Fantastic pie. Love the crust. Super friendly service. Stopped on our way home. Craving a good pie...mission accomplished.

Well, this was a pleasant surprise. I've heard of all the great sub places in Hagerstown and this hadn't crossed my list yet, but I was hungry and thought I'd try a new place. Having written several articles about cheesesteaks resulting from my annual Philly Cheesesteak Tour with some buddies, I took a shot on a cheesesteak here and I'm glad I did! In Philadelphia, many will agree that the roll makes the sandwich. While I judge a cheesesteak on several different criteria, the absolute star of the show was the super soft roll, freshly baked in house, that held my sub. Firm enough that it held the filling, but incredibly soft. The meat, cheese and grilled veggies came out hot and delicious with a side of seasoned tasty fries, as pictured here. I only had two minor things that kept this from being one of my few 5-star ratings. First, while tasty, the fries could have been a bit crispier for my liking and second, I do like a bit more of the meaty, cheesy goodness in my steaks. No problem with the taste and did I mention the bread. Apparently made from the same stuff as the pizza crusts. I'll be back. Give it a shot, but dine in. I'll try the pizza on my next trip. read more

American Pie Pizzeria - Special Cheesesteak with grilled onions and mushrooms. - Pizza Near Me - Hagerstown, Maryland

Excellent bake made a perfect texture for the garlic bread. The salad was wonderfully fresh and crisp. The texture of the fettuccine was awesome and the flavor of the sauce really full and comforting. The service was so friendly. I always love coming here. They are an awesome part of our community. I hope you try it out. I'll be back for the excellent texture of thier pizza crust and bring my friends and family. read more

My first time there today, but not my last. The food and service were exceptional and the price was very good.

Best gluten free/vegan cheese in the tri-state region. Highly recommend. Owner is very attentive to dietary needs.

I'd say this is some of the best pie in the Hagerstown market. Sauce has a little tang to it, the cheese is real and has a solid pull, and the crust has a good crunch to it with a soft center. read more

Great pizza joint. Reminds me of the great pizza joints from the 90's. Wonderful throwback decor and great pizza. Stopped here after a day of skiing for lunch. Will return for sure. read more

Oh. My.. gosh. Have you ever taken a bite of food and your eyes roll back in your head because it's so delicious.? I have not had pizza this good in a long time. The crust is spectacular. I have been a huge mushroom pizza fan my whole life and these are fresh mushrooms, not canned. The wings were absolutely delicious as well. A++++ y'all are doing it right! read more

Avoid!!! Absolutely beyond a rip off!! Ordered online, food never arrived..got a run around first with "driver picked up food at 9:58, give him until 10:40 because we aren't close to you (website said 2m4 miles away when we ordered!) Email confirmation said delivery betweenb10:05-10:20...called customer service at 10:35 and was told driver had an emergency and delivery won't happen can we pick up? No, we are from out of town and now out $66 plus everything is closing!! To top it off, Refund will take 24-48 hrs.?? You can get my $$ immediately but not refund? I'm betting some driver was near being off and had our pizzas to take home! Unbelievable that this is our 1st impression of this town!! read more

This is a cheesesteak literally the width of a hotdogs bun lmao. I just want a regular size cheesesteak lol. I was shocked. read more

American Pie Pizzeria - All I can say is wow. If you like your cheesesteak on a roll the size of a hotdog bun GREAT! But I don't. - Pizza Near Me - Hagerstown, Maryland

See all

Burnt fries. Should never have been served to a customer. Rest of the food was solidly average. read more

The food is so good, everything is made to order which makes it even better. The owner is so friendly, he makes it a point to speak to his customers which you don't see often. Hands down best pizza in the area! read more

The crust and sauce on the pizza are great. Wings were meh. I would definitely order the pizza again though.

Hands down best pizza around. Pizza is flavorful, perfect crust, cheese and excellent service. Real pizza fans go here. Im from NJ and I'm not playing around. Took a long time to find a decent pie in these parts. read more

I wish I couldn't put a star because the crust tasted old and the cheese was nasty so I did not recommend this so-called restaurant

Anyone who knows me knows I love white pizza. I have ordered it truly all over this country. This is my absolute favorite! It has olive oil and garlic base with sun-dried tomatoes, provolone, feta, mozzarella, roma tomatoes, and onions. It is awesome! Go get this pizza right now! read more

The cheese part of the pizza was good. The crust was slightly overdone and a little tough. Would not recommend the calamari or funnel cake sticks. Average pizza place, would suggest ordering elsewhere with many better options in the area. Gave 3 stars instead of 2 because the delivery from Uber Eats was prompt, no complaints there. read more

Waited 10 minutes for drinks, even longer for our food, when it did come out it was wrong. Waited almost as long for the check as we did for our food. We were the only customers in the restaurant. Really sad over this experience because the food was amazing. read more

We went here randomly and it the absolute BEST.... Homemade crust, garlic bread, steak and cheese sub along with the best Greek salad! I would highly recommend this restaurant if you want freshly made food! read more

We stopped here on our way driving from NY to NC. We wanted pizza and we wanted to support a small business. We called our order in and it was ready when we got there. The pizza was very good and my teen daughter said her Greek salad was "delicious." we are back on our way, full and happy. Bye bye Ms American Pie. See you again on our next trip! read more