Always good pizza. Love the eggplant Parm sub. Staff is very friendly. We usually get delivery and they are pretty quick.

I have ordered from Vince's Pizza Smithsburg, Maryland MANY times, and never had an issue while it was owned by Roberto Gonzalez Sr. However, it is under new management now, and they are not making pizza nearly as good. It doesn't even come close! Yesterday, I ordered a Sicilian pepperoni with EXTRA cheese pizza. I'm including photos to show what I received. They didn't even put on a regular amount of cheese, let alone extra cheese. The pizza didn't even taste good. I was so disappointed by this. It's a shame they clearly didn't care what they sold me. The new management isn't making quality food. So, so disappointed! read more

Vince's New York Pizza - Not even a regular amount of cheese, let alone extra cheese that I paid extra money for! - Pizza Near Me - Smithsburg, Maryland

See all

Me and my mom stopped here on the way home and I'm so glad I did. Service was amazing, the women taking our order was very sweet and the pizza was really yummy. Definitely recommend and definitely will come back! read more

Vince's New York Pizza - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Smithsburg, Maryland

Figured I'll have something delivered tonight. Didn't feel like going out. They told me a 45min delivery time. I live in leitersburg. Finally got it after 1hr 25min. read more

Superb pizza Great service It's got table/booths and a bar with stools by the front windows They do mostly deliveries but it's definitely worth dining in read more

Unlike some whiney guy complaining for 1,000 words on here about lasagna and the fact that this place, in the middle of nowhere, isn't plated fine dining, let's focus on reality: it's good, solid pizza. The crust is crunchy outside and soft inside and it has a great flavor. The sauce is sweeter than I personally like, but still good. Toppings were good. I had veggie, my friend had pepperoni. We were both pleasantly surprised with how good the pizza was. We'll be back. read more

Vince's New York Pizza - two pepperoni pizzas - Pizza Near Me - Smithsburg, Maryland

It used to be better still good just not the same, both food and service seem different

Excellent pizza and Italian dishes. Roberto and his staff always do an excellent job. Fresh baked bread is a plus. I've never been disappointed with any of our selections. read more

This place was fine. The pizza and appetizers were good. There didn't appear to be any table service as they just handed things over the counter as they were ready. No one else was in the place though, so it wasn't because they were too busy. Many people may not care, but they don't wear gloves or separate duties. In other words, the person taking money, touching food, and cleaning are the same person. Again, I understand this is not a big deal to some. read more

The owner is the sweetest human. The pizza is great! Definitely recommend if you're looking for a laid back pizza place.

I don't have a cousin named Vinny but I have been to NY, so having an authentic pizzeria in the small town of Smithsburg is definitely no crime. I wanted to take in the humble space but instead my family decided to order delivery. Now I wasn't on the phone but heard it was free, (we lived 0.6mi away) bonus! We ordered a medium pepperoni and a large mixed veggie with Italian sausage. They arrived piping hot with fresh cut veggies and plenty of meats. Im not sure if they were house made but the onions were julienned rings instead of diced which I liked and it helped with caramelization. The sauce to cheese ratio was perfect for me without either overwhelming the other ingredients. And the most important part, the crust, was both chewy and light. Both pizzas were pretty stretched in their boxes almost gaining an inch and although I would have personally liked it a bit more well done, it was still a solid pie. I looked up their website and realized the menu is extensive! So I better go check out a calzone, chocolate dipped cannoli or some Sicilian style pizza! I also saw the medium pizza is 14" and the 16" large ($12.99) is just a dollar more. Thats almost better than scoring a date with Mona Lisa Vito! Way to go Vince, I will be spinning my wheels to get back before you can say posi-traction! read more

Vince's New York Pizza - Med pepperoni on left, stretched. Large green pepper, mushroom, onion, Italian sausage on right. Both had chewy, delectable crust. - Pizza Near Me - Smithsburg, Maryland

By far the worst place we have ever eaten. The stromboli was a wad of cheese and we saw very little steak and there seemed to be crust in the end pieces but none in the middle. It was wet with a greasy liquid floating on the plate. read more

It was unexpected to find such excellent pizza in little smithsburg but being from new York I have high expectations for pizza and Vince's did not disappoint. Ambience is a typical pizza joint, a bit on the dumpy side but the staff was friendly, the food came out fast and it was delicious. My dining companions got steak and cheese subs and a gyro and everyone loved their food. read more

Inconsistent, fries lack size regularity, crispness, sauce is it there, flavor? Cooks look at you ad another order. read more

Had carry-out here for the first time, this evening. When I walked in the owner warmly greeted me, then continued to ask questions being genuinely interested in me as a person not just a customer. I watched as a few others came and went, which he knew by name. The food was absolutely amazing and I couldn't be happier that I found this place!! It is our new default/go-to read more

Typical pizza joint inside, but clean and neat, and the food is fantastic. Wonderful hot, delicious pizza and their steak and cheese sub is one of the best I've had. We used to frequent another pizza place in town but it has really gone downhill with the food. Vince's is now my go to place to eat in Smithsburg. It never disappoints and the owners are very friendly read more

We stopped in this cold morning for a bit of pie just after they opened at 11. They took great care of us and the pies were most excellent! The staff brought out the very hot and tasty pizzas, the sauce was spot on, the crust was also nice and the fresh cheese that I think they make on site was very good. Our two large pies hit the spot. We will definitely make this our lunch stop on our motorcycle rides. read more

Vince's New York Pizza - two pizzas on a table in front of a window - Pizza Near Me - Smithsburg, Maryland

This is some of the best pizza I've ever had and their other menu items are great too, they make the best sub rolls and I've never had any issues with my order or any of the staff. read more

Best veggie sub I've ever had and one of the few places my very picky daughter will eat pizza from. I don't like New York style pizza, but I'll eat it from Vince's. It's that good!! My husband is a foodie and says their steak and cheese sub is better than any he's ever had, including the one he ate in Philly. The staff is wonderful and very friendly. read more

I wanted to support a local business and I had seen good comments for Vince's. I am considered a high risk individual for COVID-19, so I am very cautious about outside contact. I ordered my food and had it delivered. Excited to have a meal I didn't prepare and considered it a treat. I ordered a cheeseburger sub, fries and a small pizza for the next day. I was going to eat well for the next two days. The delivery arrived fairly quickly, but then things didn't go well. The delivery person was not wearing any kind of protective gear, a mask or gloves. So that made me nervous, then he asked me to sign a receipt using his pen and I did before realizing that I shouldn't have used his pen. I washed my hands multiple times and then ate part of the sub, but my mind kept going to the thought of how was this restaurant protecting me and their employees from this virus. I didn't feel safe eating the food they had delivered. In the end I threw the food I considered a treat into the trash. During this scary time, I need to know that businesses I support are doing their best to protect me and their employees. I didn't see evidence of this with Vince's. I was very disappointed and I hope this business reads this review and thinks about how they are presenting themselves with taking this viral threat seriously. We all need to do our part to protect each other. read more

What I love about Vince's is the picture of there Vince's special is the same pizza you get delivered to your house. I love their delivery is free and fast. Their drivers are nice and courteous. Their online ordering is awesome I can pay and give a tip all in the same transaction online. Online specials are great along with a variety of 2 liters. They also have the best French fries along with their subs. I ordered their Sicilian special it was so heavy and loaded with toppings it fed a large group of six and still having leftovers. I consider myself a pizza snob I hate the production line pizza of your franchises I love pizzeria pizza and this is just like getting a slice in New York City. read more

These guys are fantastic! Our food has always been on point and the delivery is quick and super friendly. They are on our regular list!

Just moved to Smithsburg this month, and ive ordered twice from here now. Both times, PIPING hot food was delivered and it was under 30 min. Amaaaazing chicken quesadillas read more

Very nice staff, extra helpful. Pizza was like it was right off the street in New York. Good prices too.

The people here are super friendly. I called in my order and came to pick it up. It was ready and hot when I got here. Me and the kids decided to just eat in and the Pizza was awesome. This is our new go.to place for pizza! I can't wait to.come back and try more of the menu. read more

It's nice having great pizza in such a remote area made by actual Italians. Having eaten pizza in New York, Boston, and Italy I can say Vince's is definitely up to my pizza expectations. read more

Great little gem in the town. Pizza was great; cooked just right, crust was on point. I'll be back!

BEWARE OF ORDERING ONLINE!! I ordered a pizza online only to get a call directly after with someone stating they could not deliver to me because I was out of delivery range. ( I live about 7 miles from the shop) I said 'no problem, just cancel the order' and ordered from another pizza shop. I noticed that they still charged me for the pizza, but as it was 'in process' on my online bank account I figured it would never actually post. But it did.... I then tried to call back about 20 times to speak with someone that could refund me the money. I even said I'd settle for a pizza being delivered to me. Eventually I spoke with a man who said he'd attempt to contact the CC company to try to get me refunded.... My guess is I'm going to end up paying for this pizza I never received... Don't understand why they couldn't just send out a frickin pizza after all the hassle!!!! read more

If I could give more stars, I would. I organize a family reunion each year and was looking for a new pizza place to cater one of our dinners. We ordered pizzas, eggplant parm, and pasta. The pizza was ridiculously good, fresh, hot, and flavorful. It was delivered to Thurmont, but arrived as fresh as if we were eating in the restaurant. The eggplant was also really good and everyone enjoyed it. We ordered buttered pasta; they sent marinara. You'd think this would ruffle feathers, but our group was thrilled b/c their marinara sauce is outrageously delicious - very flavorful homemade taste. They threw in a huge salad with dressings and delicious garlic bread at no charge. The food was absolutely perfect and the amount of food they provided was over the top. Working with Roberto only enhanced an already fantastic experience. We will be ordering again next year. I wish I lived in town b/c we would be frequent visitors! Thank you! read more

Found this place via Groupon. It very exceeded exceptions.the are very friendly and the food is so fresh. I will definitely be hitting this place pretty frequently read more

Ordered a 30 wing platter and only received 25 wings. Charged full price of 30 wings. This was my go to for fresh italian food in the past. Seems as though it has lost its leadership and quality in the past few years. read more

This pizza is "change your life" good. Everyone who was working were pleasant and friendly. When I told the staff I was from out of town they recommended things to do, and they made my trip incredible. Wish we had one where I lived! read more

Great Italian menu and the pizza is delicious. Comfort food at its best! Highly recommend when in the area.

Really good pizza. Made fresh and the toppings always perfect. You can try the other places, but I bet you come back to Vince's!

After getting rained on all day at Catcotin, our group decided to skip cooking over the campfire and hit the road. We called Vince's and they were happy to have us. 16 kids and 8 adults. Served us up 8 pizzas quick and were tasted great. All the staff was friendly. We will stop back again to try more than just pizza next time! read more

Awesome food and very good service. Also very fast for deliverys. I had no clue they delivered all the way to cascade but i was happy thwy do and will be calling way more ofteb read more

Vince's makes the absolute best pizza I have ever eaten. Their service is fantastic and the delivery drivers are fantastic. The ingredients they use are so fresh that they must grow everything right there. If you've never had a Vince's Pizza, Sub or Salad then you never had the best Italian food available. read more

Pizza is good but, everytime i order from them it takes over an hour for delivery. By the time i get it i have to reheat in the oven.

This place is open till at least 8:30 on a Friday. Yelp said it was closed but it's off. They had street tacos on the menu so I decided to take a chance on the theory that if a pizza place was going to serve Mexican, it was probably good. They weren't the best tacos I've been ever had but they were quite good and much better than I would have expected in a town with as few restaurants as this. I'd get them again. read more

The pizzas at Vince's are excellent. Cheese is fresh, crust is perfect, and just right on the sauce. I am making this a four-star review instead of five, because the only thing I see as a weakness is the confusion over serving Mexican dishes alongside pizzas - that can be a bit confusing for customers. Vince's is best doing what they do best, and that is those pizzas! read more