Everything about this place is amazing. Flight of in house brews was awesome for the price. Burgers were excellent and waitress was awesome. We stayed in Mentone and this place is just right down the road. Try if you are in the area. read more

See all

Food was very good. Service was ok but our waitress seemed distracted at times. The decor is interesting and eclectic. There was live music about to start which was interesting because the dining areas are quit small. read more

Vintage 1889 - View of the restaurant in its previous life. Interesting! - New American Near Me - Fort Payne, Alabama

First let me say the place has a great vibe, and this is the kind of place I love to support, I just wish the experience had been better. Stopped in to take an employee to lunch and the place was not super busy, so I am not sure what the problem was. We were greeted, our drink orders taken and we asked for some fried pickles while we looked over the menu. A few minutes later we placed our order...... almost 20 minutes later our pickles showed up followed by our food not 30 seconds later, and everything was cold. Cold and bland. That's all I can say. read more

Vintage 1889 - Vibe - New American Near Me - Fort Payne, Alabama

See all

Visited Vintage 1889 (March 21, 2026) around 1:15 PM with my psychiatric service dog. She is a trained service animal that assists with my disability. Upon attempting to enter, I was immediately told no dogs were allowed. I explained that she is a legitimate service dog under the ADA, but access was still denied. As a result, we were unable to dine there. This appears to be a misunderstanding of ADA rules, which require public accommodations like restaurants to allow trained service animals (including psychiatric service dogs) in customer areas, without exceptions for "no pets" policies when the animal qualifies. The location has a nice historic charm and I've seen positive mentions of the food and atmosphere elsewhere, but this experience was disappointing and prevented me from enjoying the restaurant. I hope they update their approach to better accommodate people with disabilities in the future. read more

We had appetizers as our meal: chips and the triple dip, and a flat bread pizza (cut into 4 slices). Polite and attentive wait staff. Neat location. Eclectic decor that is fun to look at. read more

This is an amazing place! The food and drinks were incredible, the employees were so friendly and easy to have a conversation with and the overall vibe told me that this is the place to be. Also they have live music playing throughout the week and they are really good. This was by far the best meal I had during the week while I was in town. Highly highly recommend the key lime pie. read more

See all

We both had the Vintage burgers great flavor on a pretzel bun that came with fries. Wife decided to have a side salad which had lots of arugula lettuce, onions, tomatoes and cheese with ranch dressing. Our waitress was nice but needs to listen before running off. The restaurant had ample seating and they were setting up for live entertainment when we left. Food prices were good as was the menu choices. read more

Downtown Fort Payne. Started with the Artichoke dip. Not bad but definitely microwaved, it was stuck to the side of the bowl. But overall taste not bad. For main meal had the bbq burger. Ordered it medium. Came well done. Not very big, and not even sure it had bbq sauce on it. Taste was ave. Quality was below ave and overpriced some. read more

If I could give zero stars I would 1st and last time we will eat here. Waited an hour and 1/2 for our food barely checked on or had our drinks refilled no apologies for our wait I get it things happen if you are short staffed but at least check on your tables and try to make the experience so someone may come back and give you a second chance. Then had to ask for a copy of the check which was wrong just wanted to give me the little credit card machine to tap my card and had attitude to boot food was fine nothing that was worth the wait I could have driven to the store and home made dinner and it would have been better than this read more

In town from florida on vacation and highly recommend stopping here!! Food was delish! we got the spinach dip appetizer (probably a skip next time but wasn't too horrible, chips just a little stale) I got a burger and fries and it was very good, the burger was cooked perfectly, juicy and flavorful. My husband got the raspberry chicken salad and he ate every bite! They also had live music when we were there which was nice and actually not too loud if you're in the bar area. The staff were so friendly and everything was super quick! read more

See all

I'm giving 2 stars because the sweet potato fries were really good but everything else was very subpar. If I'm gonna pay $18 for a steak sandwich I would expect a solid helping of steak. It was literally four tiny strips and all bread. Prices are way too high for what you get. Also, the service was terrible. read more

Fantastic place to be, certainly one of the best restaurants/bar in DeKalb county. The steak was cooked to perfection and the home made garlic butter took it to a whole new level. Live music didn't suck either. read more

See all

This place has gotten better. The restaurant is still not my favorite. Very slow service! The wait staff always looks lost. They opened an area in the back for bands and it's not bad if you're just there for an event. If it's food you want, you'll be waiting a long time. read more

Flat bread pizza cold, soggy and tasted like a frozen pizza. The loaded cheese fries were good.

I would go here if there were absolutely no other options, which is what sort happened with us. The artichoke dip was obviously a frozen meal that was microwaved. The veggie burger was a premade patty that was very dry. The salad was mainly lettuce with hardly any toppings in it. The decor of the place is cute and service was a little slow seeing as how there was only 1 waitress for the lunch crowd. I don't think I would go back again. read more

See all

We walked in stood there about 5 min before anyone greeted us no one was in the dining room I finally see a waiter and ask do we seat our selves? He says yea over here is fine. The restaurant is in a beautiful old building I ordered spaghetti with meat sauce it didn't even smell good this was the most un Italian restaurant I have ever been in food was tasteless read more

Easy stop in and tasty food. Kind-hearted service. A fun vibe, but it's clear that locals/regulars take priority. That's not a bad thing in a small town, but out-of-towners might keep it in mind. Things were overall delicious, but skip the French fries. Something with the fryer or the fry is off. There's plenty of other great stuff on the menu to enjoy read more

Vintage 1889 - Fried green tomatoes - New American Near Me - Fort Payne, Alabama

Soup and chicken salad salad were delicious. Service quick and server friendly. Inside an old mill and full of Southern charm. Adjacent to The Mill Antiques- win/win. read more

Great atmosphere and menu selections. Live music and outdoor seating. Fried green tomatoes were delicious and Vintage Chicken was wonderful. Hubby had shrimp and grits, which was lovely too. read more

Met at Vintage 1889 for a business lunch. We were promptly seated and placed our orders. I ordered the Lynn's Ham and Cheese sandwich and a bowl of the sweet pepper gouda soup. Both were delicious. The atmosphere is wonderful and the staff was gracious and attentive. I would highly recommend stopping in for a quick lunch. read more

Everything great, service food drink atmosphere you name it. I can't wait to get back. January ahh yes we will be back

Service is good. The place is cool. They had live music the night we were there which was fun. The food was very average. My wife had a mufellata with pasta salad and I had a Ruben with seasoned fries. My sandwich was good but a little skimpy on the meat. Fries were good but probably just frozen seasoned fries dropped in a fryer. My wife's sandwich was a mess. The olive dressing was super greasy and soaked through the bread. The meat on the sandwich was fried until it was tough. None of this would be a big deal if we were eating at a gas station deli. But with the money you pay at a place like this the expectation was much higher. Not sure if I'll give them another chance on a follow up visit. It's a little too expensive to roll the dice on another underwhelming experience. read more

Food was delicious Great service and ambience. Right next to antique store is a plus! read more

Vintage 1889 - New American Near Me - Fort Payne, Alabama

If you are passing through Fort Payne and are stopping for a meal, this place would be worth a visit. The service was great, the menu is diverse as far as bar food goes. I had a Reuben sandwich which was just ok. The atmosphere and decor was true to the name. All in all, a pleasant stop. read more

We stopped in on our way to Florida. Everyone was super friendly. Our server was super on top of everything, and the food came out super quick. The food was also amazing, great taste. We ordered the pizza and the Cuban, and loved both of them. The restaurant is also decorated so cute, we loved it all. We will definitely stop back anytime we're in the area. read more

Vintage 1889 - New American Near Me - Fort Payne, Alabama

See all

The food was amazing! I had the pimento cheese BLT. This was delicious. The service was great. From the time we sat down to the time our food was delivered was very quick. Even though they are efficient in their service they do not sacrifice quality. This seems to be a fun and friendly place to come for a meal or just a drink. You can feel comfortable with friends or family. read more

Wow ! They have a big burger called a Bonanza burger with a family homemade sauce. I get a craving and nothing will satisfy that want until I get to the Vintage and bite into that delicious burger with seasoned fries. A pleasant atmosphere inside or out on the patio. The servers are friendly and efficient. Don't take my word for it, just go by and grab a great burger. read more

Sometimes it's really worth getting off the interstate and going through town! We happened upon this place on our weekend getaway. We are not disappointed and will definitely be going back in the future. Vintage is definitely the word to describe this place. From the firetruck attached to the building, to the nice wood beams in the ceiling, to the bicycles hanging from the ceiling as well. I guarantee you you could look around and see a lot of different things every time you go in there. For an appetizer, we ordered the sweet potato fries. It came with a caramel, dipping sauce, and ketchup. Definitely did not need to catch up. The caramel sauce was amazing. It could have been a dessert. However, it said it came with Rosemary on the fries, but I did not taste any of the rosemary. But would still order it My husband got the steak sandwich and it was wonderful. They steak was cooked just the way he liked it. It was super tender. It could have been season a little bit better, but it did not disappoint. My husband got the steak sandwich and it was wonderful. The steak was cooked just the way he liked it and was super tender. It could have been seasoned a little bit better, but it did not disappoint. he had a side of cream spinach with it, and said it was very good. I had the goat cheese, pesto, burger, and it was amazing. A little on the messy side but it definitely did not disappoint. The goat cheese and pesto was a perfect combination. I ordered a side salad with balsamic vinegar it and it was a very good sauce salad. The service was very delightful, and we will definitely be going back again. read more

See all

Excellent food, Excellent service, beautiful location inside and out. This used to be an old sock mill where they manufactured Made in The USA socks and my wife thought I'd like it because I've been supplying industrial sewing machines to the textile and apparel industry for 35 years. They even had some of the old sock knitting machines still in the restaurant which was really cool! Everything about it was just really good! read more

See all

We stopped on here and had a really good burger. I'm looking forward to going back soon for dinner!

I love going to Vintage 1889 for lunch. I usually get the chicken salad salad with the raspberry vinaigrette or the Pimento cheese BLT. Even with the expanded dining room, my biggest complaint, especially at lunch, is that the music from the l kitchen bleeds into the dining area. My last visit they were listening to heavy metal, so a lot of heavy guitar and gravely screaming lyrics, which is not necessarily what everyone wants to hear on a Wednesday afternoon. Otherwise, awesome fast service and quality food. read more

Vintage 1889 - Pimento Cheese BLT and pasta salad - New American Near Me - Fort Payne, Alabama

We made a bit of a drive for a date night to check out Vintage 1889. Really cool atmosphere if you don't mind a kind of dive feel on the inside. Outside has more of a vintage feel. They also have some outside deck seating as well as a back room for larger events. We grabbed a seat on the inside since it was a little cool outside. Great selection of ciders (AO and Cider Boys). Couldn't resist the Blackberry .... and they had it on draft, so good! We started our meal with the fried green tomatoes. Judging by how we destroyed the plate in a matter of minutes, I'd go as far as to say they were good, dare I say great. My Wife had the Brown something (it's basically an open faced turkey sandwich with gravy). She really wasn't a fan as it didn't hold up to the original. They were really nice and offered a replacement meal which she swapped to a burger. I went with the cheese burger with bacon. Aged cheddar and great overall flavor. Burger was cooked exactly how I requested and came out really juicy. Fries were freshly cooked and done to perfection. Really good overall experience! We really enjoyed our evening here and will come back to try some additional menu items. read more

See all

Great live music, terrible Old Fashioned, which I found kind of ironic. Food was ok. Wait staff was trying hard it they were understaffed IMO. read more

For such a great menu, you would expect better quality service and ambiance. I loved that there were vegetarian options and the presentation of every dish was spectacular. But presentation means nothing if your food isn't even hot. Not to mention, sitting outside to avoid a loud crowd proved not-so-smart since there is no pest control for outdoor seating. Barely warm food, attacked by bugs, and our waiter forgetting us towards the end of our meal? I won't be back. read more

Just stopped by for lunch. Was excited to see they had Muffelettas. It comes with chips. When order was received, I quickly noticed it was not on the proper bread, nor was it round like a true muffuletta.what's that oozing out of the sandwich that had very little meat and a thin slice of cheese. It was ground mustard! What??? It completely overwhelmed the star of the sandwich, the olive salad! To top it off, while watching other diners eat whole chips, my husband and I were served the crumbs from the bottom of the bag. I can say without a doubt, I will not be back. 1st impression was a bad one to say the least read more

Vintage 1889 - New American Near Me - Fort Payne, Alabama

We stopped while traveling having seen some good reviews but we're kinda disappointed. The spinach and artichoke dip came out cold. So many flies circling us as we ate. They opened the big doors to try to get them out but still. The sandwiches were ok but not great. Filled our bellies with nice portions but wasn't impressed to recommend to others. read more

See all

I've been curious about this place for awhile. Food was good. A little pricey for the simple sandwiches but that's the way things are now. It wasn't the great atmosphere that I had hoped for. My one suggestion is for them to put the meal descriptions on the menu. You have no idea what you are getting on some of the meals unless you ask the server. read more

We went there on Oct 25, 2022. I had the chicken salad. It was fresh, delicious, and I understand that all of their bread is made in-house. I really like the field greens served with the sadwich, not a fan of the ice-, berg lettuce that most other sandwich shops serve. We ate outside due to helth concerns. I like the his option. My husband is not a fan of doing this. The seating, like most outdoor places, is right next to the street. He doesn't like the noise. I liked getting s peek st the mountains. read more

Enjoyed! Friendly service! Food good. Lots of parking. Cute decor. Loved shopping. Wish I had more time there!

Great Sweet tea! Original burger was a three napkiner-AWESOME flavor was real deal! Heather our server was great she gets the job done well. Rustic Antique Mill with Antiques for sale next door. The decor feels right. Laid back vibe. Sat at bar very comfortable. Lots of beers can or draft. Liquor variety of bourbons to choose from. Live music Th,Fri & Sat. read more

Vintage 1889 - Vintage Burger Pretzel bun with side pasta salad. - New American Near Me - Fort Payne, Alabama