A great local place. They were busy but we got a table quickly. Very nice staff. Everything on others tables looked good. We wanted a small meal so we ordered spaghetti & meatballs to share. It came wth a house salad. The salad was very good. The meal was excellent. The pasta itself was very good. Many times the pasta is bland. The sauce and the meatballs were also very good. It was enough food so we didn't feel stuffed. We are traveling and hate to waste food. It's very quaint inside and feels very homey. Would def recommend eating here. read more

Everything was good . The food And service was excellent. Centrally located. Good hours

We enjoyed a lovely time on a Friday evening at this hometown favorite. The restaurant was busy, but not too loud. We had reservations and we were seated immediately. The service was attentive without being overbearing. Our dinners were excellent and we really enjoyed the homemade salad dressing. We skipped the Key Lime Pie and opted for the cream puff instead. That was the perfect dessert to end our meal. Uncle Primos will be on our list again the next time we are in the area! read more

Food was delicious. Service was excellent. Atmosphere was cozy and warm. The antipasto salad was all you can eat and very tasty. We highly recommend this quaint hidden gem. read more

Uncle Primo's - Lager - Italian Near Me - New Philadelphia, Ohio

See all

The hostess asked me how I was doing when I arrived. I told her I have it made, I am eating at Uncle Primos tonight. You better have a reservation at the Uncle. 5 . read more

We have been to Uncle Primo's twice. Both times we had a positive experience. The front of the house was very efficient. Both times the restaurant was quite busy but we were promptly seated on time for our reservation. At one visit, it was homecoming for the local high school but our table was ready at the appointed 7:00 time. No small feat. The service was prompt and friendly. The salad, which was included in the meal, was abundant, tasty and well appointed. We were offered refill of the large family style bowl. I had veal parm on one visit. Although tasty, it was a ground patty priced at $27 which seemed a little high for a ground patty of veal rather than a chop. The next visit I had the lasagna trio which had lasagna, linguine and ravioli. Lots of food. Best part was the lasagna. My wife had eggplant parm that she enjoyed. Our dining companion had spaghetti with meatballs and was pleased. At one visit we had ordered the garlic bread sticks. That was unnecessary since a lot of bread was provided. All in all, a very favorable experience. We'll go back again soon read more

See all

We found this country gem thanks to Yelp on our trip back home. Both food and service were exceptional. Ashley, our server, suggested our lunch order be the soup of the day, a delicious Cream of Crab, and unlimited Italian salad what a great suggestion and nutritious lunch, thank you! read more

Uncle Primo's - Menu with soup of the day - Italian Near Me - New Philadelphia, Ohio

See all

This was our first time and it certainly won't be the last! The food was outstanding and the service was great!! So glad we went!

I love having dinner here whenever I'm in the area! Lovely service and excellent dishes. They're always busy but can always get us seated. Tonight we sat on the patio for the first time and it was fantastic! Secluded and comfortable, no noise at all from the inside of the busy restaurant. Great service as always too. Highly recommend! read more

See all

On vacation in Ohio with the family we all had a craving for Italian and this was the first place to pop up when we google Italian food near me. I must say this is by far the best Italian food I ever had in a long time and the staff is super friendly and accomdating. I had the pleasure to try something unique and different for me, I tried the, spicy Hungarian peppers with sausage and side of fettuccine and it was beyond amazing and my mom ordered the spaghetti and meatballs and she said the meatballs are excellent and great tasting, we also found out their orginal sauce isn't as sweet but they do have option to get a sweeter sauce if you so choose too which isn't seen at much resturants, and for dessert I didn't get a picture but we had the keylime pie, with a fresh lime on top, absolutely delicious! read more

See all

Friendly efficient service, very reasonable prices, and excellent food. My favorite is peppers and sausage with pasta, but they are known for great lasagna. read more

the salad is basically the same, everything else is a gross misrepresentation of what it used to be. complete disappoint across the board. absolutely overpriced and dissapoin. wish it was what it used to be. Cibos quality and product with primos pricing. avoid this place. sad shell of what it was. No desire to ever come back. Huge disappointment. read more

Best food that I've had in the valley. Also the MOST expensive meal that I have. I've been here several times this year. Get a reservation!!!!! If you are lucky enough to come at a slow time you will have good service. If the place is busy the service gets slow AND forget about having a quiet conversation. It noisy and crowded. read more

Where do I begin. From back of residential properties in new philadelphia, you could tell this is going to be a local favorite from crowded parking lot. The complimenty bread and salad is great. One of best salads there was with a homemade Italian dressing with meat, pepporoconis, olives, and crisp veggies. Main entree was devine. Perfect portion of chicken Alfredo with shrimp. The creaminess of sauce is perfect consistent for both grilled shrimp and chicken that is great with fettuccine. And to end off with the well known key lime pie, left me speechless. As a key lime pie afficenado, this made number one. The tartness of key lime was marvelous with sweet whip cream and graham cracker crust. For a nice garnish, a lime is placed on top. Will definitely return, when I'm back in area. read more

Uncle Primo's - Fettuccine with a creamy sauce that is perfectly consistent with perfect grilled chicken and shrimp with homemade shaved parmessan. - Italian Near Me - New Philadelphia, Ohio

See all

My favorite restaurant in town!! Especially love their crab cakes and the sauce that comes with. And the service and environment is always stellar. I know they switched owners and I haven't been back too often since, but I'm confident all was handed over as well as they could. I know they have the original recipes and with change, it's inevitable to have some differences. I'm excited to come back sometime soon in the near future. read more

If you're near New Phila or Dover and want great food, fantastic service and a reasonably priced meal, this is the one to choose. If you don't mind a little heat, you've got to get the stuffed Hungarian wax peppers! read more

We were in Ohio celebrating an anniversary and wanted a nice individual restaurant; no chain ones. This restaurant popped up while googling and it was the right choice. Small, intimate, great food, great service! Couldn't ask for a better meal. Make a reservation for Friday and Saturday read more

We walked in with a party of 11 on a Friday night after 7pm and were shocked to find a packed house! But it didn't take long to understand why. Despite our oversized group, we waited maybe 15 mins to be seated, and were served kindly and efficiently. Every single dish was both traditional and unique, yet prepared to perfection. The sauce has a subtle sweetness which we loved. Our bill was very reasonable given the generous quantity and delicious quality of food we received. This is a wonderful option for families or couples. read more

Uncle Primos is a unique restaurant with a small bar in the front. Their lasagna and spaghetti are excellent. Their salad dressing is the most unique and best in the area. This place has become our special event dinner since we live an hour away. read more

Great food! Great people! Great service! You won't go away hungry! We have eaten here for 20 years!

Food is always good. Staff is friendly and service is prompt. Highly recommended. Give it a try!

Food was great and service was amazing 10 out of 10 would go back again! Lasagna was like my Italian grandmother use to make

wonderful atmosphere and great food...the staff is very polite and friendly...this is one of our favorite restaurants

This place is hopping on a Friday night! Be sure to call ahead for reservations. Service was quick and efficient. Complimentary salad was great and so were the Chicken Parm and Lasagna. Highly recommend Uncle Primo's if you are in the area! read more

Six of us for dinner last night. All of us were very happy with our meals. The service was great and the waitress top notch !! Can't wait to go back again. read more

Yup, the 5 out of 5 reviews are correct. This place is great! It's an old established restaurant that makes good things happen. I had the Primo burger with sharp cheddar cheese. It was cooked as I asked at medium and the cheese was great. It came on an upscale bun that just made it better. It also came with a nice size salad (maybe a bit much dressing) and I asked for a side of broccoli. Broccoli was perfect and had shavings of Romano cheese (I think) My co-worker had chicken salad with a side of French fries. Fries were great, fresh cut and fried crispy. Chicken salad was great! Today Uncle Primo's you get an A+! read more

See all

Outstanding experience. Solo spot at bar. Tender medium filet. Clean tomato sauced angel hair. Wish seating was a bit more cozy and comfortable, like a bit finer dining for special occasions, but oh well. House salad dressing was like an oily red tinged Italian. It was good. Need to go back with a guest to try again. read more

Uncle Primo's - Italian Near Me - New Philadelphia, Ohio

See all

Frequented this restaurant many times; Terrific food and the staff is amazing. Highly recommend.

The fish is to die for. The Mahi Mahi blackened is the best I have ever had. The filet mignon can't be beat. Give this place a try. You won't regret it! read more

Wish they were open on Sundays. !! I knew the previous owners & the food was always great. I will have to come from Canton to try this great restaurant under new ownership !!! read more

Uncle Primos is one of the best Italian restaurants in the area. Their pricing is moderate-high depending what you order, but the quality and amount of food is well worth it!! Everything has great flavor and is perfectly cooked. The chicken parmesan was still crisp when arriving to the table and the fettuccine alfredo was super creamy and did not dry out while eating. I find these to be commons errors when ordering these dishes, but Uncle Primos did not disappoint. If you are craving Italian, check this place out! read more

Uncle Primo's - Fresh Garlic Bread, Chicken Parmesan, and a side of Fettuccine Alfredo. - Italian Near Me - New Philadelphia, Ohio

See all

My daughter and her family enjoy this restaurant, so we decided to eat here before I leave town. We didn't make reservations because it's a Wednesday night, we figured we wouldn't need to. Parking lot was very full when we pulled in and it was very busy inside. They were accommodating even though we didn't call ahead. I think we only waited 20 minutes for our table. The special today was manicotti, I tried to order it with white sauce but it is already cooked in red. She said they can take some of the sauce off and add the Alfredo to it. I wasn't very hungry so I just ate a few bites of my daughters. It was good and she enjoyed it. My son in law said the pork chops he ordered were tasty. Everyone seemed happy. We brought home a custard dessert thats homemade, it looks sinful. Can't wait to try it. I would definitely frequent this restaurant if I lived here. read more

See all

Went there for daughter's rehearsal dinner. They took great care of all four large tables. All the food was excellent and they even rebottled the sangria that was in pitchers so we could take it home. read more

A lot of food was cold when it came out. Chicken Alfredo wasn't like normal. First bad review from me here but not going back. It has changed. Service was still great from waitresses. read more

A really good spot to eat. Great service and great food. They have a really wide menu selection as well.

I grew up in New Philadelphia and a few blocks away from this restaurant. I remember when it opened and how often my family would go enjoy a great meal. It's been nearly 30 years and I went this past weekend with my husband (not from the area) and felt extremely nostalgic to the place and the wonderful food and service. I live in Columbus, OH and we are surrounded by a plethora of dining options. You don't expect such fine food in a small town in the middle of the rolling hills of Tuscarawas County. Thank you staff and management of Uncle Primo's, you made this New Phila girl proud of her hometown! read more

This review represents seven 5 star reviews. We were a party of 7 who came here based on Yelp reviews. We loved it! We called for reservations just about 1 hour before we were going to arrive. I am glad we did. There was a line waiting but our table was ready and waiting for us. I loved the house salad that came with our entrees. All 7 of us LOVED, LOVED, LOVED our food. We loved the tomato sauce. Good size portions. At the end of dinner, I left the table for just a couple of minutes. I returned and saw that everyone had ordered dessert. The pieces of pie were huge. We all sampled each other's pie so we tasted key lime, dark chocolate, and the cream puff. Perfect ending to a perfect dinner. The prices are very, very reasonable. I wanted to return the next night. read more

Uncle Primo's definitely has an old-school red-sauce America feel. The place is always packed, and for good reason-- the hearty portions, quality service, & good house wines make it an excellent place to gather family and friends. I would certainly go back! read more

Uncle Primo's - Front entrance - Italian Near Me - New Philadelphia, Ohio

See all

When we pulled up the parking lot was full -- it's a Wednesday night! Thankfully we had reservations. The food is amazing. I had the pan seared Mahi Mahi -- juicy, flakey, amazing and if you enjoy garlic bread their version knocked socks off!! Highly recommend to make reservations and bring your appetite. A friend had the cream puff for dessert -- he couldn't finish it -- defiantly big enough to share. Will come again when back in the area read more

We loved our experience here. We went out for our first date night here after welcoming our second child. It was such a positive experience. From the service to the food we had a great time. It was super nice that the owner was going around visiting tables and chatting. Very fun and welcoming environment. read more