So many wonderful things here! The staff...especially Kaylee and her crafted cocktails, Steph with the best specials. But the pizza and the Gambino? Amazing!! Drunken meatballs? Heavenly! Love it!!! read more

Great pizza! Their new space is beautifully done and a needed welcome addition to the area. Always have great fast service. read more

Disgusting! Ordered a cheese steak, it looked like dog food. No actual "steak", just some unknown chopped up substance that appeared to be some type of fake meat substitute. Asked for sweet peppers, they added 3 tiny pieces. For ~$50.000 for 2 cheese steaks and fries I expected better. Never again! Take a lesson from Jim's Steaks on South Street, those are REAL cheese steaks. I'm done with gross, overpriced junk food. read more

Great pizza and also really good chicken parm ! Very nice new place in Honeybrook and friendly staff

This nice place has Amazing menu, food, service and made me a custom cocktail! Would go again!

More than a pizza parlor. Home cooked Italian menu. Quick and Pleasant service. Prices are very reasonable. read more

The Godfather cheesesteak is the best around. Try the Brooklyn style pizza. It is fantastic. They use a different sauce than their regular pizza. read more

Great location, spacious, nice service. Fantastic pizza! The crust is amazing, not the usual blend flavor. I don't eat tomatoes but love pizza - the struggle is real. They have so many non-tomato sauce options, it's wonderful. We tried the buffalo chicken, honey mustard chicken, bbq chicken, the barbecue was the best, so different. We will be back :) read more

Wow! I've had some good tomato pies from "the best" places there is. Including Coroppolese which was always my favorite. Although this is different style, it's right up there with the best. Pleasantly surprised to stumble upon this spot. Will definitely try more of their menu soon. read more

Jerry's Pizza Pie - Pizza Near Me - Honey Brook, Pennsylvania

We have been patrons for over 10 years. We live in town. It's always been 'good' and a typical small town pizzeria with decent options. Never a reason to complain. However, ever since they moved locations, quality has dropped significantly and orders have been extremely high in error rate. We order nearly every week but usually 2-4 times a month - often delivery. The last 4 orders in past few weeks have seen all 4 with a significant errors (first without an entire app, second one with error on saucing instructions and third had entire pizza that was the wrong one). And this is just the most recent in memory. Today, an entire pizza that was listed incorrectly on their site (Slice) and so we got something not correctly advertised, and the other pizza was under-cooked And came pretty mangled - as if it was rushed. I get ya'll might be busier, but quality and output has suffered and leaves us few options but to seek elsewhere. We have offered feedback every time there has been an error (and don't ask for free items - just that they correct it in future), and while the management/owner has been great at correcting and making it right... it's just simply not worth the frustration, time and again. read more

Only thing that is impressive is the service. The food is average, like any other pizza place. They have no idea how to make a pizza steak. Doesn't mean you make a steak and put sauce and cheese on top. Hoagies just okay. read more

The "new" Jerry's has attracted bigger crowds since the physical move. Curiosity, I guess. It seems much the same although the main dining room is a little bigger. Jerry's makes excellent pizza. The only significant difference I could detect is that the new Jerry's charges significantly more for wine and presumably other alcoholic bevs. Service was good; they're trying hard to please. But the value proposition is now a little worse. read more

Jerry's is simply the best! From there pizzas to the sandwiches, you can't go wrong!

We do not live in Honey Brook, but often stop here when visiting family or clients in the area. I wish we had a place like this near us. Consistently good value. Friendly staff. Everything is fresh made, well presented, reasonably priced. Inside is clean, plenty of seating for those looking to eat in. In all the times we have been here, nothing was ever bad or off. Portions are decent. Fresh ingredients. Lots of options to choose from. Fast at major meal times for pre-made pizzas, calzones, bread sticks, etc. read more

Ordered takeaway from here for the first time with some family. We ordered two large Sicilian pizzas- one pizza with cheese and the second pizza with cheese, pepperoni, sausage, bacon, and spinach. Total came out to approximately $50. What's Hot - Service. Pretty good. We called in our order and the staff told me the pizzas would be ready in 20 minutes, which they were. Service was timely and efficient, which we certainly appreciated. - Quality. Delish! Good quality Sicilian crusts are not an easy find. Their crust was thick and chewy. The consistency wasn't too dense, either, which is very important. It's not easy finding a thick and chewy crust that isn't too dense, because you get filled up too easily. Their crust is probably at least one inch thick, if not a little bit more. Be prepared to eat their Sicilian pizza with a knife and fork, haha... - Portions. Really good. The large size for the Sicilian pizza took up the whole box, with very little room around the edges. We all noticed and remarked on how hefty the pizzas felt in the boxes, which was a great sign before we dug into the pizzas. Additionally, each slice of pizza was a pretty good size. They don't skimp on the toppings and each slice had a good amount. - Menu. Pretty good variety. They have appetizers, salads, calzones, pastas, pizza, desserts. Not vegan friendly, but could work for vegetarians. - Price. Not unreasonable, especially given the size of the pizzas we ordered. What's Not - Price. $50 for two pizzas is pretty pricey, but to be fair, the portions of the pizza kind of explain why. - Website. Their website is not very user friendly. I got on their website through Yelp and it was very difficult to find a menu with the prices, as well. I appreciate that this is a more rural area and not very populated. It appears that many customers may already be aware of their menu, but we weren't. In this day in age, the minimum is having a functioning basic website with the basic information. This website didn't have the right links with the necessary information, which made it frustrating trying to figure out what we wanted. Final Answer Pretty delish and this may be a go-to spot for good Sicilian pizza. read more

Jerry's Pizza Pie - Sicilian pizza w/pepperoni, sausage, bacon, n spinach - Pizza Near Me - Honey Brook, Pennsylvania

See all

We celebrated a 65th birthday at Jerry's recently. The food and the service were excellent. Jerry himself checked with us to make sure that our experience was satisfactory. He could not have been nicer or more accommodating. The entrées were delicious and generously portioned. We will definitely be returning and would highly recommend! read more

Best pizza pizza best sauce, great service and I like the people that work there we go often

This place is amazing the food is so good. It's was my first time there and the service was amazing. The ambiance was quiet because it has just opened so we were the first ones there. I will definitely come back. There is plenty of seating and parking. read more

See all

Have been to Jerry's before. Every time I've been here it has been a good experience. The waitress was nice and attentive and the food was adequate. My only complaint is because I used a card, $.43 was added to my bill. I may have missed it, but this should be somewhere on the menu that using a card will incur a fee. 3 stars. Sans fee, 4 stars. read more

See all

Jerry's Pizza Pie has been my go since we moved to Honey Brook when I'm craving for some crispy chicken salad , fried Zucchini, wrap or pasta dish . Portions are generous and certainly satisfying.. read more

If you want a lot of extras with cheese melted on top, The Special Cheesesteak is the cheesesteak for you. We did have a roll blow out. read more

See all

Jerry's has the best pizza around. Food used to be a little bit better when Phil was there, but Claudio and his sons still do a great job.

Best pizza in the area! Very busy place but they are on top of it. Everything is fresh & hot. Delish! Highly recommend. We use the Slice app & pick up on our way to our seasonal campsite. Restaurant is very clean. read more

Great pizza / food and good service Also beer available on site Owner is friendly and has a great attitude. read more

We go there often, the best Chicken Parm, Chicken Marsala, Lasagna, and pizza around. Rosa is a great waitress.

Best pizza we have had since moving to Honey Brook! Their sandwiches are delicious too! Portions are very generous. And they deliver! Definitely our go to when we want pizza! Try the Philly Cheesesteak pizza so yummy! read more

A nice little local pizza shop, clean ,food is plenty, but average for the most, pizza is good , hoagie's are so so,cheese steaks are good ,dinners are decent.staff is friendly, and prices are good. read more

Best sandwiches in the area. Super dine-in restaurant and super clean! Handicap accessible. Friendly staff, stop in today and find out!

This place is okay, but they screw up a lot!! Ordered a sicilian pizza, they made a round pizza. Gave us a bottle of soda to make up for it? Should've made another one instead of that lame offer, specially since we are return customers. My daughter ordered wings, she got something that was not wings and it was fire engine hot. There have been other mistakes as well. Make them read the order back to you, and check it all before you leave, and make them make it right, right there and then. *You can get the 40 oz cans they sell for half the price everywhere else, highway robbery prices there* read more

Family atmosphere great selection friendly and courteous staff members greeting you as you walk in and go in there for decades your family when they know your first name. Great prices and great food...!!! read more

The best pizza and Strombolis around. The Brooklyn crust is Amazing with anything. Try it!

I have not been to Jerry's in a while just because of where I live but I got to say the pizza is great and pleasant people working the counter Looks like I will have to go out of the way to go to Jerry's more often read more

It's our favorite place to go eat here in Honeybrook. Tried all the other pizza places but their pizza crust and service was the best. Spent 2 years going through their menu... never a bad dish. Just moved again and we'll be missing them almost as much as the grandchildren! read more

I have been eating pizza here for over 25 years! Not much eateries in Honey Brook, so thankful they make a yummy pizza. The staff is friendly and they have their systems down, so you don't have to wait long for your order. The pizza has just the right amount of sauce and they are not skimpy with cheese; sometimes it is as if I ordered extra cheese. The crust is chewy and crunchy... yummos! read more

Jerry's has decently good pizza! The price isn't too terribly high considering the prices for everything are inflated at the moment. Their fries are good as well, but I personally didn't enjoy the garlic knots the last time we visited. Their staff is always very helpful. One of our favorite local pizzerias! read more

Ten years ago when we had family living in the area we frequented Jerry's Pizza Pie. Their pizza and pepperoni rolls are awesome. We fell in love with their cheesesteak pizza. Well, five years ago we had no more family nearby and we did not get t the area. Well, today we stopped and brought home three large cheesesteak pizzas and 48 pepperoni rolls - enough to save for our Super Bowl party. So glad we went the extra way for this. Great food and wonderful people. You have to stop in here and enjoy for yourself. read more

They have redeem them self from a few years ago . They have great white pizza and there margarita pizza is the best I ever had . It's a must eat in for that pizza tho as its crust will get soft in the box on the way home . read more

Jerry's Pizza Pie has been my go since we moved to Honey Brook when I'm craving for some crispy chicken salad , fried Zucchini, wrap or pasta dish . Portions are generous and certainly satisfying.. read more

Great pizza! Cooler for a cold 6pack to go; plenty of choices. It's hit or miss; plenty of seating to leisurely enjoy your meal....or packed solid, no seats available. So we go, knowing we may need to opt for takeout. Which is fine. read more

I love the pizza here! The sauce is sweet and tastes so good! Always have my order correct and ready to go when I arrive!