I wish we could give decimal point scores because this establishment would definitely be a 3.9! I refrain from giving it a four star rating only because the food is very traditionally American. Which is what they are going for and they succeed but unfortunately there's just nothing to exciting about it. The side salad we had was some lettuce, and arugula with some bacon bits (not real bacon) and it was what you would expect from a pizza shop when it comes to a side salad. Mine did have some wilted lettuce that was a bit discolored but you can't be perfect all the time, no restaurant is! The "Ranchsticks" were really good! It was almost like a little mini-pizza in itself. It had a really wonderful ranch sauce and then covered in melted cheese. The flavors were abound! The "Engineer" calzone was enormous! I was in awe of this bad boy when it came out! You definitely get your moneys worth out of this $11 calzone. The flavors were very expected. It tasted like mushroom, olive and Canadian bacon, and that's what you got. Nothing hiding there to jump out and surprise you; just as advertised! The service was fantastic! We were never having to wait and look around for our server as she was always attentive and made sure our needs as customers were met. The glasses never went empty as I would say! They did have some live music going on which was a nice touch, but I will say, if you're on the dining side and not the bar side it would be nice if you didn't have to listen to the live music as the two sides are separated and if we wanted to go into that atmosphere we would've simply walked to the bar side but instead we just wanted to quietly eat our dinner and converse but it was made difficult by the live music continually switching back and forth from side to side. The history of the place is awesome and was the actual train station back in the day and being a guy who loves history the ambiance was lovely and appreciated! They are also extremely clean and everything seemed very well kept. Wouldn't mind stopping by again and catching the train and maybe this time actually get the pizza, haha! read more

Train Station Pizza - Ranchsticks (without bacon) - Pizza Near Me - Buhl, Idaho

See all

We have been customers here over 5 years using delivery and in person but after tonight not anymore. We called in for delivery tonight 11.30.23..pm. I ordered the idaho Nachos. At 10.99 you would think I would get tomatoes and cheespe as it says on the menu. Nope. It was so small it doesn't fill the bottom of the little black container. What a joke. I ordered a dinner salad and asked for tomatoes. 2 small and very thin slices. Haha. Oh the lettuce was warm and b rown and wilted. Yuk. I ordered a large Diet Coke What another joke. 2 bucks for a 12 oz cup. Size of a can. I hope I don't get sick. read more

They have amazing specialty pizzas! Try the cheeseburger or taco pizza; you won't be sorry. Also, the sourdough crust is delicious.

My wife is from Buhl and when we visit Dad we will always have to order pizza from Train Station at least three to four times during our visit. Excellent food and service! Thanks you for your service while we were visiting our family. read more

Wishing great success for this business. We haven't visited, but have had pizza delivered and it was very good. They have a large selection of specialty pizza too. read more

Humble, rustic, and out of the way. Parking out back. But the pizza was quite wonderful. The service was prompt and considerate. Sit away from the windows late afternoons in the summer as the glare was uncomfortable. read more

Excellent pizza! Lots of different topping and crust options to satisfy everyone, even vegan and gluten free. I have a few food sensitivities and I can eat their pizza without issue, which is nice because I love pizza, but it has been problematic. I've had the All Aboard and March car without issue. Fun menu, huge pizzas, super friendly staff, good value. read more

We stopped for dinner here while camping up at Miracle Hot Springs. The food was great and so was the service. The ranch sticks with bacon were delicious and so was the creamy mac n cheese. We truly enjoyed everything about our experience here and will definitely be going back. read more

First off, this is a GUN FREE ZONE. You cannot protect yourself there. Owner does not have a clue what that means. She thinks the police will get there fast enough..... THEY said so. Second, not happy with the pizza. The toppings tasted fine, but my "thick" crust pizza was not. It was also not very sourdough. I could not detect ANY sourdough flavor at all. They did allow me to substitute and doubled one of the other ingredients for me. read more

Overpriced cardboard. Sadly frozen pizzas are better. I love to support local, but I just can't stomach this.

We LOVE train! It is our go to for pizza delivery! The ranch sticks are delish. We always accompany our pizza with the "ticket taker salad." It is perfect and a good size for two people to split. Train also offers three different crust options. White wheat or sour dough. Recently I tried a calzone - it was amazing. We have never been disappointed & delivery is always friendly & speedy! Thank you Train Station! read more

We ate here for the first time tonight. There were no other pizza places open in Buhl on a holiday weekend and on a Sunday, except for this place. The pizzas were a tad on the small side, but they weren't too bad. I like that they offer sourdough crust, which I'll likely try the next time I order. And the lady helping us was super nice. I'll be visiting again! read more

Never too busy, lots of extra attention. Food is great. Atmosphere-ambience, little bit country. Great parking, nice selection of food...home cooking. Has much potential for outside dinning, and a grundle of history. read more

Train Station Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buhl, Idaho

Yes, give it a try. We liked it. Ordered the gluten free, and cauliflower pizza. Pizza and salad were good, as was the service. The garlic salad dressing is made right there, and was excellent. We found the service outstanding. What's not to like? read more

Very awesome place! Love the pizza cold beer and football. The people who now own are the best! Will be Stopping every time we come through. Yum! read more

Found ourselves in Buhl, Idaho for a basketball tournament. Took a large group for pizza and were not disappointed! The pizzas came up fast and were delicious! Lots of varieties and all of them were well done. A decent selection of draft beers and salads or sandwiches for those not in to the pizza - although why wouldn't you be?! Their sourdough crust was outstanding and the servers definitely aimed to please. read more

We stopped here after swimming, they weren't busy at all. The pizza was amazing, the waitress never let our drinks run empty and always checked on us. Definitely will be stopping again! read more

Great crew that has done a lot with the place. They have remodeled the dining room and cleaned it up, but most importantly, they make good pizza. read more