend a dime there again read more

My family eats here often on nights when we need a quick dinner. All of us love the pizza and are happy to support a local business. They have a big menu with lots of options so even the pickiest of people will find something they enjoy. My personal favorite is the buffalo chicken pizza, but I've also heard that if you want something different you can't go wrong with the frypie. Overall, I love it's my favorite pizza place in the Mars area. read more

We order from Supremos about once a month. Their thin crust cheese pizza is a favorite of my boys, and the Loaded Fry Pie is a worthy splurge. Easy online ordering and prompt delivery are also pluses. read more