Once a month, I make a trip to the charming city of Waynesboro to restock my nearby antique store. During my visits, I always take the time to explore and support the local restaurants and shops that this quaint town has to offer. On this particular occasion, I happened to stop by the antique store next door and found myself entering a delightful restaurant to quench my thirst. As I scanned the menu, my eyes were drawn to their mouthwatering pizzas. Intrigued, I decided to give them a try. Our charming server, Ana, warmly welcomed us and recommended we try their signature deep-dish pizza with half cheese and half pepperoni toppings. The pizza arrived, and I was immediately captivated by the perfectly golden, flaky crust. The sauce and cheese were equally delightful, melding together in perfect harmony. I wholeheartedly recommend that anyone living in or visiting the area make it a point to stop by this hidden gem. Their extensive menu is sure to have something for everyone. The restaurant is spacious and can accommodate parties for any occasion. Be sure to ask for Ana; she was incredibly kind and attentive throughout our visit. I eagerly look forward to my next visit to Waynesboro, where I can sample even more of the delicious dishes this restaurant has to offer. read more

See all

I will never order food again, I have never, NEVER received what I have orderd and they tell me they will be right back with it and I don't see them...What a shit show.... read more

We've ordered from Brother's for over a decade. The pizza has always been hot, fresh, and flavorful. The calzones are HUGE and the subs are on the large size, as well! Price is average for area and service is fast and standard. I would definitely recommend this restaurant if you're looking for a quick, tasty meal! They offer delivery, eat-in, and pick-up, so there's several ways to enjoy a great meal with them. read more

The food has always been great. I have had take out and delivery. Everyone I have delt with has been very friendly. I will definitely try dine in at some point. read more

I just had the Leave It To Us sub with L, T, M, O, Sweet Peppers and sautéed mushrooms. This sandwich is the best. The taste is incredible and I normally don't eat bread but the toasted roll is just great. You must come and get one. Get their wings, pizza, Italian and Mexican foods too. They're also really good. We order deliver as well read more

Brother's Pizza - Leave It To Us Pizza Sub - Pizza Near Me - Waynesboro, Pennsylvania

Great food! Nice folks Extensive menu. Certainly MORE than Pizza. We love their subs. Capacola ham and cheese. Ask for it heated !

If your expecation is a stereotypical pizza and sub shop then Brother's definately delivers on that experience and will hit the mark for you. We get Brothers a couple times a month and have never had a bad exprience with either the quality or service. Delivery is always prompt and the pizzas haven't been tossed around inside the box making a mess out of them. The subs are appropriately portioned with a good flavor that you would expect from a pizza and sub shop. The onion rings and fries were suprisingly good. At the risk of getting on some Yakuza hitlist, I also want to point out they know the ancient sub shop secret of making a little tent out of the bag so the steam doesn't turn the fries soggy. I know a detail like that seems trivial, but it really is one of those insider pro-tips that goes unrecognized unless it wasn't done. If you ate here and your expecation wasn't a pizza and sub shop then lets be real - This probably wasn't the first disappointing outcome from a choice in your life, was it? read more

Pizza is excellent. Breakfast is super. Prices are affordable. Lots of locals Place is alway full

Good food , always seems like a value, because if you don't leave full it's your fault. Good pizza and wings and salads. Never ordered the other side of the menu but I'm sure it's quality with sandwiches subs and Mexican food you really can't go wrong. Always friendly service, on of the old regulars I miss. read more

Best philly on the planet. Home made roll, tender meat, all the toppings.... legit. Don't judge by the location of front of the building. It's nice inside. Staff is great read more

The service is great. It is not a large business. It has a few shops, but I prefer the one in Rouzerville. My family has been there many times and the servers know what we order to drink. They just bring it over to us. The pizza is good for the area. They offer both a New York style and Sicilian pizza. They toppings, sauce, and cheese are good quality. The portion is great and filling for my family. They offer subs, some pasta, Stromboli, calzones, salads, and a variety of Mexican food. I can say that I have tried most of the menu and have not been disappointed. The price for the food and drink is great as well. It is afford for a family. The wait time for the food is average, but the quality can't be rushed that they provide. read more

This local pizza shop is great! The staff is always friendly and helpful. The delivery is always pretty quick even during peak times! We order from here often and have always had great service and great food read more

This is usually my go to take out place and I've always been happy with everything I've eaten, but today I ordered the black and blue salad, it comes with grilled shrimp on top which is yummy. The only thing is they still had the tails on. That's the first place I've ever seen do that. Otherwise, it was delicious and fresh. The staff are very friendly and professional, and the delivery guy was friendly and efficient. For this particular review I'm giving 3 stars because I wasn't happy with the shrimp tails. I do recommend the taco salad, which is delish and their pizza! read more

Brother's Pizza - Black and Blue salad with grilled shrimp,onions,chunks if blue cheese, tomatoes and avocado. - Pizza Near Me - Waynesboro, Pennsylvania

Brothers rocks!! They have great salads and appetizers. Everything is always fresh. They will customize anything. They also serve breakfast, which I have yet to try, because they don't deliver breakfast. Their pizza is really good, along with their wraps, paninis and subs. I eat here, via delivery, weekly. The only problem I've ever had is, twice the calamari had gone bad. We just quit ordering it. Everything else is great, and they have really fast delivery. read more

Waited an hour and a half for food and when I called back he told me to chill out and to go ahead and pay for it and if it was cold to call back food never showed up at any point read more

!!!!!***UPDATED WEBSITE / MENU***!!!!! The website/link on YELP is incorrect, as is the link for the menu. Both take you to one of those unclaimed domain "websites" that will just be one page with several , unrelated links. YELP link incorrectly takes you to ww7.brospizzawaynesboro.com. The correct WEBSITE IS WWW.BROTHERSWAYNESBORO.com but it may redirect you through a local wyinn.com, which is some sort of local social media/advertising conglomerate for local businesses in the waynesboro/Chambersburg area. Haha I realize now this post looks (and reads) rather ridiculous but just use the WWW.BROTHERSWAYNESBORO.COM address to find both the correct restaurant and menu , and you're golden... read more

This place Rocks!!!!! The pizza and calzones are amazing!!!! Very friendly staff! Very clean inside! Highly recommend!

Me and my family ordered here as our first meal, in our new home. The person on the phone was nice, the delivery guy was awesome. However, two of the people who ate the tuna spent their first night in the new home being violently ill. Like any decent person, I wanted to get in touch to let them know that it might be prudent of them to pull that batch from use. I did not yell, I did not demand free food, and the response was that it was not them(Brother's Pizza), that they need to go to the hospital because it isn't their food. After I reiterated that it was not one person but two who fell ill, he basically said he would look into it and hung up the phone. There are too many "sub & pizza" shops in the area to accept anything but great customer service and someone who listens loudly when constructive feedback instead of yelling is given. Wont be taking our chances here again. read more

The pizza was delicious! And the service was fast and attentive. Love the restaurant atmosphere and it has lots of seating choices, perfect for a small or large group. read more

Brother's Pizza - The pizza was delicious! Hot & fresh. The service was great. Love the restaurant atmosphere and it has lots of seating choices. - Pizza Near Me - Waynesboro, Pennsylvania

If your kitchen is closed and you are no longer taking orders, turn your "OPEN" sign OFF please.

Usually a business like this would support another business and make a good deal on 20 pies. Not this place. You pay the standard price for their pizza. No deal... from now on my business will patronize a different pizza shop. I mean after all you gaining exposure with people who may not know your brand thanks Brothers. read more

All of their menu items are very good ... this isn't just a typical Italian pizza joint , (tho the pizza is good too and better than the other pizza delivery places). They make great subs, and the meals are always good too (shimp alfredo, etc) read more

I've loved their pizza every time for a few years now. I got one yesterday that disappointed and, when I called, they sent me another one. Great service! read more

We love the pizza and the subs. The delivery is prompt for the most part. Sometimes on really busy nights it's takes longer than usual but is you call in and your nice they will do anything to help out. We love this place‼‼ read more

Avoid at all cost, the grill line pushes low quality food out quickly. Quality is absent in all regards. I have ordered Wings for the third time now, asking that they are cooked "well done" for the second time I have received slimy and soggy wings. If you want wings this is not the place. read more

Great food for a quick and inexpensive meal. Staff is normally attentive, but occasionally a new person slows down the works. Great food including meatball sub, cheeseburger sub, pizza, tacos, salads, stromboli, etc. Also serve a good, inexpensive breakfast. read more

I love the Brothers Pizza in Greencastle, PA. This one in Waynesboro is horrible. I will drive to Greencastle from now on. I ordered a chef salad and it was nothing but lettuce and a few onions . No thanks . I won't return. read more

Pizza very good , pony up for the works on the Sicilian pizza it will feed the whole family for days. It is hard to take pizza seriously when its on the same menu with a burrito, bbq'd chicken, taco pizza had them all very good. Worth the drive cross town, usually able to get in and out quickly. read more

We have had now two extremely bad customer service experiences! The first was when we were told 30-45 minutes and it took 1 hour and 30 minutes and our pizza was cold. The manager did not care about my complaint and was very rude and we sent the cold pizza back with his driver. Today we tried to order from Brothers and was told by the same manager that we are to far (we live 2.5 miles away) I told him we are not far and they deliver farther he said it is because of our complaint of the cold pizza and delivery time last time we ordered ( which was months ago). He proceeded to say that we are never allowed to have delivery from them again because no of our one complaint! read more

Best philly on the planet. Home made roll, tender meat, all the toppings.... legit!!!!

One has to wonder what is going on with these review sites, or with Brother's Pizza in general. I wrote a review last year, which was not a flattering one, and posted it on every review site I could fine. Lo and Behold, I cannot find my review on any of them now. Odd. We used to enjoy this place, until we called an order in for carry-out one evening. The order was correct except for my sub. We ordered a steak and cheese sub and got a sub with nothing but bacon on it. I'm talking nothing but crumbled up bacon. When we called to advise that the order was wrong the owner argued with me on the phone, saying that we ordered a bacon sub. Uhm no, I guarantee I didn't because I don't like bacon. He was incredibly rude and actually sat on the phone and ARGUED with me about my order for over 5 minutes!!! Really? What has happened to customer service??? Wouldn't he think that I knew what I ordered? It's not like I called and said oh, you forgot the onions on my sub. I ordered a steak and cheese and got a BACON sub!!! The experience was enough that we have not patronized the establishment since. I have never, ever experienced a more rude person in my life. Do not eat at this place if you value being treated with respect, as you should be as a person who is supporting the livelihood of the owner and the employees. read more

Pizza was so/so but wings and salad were excellent! Pizza was thin, not a lot of sauce, toppings slid right off and almost $2 per additional topping! read more

So after my last experience with this place, i decided to give them another shot. I felt like something different as in my household we normally stick to safe places like Domino's Pizza. We certainly got something different! I believe some people call it food poisoning. We order nachos and the meat was grey...GREY! They said 30-45 minutes, the food arrived an hour later. I am very nervous when it comes to mom and pop shops because its either wonderful or horrible. There will not be a third strike for this place! Keep your money and if you are in Waynesboro and don't feel like cooking, order from anywhere else but Brother's. The only saving grace they have is the delivery driver we had. He was nice. read more

I have been going here for years! They have amazing food and great service. I drive from chambersburg just to get some wings and cheese fries! It is definitely worth the drive! They have expanded their menu over the years and in my opinion everything is delicious. Great food and great service, definitely recommend. read more

I have been ordering from this business for years and today I had the worse experience. I called and ordered take out. I told the girl on the phone that I wanted a panini chicken sandwich and when my order was delivered I got a regular chicken sandwich. When I called I was told that I was going to have to pay full price for a panini chicken sandwich and the female manager kept interrupting when I was trying to explain the situation. I got upset and had to raise my voice my voice because she kept interrupting me and then on top of it she hung up the phone on me twice. I hope she isn't the owner because if so that business will go down soon. I will never order from this restaurant ever again. They are being ran by some rude un costumer friendly people. I spoke clear for that girl who took my order and to get told that you aren't going to make this right for a loyal customer, I will never spend another dollar there. read more

Hit or miss. Let's look at the facts. It's an American restaurant in which Mexicans make Italian food. Mind blowing, I know. But usually its pretty darn good. The place inside is strangely out of place. Not just for a pizza place, but for the location. A hole in the wall between a roller skate rink and a bowling alley should probably look like a demiliterized zone and smell like wet dog. It doesn't though. It's very nice inside, a few tables, mostly booths, a very nice counter and stools, a few tvs to watch whatever they think you should, and, oh yeah, usually decent food. Like I said, hit or miss. The first few times I went, the pizza was fantastic. Few times in my life have I ever said that the crust was better than the pizza itself. But they had that magic. Had. Lately, the wizard is either off, or dead. The pizza is still ok, and the wings are alright, but I no longer strive to go there over Dominos. If you catch them on a bad day, its going to seem like a waste. If you get them on a good one, you may just be getting a fluke. read more

The waitress Cindy is a complete...b--ch. I have never felt so rushed, and an inconvenience as I did with her. Not to mention, she charged us for things that we originally asked for but didn't get. So when I brought it to her attention she simply cut me off, and said I'll fix it. Came back and rapidly showed me the small difference in price, and handed the receipt off to me. Sorry I refuse to pay for something I never got. The way she speaks to the other employees is horrible as well. Also I understand the cooks are in the back, but they should clean up their appearance a little bit. The one woman cook looks like she is from the backwoods, unprofessional at its best. I remember the young girls Amy, Holly, and Tammy that worked there, and were so friendly and efficient. Obviously those girls moved onto better things, but where can you find good help anymore? read more

worst customer service ever...i asked for a meatball sub and a turkey sub fries and a 2 liter...they said 16$...i said ok didnt think twice...till it arrived and all i got was one sub and a very small bag of fries...i was so pissed, not only do i have to wait but then they will charge me more...I was so mad that one sub and a dollar size fries were so much money...then the guy argued with me saying that is what i ordered ...he must think pissing off customers..especially one that orders a lot from them doesn't mean nothing to him..all i got to say is WOW read more

Best pizza around town! The steak and cheese is comparable to what I've had in Philly. Bread used for the subs are AMAZING! All the food I've had there has been absolutely delicious. Delivery time has been slow at times and so I prefer to go in and pick it up. Very happy with this spot. read more

Subs are fantastic. The waiters are very friendly. The make their sub rolls fresh from scratch every day and it adds a lot to the sub. I like the chicken cheese steak the best. Pizza is good and the salads are huge. read more