Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Upper Crust Pizzeria

    3.1 (413 reviews)
    ModeratePizza, Italian, Salad
    Open 11:00 am - 10:00 pm

    Order Upper Crust Pizzeria Takeout or Delivery

    Upper Crust Pizzeria Photos

    UPPER CRUST PIZZERIA ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Moderate noise
    Casual
    Good for kids
    Good for groups

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Upper Crust Pizzeria

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Veggie, bbq chicken, scallion & bacon, pepperoni
    Kelly C.

    Service was fine. Walk- in, order, seat yourself (or not, for take out) and they heat up your pizza. This location is spacious which is nice. The portions are HUGE. I liked the BBQ chicken & veggie pizza. I think it satisfies the pizza craving when you're looking for a quick fix.

    Truth in advertising???

    Management should go back to school or hire a copy editor! The advertised 18" calzone was only 8". To make matters worse staff couldn't care less when I pointed out the difference.

    half and half of bbq and Hawaiian

    I like the Pizza here esp thin hard crust! My favorites are BBQ and Hawaiian. I cannot stop eating.

    Pepperoni paper thin crust for better or for worse. Good sauce good cheese good pepperoni.
    Jose B.

    Although all the ingredients were fine I couldn't get behind the the cartoonishly thin crust but great cheese sauce and toppings.

    Rosa Y.

    Honestly not a bad slice after seeing a movie at the theater next door. The slice they gave me was a touch too generous (may have really been two slices), but it was thin crust, with the right proportion of cheese/sauce, that kinda folded. Not a mindblowing slice, but met expectations.

    Honey Butter Fried Chicken Sandwich
    Jen S.

    Ok Upper Crust! Your mouthwatering FB ads for BOGOCHX worked! I've been wanting to try your new chicken sandwiches for a while and your ad finally talked me into it. Just as a note , online ordering is very simple. My husband and I very much enjoyed the honey butter chicken sandwiches! We split our sandwiches in half. They aren't giant but they can be made into two meals. Looking forward to part 2 tomorrow. The chicken is juicy and the crispy batter is perfect. We love upper crust !

    Insider tip: Online you can select two different specialty pizza halves when you build your own pie!

    You've got a few pizza options near Coolidge Corner. I've found Upper Crust to be the best for putting out a consistently great pie, fast, on-time, accurate, and with the best service. If you're going to make a commitment to a pizza place, this location in particular should be at the top of your list. My family is always happy when I bring home a pie (or two or three). Insider tip: Online you can select two different specialty pizza halves when you build your own pie!

    Caesar Salad (Large)
    Devon K.

    Here's the thing, I love Upper Crust Pizza. I'm usually a fan of thick crust, but I think they are so good at balancing their flavors that the thin crust works well. The location is right in Coolidge Corner and I had it delivered to my house (free to Brighton!), but the experience was definitely 3-star worthy. We ordered a large Caeser Salad ($8.50) and a large Vegetarian GOAT pizza ($22). The big problem is with that salad. As you can see from my picture, that is not an $8.50 salad. A couple pieces of romaine, some shaved parmesean, lemon wedges, and Ken's salad dressing in the bag. Ridiculous. We expected it to be huge and loaded with toppings, but this was snack worthy and just thrown together. Was really salty about that. The Vegetarian GOAT pizza is great and definitely worth the cost. It's huge and loaded with a multitude of flavors. I love the goat cheese and artichoke hearts on top. The problem with my pizza came because it was delivered. Upper Crust apparently uses DoorDash for delivery. So even though I got a text from Door Dash that my pizza would be here in five minutes, that driver clearly got another ping and 30 minutes later our pizza arrived ice cold. It was only 10 minutes past the "expected time window,"but because he had clearly just been driving around with it we got cold food. Also, we had tipped online and drivers for DoorDash don't get the tip (DoorDash is complicated as they use tips to offset their payment to drivers) which made me upset - had I known in advance, we would have tipped in cash. I might go back to this location for pickup, but only for pizza. Avoid the salad at all costs, just really really not worth it.

    Christine B.

    After eating here, I can finally say that I've tried all three pizza places at Coolidge Corner!! My judgment: Upper Crust is probably the place to go to when you need a quick and easy option. My friend and I came here on a weekday night, ordered a slice from one of the pre-set pizza options from the menu, and had our pizza slice in our hands within a couple of minutes. It was that quick and easy! With the convenience that you get from Upper Crust, I would say you lose out on some of the atmosphere and flexibility in personalizing your pizza that you can get from its other two competitors. Upper Crust is a bit run-down, yet has a very classic small pizzeria feel. If we are going to compare atmosphere and aesthetics, Otto's and Oath Pizza feels more modern and would be more appropriate for date nights or dinners with friends if atmosphere is important. At Upper Crust there are no options for personalizing your pizza like you can at Oath Pizza. However, other than being a quick and easy option, a pro of Upper Crust is that their pizza slices are HUGE! Definitely very filling and worth your buck. In terms of flavor, I found it to be average... nothing too special, but not at all bad. Like I said--it is a quick and easy option that gets the job done...can't expect too much!

    Nashville Hot Fried Chicken Sandwich
    Franklin Z.

    I didn't try the pizza...but the Nashville Fried Hot Chicken Sandwich was INCREDIBLE here!! I can't vouch as to how authentic the spice level was but for me, it wasn't intolerable and was actually very flavorful. The chicken was super crispy on the outside but nice and tender in the inside. I was also given honey butter and ranch dipping sauces and think the ranch sauce serves as nice, cool contrast and complement to the Nashville heat. I am very pleasantly surprised about the taste, and definitely will return to order this! Service was also very fast and friendly.

    Cracker pizza
    Patrick C.

    Well the staff was polite. The food was on time. The pizza was not very good. Overcooked and crumbly. Alot of sauce very little cheese.

    Chickadee Strip?

    See all

    Photo of Food B.
    132
    109
    6

    11 years ago

    visiting Boston after a few years. Much better than "Otto" across the street. Nice authentic sauce and flavor .

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    16 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    16 years ago

    great pizza but the service staff at this location is mediocre at best.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Upper C.

    Upper C.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Upper C.

    Upper C.

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Upper C.

    Upper C.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Upper C.

    Upper C.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    18 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Jen K.
    0
    25
    0

    16 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    15 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 11 of 11

    Ask the Community - Upper Crust Pizzeria

    You might also consider

    Bottega di Capri - Italiano Sandwich

    Bottega di Capri

    4.4(512 reviews)
    0.6 miBrookline Village
    $$

    The best Italian food I've had in the Boston area!! And the best Alfredo I've ever had -- unlike a…read morelot of North End food that is too creamy and salty, this was light and the taste was complex and DIVINE. The owners and everyone working there were so kind, it was such a wonderful, local vibe in there. Very excited to return.

    This is my secret hidden gem of an Italian restaurant located outside of the North End! Absolutely…read moreone of my favorite spots and whenever my friend visits from out of state, this is a must-go for him! Located in Brookline, Bottega di Capri is a cozy and quaint Italian spot. The food is absolutely delicious and clearly fresh. I got the Shrimp Scampi while my friend got the tortellini with cheese and added shrimp. Honestly, everything was so tasty and flavorful, plus the portions were huge for a terrific price! I was so excited for my leftovers the next day. They were super accommodating and provided great recommendations as well. The pasta sauces were incredible -- my friend ate the bread with the sauce and said it was heavenly. Major shoutout for the great service provided by Jimmy as well, he was so friendly and caring! It made this meal feel extra homey. (He even packaged my pasta to go for me to make sure I didn't spill on my dress I was wearing). Definitely recommend giving this spot a try and supporting a small business!

    Photos
    Bottega di Capri - Vibes

    Vibes

    Bottega di Capri - Penne pasta in Alfredo sauce with sausage

    Penne pasta in Alfredo sauce with sausage

    Bottega di Capri - Outside

    See all

    Outside

    Tonino - Wow

    Tonino

    4.7(127 reviews)
    2.1 miJamaica Plain

    Another 10/10 visit to Tonino in the books!…read more It's such a hard reservation to get, but so worth it. I'm actually getting salivating while posting this review and looking back at my food pictures. I get the Eggplant & Ricotta Pizza as my appetizer and the Rigatoni Amatriciana as my entree each time I go - because they're consistently amazing. The service is always warm and friendly, and I also love the music playlist they play. Believe the hype & come to Tonino!!

    People rave about this place being better than the north end; I would say it's definitely more…read moreoriginal, and the approach to food is much more intentional. However, I don't know that it lived up to the hype that I anticipated. We got the pizza Bianca with ricotta with hot honey, which was basically just like plain toasted focaccia and ricotta (wasn't anything to write home about). The taleggio was 100% our least favorite and we didn't even finish half. We had asked the waiter to describe taste profile, which they said was a "little funky" and had asked for clarification if it was closer to blue cheese. Once it arrived, it was like a verrrrrry strong/stinky Brie on the inside. The balsamic didn't really contribute to the taste at all. Sad that we didn't like this/kinda made me feel yucky after eating. The cavatelli was very good- nice light creamy sauce with the sausage and bitter broccolini. Very well balanced. Forgot to take a pic of the tiramisu but it was good, too! It's kinda salty (they add sea salt to the top). Drink menu was limited. Had two different glasses of red wine but wish they had something more full bodied on the menu!

    Photos
    Tonino - Interior

    Interior

    Tonino - Countneck Clams

    Countneck Clams

    Tonino - Countneck Clams

    See all

    Countneck Clams

    Bar 'Cino

    Bar 'Cino

    4.3(367 reviews)
    0.8 mi
    $$

    Said yes to the bread. Had the olive oil served on a plate by itself - superb…read more The flat bread pizza is insane. I would go back just for that - crispy + slicing with scissors adds a whole other feel to it. I feel in control of my flatbread. Calamari was good but I'd choose the flatbread over anything. Can't go wrong with fig, goat cheese, and prosciutto. Emma didn't like the dill on there but I didn't mind. Enjoyed with a nice glass of white wine while we dined outside.

    Had such a great experience at Bar Cino! The interior is so cute and the service was truly amazing…read morefrom start to finish. Parking in the area can be a bit tricky, but it's super convenient to get to via the Green Line, which made it easy overall. For food, everything was delicious: The Romaine & Kale Caesar was good, though I wish it had whole anchovies for a little extra punch. The prosciutto bruschetta was incredible, definitely a standout. The crispy cauliflower was my favorite dish of the night, so flavorful and perfectly cooked. The rigatoni bolognese was solid and comforting. The Chianti-Marsala braised beef short rib was insanely tender and cooked perfectly (just wish there were a few more mushrooms!). Also have to mention the dirty martini was so good. Overall, such a great spot with a fun vibe, amazing service, and really tasty food. I'll definitely be back!

    Photos
    Bar 'Cino - Modern feel

    Modern feel

    Bar 'Cino - $15 BAKED CLAMS: The most amazing clam sauce that's ever touched my tongue. We had to ask for more bread to eat every last drop.

    $15 BAKED CLAMS: The most amazing clam sauce that's ever touched my tongue. We had to ask for more bread to eat every last drop.

    Bar 'Cino - $24 TUSCAN SALAD with CHICKEN MILANESE: perfectly flattened and crispy chicken, seasoned amazing! The salad was absolutely delicious.

    See all

    $24 TUSCAN SALAD with CHICKEN MILANESE: perfectly flattened and crispy chicken, seasoned amazing! The salad was absolutely delicious.

    Bottega Fiorentina - Gluten-free bolognese with fresh mozzarella

    Bottega Fiorentina

    3.6(372 reviews)
    0.1 miCoolidge Corner
    $

    For me, I rate this 4.5 stars as there's room for improvement…read more The PROS: - amazing meat & cheese quality - very generous portion size - flavorful - outdoor chairs to sit outside - friendly staff The CONS: - a fully split-thru subroll allows contents to fall out - lack of size options sm/md vs. lg - "hots" are listed but they're not "hots". They're hot peppers/banana peppers. True hots are the red hot relish spread/hoagie spread - It'd be fantastic if the sandwiches came with Scala Bread or had an option to. I love the sesame seeded bread I ordered the Italian, and again, the meat & cheese were fantastic. They were sliced thin, and full of flavorful. Drawbacks to the sandwich is that the lettuce was spilling out from the back, and the pickles were a bit thick and perhaps had a pungent taste. Maybe the solution is to slice the pickles thinner and have a more savory brine. Regardless, tasty and you'll get your fill.

    I had such an amazing experience here! I love when businesses are easy-going and encourage…read moremodifications. I got the Chicken Parm Panini and was able to add both a lil vodka sauce and pesto on top, YUM! Not sure if offended the staff or Italians with that one. While you're waiting for your food to be prepared, they have a selection of packaged goods and cute trinkets/gifts. It makes the atmosphere all the more engaging and cute! I was SO close to buying these adorable pasta candles as well as some Pan di Stelle cookies...might need to swing back. My panini was delish! The breading they use on the chicken is the perfect texture and even with my 3 sauces, lol, it didn't get soggy. The bread was textbook as well, 0 complaints.

    Photos
    Bottega Fiorentina - Counter

    Counter

    Bottega Fiorentina - Burnt chicken in the chicken parm took out to give to the dog. Super dry and tasted like cardboard

    Burnt chicken in the chicken parm took out to give to the dog. Super dry and tasted like cardboard

    Bottega Fiorentina

    See all

    Prairie Fire - Fennel Sausage Pizza

    Prairie Fire

    4.1(263 reviews)
    0.1 miCoolidge Corner
    $$

    Was in Boston for work and ended up at Prairie Fire in Brookline -- so glad I did…read more Sat at the bar and the bartender was super helpful right away -- recommended the malloreddus and suggested a red wine to go with it. Both were spot on. The pasta had this rich tomato sauce with burrata on top, really hearty and delicious. The wine pairing made it even better. Also got the oysters which were phenomenal. Honestly the bartenders made the whole night. Friendly, knew their stuff, and made a solo work trip dinner actually fun. Really nice vibe inside and will definitely be back next time I'm in Boston.

    A fantastic meal with my mother at what I'd call a true local gem. The atmosphere is warm and…read moreinviting with plenty of bar seating and tables that give it that homey neighborhood feel you don't always find anymore. We opted to sit at the bar in front of the wood-fired oven, which turned out to be a great call. Watching the kitchen work was half the fun with pizzas and dishes coming together right in front of us. The drinks menu is impressive too, with a large selection of beers on tap plus wine, cocktails, and mocktails. For food, we kept it simple and shared our way through the menu. The Farm Green salad was crisp and fresh, pa perfect starter. Then came the asparagus, roasted in the wood-fired oven and served with a sauce that elevated the whole dish. We finished with one of their wood-fired pizzas, and it did not disappoint. Everything had that subtle smoky char you only get from a real oven. Service was excellent from start to finish. If you're looking for a spot that feels like a neighborhood staple with food that actually delivers, this is it.

    Photos
    Prairie Fire - Interior

    Interior

    Prairie Fire - Steak tartare

    Steak tartare

    Prairie Fire - Tuna Crudo

    See all

    Tuna Crudo

    Upper Crust Pizzeria - pizza - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...