Never disappointed at Wagner. Great fish dinner on Friday from 4-7, but hard to choose between some…read moreof the other specials like stuffed pork chops or stuffed peppers; my favorites. The waitresses are delightful and serve promptly.

The Wagner is an institution in Penn Yan. We have been coming here since 1992 and the food and the…read moreexperience has not changed. Not one little bit, except our favorite server back then seems to be in management now. The food is good, it is not in the Michelin guide but I don't want it to be. It is reliable and quality diner food. They have lunch and now fish fries on certain days but I've only had breakfast. lots of omlette choices pancakes (buttermilk or a Penn Yan special, buckwheat) and breakfast sandwiches. If you go you won't be disappointed. I think it may have been a bar in its previous life ... it's a little dark inside but you can get all the sun you need at the lake. Servers generally last years there and are top notch and friendly.

There is a sign on the door stating that if you wanted fast service you had to request it. I wasn't…read moresure what that meant, but soon found out. It was a super crowded place, and the food was good, the only issue was the speed of service. Total of 2 hours elapsed before we received our food. I'm not sure if the kitchen is so small, that it gets backed up or what. I don't understand how one order can trump another just because you say you are in a hurry. Maybe it makes sense to the locals, but not so much to out of towners. The food was good, but I would not go again simply due to the wait.

Toni's is a favorite of mine when I am in the region. Homestyle cooking in a diner atmosphere…read more Service treats you like family... the ones you like to visit on vacation. Warm, welcoming and fun. Food is made to order. Sooo, pack your patience and enjoy the ambiance of friendly locals sharing stories over a cup of breakfast blend.

First time here and the breakfast was very good. Had the special of the day: country fried steak,…read moreeggs and toast. I would recommend. Our server was also very nice and had a fun personality. It's a bit small to be expected (seat yourself at any open table).

Eggs cooked perfectly. Excellent sausage. Good toast. Pancake was good but cheap syrup ruined it…read moreand lost the fifth star. Kind of a tight fit but okay inside. Service was okay. My best bet for breakfast in Penn Yan.

Great value! What a lovely brunch we enjoyed at the Water St Cafe. We didn't go more than 5 minutes…read morewithout a warm-up on our coffee. Excellent service. The portions were generous and food was flavorful. As a starter we enjoyed home fries loaded with homemade sausage gravy. That was a meal in itself! The coffee mugs were a hand-thrown pottery that was unique and beautiful. We stopped in on a Saturday and there was a local brewery offering their drinks, along with a volleyball team raising money for a trip. Lots of young people in the "team room". It was an engaging spot to enjoy food and we would definitely return! Good meetup place for friends.

HORRIBLE SERVICE! HORRIBLE STAFF!…read more You should have been prepared for the people that came for the Ironman. We put our name on the list, waited to be called, came when they called, they sat us down and then we waited and waited and WAITED. And no one came. People were seated after us, their order was taken , their food was served...and we just waited and waited and WAITED. WE WERE NEVER SERVED. Even if their food was good (which I'll never know) their service, and lack of customer service and people skills is absolutely disgusting and unacceptable.

If you ever find yourself in Waterloo, NY, do yourself a favor and stop by Tucci's Diner. From the…read moremoment you walk through the door, you're greeted with warm, positive energy that instantly makes you feel at home. It's the kind of cozy place where the atmosphere alone can brighten your day. The menu is extensive, offering something for everyone, and the food is absolutely delicious. Whether you're stopping in for a simple cup of coffee or sitting down for a full breakfast like we did, everything is prepared with care and served with a smile. Nick, the owner, truly sets the tone. He welcomes every guest personally, greeting you like you've just walked into his home. His attentiveness and genuine hospitality make all the difference. Bonnie, who was helping that day, was equally amazing so friendly, happy, and kind. You can tell she's a truly good soul who loves what she does. This family operated diner delivers an experience that honestly feels better than many Michelin-starred restaurants. It's not just about the food, it's about how they make you feel. If you're visiting the wineries around Geneva and Seneca Lake, don't forget to add Tucci's Diner as a must stop on your trip. It's the perfect place to start your day or recharge in between tastings. If you're looking for a place where you're treated like family, this is it. A true home away from home. Rich & Donna Go Fort Benning / 82nd!

Do I recommend this business? Absolutely ! This is an adorable little local restaurant. It was busy…read morebut we were pretty much seated very quickly. Our waitress had one speed, super sonic speed! I believe her name was Bonny, she was such a happy and pleasant young lady with a smile that never left her face. She was hopping from table to table working non stop. The young lady that was cleaning table also did an amazing job. The food, was served quick and hot and delicious. Would stop again if in town.

What a goldmine for breakfast, lunch & snacks! Service was so friendly. Lots of options for picky…read moreeaters

I was camping at Keuka Lake State Park and needed some good breakfast and coffee. This place popped…read moreup with a lot of reviews and was about 20 minutes away! Lots of parking but it gets pretty busy. The restaurant is fairly small so seating can be limited. There is additional outside seating. They also have a general grocery store with some unique items. Coffee was good, my breakfast sandwich was awesome with bacon & ham and I should have bought more fry pies from the grocery store. I had a great visit! Looks like typical breakfast is in the $5-$10 range.

Best little diner I have ever been to. Homemade delicious food (especially the fresh homemade…read moreraisin cinnamon toast) and down home feeling! We have been visiting the past 20 years during our summer visits and the staff always remembers us! Good food for exceptionally reasonable prices in a warm inviting atmosphere is what this cafe is!

I was waiting for someone to get out of an appointment, so opted to grab breakfast here one day…read more You know the kind of place that your grandparents might go to because they think it's "a good deal"..? That's what the feel is from this cafe... it's somewhere my grandparents would like. It's convenient and inexpensive. I appreciate the casual nature of being able to seat myself, and the initially prompt attention. I'm not going to complain about having a coffee at my table within 2 minutes of sitting down... ... but was it a great overall experience? No. The food is fine. When I originally ordered my 'garbage omelet' (it includes ham, peppers, onions, sausage, cheese, tomatoes, and mushrooms inside it) and rye toast, I was ALSO going to order a side of bacon... but the server decided my order was done after I said "rye" for the toast on the side of my plate. She left the table before I could even get "and could I get a side of bacon?" out. Next thing you know, I have a receipt on my table for breakfast. (As far as the omelet goes, it was "meh"... a plain 'ol middle of the road omelet.) The one time she came to check on me after already leaving the receipt, I actually said "Could I also please get a side of bacon?" ... and guess what? Never got my bacon. The server completely forgot... and never checked on me again. The only thing I can think is that the server didn't want to interrupt me because I was also reading a book at the table (again, waiting for someone to get out of an appointment - and I didn't want to completely drain the battery on my phone), but I have no idea. Either way, she forgot my bacon... and I would have loved a coffee refill at some point too. :-/ TL;DR Looking for cheap food? This is your place. I paid $15.15 for a coffee, sizeable omelet w. rye toast, and tip. If you're looking for anything especially interesting or memorable though? Not so much. I said it above and I'll say it again: it's convenient if you're around Dundee for something (as opposed to driving to Watkins Glen, Geneva, or other surrounding areas) and inexpensive.

Not much to look at from the outside but breakfast was amazing…read more Sadly this is the last week of business.

This is between 3 and 4 stars. The food is very basic, but filling and cheap. Lots of locals were…read morein attendance, as opposed to tourists. My big complaint is it was cash only. Since the food was cheap that wasn't a problem but it was inconvenient.