PJ Cools Ice Cream Shoppe is definitely worth a stop! The ice cream was fresh, creamy, and…read moregenerously portioned. I had the peanut butter parfait, and it was absolutely delicious--rich peanut butter flavor with the perfect combination of toppings. My wife ordered chocolate and black raspberry in a waffle cone, and both flavors were excellent. The waffle cone was fresh and added the perfect crunch. Friendly service, great quality, and a fun atmosphere made for a fantastic visit. We'll definitely be back!

04/2026 An update: The first warm spring day and we went…read morefor ice cream as a family! It was hard to choose, there were so many good choices! The waffle cone with peanuts was especially good! The prickly pear with lime was fantastic!

Rosie's Handcrafted Ice Cream was such a great find! I had the Bada Bing Bada Bourbon on a cinnamon…read morewaffle cone, and it was absolutely delicious. The ice cream was rich, flavorful, and the cinnamon waffle cone was the perfect pairing! I also really appreciate that Rosie's offers so many vegan and gluten-free options. It's nice to have plenty of choices instead of feeling limited, and everything looks so thoughtfully made. Definitely a spot I'd happily come back to!

Stopped in with some friends after hearing this is the go-to spot for ice cream in Buffalo. It was…read morepacked when we got in, which was definitely a good sign! I got the cold brew ice cream and definitely would've tried a few more flavors, but wanted to be mindful of everyone waiting in line. I got one scoop and the portion size was very generous. The cold brew ice cream was good! It does have actual coffee grounds mixed in, which is a cool idea in theory, but I wasn't the biggest fan of the texture. The grounds also tend to get stuck in your teeth. Glad I was able to try it out!

The ice cream and service is consistently great at this location. During my most recent visit,…read morethere were a lot of people but the staff was dishing out the ice cream quickly. I ordered the Buffalo Pot Hole ice cream in a dish and oh my gosh, it was delicious! I look forward to coming back soon.

Frosty's has been a staple in our family's summers since we moved into the area. My son who just…read moreturned 3 has already been to 4 opening days. (That math is crazy) We saw they were opening a couple days due to warm weather and had to get over there to get some ice cream and say hello. It was PACKED! Probably would be less packed now that the weather is cold and snowy again but we waited in line and got our treats. I ended up going with a root beer float this time. We also had an assortment of cones and dishes of soft serve with plenty of sprinkles. We can't wait until they open up fully for the season and will be here quite often.

I was craving a late-night snack and was pleasantly surprised by White Rabbit. I've driven by it so…read moremany times without stopping, but I'm so glad I finally did! The restaurant has a charming Alice in Wonderland theme that creates a fun and unique atmosphere. Their dessert selection was absolutely delicious, making it a great spot to sit down and satisfy your sweet tooth. Our waiter was fantastic--friendly, attentive, and very knowledgeable about the menu, which made the experience even better. If you're looking for a cozy place to enjoy some amazing desserts, I definitely recommend giving White Rabbit a try!

I had no idea what to expect of this spot. Came with friends after a dinner, wanting to extend the…read morefestivities but not get a drink. This was perfect! It smells insanely good inside, like fresh waffles. The desserts can be a little pricey, but are definitely shareable with a group. Got a warm brownie dessert and a crepe and would recommend both. Fun little spot to check out for something decadent.

Nice local spot for homemade custard!! I love coming here when I am back in town…read more The sundaes are HUGE! They could easily be split between two people in my opinion. The employees here work really fast and have great service. Deducting a star because of the AI slop menu. Please just use canva

I do have a soft spot for ice cream, more specifically frozen custard. So when I saw that Hibbard's…read morehad frozen custard we just had to stop. I ordered a chocolate (I know, boring to some) but it's my go-to flavor for custard. I always, when possible ordera cone, upside down in a cup. Less chance of spills. I was happy to see the cone holder had a big rim actually eliminating the need for a cup. Good to know for next time. Anyhow, the chocolate was good & my tummy was happy. Me too. 2025-72

Friendly service, good prices and a wide selection of Perry's ice creams. They also have dogs,…read moreburgers, fries, etc, but that's not what I was there for. I ordered the flavor of the week, espresso caramel custard twist. It was a great combination that I've never seen anywhere before and it was nice and creamy. The large size was $5.25 including tax (sorry, no picture; I was excited to eat it). Though very friendly, the service was a tad slow and my custard had a little hollow section in the middle. I'm guessing they have some new employees that are still learning the ropes. I would visit again... Maybe later in the season. To note, there is an extra fee when using a credit card. They have seating under a roofed patio as well as some tables behind the building in the yard underneath some trees.

Lots of ice cream options and fast service! Definitely a cute spot to grab a bite and sit outside.read more

I came in with my family for some ice cream after shopping around The Boulevard and was so excited…read moreto try Millie's! The inside of the shop is so cute and pink and it has some nice seating areas. The staff was also super nice and let us sample some of the flavors. I ended up choosing caramel apple dumpling, and I'm so happy I did. It was delicious creamy full of chunks of apple and caramel, and just tasted like fall. My family got different flavors and they loved them as well. I cannot wait to come back again and try more flavors really soon!

First time trying this spot because I was craving some authentic, homemade ice cream!…read more I had the vanilla and chocolate on a waffle cone. The chocolate was fantastic!! Definitely my favorite of the two. The vanilla, however, was a little too sweet for my taste. I was expecting more of that rich, creamy homemade vanilla flavor, but it tasted more sugary than creamy. The waffle cone was also a little too cakey for me, I prefer a lighter, crispier cone. Aside from that, the place itself was clean, the music was great, and the service was courteous. I really enjoyed the outdoor seating area, especially since it was such a beautiful day. It made for a really nice atmosphere to sit, relax, and enjoy some ice cream. Overall, I'd love a richer, creamier vanilla with a little less sweetness and a lighter, crispier waffle cone. But that's just my personal preference! Definitely stop by, try it for yourself, and form your own opinion. And if you're a chocolate lover, the chocolate is worth trying!

Ice cream good and my husband really liked the banana split. Cute interior. Overall aesthetic and…read morelocation not great. Prices were reasonable and happy to see a lot of people enjoying this privately owned establishment.

A small ice cream shop with an outside order window and ice cream counter inside. There are just…read moretwo benches outside, so it's not really a place for eating outside. The workers were friendly and the service was fast. Note that a small ice cream is a pretty big serving. A family who ordered after us were surprised at the sizes too!