Pizza amazing! All fresh ingredients. Recommend 100% and wish it would open for lunch!read more

The best pizza. And don't forget the fresh mozzarella. Amazing!! The only problem with getting…read morepizza here is that you're spoiled and won't want one from anywhere else.

The pizza was amazing! Being a NYC raised person I can say best pizza in this area! Also delicious…read morechurros! Thank you!

Was a good place at one time. Went in to place an order for a couple pies about a month ago at 8pm…read more Person behind the counter told me they shut off the oven because they close at 9pm and can't take pizza order. I left and placed an order at another pizza place 15 minutes later who was still taking orders. Tonight I attempted to call Mateos to place an order. It sounded like the phone was picked up and hung up. I called back 2 more times and got the same result. I see on their website you can place an order online, which costs a fee. The order has to be paid by credit card. No thanks! Mateo's just lost a customer. With the way rents are, they should not be turning away business.

Had a lovely evening and thoroughly enjoyed the atmosphere. We had the rib eye steak special which…read morewasn't as good as expected. More importantly we did not expect what it cost. The wait staff was very cordial but should have told us that the cost of the special was $175. We expected that the cost would be higher than usual but never expected $175. Both my partner and I reached out to the staff by email but neither of us got a response. Very disappointed.

Does Martha Stewart have mid taste?…read more The renowned homemaker and chef extraordinaire ranks Stissing House as her favorite restaurant, but when my husband and I visited, we thought the food was just ok. While I understand the concept behind their cuisine - traditional American flavors pared down to its truest form - I found the food to be, for a lack of better word, bland. Sure, this boils down to preference (I enjoy complex flavors with lots of seasoning), but it's hard for me to sing its praises when the chicken tasted like chicken with a pinch of salt, the pork tasted like pork with a pinch of salt, and the vegetables tasted like vegetables with, you guessed it, a pinch of salt. That's the point, I suppose, but it's a point my taste buds don't particularly agree with. That's not to say the quality and the craft was not at its best. I'll give it to them: the chicken was juicy, the pork skin crisp, the vegetables cooked to perfection (not overcooked, not too al dente, but just right). The biggest disappointment was the sesame puffs with ice cream. Seeing this on the menu, I thought, "Great, a complex flavor!" but was let down at first bite when I found that, alas, I couldn't taste the sesame at all. It tasted like a regular ol' ice cream puff slathered in too-dark caramel. It would have been better paired with black sesame ice cream, but I fear it wouldn't fit their menu's flavor profile. I'm not discouraging people from coming here. By all means, try it! It's a charming location, the food is well prepared, the ingredients premium. It just didn't wow me, and that's perfectly alright.

Holy crap. Just ate here and it has got to be top 5 pizza places we've tried (and we've eaten at a…read morebunch across NYC and New Haven) Menu is concise but we ate the margarita and it was unbelievable. Sauce was perfectly balanced, dough was right amount of crisp and soft. Can't go wrong with wood fired pizza but they've nailed the balance here. Highly highly recommend!

Clean spacious and bright interior. Friendly service. Simple menu, they just focus on salads,…read morepizza and drinks. I enjoyed my local beer from Poughkeepsie. Our mixed greens salad was excellent. We ordered a Margherita pizza with half a side of sausage. It was about the right amount for myself and my daughter to share. It was pretty good, thin crust, good dough. Could have had bit more char on the crust and base to help hold everything together as it was a bit too wet. I saw a reviewer here say it was as good or better than new haven pizza but having grown up in the next town over from new haven, I will say that this is better than average pizza but not really close to new haven-level. Go here if you are in the mood for pizza and are nearby.

Pizza is great, the field green salad is always fresh and the staff is always friendly. What more…read morecould you ask for

After a lovely music performance at a nearby winery, we were in the mood for some pizza on a warm…read moresummer evening. When I pulled into this historic downtown, I didn't expect to see the welcoming courtyard of the Lantern, complete with market lights and plenty of space to spread out, especially great for families with children. The pizza was as delicious as it looked and came out quickly! The servers and clients all seemed very happy, and it's easy to see why. There's plenty of parking in town within a short walk. I'd definitely come back!

Visited with my friend Dom who had posted previously about their salad, and he convinced me to have…read morethe same salad. Yes, we went to a Pizzeria and had salad! Well worth the change in my diet of carbs, but I really want to try a pizza! The salad is "The Signature" and is a bargain at $10.95. Way too much healthy food, but, since it doesn't keep in the fridge well, you will find yourself trying to finish it. I almost finished, but, not quite. Good place, nearby to my local road racing track (Lime Rock Park) and the best food that I have had on a track day in a long time.

Very rude waitress,said I wanted a signature salad to go with extra dressing,put feta cheese in…read moreinstead of gongazola,she said it comes with gongazola and you have to order what your eating here first,we were first ustomers ,waited more than 30 minutes for a pizza which my son said wasn't that good,very doughy,I felt like telling her to take the salad and shove it were the sun doesnt shine,felt like crying sitting there,would have walked out but my son ordered the pizza,got the order wrong,no extra dressing,

Awesome spot for pizza and Italian food! They're open late…read moretoo which is nice. Classics done right

This has to be the worst pizza I ever tried it was literally falling apart the crust was soggy it…read morefelt like a flower tortilla not good at all