Yetty's Pizzeria in Herkimer is a solid and respectable lunch spot. The dining area is roomy and comfortable, and the pizza especially their Red, White, and Green upside down pizza is reliably tasty and satisfying. They also have gluten free pizza options. Prices are fair, and portions are generous, making it a decent value for what you get. One of the best things about Yetty's is its huge menu: besides pizza, you'll find calzones, wings, salads, paninis, subs, wraps, burgers, pasta dinners, Italian dishes, appetizers, desserts, and more. There's really something for everyone, especially if you're in the mood for Italian comfort food or just want variety. However, one consistent drawback is the slow service, if you're on a tight schedule I'd place your order ahead of time. The quality of the food usually makes up for the wait, but it's something to keep in mind. read more

Food takes forever and is overpriced if you want to eat a whole plate full of pasta you would be better off, boiling some noodles.

Still my fav place. Everything was delicious. Service excellent. Comfortable, relaxed environment to sit back. Play quick draw and enjoy!!!! read more

See all

Slow service food very bland would not go again expensive oʻoʻoʻoʻķoʻooʻoʻooʻooʻooooʻoooʻooooooooooooooʻooooooooooooo

Been here many times and quality is consistent. Pizza, sandwiches, as well as pasta dishes ... well.. everything we have was excellent. Good size portions, served hot and quality ingredients. Favorites are Turkey Club Sub, Linguine with White Clam Sauce - upside down pizza, fried dough .. you really will anything less than awesome food here. Nice atmosphere too, plenty of street parking, outside seating. This is one of our favorite places. Very much recommended. Nice little bar too, but we love the booth seating. read more

Chicken riggies were so good. Chicken was so tender and flavorful! Yetty's pizza is always good too.

Good food. Don't like paying $1.25 for ranch that should come with an order of chicken strips...

Great food, great service, perfect local Italian restaurant ambiance. Don't pass on dessert and try some of the often unheralded Italian fare (i.e. muffuletta and/or calzone sub). One of the best in the valley! read more

Just spent over 24 dollars for a caesar salad and cheesy garlic bread, The salad I got was nothing but cut up iceberg lettuce with dressing. First, ceasar salad is made with Romaine, secondly, thats absolutely all that was in the container, cut up iceberg lettuce and some dressing. I could have went to Hannaford and bought a head of lettuce and bottle of ceasar dressing for less than six or seven bucks. I understand there has to be mark ups, it's business, but, really. a container of cut up iceberg and dressing?? Would not recommend this place if you are in the mood for a salad read more

I drive to herkimer from Schenectady for their pizza and always get 2-3 LG to bring home

Happy food! Good prices! Worth a visit! Great Italian sandwiches and meals. ......................... read more

Overall, just very flat and disappointing. Service was mediocre, the young waitress seemed like she didn't care to be there but nonetheless did her job. My husband ordered the boneless wings and they were completely cold on the inside, they were accompanied with some sweet potato fries that had a few long hairs on them, it was incredibly gross. The atmosphere is deeply lacking soul or personality. The only redeeming quality about this place was the music selection playing in the background, solid golden oldies. I'll regret dining at this place for the rest of my days. read more

Worse pizza we ever had! May be ok if you like tomato pie but...couldn't taste any cheese. Got pepperoni, onions and peppers on it and very sparse for what they charge. Yup..local but will never be back read more

Best friend mushrooms I've ever had!! They were full halves of mushrooms breaded and fried, served with a horsey sauce. Babygirl and I got more food than that and desert to take home, but very impressed by these mushrooms!! read more

Yetty's Pizza - a basket of fried chicken nuggies - Pizza Near Me - Herkimer, New York

The food took 1 hour to come out the burger came out as a hockey puck and the wings came out with our to go boxes I would not recommend.

Best spaghetti I've ever had! My mom and cousin both had a beef dip, they said it was awesome. My aunt had a taco salad, she said it was excellent. My dad had spaghetti and 2 meatballs, he also said it was fantastic. The restaurant was pretty cold for this Californian but it seems like everyone else was used to cold restaurants. The server seemed sad but she still waited on us pretty well. I've also heard raving reviews about the calzones. Definitely worth a stop! Next time I'm in NY, I'll be back! read more

The staff is great. Sandwiches (bread!!!) awesome. Stopped in on a whim and was pleased. More family than character but decent bar. Good prices and home made cannoli better than the over rated one I had in Boston read more

i ordered food for delivery at 4:40pm. called them at 5:45 as i still hadn't received my order. i was told it would be there any minute and was given 3 different excuses why my order was late. it did show up at 6:10. an hour and a half for 3 subs and an order of meatballs seems excessive when my address is in the village. Five minutes from the restaurant!! and it was missing a side order of wing sauce that i got charged for. the food is ok but delivery service is poor. do yourself a favor if you order from Yetty's and pick it up yourself. read more

A few friends and I ate lunch here and quickly realized that this is a spot the local go. And, the atmosphere makes you feel like a local. We had a woman server who was patient, helpful and very attentive. Service was great. I'd give this place a 3.5 stars: the food is all good and the value is exceptional. Large portions and cheap prices. If you are in town to visit Herkimer College come here and you won't be disappointed. Blows the fast food chains away. We started with the antipasta salad, which was enough to feed three growing boys and have some left over. The garlic bread sure isn't healthy, but damn tasty! We also ordered the Upside Down pizza, which is baked with the sauce on top of the cheese. It doesn't taste much different than normal pizza, but can be a fun thing to try. The main courses are inexpensive and flavorful. I had pasta with red sauce. The sauce tastes homemade and has a ton of flavor. The two Herkimer students I was with ordered small sandwiches. They were huge! And, came with homemade bread. Great stuff. read more

See all

Morning love this place enjoy Charlie from forever leather show highly recommend eating here

Yetty's was GREAT!! I was welcomed right in and seated immediately! The food was Awesome and came out fast! Everything was clean and in order and my waitress couldn't have been any nicer or better at her job!! Thank you Kaylee!! I wish you all the Best! A restaurant is nothing without great staff! read more

Yetty's Pizza - Entrance - Pizza Near Me - Herkimer, New York

Worst "pizza" I've ever had! Also waited 2 hours for delivery! Save your money, Pizza hut is better. read more

My husband and I use to enjoy going to this restaurant, however this last time was way different. We stopped in for lunch and I chose pick-a-pasta it ended up costing $21 my husband got a meatball sub totaling $39.51. Our waiter apparently had other priorities because I didn't get my salad or our bread until about a minute before our lunches came out. So needless to say I only had a couple bits of my salad. This use to be a place where the staff was great, the food was great, and a place you could afford to bring a family without killing your budget. Now $21 for garlic pasta and about 6 shrimp on top isn't a great deal at all! Never again will I go to this place, but it's not only the pricing it's the rudeness of staff and owners when you question the pricing. read more

Yettis is not what it used to be.food has gone downhill for the past 10 years.i dont like to give a bad review however, not only the food has gone downhill.customer service stinks.when someone orders a to go order,you had better make sure that order is perfect.nothing worse than getting an order home and you cant eat it,or it wasnt what you ordered.times are tough.small bussinesses are suffering.with that being said,customer service is very important if you want to keep your doors open.pay attention to detail,people first eat with their eyes! read more

Pizza, wings and other typical Italian staples: antipasto, calamari, etc. They have this special (super top secret) sauce called "creamy western". We tried it; it was pretty good. The portions here are so huge that it is almost ridiculous! Seriously, we were a group of four people and each one of us had enough food left for two more meals. Unfortunately, we had almost a two hour drive home, so we didn't want take home boxes, and the server told us she felt bad that we were wasting so much food! Well...stop serving such large portions. In any case, the food was tasty...what you would expect for a pizza place. Pricing was more than reasonable. I'd go again. I would just order half as much food! read more

Yettys has gone down hill horribly .. called on several occasions hours before closing time to a phone that goes unanswered or an employee that says we are closing early like 1.5 hours early .. the pizza is not as good the service sucks read more

Came in at around 4pm and have been sitting for an hour and haven't received the food we ordered 50 minutes later we got our salad. I haven't even eaten yet and I'm writing this cause I'm so bored. Other people have been coming in and getting served and leaving before we got our food. My linguini was stuck together the meatballs my friend got were cool not even hot. There were flies flying around also kind of gross. The food was over priced and definitely took way too long to be out. Was not impressed at all. read more

Get the creamy western wings. Brian is a lost soul about pizza

Awesome pizza. Flavorful and innovative! Family owned = awesome service. And with the delicious sauce you can dig right in without scalding your mouth. If you're on a date no need to worry about infinite strings of cheese or cheese gobs sliding off the sauce. Don't miss this Herkimer diamond of a pizza haven! PS Thank you "Jo!" read more

Just left this restaurant with my family due to very unsatisfactory service. We were seated at 4:55pm and we did not even receive the drinks we ordered after waiting nearly 30 minutes! Other tables who came in after us received their drinks. We were snubbed! We would expect the appetizers we ordered to arrive in that amount of time for sure! Also, I was VERY put off by the decor. The ceiling fans were caked with dust. Dirt covered the ugly looking floor and ants could be seen crawling on it! What's even more annoying is that their Christmas decorations still can be seen adorning the upper railings. It's JUNE people! Come on! Never coming back. It is a shame that this kind of quality exists in my hometown. read more

Good pizza (ask for it burnt) not so hot salads (see my picture). Customer service is not that good. read more

Yetty's Pizza - Today's salad was made with nothing but ass-ends of the lettuce. Called to complain but was told "sorry, anything else?" - Pizza Near Me - Herkimer, New York

I've eaten at Yetty's many times throughout the years and have always been satisfied, in fact, the last time I was there a month ago the waitress was very pleasant and accommodating. Today I ordered one for delivery and had to call after 1 hour and 15 min only to be told he had just left the pizzeria. By the time it got here it was cold. Needless to say that will be the last time we order from them. There are many pizza places to choose from so I'll choose one of them read more

Excellent food and service. Have been there several times and typically enjoy the hot subs or pizza.

Yettys is hit or miss depending what you're ordering. The service was great when we went, the staff very friendly and polite. However, I've had good and bad food from there. The first time we went I ordered the pizza and wings. I'm just gonna be honest and say it was horrible. The pizza was extremely thin and hardly had any flavor. We wanted to get half of it with sausage and the other half with mushrooms because someone has an allergy. They tried charging us for two full toppings 3 even though we only got sausage on one half and mushrooms on the other. The wings weren't bad. But, the best thing I've ever had there is the Muffaletta sandwich. It was very tasty and good sized. Overpriced for a sandwich with no sides but worth the homemade olive garnish. read more

I read some scathing reviews on Facebook but ignored them when a family member wanted to get pizza from there. I'll never make that mistake again. Terrible pizza and wings. That will be my last time. There are too many good restaurants in the valley to bother with Yetty's ever again. It used to be good. read more

Best gluten free pizza in the valley!!! They do it upside down like they're regular pizza too. I no longer live nearby but I was recently home visiting and I got a pizza there and I forgot how good it was so I got another one on the day I left and carried it on the plane with me and ate it in Seattle last night! They don't do pizza like that, especially gluten free out west! Thanks Yetty's! read more

Calzones were 3 stars at best. Pizza is 0 stars. Best to drive the extra 7 miles and go to Ed's in Little Falls. We'll never go back. Generic frozen Walmart pizza is better than the pie we bought tonight. read more

It was too hot to cook, and we had been out all afternoon. I ordered a steak and greens wrap and my husband wanted a chicken parm grinder. I got a call back immediately after placing our take out order to let me know they were out of greens. I opted for a Caesar salad in its place. We picked up on time, drove 10 minutes to home. I opened the salad to find 90% spines of romaine lettuce, the leafy parts were soggy with tasteless dressing. It had 5 croutons and a few grape tomatoes with a bit of shaved Parmesan. I took a couple of forkfuls and threw the rest in the garbage. The chicken parm grinder was made of chicken tenders, the bread was totally overpowering and soggy. We used to go to and order from Yettys all he tome and have noticed a sharp decline in the quality of food. The dining room has become dirty feeling and unkept. I hate to say this, but go someplace else. read more

We ordered 3 subs 2 out of 3 were incorrect so I called to let them know figuring they would either make it right and send new subs or at least offer a voucher or something instead the lady answering the phone was rude blamed me bc they were busy and she had tables and let me know that I could hear her talking to the tables so she knew I was aware they were busy. Then proceeded to tell me they decided to substitute our banana peppers for hot peppers instead of informing us they were out of banana peppers. Not to mention they added olives to one sub that shouldn't have them. I understand being busy and making a mistake but I was basically blamed for their mistakes and told I had the attitude when I was trying to stay calm even though the lady on the phone in fact was rude and had an attitude until i just couldn't take it anymore said my peace and hung up. Never ever would I ever order there again or recommend. read more

Awesome food and awesome service. Kelly was a great server and this is an amazing restaurant in the little town of Herkimer. Will be back every time I visit. read more