Such a great unexpected find. Had to return something at The UPS Store which happens to be in the same shopping center. Wanted a quick slice for lunch so we decided to stop in. I'm so glad that we did. Ordered 4 slices. Vegetable slice with breaded eggplant, a regular cheese slice, buffalo chicken slice & a ricotta cheese with sausage & meatballs. All 4 were phenomenal. Thin crispy slices filled with delicious flavors. I am kinda a pizza connoisseur and I was throughly impressed. Go check them out. read more

TPR Pizzeria - Eggplant Veggie Slice - Italian Near Me - Tenafly, New Jersey

Service was great. Pretty dining room and good bar seating/area. La scala salad is a must order. Good cocktails, plenty of menu options. Potato crusted salmon was delicious and desserts were perfect. Will definitely return. read more

TPR Pizzeria - Francese wings - Italian Near Me - Tenafly, New Jersey

The cheese pizza and the mozzarella sticks were so delicious and tasty. The service wasn't very slow and the food came out quickly.

Amazing pizza, by far my favorite in Jersey! I'm always going towards the grandma pizza, it's the best! never a lost. always a win! read more

Fantastic food and incredible staff. Highly recommend to anyone looking for quality italian food!

food is good, services and ambience are good. You must try it at TPR Pizzeria Tenafly NI

TPR is the best pizza in town. They always have been helpful for all of our Tenafly Baseball functions, and as a teacher in town, they have always been so generous to us and the community. Jacob does a great hard behind the counter. Always appreciative! read more

Love this place for my lunch as a teacher in town! They even hire graduates which is really great experience. They are friendly and pizza is great and quick. read more

This was our first time here and we'll definitely be back. Bartender Jimmy is a gem, very personable and great at what he doesn. The manager was kind enough to check on a key ingredient for my wife who has an allergy ( kudos to them for using soy free cheese on their pizza) Place is immaculate and the service great as well. read more

Update: TPR now has a bar in the back of their pizza counter. More upscale than a regular pizza joint - this fits the bill for us; casual, clean, great place for a weeknight dinner without kids! read more

Been coming to TPR since I was in elementary school. It has always been nice to eat here and order from here especially since it's one of the few restaurants that have been open since my young days. Always friendly service and the food always hits home! read more

If you charge extra for sauce, tell people in advance. It's not a pleasant experience read more

Hello. The service and pizza is amazing. Tell all your friends and family about TPR. The best in the area.

Came here for an early dinner on a Friday around 4:30pm. There was only one table occupied and the rest were empty. We were seated immediately. The waiter was very friendly. He took our order and brought out butter and toasted bread. The bread was crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. Paired with the butter it was so good. I ordered chicken Parmesan and they gave us more Parmesan cheese and black pepper. The dish was pretty big and allowed me to take some for lunch the following day. The chicken parm was really good. Prices are reasonable. I will definitely return. read more

See all

The pizza is amazing, I've been going here for over a decade. The meatball ricotta slice is off the chain. Very nice seating area inside that is great for large celebrations. Excellent service and friendly waitstaff. Very good Italian food aside from the pizza as well! read more

Eh...It was fine...Maybe more menu exploration would be worth it. Like pizza. My son had the spaghetti and meatballs; there was not enough sauce and not enough seasoning in the sauce that was there. I ordered the bruschetta app for my meal. It was a large portion for the price, that's awesome, but here again there was a lack of seasoning. More garlic, balsamic, something is needed. Busy to go area, so something must be worth it, we just didn't find it. read more

Robert was a fanastic server when I asked for my pizza well done and he was very kind. One of kind place. The environment and serve was OUTSTANDING!! Go here for yummy pizza!! read more

We pre-ordered some food and reserved several tables for a private family event last week. The owner and staff could not have been more accommodating or attentive to our requirements, working with us every step of the way. The space was configured ideally for our group, and the food itself was excellent. A heartfelt thank you to the team at TPR ! JD read more

You guys never called me that is a lie. I can pull up phone records so that is not true. And one of the chefs admitted to me that a lot of the guys in kitchen don't wear hats and that he thinks they should, but they don't. So no, TPR does not require that. Would love for health department to audit this place. And no I did not want another pizza as I am turned off by pizza after the hair was found in it. I was told the owner would call me and I never heard from anyone. Shame. And no I NEVER demanded something extra. I offered to pay whatever extra over the cost off pizza for difference. The manager insisted I do not though. This place is not only covering up the health concern but also management is lying! read more

TPR Pizzeria - Plain Pizza Slice - Italian Near Me - Tenafly, New Jersey

Always outstanding! Had the new lobster roll. It was the BEST ever. We sat at the bar and enjoy that experience. Great bartenders that are engaging if you want that or happy to leave you to enjoy your own company. The new TPR bar is beautiful!! It's our favorite "go to" always. read more

I order two chicken parmigiana dinners One with pasta one with a salad Togo $58.00 later the chicken was hard like a rock thin and well over cook, the pasta was hard ( dry pasta ) or just old l do understand the food cost is a little high also understand the minimum went up as well but $28 eight dollars for chicken parmigiana no way you can justify that.! read more

TPR Pizzeria - Chicken Parmigiana - Italian Near Me - Tenafly, New Jersey

Love the food @ TPR! Excellent pastas,pizza and chicken parm. Everything is great. No disappointments here. I'll be back soon for more excellent Italian food. Also not to mention the sports bar coming soon where I can watch the games. read more

TPR Pizzeria - Large Pepperoni - Italian Near Me - Tenafly, New Jersey

For 20 year customers, TPR is not the same. Cesar is a gem. When he cooks, all is right with the world. But really, pizza is not the same. It's crackly crums. Cive me the Brooklyn or Manhattan style. I will come for takeout every week. read more

We ordered several trays of food for a family New Years Eve celebration and the food was excellent. Definitely recommend the chicken francese, eggplant rollatini, sausage and peppers and cavatelli and broccoli! Portions in the trays were very large! read more

Missing grandma slices since I moved out of Manhattan. So glad this is now a staple on their menu. The owner just made a batch of meatballs with their new recipe and allowed me to try one. They were flavorful and juicy. read more

TPR Pizzeria - New grandma slices - Italian Near Me - Tenafly, New Jersey

I eat there often and really like the food and the staff, especially the Manager Carlo who is very friendly. The cavatelli with pork is terrific. The restaurant has been updated and looks very nice. The music played during lunch could be lower and more soothing . read more

I was a customer for over 30 years. New management must be cutting corners. The new menu lacks any of my favorites from years past. I settled for veal parmesan and it was awful. It tasted like the oil it was fried in was cheap, old or rancid. Sorry to say I won't be dining there again. read more

I don't normally give really low reviews but this was an unbelievable experience. It took 1 hour for us to get our food, four tables that were sat after us got their appetizers and main dishes before we can get our entrees. Two of these tables were groups of 9. Another table was sat after us, got all their food, and left before we were even finished eating. Found out it's because all these tables knew the owner. I'm only giving a 2 star because I could tell our waiter felt bad for us. I would not recommend coming here. read more

I ate at TPR last night for the first time but will be back for sure. Everything we had was delicious and the service was warm and wonderful. Robert, the owner, sent over delicious eggplant parm which I thoroughly enjoyed. I also had the the flounder francese which was delicious as was the amazing cheesecake for dessert. I didn't have the pizza but can't wait to try the meatball pie. It looked seriously good. read more

PROS: This place is one of my fav pizza places around. It has that Italian atmosphere vibe, the staff is very friendly, they have a large selection of well priced items on their menu, and tons of parking out front. They're also a two part business where they have an eat in and a pick up for to go orders. Both are separated from each other. The best part of it was the food came out quickly! CONS: I ordered the chicken parm and the food was a little undercooked which cause stomach pains later on. That tells me other things may not be cooked thoroughly which is probably why the food came out quickly OVERALL: definitely a place where I would eat at. I would order a pizza or pasta rather than something with meat in case it doesn't come out right read more

TPR Pizzeria - Italian Near Me - Tenafly, New Jersey

The best Italian food in town the staff are always friendly and careful that the order is always right

Stingy on ingredients they gave me a few sausages and mushrooms for the tpz special. First time ordering the pizza was great, second time ordering it was awful will not be returning. read more

I just called to order a gift card for my father for the holidays. I spoke with a gentleman I believe named Chris and he was fantastic. While they usually do not take charges over the phone and normally do E-Gift Cards I let him know the circumstance of me living in California and my father not having active email that an e-card was not likely going to work. At every opportunity him to say no he found a way to say yes. At the end of the call he then lets me know that instead of mailing this out he or someone from his establishment would drop it at my father's residence. I have been in the hospitality/restaurant business for 30 years and this gentleman that represented TPR today is an amazing representation of hospitality and superior customer service. The next time I am back east I will be sure to come in and enjoy a meal at your establishment. read more

Pizza is always on point, sauce isn't sweet like other places been coming here since I was a teen and it's always my go to when we want pizza read more

I have been eating at Tenafly Pizza for many years. I love the chicken parm and they never disappoint..highly recommend!!!

We have been coming to this place for 30 years, and they have been consistent throughout that time. Services is always been good, from when we had little kids to now parties with multiple generations. The place is always clean, and comfortable, and the food is generally excellent. read more

In this COVID world, figured my best bet for a fun and safe Friday night would be dinner at TPR, where everyone seems to be extremely supportive of the varying worries related to COVID. I even noticed a server wearing his mask outside in the parking lot. This in itself was superb! Yet again I was not only thrilled with the new food offerings, but the staff is second to none. It is my understanding that the restaurant is under new control, which further underscores my elevated experience. Mr. Robert and his new team not only amplified my Friday night, but truly made it a memorable one, which we all know good pizza can do! Furthermore, the teams ordering suggestions were beyond my best expectations. In addition to my required "veal pizza", I was served some of the most culinary creative and quality Italian food I've ever had. No offense to Rudy's, but there's a new superstar in town! I continue to recommend the restaurant. For the rest of my time in NJ, I plan to continue to support this local business that (to my understanding) has recently had managerial changes, including Mr Robert. I am unsure if Mr Robert is a regular waiter, manager, or what, but all I am certain of is that him and his newly in place team including both Ben and Regina are excellent providers. I look forward to supporting this local business, and hope that others can join me in support as the overall SMB economy rebounds from pandemic headwinds. I not only reiterate the importance of supporting local businesses during this time, but also the fact that TPR provides service, food, safety, and customer service at a level I've only historically witnessed from Michelin rated restaurants. Call me crazy, but wouldn't be surprised to see a star or two awarded to this establishment in the future. read more

See all

Surprised at how extensive the restaurant's menu was for a pizza place. I had the seafood fra diavolo and it was good - a nice amount of heat, not over the top. My friends' capellini with broccoli rabe and the gnocchi with meat sauce were good too. They remodeled in the past year or so and have plenty of comfortable seating. I would recommend trying TPR for a casual Italian eat-in destination. read more

TPR Pizzeria - Seafood Fra Diavolo - Italian Near Me - Tenafly, New Jersey

See all

Decent Italian fare in diner like setting booths and all. Warm bread basket very fresh. I had fusilli with chicken,asparagus and sun dried tomatoes. $12.95. Good size portion. A little bland for my liking and too much sauce. My wife had linguine with white clams $13.95, it was also very plain but the texture of pasta was good. The sauce had no flavor. The staff were ok and so was the service. read more

TPR Pizzeria - Fusilli with chicken and asparagus - Italian Near Me - Tenafly, New Jersey

See all

Popped in tonight for a quick dinner before another engagement later. I hadnt been to TPR in years therefore was pleasantly surprised to see it appear so modern, clean and spacious! It was quiet for a Tuesday evening at 5:15 pm. We got seated right away, ordered a salad and slice of pizza. They brought out a fresh hot mini loaf of crispy italian bread for the table. It was quite good! The salad was very tasty (I ordered the roasted peppers, romano cheese and grillIed chicken. Was about $17 and tasty. My son enjoyed his slice and even took the leftover bread home. Overall quite a nice experience. Friendly and quick service and will definitely be returning soon because they have quite a large menu. Parking is easy -located next door to Stop n Shop and quite a few things in the area walking distance including bakeries. read more