The food at Vincent's Steakhouse is superb. Our favorite is their burgers. They are the best I have ever tasted. Add sweet potato fries and you are golden!! And if you enjoy martinis, Vincent's Steakhouse makes a superb martini. I also had the pleasure of enjoying a party at Vincent's Steakhouse. We were a very large group but the waitstaff kept up with our drink orders and our buffet was very varied and every single dish was perfection. I highly recommend Vincent's restaurant, you will not be disappointed. Try their burgers on a Tuesday, they offer a special on them that you will really appreciate. Just saying, you will be happily surprised. Enjoy! read more

Good food and a great price fix menu. Staff was attentive and helpful. Everyone enjoyed their meals.

A wonderful dinner on our 35th anniversary. The restaurant is beautiful, the food is wonderful, and our server, Jessica, is loving and accommodating. We will be sure to visit Vincent's again and again. read more

Vincent's Steakhouse - Dessert .. delicious - Steakhouses Near Me - Wantagh, New York

My husband was craving a steak and wanted to find a reasonably priced steak at a local restaurant. Vincent's Steakhouse delivered a wonderful meal. Hubby got the strip steak with mac n cheese and sauted spinach. I had the boneless ribeye with Parmesan garlic potatoes and mushrooms and onions. The steaks were cooked beautifully and delicious! The sides were yummy, too. Our appetizer was the mussels in scampi sauce and although the mussels were tiny the scampi sauce was excellent! And we had the Fall Sangria which was fabulous! It was a great meal! read more

Vincent's Steakhouse - NY strip steak - Steakhouses Near Me - Wantagh, New York

See all

3rd Times not the charm. Went for a last minute Valentine's Day dinner. Ordered the baked clams, mostly bread crumbs. I had the porterhouse for my main and while the filet portion was very good, the rest was inedible. I could barely cut it, it was fatty and gristle. I so wish this was a better spot. Oh well. read more

Steak was great and perfectly cooked. Only problem was Happy hour is only at the bar and you cannot fit more than 4 people on it . When you sit at a tablethe happy hour does not apply. read more

Old steakhouse feel, professional service staff and good quality meats. One of the better steakhouses on Long Island.

Its a great place, service is fantastic, atmosphere is really nice, its one of those non formal steak houses. The drinks where great, seafood aps very tasty. We had the porterhouse for 2, perfectly cooked. Odd was we only had 2 side choice but we god mac and cheese and creamed spinach. Both were ok but could use some focus and jazzing up. Desert was super, carrot cake and lava cake were great. Nice place, pinch and only a pinch pricey but we will go again. read more

See all

Service was excellent, drinks kept coming, and very friendly. The ambiance was real nice, casual dressed, not loud but not quiet.(in a good way). The food was outstanding started with the hummus, and the shrimp. It was so good the three of us ordered a 2nd round. We then had a 40 oz porterhouse & a filet mignon followed with cream spinach, mashed potatoes, & steak fries. Dessert, to much to type. The restaurant is awesome, I actually like it better than the more expensive steakhouses around LI. read more

Tough to review this place because the service was really good towards the end but none of us really enjoyed our meal and said we wouldn't come back. We walked in Sunday 2:30pm. There are about 5-6 tables occupied. We stand there for a bit. No hostess, looked like only waitress was making drinks. After standing there awkwardly for a few minutes the waitress instructs us to sit where we want. We came for restaurant week so we order from there. Hubby buffalo wings, my son honey bbq and I get Cesar salad. Everything was good, not great. Just meh. Lunch: . Hubby orders steak well done, don't judge him, and when he cut it I knew he wouldn't like it but he's not one to return food so he did his best. Honestly it was red. My chicken Milanese was really crunchy but flavorless. Idk. Son's burger, had no mayo or ketchup, no special sauce, nothing. Bread fell apart and the fries were ok. Overall we were underwhelmed. After we sat service improved dramatically and they were friendly and quick. read more

See all

Went there for the first time to celebrate my mother-in-law's birthday. At the end of the meal, they made a beautiful cake slice presentation and fuss over her birthday, which we didn't ask for they just did it on their own! We all ordered off the brunch menu, and I had the cannoli cream French toast, oh my God it might've been one of the best things I've ever eaten! Our waitress was so adorable and friendly. We will come back! read more

Vincent's Steakhouse - Surprise birthday cake! - Steakhouses Near Me - Wantagh, New York

Service was horrible. Had to ask for water after given our table and waiting 15 minutes. It was Saturday night at 7:00 and place was empty. Steak was very good, but wife got only salad for dinner and they must have forgotten it. She didn't get it until 10 mins after I got my dinner. One person in our party was still eating when they took all others' plates away. I felt bad bc it made that person feel like everyone was watching her eat. For dessert waiter came out for my first AND second choice telling me they didn't have it, but got my third choice for free making up for it. Overall, service or lack there of, solidified my decision to give it a negative review. I would recommend any other steakhouse. read more

On Friday night, I went to Vincent's Steakhouse in Wantagh. We decided to give it a try, especially since there were so many excellent reviews on Facebook in the local groups. My friend and I are both foodies so it is nice to give great feedback for a place that truly deserves it. The staff are very hard working and accomodating. Vincent, the owner, made room for us even though we made a last-minute reservation. He is truly a great guy who runs a wonderful establishment. There is limited parking out front but plenty out back. The interior of the restaurant is simple but classy. On Friday nights, there are live bands. The band played a lot of songs from the Rat Pack. It was quite a sophisticated atmosphere. There is no dress code, but most people dressed appropriately. There were a few young couples dressed in jeans, but that's their generation for you. Vincent's has a very nice cocktail selection and wine selection to choose from. On their main menu, the appetizers are very appealing. You may wind up trying more than you can eat. We opted to try their pre fixe menu for Restaurant Week. Everything was delicious! Jessica, our beautiful and ever so polite server, recommended the Beer Cheese Soup. It was spectacular, to say the least. I normally would never have tried it, but all of her suggestions were spot on. My friend ordered the mussels, which came with a zesty broth, just the smell of the garlic made your mouth water. They served us cornbread with jalapeños and a cinnamon butter. The bread was fabulous, but I'm not a fan of the cinnamon, so we opted for regular whipped butter. The portions are not skimpy whatsoever. In fact, there was a lot of food leftover that we took home. This is the perfect spot for date night, getting together with friends or family or even dining alone. The music just makes the environment very inviting. I look forward to coming back here very soon. The reviews did not do this place justice. It was that good. I'd have to say this is in my top 10 restaurants on Long Island. read more

See all

Just ate there last night after reading the reviews. Wanted to support a local restaurant instead of big chains like Ruth Chris Steakhouse. The four of us enjoyed all of our food, and our server was very accommodating. The pricing was good as compared to other steakhouses. We had the special appetizer calamari was ok. The Barada salad was excellent. We had Serf & Turf, pork chops, shrimp, and lobster, risotto, and filet mignon for dessert. We had Keylime pie, cheesecake, Apple Walnut slice all were very, very good but the tiramisu was egh. This is definitely worth checking out . read more

Came here on a Sunday night recently. It is not a loud place at all, which I love, because I prefer to be able to talk to the person I'm with. Service was excellent without being obtrusive. Had the best dirty martini I've had in my life here. Steak prices are very reasonable and actually include sides for the price. Steak was perfectly cooked and the sides were delicious. Thanks again! read more

Vincent's on Fridays is great. Food, service and waitstaff are all terrific and for added enjoyment the music of Tom Smith adds to the experience. Tom plays and sings everything from Americas songbook to the Beatles- in fact when he sings in Italian it is pure joy! Reasonable prices, steaks include a couple of sides so not all aka carte like other steakhouses. Finally it's always great when Vincent himself greets the diners! read more

Service was good. Sangria was excellent. But the steak was disappointing to be honest. A steakhouse without a bone in ribeye just doesn't do it for me. The dry aged ribeye was thin, a little overdone for the ordered rare temp, and unexpectedly came with a sauce poured over it. It just wasn't worth it in my opinion. Can get a better not dry aged, but prime ribeye, larger and bone in, not too far away. Will keep an eye on reviews and if they change it up, would consider returning. read more

Vincent's Steakhouse - Ribeye - Steakhouses Near Me - Wantagh, New York

I love this place! Our second time here and another delicious meal. The pear martini s are amazing ! We had the hummus nachos which were the best thing ever ! Chicken Milanese was delicious . My husband got the baked clams / forgot to take a pic . They were to die for . Owner and staff are awesome . :) read more

See all

Food was pretty good entertainment was good atmosphere was nice waitress was very good bill was a little pricey

Went in for an early Saturday night dinner for the first time and was pleasantly impressed. The food and drinks were excellent, but not to be outshined by our server, Fran! She was phenomenal, so friendly, attentive, and made sure our first dining experience here won't be our last! read more

This is a hidden gem. Very nice decor inside. Food is fantastic with nice portions. A little pricey but I think it's well worth a visit especially for a special occasion or date night. Service was excellent as well with the staff always making sure everything is OK and your water is filled. Their non steak dishes are outstanding as well. read more

Celebrated our 50th wedding anniversary with a party of 14 people. Everything was excellent. The food, the service, the atmosphere. Could not have asked for more. read more

Didnt want to write this review. We went on Monday night for the pre-fix menu. Only one of us wound up ordering off that menu. The others in our party ordered off the regular menu. Food was not good. Steak fatty. Portions small. Chicken was fake looking and oddly shaped round pieces, extremely chewy. We just said to ourselves maybe its us. With the pre-fix menu you get a dessert. We asked for the cheesecake to go. Didn't even look at it in the restaurant. When we got home we took it out of the bag and its moldy. We will definitely not be back. Not sure how this would get past someone putting it together. Gross. Sorry read more

Vincent's Steakhouse - Moldy cheesecake - Steakhouses Near Me - Wantagh, New York

Quality food for a more casual steakhouse. Desserts were not impressive at all unfortunately though - the carrot cake was lacking the typical cream cheese frosting and the tiramisu was very cakey (not sure they even used lady fingers) and had no espresso taste at all. Nice and spacious inside. Prices are pretty reasonable. Service was great. read more

I really wanted to like this place. The appetizers were delicious and I thought we were going to be in for a good night. Very good french onion soup. However the steaks left a lot to be desired. While they were cooked perfectly as ordered, there was absolutely zero seasoning. Not an ounce of salt or pepper. The house steak sauce tasted like ketchup. Chocolate cake for dessert was nothing special; it tasted like cake from a diner. We went on a weeknight and the place was empty. It said the steak was dry aged on the menu but it didn't taste like it. They were tasteless. If you call yourself a steakhouse and have steakhouse prices you expect better. To top it all off they charge the dreaded 3.6% credit card fee which I've never seen a true steakhouse do (most people don't carry around hundreds of dollars unless Peter Lugers). The servers were awesome... friendly and knew the menu well. I feel bad saying this but unfortunately I don't think I'll be back. read more

I took my family to Vincent's last night and couldn't of been happier with the food and service. We all ordered different things ranging from steak, pasta, burgers and a Caesar salad and my entire family loved the food that was served. I typically don't review restaurants unless I am impressed by the food. I will say that the portions aren't huge and you'll probably not be taking home left overs but I feel that the portions were a perfect size for my family and nothing was over priced. For anyone looking for new places to eat I highly recommend trying this place. read more

Great addition to the neighborhood, menu a little different from Thom Thom (which is also very good) they offer sushi, Vincent's it's more of a traditional steakhouse,Plenty of seating, the decor is wonderful, you get that Home Lodge type feeling, Ivan was fantastic service was quick everything was correctly done, checked up on us multiple times to see if we were doing good, Phone was flavorful delicious can't go wrong with anything on the menu, I had Vincent's Grill which is more like a traditional Argentinian mix grill, chorizo, chicken and steak we're all done to perfection, Adans burger was a Mouthwatering mouthful, they also have a cocktail menu and full-service bar, all the desserts or homemade read more

See all

Dam first to start this place was real nice. I had the filet magnon, broccoli, and baked potato. It was fanominaly marvelous. The prices were a bit high and the wait was about 15 minutes for food but otherwise it was great, and there was even a nice little jazz band played in the front. Anyways the moose cake for dessert was like usual moose cake so yeah. read more

See all

Excellent steak and sides!! Full of flavor, no steak sauce needed. I had the filet mignon cooked well done and it was not a hockey puck. It was cooked perfectly and full of flavor. The mashed potatoes and Brussels sprouts were excellent as well. My wife had the porterhouse cooked medium with mashed potatoes and creamed spinach, all fantastic. We will be back :) read more

Little Vincent's Steakhouse is a unique venue with an excellent selection of steak and fish dishes. If you want great food excellent service and a check that won't break your bank account I highly Reccomend coming to see Vincent...the chef/owner who took the time to say hello at our company holiday event. Bravo Vincent's....Tracy our hostess was awsome! read more

Vincent's Steakhouse - At the Bar before the meal. - Steakhouses Near Me - Wantagh, New York

See all

Food was mediocre. For a steakhouse the steak was not good! Ordered porterhouse for 2 Medium for $100 came out raw! They took it back it came back dried up like they microwaved it! The food took an hour to come out when there were only about 5 tables. The service was not good! Waitress was not attentive at all. My child's burger was asked to come out as soon as it's ready that took over an hour. There was no manager at all! All the customers were always looking for someone for help. Only 2 waitresses. This should be called Vincent's Burgers not Steakhouse! Even the burger was not good! Way overpriced not worth the money spent. Overall bad, service and horrible food. You're better off going to Ruth Chris and spending your money there! read more

Excellent place!! This is our go-to place, from the fun, creative cocktails to the delicious food! We love the Caesar salad and baked clams to start, and all of their entrees are delicious read more

Wonderful lunch, attentive service, , and an amazingly reasonable brunch menu. Moreover, the Tuesday half-price burger special is unbelievable! Five stars. read more

Gave them a second chance. Still won't recommend to anyone. Can't get steak temp right and didn't understand the concept of melted butter for surf and turf. Had to wait 15 minutes for them to bring out correct temp on steak. While my wife sat with her food getting cold. read more

We ordered a filet mignon and ribeye. Both were decent, cooked accordingly. Nice that the steaks were served with your choice of "starch" and vegetable. We got baked potatoes and asparagus. Not the same top-quality or presentation that you would get from a fancier steakhouse but decent. Cons - lacked ambiance and odd choice of pop music playing. read more

Terrific! Lovely live music on weekend evenings. Great staff. Delicious food! Amazing dessert selection! Nice hidden gem for a lovely night out! Family outing or date night too! read more

What can I say? Vincent was so very helpful. Truly service with a smile. The food was so delicious and tasty.Thank you so much for a wonderful baby shower. read more

See all

First timers at Vincent's and we chose New Year's Eve which could be a dicey choice but this place did not disappoint. The restaurant was beautifully decorated and reservations were carefully scheduled so it never felt crowded despite the holiday. There was live music which was pleasant and provided ambiance but didn't prevent table conversation. Most importantly, the food was spectacular. The charcuterie platter was abundant and everything was fresh and delicious and high quality. The Mediterranean nachos were curiously presented in a bowl so we didn't know what to expect, but we could've licked the bowl clean! The steak choices provides every option you'd want and, for a steakhouse, each steak included a starch AND a vegetable which is practically unheard of, all at very reasonable prices. Every one of our 8 steaks was well seasoned, perfectly cooked, and delivered on flavor. The sides were generously portioned and tasty. Desserts covered all the bases and were beautifully presented and a perfect sweet ending. Overall, having been to many other local steakhouses, you will not see a better bang for your buck, a more delightful atmosphere and a more delicious meal! Six stars!! read more

My friend and I came here to try the Restaurant Week lunch menu. Vincent's exceeded all expectations. Usually, Restaurant Week menu items are hit or miss but Vincent's went so all out on their selection that we felt as if we were "stealing" our meals because the value was so good. We started with the Beer Cheese soup and the Steak Tacos. The flavors were so rich! I was especially impressed with the soup, which I am told is not yet a menu staple. For our main course, we each had the French Dip with sweet potato fries. French dips can be hit or miss, with dry flavorless meat and au jus that's mostly salt. Not so with Vincent's. Up until now, Homestead was my favorite French dip on Long Island but Vincent's is absolute perfection. The sweet potato fries were crisp and delicious, too. Dessert was chocolate mousse cake and cannoli and both were outstanding. It was easy to tell how freshly made our desserts were. What made our experience truly unforgettable was the excellent service by Frank. He's extremely knowledgeable about the menu and happy to recommend items. We're looking forward to seeing him again soon! While pictures would have made this review even better, we were so excited to try everything that we didn't think of it. Next time! And there will be a next time. read more

Sunday brunch is amazing!!! Frank is the best waiter/bartender EVER!!!! Food is yummy .