My favorite pizza spot in quarryville, and there are a lot to choose from. Their lunch specials are great. They're a staple in the community and are always making improvements for their customers. I have nothing but good things to say about all of my experiences over the years! read more

Two Cousins Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Quarryville, Pennsylvania

I went here for the first time 9/1/2025. My wife and I were not super hungry, so we decided to split a large sub. Due to lactose issues, I asked for cheese on just half of the sub. The guy at the register said that they cannot do that. Confused... I said it slower that I want cheese, but only on half of the sub. Granted... the Italian sub comes with provolone cheese.... He again said that they are unable to do that. He said the only thing they are able to do is put cheese on the side. So I ordered it with "cheese on the side." After waiting 10-15 minutes for what I assumed is a simple sub to make, I received my overpriced sub with barely any meat on it. I also received a separately wrapped container with slices of cheese in it, to which I was charged an extra dollar.... So apparently it is impossible to just put two slices of cheese into only half of the sub. And because of a lactose issues, they charge an extra dollar just for asking for less cheese. I'm just glad I didn't order a pizza with half pepperoni. I'm sure I would have received a cup of pepperoni on the side and paid extra for each slice. Just ridiculous.... And the icing on the cake... I got sick after eating the sub. If you like paying 2x the amount for your food and even extra if you want to take away ingredients, wait 10-15 minutes, then this is the place for you!! read more

We love Two Cousins! We live in the Quarryville area & this place is our "go to" for pizza & sandwiches. We have ALWAYS been very satisfied with the food & service. We would highly recommend to anyone, if you are in the area. read more

We sat down to get a slice of pizza today. After finishing, we collected our dishes to return them to the front. We were ordered by the owner to bring all of our dishes back to the table. After expressing that we would not be back, he responded by saying he did not care. Okay food, mean people. read more

Waitress rolled her eyes when she thought we weren't looking. All we did was ask for a table

I gotta say, that had to have been the WORST cheesteak I have ever had from anywhere in my 57 yrs. Huge NOPE on the rolls made out of pizza dough, that ain't no amoroso roll, or anything even remotely built for juicy cheesesteak and cheese. Yuk! Sops up every bit of slop and you cant even pick it up, it's pourous and soaked, you need a fork. I worked in several deli's and NONE of us on the grill EVER chopped steak up so fine like mince meat like that! Gross! It's supposed to be chopped thinly sliced steak, not meat "spread" oh God what an abomination this was. How anyone eats a cheesesteak all beat up and chopped to smithereens like that until its so fine it's darn near like Underwood Potted beef spread, is BEYOND me! The rest of that went in the trash where it belonged. Totally turned me off for returning for anything else because if you can't even chop a cheesteak properly, thats just the start of your problems. $13 in the bin. PLEASE for the love of the Philadelphia Cheesesteak learn how to chop a steak so that it is edible and not spreadable! Gross slop on pizza dough shaped into a roll. Blech! Use real steak rolls - apalling! read more

I'll start out by saying we are from NJ, so we know what good pizza is. After reading a few negative reviews we were skeptical but gave them a try anyway. It was DELICIOUS!! We ordered a well done cheese pizza and an order of boneless wings. They delivered right to our campsite which was super convenient. The delivery driver was on time and nice. We will definitely order from Two cousins when we are in the area next time. read more

We decided to try a different place (for us) for Italian food take out. The order consisted of a large regular Stromboli with added onions and peppers, two Cheese steaks and one dozen wings - our total bill was just under $67.00. The bread/rolls are touted as home made so we thought the sandwiches would be delicious! The rolls were very pale outside and gummy inside. The inside texture was not from juices from the steak, the rolls were underbaked. The chipped steak itself had no flavor...at all and there wasn't much meat in the roll. The Stromboli was pale and could have been baked a little longer. ( we did not show up early to claim our order, it was wrapped and ready when we arrived) The onions and peppers that we paid extra to add ($3.75 each) in the Stromboli were barely present. The inside was just ham and cheese - not the full assortment that is listed on their menu. The dozen wings were fine, but the celery was dried out and it had dark spots all over - it should have been thrown away not passed off to a customer. I didn't get a photo of the celery before I threw it away ‍. Two Cousins is next door to a huge grocery store so fresh ingredients are easily available. The staff were nice enough, but we will never go back. This was an expensive lesson and an unfortunate meal to share as part of a birthday celebration. read more

Two Cousins Pizza - Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Quarryville, Pennsylvania

See all

Tried the regular cheese pizza: nondescript crust, flavorless sauce, oily. The overwhelming taste is the taste of whatever oil they put on it. I will not return. read more

Would NOT recommend Two Cousins Pizza in Quarryville, PA. My mom walked in to order a cold Italian sub and waited 15 minutes. On her way out, Wednesday 11/02/2022 at ~6:30/EST, the long dark haired girl in a lavender shirt didn't know I was sitting in the car facing the store window and watched her shoot my mom the middle finger on her way out. No confrontation had happened; just placing an order and waiting. I guess they smile to your face and do stuff like that on your way out. When we called, they had nothing to say and then blocked me on Facebook after posting this same thing. Would rather stand by a rude employee than reach out. Their food isn't that good to warrant that kind of attitude. read more

The size of this hoagie (sub) made Wawa look thick! Their Italian hoagie is literally only as thick as a slice of cooked ham, a slice of salami and a slice of provolone. That is the most generic, American, Italian hoagie I've ever had. The meat was bland and I just can't get over how thin it was. I will say their home made roll was tasty but that was every bit of a $3.00 bargain sandwich that you would expect at some obscure off the beaten path convenience store. I understand Quarryville isn't Philly but we've got some great pizza and sandwich shops in this town and with a sandwich like that two cousins isn't one of them. read more

See all

It's a friendly place good food very clean place safe and charming place wife or special friend it's a nice place for date someone

we ordered two pizzas while camping. they were burned on the bottom and had to much salt. my kids would not even eat them, and they eat everything!! check the pizzas before you give them to a customer just gross read more

Wow did we hit the jackpot. No cooking while camping at Jellystone. We ordered the first night and then every night thereafter. The prices are so reasonable. The pizza was fantastic. We ordered 2 xlarge cheese pizzas, they were extra cheesy and the crust was great. We also ordered a Greek salad and it was great as well. Loved this place and delivery was quick and free. Totally worth ordering from. Now we wish we lived closer read more

Pizza is delicious , staff is horrible!!! We ate here on vacation. Me, my husband and 3 kids. When walking in, we were met by the most unfriendly girl who took our order. She acted like she did not want to be there. No one was friendly. The decor is ugly. The only good thing was the food. If the staff was friendly , I would look past the decor and give it five stars for pizza and 4 stars for wings. The wings could have been crunchier. The pizza is delicious. It is too bad the staff is unprofessional and messy looking. We come to vacation in this area yearly. I would only order take out again, so as not to deal with the horrible staff too much. read more

The pizza was delicious! We ordered several to our campsite at Jellystone and it went over well with everyone. It was hot, fresh and delivered in a timely fashion. Would definitely order here again! read more

Not sure of some of the bad reviews. I've been coming here since they opened. I have never been disappointed with a single order. It's been at least 29 years. That's a great track record!! read more

I have been going here since I was little and it still holds up! Whenever my family needed a quick dinner, we would go pickup a turkey sub and a cheeseburger sub from Two Cousins. They use their pizza dough for their sub rolls, which combines perfectly with the rich, creamy mayonnaise. And, while the staff doesn't seem the friendliest at first, the owner is a really nice guy if you get to know him. This will always be a family favorite! read more

Wait wait wait. You will always wait way longer than any place around when you call in an order. And the girls they hire and fire and quit makes things worse, always a new girl learning (and messing up the order). The Owner? He doesn't care, he says you took too long to pick up your order when the girl on the phone said an hour. And he said he did not know why the order was totally messed up. I will tell you what I do know..I will not order from there again! read more

Rude workers, and expensive food. 2 Cousins Pizza in Quarryville is a horrible establishment. I bought a large cheese steak and they didn't ask me if I wanted red sauce on it. They gave it to me and I asked them to make me one without the sauce. The guy told me no! After a minute of arguing he told me that he would make a small cheese steak with no sauce. I asked him why not the large and he told me that I made the mistake not him, so he wasn't going to give me a large cheese steak without the sauce. Sad I used to like that place. LikeShow more reactions read more

Two Cousins is arguably the best place in Quarryville to get food. Yes, there are some cons but the pros majorly outweigh them. Great food, great people, enough said. I highly recommend the Cheeseburger Sub! read more