Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Underbelly Meat

    4.8 (42 reviews)
    Closed 10:00 am - 5:00 pm

    Underbelly Meat Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Underbelly Meat

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Italian style roast beef
    Pat A.

    Came here yesterday for the first time to try out their featured Italian style roast beef sandwich with my wife and we absolutely loved and enjoyed it! Best sandwich I've had in AZ since moving from NJ/NY area 7 years ago. We loved that almost everything they serve is AZ locally sourced, We will be back again !

    Heavenly sandwich
    Melanie B.

    Underbelly butcher shop is everything I remember about the Midwest butcher shops. Staff is so friendly and knowledgeable. The GOAT of sandwich Grilled cheese with bacon and 5 cheeses and that tomato concoction put me in a food coma Sublime just is a small word. They need to do a food truck of sandwiches. My steak I bought and grilled was just like prime healthy thank you

    Check out the sandwich specials. You won't be disappointed.
    Angelo S.

    Visited for the first time during the lunch hour. The special that day was the Patty Melt sandwich which was fantastic. The beef patty was flavorful and was cooked perfectly. Their meat selection is locally sourced and co priced fairly, so if you are looking for meats to grill or whatever your presentation is going to be, this is your place.

    Raw milk, raw cream, grass fed ground beef and bone broth.

    See all

    3 years ago

    Always great selection and service! Highly recommend for locally sourced meats and other essentials

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Underbelly Meat

    Review Highlights - Underbelly Meat

    Left with some grass fed tallow, to top sirloin, and some freshly ground beef!

    Mentioned in 6 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Arcadia Meat Market - Golden brown turkey cooked to perfection

    Arcadia Meat Market

    4.3(113 reviews)
    5.4 mi
    $$

    Best meat market ever. Eating grass-fed proteins is the lifestyle I'm trying to live. I love that…read morethere are so many options to choose from. Sausages, patties, chicken parts, and various other meats. The butchers are great. Very helpful and friendly. They always greet upon entering the store. The store is small and quaint to get what you need in a few twists and turns. Some other items sold there include syrup, milk, eggs, wine, baking mixes, cheeses, pickled veggies and so much more. All locally sourced. This is a carnivore's heaven.

    I went in because the owner of Arcadia Meat Market bought the butcher shop I normally go to, and…read moreclosed it for remodeling. When I came in they were having a sale on their frozen products which was great because their prices were insane. I then began to talk to the person behind the counter about bulk ordering (whole, 1/2, and 1/4 cows) and the custom cuts process, because they are a "whole animal butchery". I was handed a card for a website that delivers arizona grass fed beef. I've never been to a butcher that doesn't allow custom cuts or bulk orders. You might as well go to sprouts for the same service and save the money. I bought some meat since I made the drive and the meat is definitely high quality, but my butcher was selling grass fed grass finished beef for $3 less /lb. Not to mention I was able to get bulk and custom cuts for even cheaper. I'm so disappointed that my butcher is getting replaced by them.

    Photos
    Arcadia Meat Market - Turkey!

    Turkey!

    Arcadia Meat Market - The hot Italian

    The hot Italian

    Arcadia Meat Market - Meat counter

    See all

    Meat counter

    Rusty Nail Meats - Bacon wrapped jalapeno poppers

    Rusty Nail Meats

    4.6(140 reviews)
    11.9 mi
    $$$

    We recently asked our friendly butchers to introduce us to something we hadn't previously tried…read morehere. I grew up rurally and had never eaten pork chops bought from a store until moving away. Same with ribs. My father, a Journeyman electrician had friends who farmed and sold their own pork. None better! Rusty Nail's pork chops, especially their porterhouse cuts, are even better than the ones I recall so fondly from my youth. Tender, perfectly marbled and flavorful like none other. They're not "grocery store" cuts. We also bought a rack of baby back ribs. My least favorite step in smoking them is removing their membrane. Not only was this (attention to detail!) step already completed, they were fall-off-the-bone highest quality. So good! Unlike when I was young these chops can be grilled to medium or medium-well if preferred, preserving their juices and maximizing flavor. These too are now on our dinner favorites rotation. Simple seasoning with salt and pepper is all that's needed, although next time we're trying their seasonings. We will continue shopping here regularly. We've referred every friend who enjoys value and great meals too--in other words we have suggested to everyone we know to give these great people (and local ownership!) a try. Without fail our friends are truly grateful.

    We are really lucky to have this butcher in the area…read more Pros 1. Prime beef 2. Wide variety; everything from chicken to alligator (yep, you read that right) 3. Very helpful and friendly employees 4. The loaded and twice baked potatoes when they don't have much pepper (just a personal preference). Just reheat slowly in foil until soft and melty. Trust me. They are delicious. If you want one with less pepper just choose one with less black specks. 4. Amazing price when they have a sale. For their anniversary they had 10 pounds of prime beef (their choice) for $110! Phenomenal price and great cuts were in my mystery box. Cons 1. Save your receipts just in case you need to return something. I bought two whole chickens that ended up smelling off/bad (rare instance that this happened here). I was able to return them because I luckily still had the receipt. Wouldn't have been able to return nor exchange without the receipt.

    Photos
    Rusty Nail Meats - New York strips

    New York strips

    Rusty Nail Meats - Steak seasoning

    Steak seasoning

    Rusty Nail Meats - Tomahawk ribeye

    See all

    Tomahawk ribeye

    Underbelly Meat - butcher - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...