Should be zero stars for mediocre and under cooked foods that gave me horrifying stomach illness for over 24 hours! The garlic knots are bland, dough raw and chewy, no garlic and lifeless ...like the employee Karen that was rude beyond measure. I do not believe the reviews online, they must be falsely generated, check yourself. For a " family owned," business i expect at the least humble, wholesome, grandma recipes..im out. read more

The best calzone I've ever had. The best people very friendly Great place I will be back to eat here. read more

Vinny's Pizzeria - Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Herkimer, New York

See all

We absolutely think their subs are hands down THE BEST in the entire area. They are worth every single cent! Delicious and they pack their subs. We are from Philadelphia, Pa originally. So we are very picky about that. I highly recommend this place! read more

Awesome calzones...services is great and you have to try the garlic knots..The workers are great very friendly

Can't go wrong here. Their subs are my personal favorite, but their antipasto and slices are phenomenal. Service is always on point and ambiance is what you would expect from a local Italian restaurant in the valley. If they were closer or I still worked in Herkimer, I would probably go here more often. read more

No utensils!!! That's a problem!!! Food was good but can't eat without utensils!! Now what?!! Food was good! But you can't eat antipasto with hands!! I'll never understand why restaurants don't gives utensils automatically! read more

Best subs in herkimer county. Family run everything is quality but I come back every time for subs! read more

Vinny's Pizzeria - Turkey sub all the restaurants advised fixings added bacon...bang a rang Peter - Pizza Near Me - Herkimer, New York

I asked if there were any specials when I walked in and they told me that the specials today were pasta fagoli and chili Chili? In a pizza place? They were out of the pasta fagoli so I ordered a slice of sausage pizza and a bowl of chili. They were great! The chili rated 3 alarms as far as heat goes. I treated my sister and my mom to lunch and the bill was under $40!! This is not SF! Good little joint! read more

Vinny's Pizzeria - Vinny's! - Pizza Near Me - Herkimer, New York

I would definitely recommend this place as I've been coming here for 15 years. The portions are big, their sandwiches are big, especially if you get the large. Their pizzas are what their known for. It is family owned. They started as hole in the wall and got bigger. I have experience time and time again when you eat there it can be a long wait. Overall this is a great place ! Highly recommed! read more

Doughy but delicious pizza. Friendly family staff, great prices. If I'm ever up here again, I will come back. $2.25 for a buffalo pizza slice? Done. The pizza dough is chewy on their regular and specialty pies, but maybe you could ask them to bake it a bit longer? I find the doughiness a pleasant change-up from traditional NYC pizza. The sauce is tasty but not quite seasoned enough. Add some garlic and oregano and you've got yourself one really delicious slice. read more

Vinny's Pizzeria - a close up of a pizza - Pizza Near Me - Herkimer, New York

Known for the best sub in the valley, now I can say that there pizza rivals others in the valley area as well....Went there the other night looking for some pizza and a few beers. I had called ahead letting them know that I was bringing a party of 13. They were very accommodating . They had saved us a couple of tables and had set them up very nicely. We had a nice variety of pizza.....Eba, sausage and peppers, and chicken wing.....they were all excellent....... Our server was the best, always asking if there was anything else she could do for us..... Thank You Vinny's for your hospitality.... We will be back! read more

Today was my first time eating at Vinny's, and I've got to say I'm impressed! Even though I only ordered an ordinary slice of cheese pizza, the taste was wonderful and the crust was the perfect thickness and crispness. They also offered to add a topping for 50 cents, or they had some specialty slices that looked delicious as well. The staff is friendly and helpful, going through the prices of the items I was inquiring about without any sense of feeling rushed or annoyed. They warmed up my slice for me to the perfect temperature (slightly too hot to eat) and brought it to my table with a smile. The inside is clean, tidy, and comfortable, with booths and tables, nice but minimal decorations, and a decently sized TV. The only thing holding back a 5 star review is the vinyl booths are a bit beat up (still comfy though!). I can't wait to try more in the future! Maybe the Sicilian slice next time! Bravo! read more

Sadly the food at this place has gone down hill. Antipasto was good The sauce on pizza had no taste, the wings tasted like the fryer grease was very old and very dirty. Restaurant full of smoke and grease smell from dirty fryer.- if u go there you take the smell with you on your clothes. We ordered greens and they were grey, mushy and tasted like they looked. We did not eat them and told the server, she was nice and apologized but left them on the bill. We paid only to throw them out. I hope this place finds a decent cook or I cant see them lasting very long. I am rooting for them. read more

I've lived all over the state and this is the best pizza I've ever had. I lived in NYC for 6 years and say that. Crust has a nice chew and the sauce has enough sweetness and enough tart. The other items on the menu are solid, but their pizza is special. read more

This place is amazing. The chicken wing pizza I had been my first stop for many years coming from Boston to herkimer. Been coming to this place since it was on main st. Only thing that I dislike about vinnys is that they are closed on sundays. read more

OMG the calzone should be for two! Best I ever ate but could not finish. Sweet potato fries were excellent. Prices very affordable. If you are in Herkimer you must eat here. You may not need dinner that night if you lunch here. So much food..... read more

Very clean pizza place! I love their meatballs--which are something I would never think to order out because they are easy to make at home, but their meatballs are the BEST! Odd hours though, I always happen to call when they are closed! read more

Would never set foot in this place ever again! !! One waitress for the dining room at the start of a holiday weekend. Took 10-15 minutes for my husband and i to get drinks and a menu. Then after 30 minutes after ordering our dinner we still had not been served our dinner. Then the cashier tried to charge us for food we never received! !! read more

Vinny's pizzeria is the best pizza in Herkimer County . Love that they don't just have pizza the have dinners . I love their garlic knots and their cheesecake bits. La pizzería de Vinny es la mejor pizza en el condado de Herkimer. El amor que no acaba de tener la pizza tienen cenas. Me encantan sus nudos de ajo y sus trozos de queso. read more

Best pizza in Herkimer. Fast service, friendly staff, great food. And now they're even selling their sauces online! Awesome stuff all around! Be sure to try the chicken wing pizza. read more

After hitting 4 stops in the last 24 hours on the thruway this is by far the worst pizza yet. It had entirely too much crust and tasted like it came straight from the freezer. read more

Walked in to check pizza prices and the prices werent too high. I was going to order one with some wings but I wanted to try their hot wing sauce first. I was given a sample to taste only to find out it was nothing but straight hot sauce. I walked out. Just hot sauce? You might as well go out and get a bag of frozen wings and a bottle of red hot....save yourself some money and make them yourself. read more

Um so I went here with my homecoming date for a quick bite (cuz ya know homecoming food is sh*t... this wasn't any better) to eat and it turns out it took 2 freaking hours for the pizza we ordered to come out and Kirk was literally dying of starvation. We FINALLY got the pizza and it was made out of cardboard I stg but ya know a Kirks gotta eat. So then when Kirk bit into it, all the cheese fell off and he was left with cardboard and sauce which was like pretty upsetting tbh. So then afterwards I felt like getting cheesecake that they had on display and it was 4 mf dollars and 60 cents but i mean i still wanted it. Then I sat down ya know, hype asf cuz i got my cake and I opened the mf container and what do i see??? Orange a** liquid at the bottom and my cake was literally floating in it. Like it dead a** smelled like a rotten fugde-sicle tho. Then Kirk goes in for a bite and he stabbed his fork into a whole a** weave, like are u kidding me???? So anyways... Vinny's isn't exactly my fav place and if I could give them like -700 stars I definitely would cuz my $4.60 cents went in the mf trash. Plus i legit had explosive diarrhea after and BETTER YET it got my mf WHITE homecoming dress. And it ruined my boi Kirks tux, lemme tell u he was so upset. Then our special night gets EVEN better and Kirks mom had to pick us up and she was like "why does it smell like f***ing sh*t in here" and Kirk was like "um mom it was the pizza." So Ummm i'm never gonna go here again, sorry not sorry. AND UMM vinny u can pay for my dry cleaning buddy. read more

Vinny's Pizzeria - a slice of chocolate cake - Pizza Near Me - Herkimer, New York

I enjoyed the wings a lot and even though the pizza was a bit on the thick side, it brought good flavors and tons of fresh cheese. I recommend the butter-garlic wings because of how crispy and tasty they were. enjoy read more

My husband and I are from Philly. We miss the big fat "hoagies" (subs) from home. Well we gave Vinnies a try. I kid you not they EXCEL at making our "mixed meat" subs each and every time. They DO NOT skimp on anything! We both are extremely happy (and we are picky) with the quality of those subs. Go ahead and try the mixed meat subs and you are going to be a loyal customer just like us. We just wish we knew about them years sooner! A++ all the way around in food and friendly service. read more

i ordered a buffalo chicken calzone (without the meat) and what i got was a calzone with nothing in it but uncooked mozzarella cheese, and the whole thing was drowned in buffalo hot sauce. At the same visit my friend ordered a sub, and the bread was not fresh at all. I went there 5 years ago and ordered the same thing and it was good. but nowadays it's gone downhill. I will not be eating there ever again. read more

Very delicious, one of the best pizza places I've ever eaten. I'll go there anytime I'm in the mood for pizza! Keep up the amazing job!