Fratelli's If you're spending a day outdoors at Cunningham Falls State Park or exploring Catoctin Mountain Park, Fratelli's NY Pizza is exactly the kind of low-key, satisfying stop you hope to find afterward. This place is a true neighborhood gem--no frills, no fuss, just solid comfort Italian food with good portions (and yes, plenty of cheese with pizzas). We came in just before the lunch rush on a Tuesday, fresh off a hike and absolutely starving, and the timing couldn't have been better. The dining area is on the smaller side, but it felt cozy rather than cramped for our group. One standout was the staff--especially the woman who seemed to be doing everything at once: hosting, taking orders, answering phones, and pitching in behind the counter, taking payments etc.. Despite juggling it all, she stayed friendly, patient, and helpful, even offering menu suggestions without missing a beat. It honestly added to the charm of the place. Food-wise, don't expect anything fancy or Instagram-worthy. Presentation isn't the focus here--but flavor and portion size deliver. Everything we ordered was hearty, satisfying, and reasonably priced, which feels like a win these days. Location is super convenient too--right off Route 15 with easy parking out front (next to a gas station), making it an ideal pit stop whether you're heading into town or back home. Bottom line: Fratelli's isn't trying to impress you--it's trying to feed you well, and it succeeds. Perfect post-hike fuel and a spot I'd happily return to on future trips to the area. read more

See all

Ordered a simple pizza and got a frustrating experience instead. The crust was undercooked, doughy in the center, and barely edible. Service was slow, staff seemed annoyed, and no one cared to fix it. Definitely not worth the time or money. I won't be returning. read more

I like there ham/turkey club sandwich it is huge for only $ 7.99. White pizza with tomatoes and onions, awesome.

I stopped here on my way home, craving ny style pizza. Disappointingly the didn't sell slices!!!! It smelled so good in there I had to ask what was cooking- it was onions! I ordered a chicken parmigiana sandwich and that was a total disappointment! It wasn't a whole thin piece of chicken cutlet but cut up pieces with a glop of cheese gluing the small pieces together. The bread was so soft not crispy at all. A soggy mess! The woman at the counter was very nice and the place though small had a few tables. This location was next to a mini mart and gas station. Maybe try it but I won't ever again. read more

See all

We had a wonderful lunch today. We sat in a little corner park in downtown Thurmont and ate most of our meat Lovers Speciality Pizza. While we dined, there was a plethora of classic cars going bt. read more

See all

food was the worst shit I ever tasted, and they were so racist to us Latinos/Black. The services was so bad to us, they kept attending everyone really nice and keep checking everyone. But since we walked in, terrible looks, we started talking in Spanish, and they kept looking at us and whispering, too them 20 mins to attend us. Though there was only one table full, then once they attended, they didn't even bother to ask for drinks or anything just waited for us too order. It was so obviously we weren't welcomed. Then we got our food, and tasted all shit, supposedly the pizza is good here, but so oiling and just no flavors. And the pasta taste plain and tasted old. Never coming here again, and I don't recommend coming here. Unless you're white. No offense to my white folks. read more

Needed gas. Needed pizza. I was able to get both at one stop. My 7 year old autistic son did not have the patience for the drive back to Lehigh Valley, PA. The pie was so good that we ate in almost perfect silence during the rest of the ride. The ambiance is very mom and pop. I felt like I was the only non-local when I popped into the restaurant, but service was quick and friendly enough. If I'm back in the area, I'd stop by again. read more

Absolutely awful. I ordered appetizers for delivery and live 5 minutes away. Took 2 hours to get here, and they were not apologetic whatsoever when I called and asked what the ETA would be. Would not recommend. read more

Let me start by saying the pizzas were delicious!!! This was my first time here and I called ahead to place the order. The lady that answered the phone was very rude. What I wanted to order, based on the menu posted on their Google Business Profile, was not current and supposedly what I wanted had not been on the menu for years. I politely suggested they should update it to help future customers. (I for one use Google all the time when choosing a place) Well, things went down hill from there with her response. I changed my order and went to pick it up. She was no less rude when I picked up the order. Polite customer service and an updated GBP goes a long way in attracting and retaining customers. read more

Great pepperoni pizza but not so good veggie pizza. With the veggie pizza, they used canned mushrooms and the spinach seemed like it also came from a can (little piles of green mush). If you don't have fresh mushrooms or spinach, don't use canned as a replacement. If you need to charge more for fresh ingredients, that's fine, it'll taste better. Won't get the veggie again but will definitely come back for the pepperoni. Loved the thin NY style crust and being from NY, it was pretty good. Wold have been a 5/5 if not for the canned mushrooms on the veggie pizza. Otherwise they make very good pies. read more

Last night, I parked my truck at this stop for the evening and seen this establishment attached. Due to COVID-19, the volume of to-go orders was huge and the kitchen was swamped. Despite the mad rush, the pizza I ordered was delicious. The only negative I had to say was maybe a lack of hospitality, but given the situation, I understand the lack of cordial from the staff as they were walking on top of each other in a tiny kitchen trying to keep up. I actually appreciate the sense of urgency to keep the kitchen running. Ended up eating here for the second night in a row. Was way less busy and the hospitality that was lacking the night before was there tonight. Will always swing through here when I am going through this area! read more

We needed a place to eat while camping nearby and this was one of the few options. The shop was dreary, the staff abrupt, and the wait long. Fox News was blaring from TVs in the ceiling and I wished we picked somewhere else. The pizza was pizza, middle of the road. Not worth the rest of the experience. read more

I like the pizza here. I get a sausage and broccoli, no-red-sauce pizza. It's very good! We all like the pizza here. Hot subs are good. Stromboli's are good. I wouldn't recommend the calamari-not good. There aren't many places to eat in Thurmont and this place and Kountry Kitchen are our favorites. read more

Fratelli's New York Pizza - a restaurant menu - Pizza Near Me - Thurmont, Maryland

Very good pizza and sandwich joint. We usually do delivery and the food is always good

Very slow service. Not to mention horrible costumer service! 45min wait time is actually 1.2hrs...

We've been here a couple times. Sadly, I'm not a fan. 1st: Their pizza is nothing that I'd recommend to anyone. Seems like that they go cheap on the dough, sauce, & cheese. 2nd: last time we were there, service was pretty disappointing. It seemed like the waitress was annoyed that me & my kids were in there. No, my kids behavior was prefect; so it wasn't them. The waitress must have been in her 30s or 40s: so I was surprised by her attitude. I expect mediocre service when I'm served by a teenager, but not from someone that I wanted to tip well, but it just seemed wrong to do so. We'll try it out again @ some point: but we'll have to try something besides the pizza. Hopefully, the service will be a bit better. read more

Fratelli's New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Thurmont, Maryland

I had an absolutely delicious pizza from here yesterday. I read some of the reviews and think people believe there personal tastes constitute a good pizza. The folks at Fratelli's advertise a NY style pizza and in my well experienced opinions they hit all the marks of a tasty specimen right down to the proper amount of oily residue from the pepperoni and a droopy end that is best folded for the first few bites. It also passed my three flavor test during eating and cooling the first was piping hot from the oven a swirl of flavors. Second is the cooled a bit 2nd slice which highlights the quality of the ingredients and the 3rd that is the bread that makes up the crust and tanginess of the sauce. I would be doing them an injustice not to mention the Cheese and pepperoni toppings where generous if not down right abundant. Five stars and I will be adding the phone number to my contacts and returning soon !!! read more

The cheese steak si very good. However a woman that runs the place is hostile at best. Keeps me from wanting to eat there or try anything else. She talks to the staff like they are dogs. read more

This place is better than NY Pizza. I stop here whenever I pass through, even if I'm not hungry. I'm a Truck Driver and have had Pizza all over the Country...driven over 2 and half million miles and this is my favorite pizza!!! No joke. Had subs here too but can't resist the pizza!!! Enjoy read more

The service was below par. The food took too long and wasn't what we ordered. The pizza was too greasy and missing toppings. The steak and cheese had no cheese and the mozzarella sticks were cold. read more

We placed our order in-store because at 7:45 they stopped answering their phones I ordered half a meat lovers, half with mushrooms,olives and onions. The olives were WHOLE! I have never heard of a place putting whole olives on a pizza. Not only that, they were tough and flavorless, so they didn't even taste good. It was just gross. I'm super disappointed. We payed $20 for this pizza and it was as awful. It's like they were mad because we placed a late order or something. read more

My husband loves their steak and cheese sub so much that any time, we go some place else and he orders a steak and cheese sub, he says "it's good but it's not Fratelli's good". He has yet to find a steak and cheese sub he likes more than theirs. My daughter and I LOVE the pizza with green peppers and onions. We eat here at least once a month. read more

This is my favorite place to stop for pizza. They sell slices too. Their Italian salad with house dressing is also very good.

One star for the tasty pizza and what seemed like fresh ingredients. However I give this place just one star for giving us uncontrollable bowel movement for 2 days straight... Not sure what they put in their pizza or how fresh the "seemingly fresh" ingredients were, but jeez Louise, those two days were horrendous. Not risking it so I will not be going back. read more

Horrible experience food was nasty and over priced service was slow I wouldn't tell no one about this place you do better going to 7 - 11 next door read more

I love this place! Delicious pizza, amazing fries, fabulous subs! Mmm! A hole in the wall with generous portions and great prices! Favs: Cheese fries Cheese steak BBQ pizza Tuna sub Grilled chicken salad Cheesesteak pizza read more

What can I say about this place. I have never had a bad dish from this establishment. The staff is professional, friendly and they make you feel like you're part of the family and not just a customer. The Greek salads are humongous. There steak and cheese superb. Their New York style pizza is wonderful I strongly recommend holding it if you plan on eating it without cutting. read more

Really messy melty pizza but a solid place for easy lunch. Not quite up to my NJ standards but WAY more edible than expected. read more

Fratelli's New York Pizza - Pizza is tasty but very messy and crust was a bit undercooked rendering it floppy as hell. - Pizza Near Me - Thurmont, Maryland

Love the food the the newest girl that Answer phones always sounds dead and not very nice

Went here for lunch. We had the New York style pizza, a Greek salad, and mozzarella cheese sticks. The salad was huge, and had a really good amount of feta cheese, tomato and a house dressing. Unfortunately it was all iceberg lettuce. The mozzarella sticks were really good, different than a lot of places, in a good way, and had plenty of dipping sauce. The pizza was great, you can pick your toppings from an expansive list, a medium easily feeds 2. Wait staff was friendly and very helpful. Their water was is terrible, but that's the cities problem. They have bottled available. Fair prices and good pizza. They also have a huge menu with many things to try! read more

I got spaghetti and meatballs to go it was good , and fresh I'll be back to try the pizza read more

Always good! Has been our go to place for pizza since we've been in Thurmont. Closest to Philadelphia style pizza we have found in the area. Cheese steaks aren't too bad either! Clean place and always courteous staff. read more

This place sucks they made me and my kids wait and I got my firs then waited 7-10 minuets for a sub same amount of time for my sons small vegetarian pizza I will never go back read more

If you want to order food and eat it all at the same time DO NOT come to this restaurant. Everyone in the restaurant had food but us. We had to eat the food in shifts. It was the more horrible experience ever. The waitress was not nice either. What a sour puss. She only came back one time to check on us. This was very poor lunch. I would NEVER return. Do not waste time and money. Do not stop here. Pass this place and move on to another destination read more

Bone dry wings and greasy pizza the only reason I'm giving 3 stars is because their steak and cheese subs are decent. The fries are a joke, and the staff are sketchy. Disappointing but the prices are dece.t. I usually only go here if rockys is closed. Or because members of my family like it. read more

First thought: this doesn't look very "NY Italian." I grew up in the metro NY area. So I know what I'm looking for when I hear that claim. We had just sat down when one woman wanted to take our drink order. I told her I hadn't even looked yet and would like to, but she seemed a bit annoyed at that and repeated "we have coke products." I didn't want soda and was rushed into a water. Again, when we placed our order, the attitude we received seemed "annoyed;" it seemed only regulars were allowed a friendly atmosphere. I think the delivery guy overheard me discussing Yelp, because after that, attitudes changed vastly, and the one guy in the kitchen didn't seem put off when I asked for vinegar. We tried the super Italian sub, and no, it wasn't NY style, but it was good regardless. We also ordered the pizza. This was definitely not NY style, and while my 4 year old liked it, we felt like it had no real flavor. read more

We go every monday for their cheese pizza and two liter of soda for $6.99 deal. The waitress is always super busy and the dining area is small but its so nice to see locals serving good food at a great price. Esc. when that end of town is flooded by franchises. read more

Excellent Pizza. Also very good sandwiches, especially the Tuna. This is a "hole in the wall" place with excellent pizza. I live in Thurmont and I eat here very often. The service is consistently pretty good and the prices are very reasonable. I highly recommend the BBQ Chicken Pizza. *Update - 9-7-10* I also highly recommend the Cheese Steak Pizza! Actually it's all really good! -R read more

I have been to Fratelli's twice--once for pizza and once for a hot veggie sub. I think the food is excellent and the prices are very reasonable. Service was very friendly when I was there. I saw huge bags of onions sitting by the kitchen, which I took as a positive sign. If I lived in Thurmont, I would be a regular. read more

ATTN NFA and FEMA students, if you have a car- head out of Emmitsburg and come eat here and order out. Delicious! Best pizza I've had in the area. Beats the Pizza Hut and other pizza shop in the area hands down. Authentic, great tasting, and a great deal- I paid $11 for a large one topping pizza. Will visit again. read more