We were visiting the area from Florida and I needed a quality north shore beef. Tostimos knocked it out of the park! We got there a little after lunch. We checked out the menu at the counter and went with a super beef, 4 way, add horseradish. Service was fast and super friendly. We grabbed a seat and our food came up in good time. This sandwich was a glorious monster! It was covered in the James River BBQ sauce, cheese on the bottom, and had a perfect amount of mayo. Those onion rings added the perfect crunch. The bun was toasted to perfection, super crispy, but not burnt. The beef was tasty and incredibly tender. We had zero complaints. This was a top quality beef! Overall, we loved our visit to Tostimos. Nice spot, incredible food, and friendly service. Highly recommended. read more

See all

Located next to Old Navy in a mall plaza, it's pretty unassuming. Order and wait for it. Teen girls with the usual bored faces at the register. Harry Belafonte on the speakers. An older man walked over to my table and said. Best roast beef ! I come here all the time ! I got the regular roast beef Pretty darn good Very no nonsense dining read more

Tostimo's - Roast Regular Beef - Pizza Near Me - Seabrook, New Hampshire

We ordered some food from here on New Years. We got a small pizza, a chicken sandwich and onion rings. The sandwich was the spicy bird which had crispy chicken tenders, red cabbage, Nashville hot sauce and ranch. The original sandwich also has pickles, which I omitted from my order. While I wouldn't say that the sandwich was bad, I don't think I would get it again. The bun definitely wasn't the sturdiest; that combined with the sandwich being drenched in sauce made the sandwich a bit difficult to eat and overall just not as enjoyable as I had hoped. On the positive side, I tried some of my boyfriend's pizza and thought it was pretty good. The onion rings were also good, they had a nice crispy batter. If we were to get food from here again, it might be a good idea for us to just stick to the pizzas and appetizers. read more

Had a large cheese pizza. Greek style and the best I have had in 50 years since Peabody House of pizza was still in business. Lots of oil on top which if not your preference you can just let it drip off but that's how it should be. Had to try the skinny fries since they make them in tallow fat. Almost as good as McDonald's! Place is nice and clean with great staff. 100% will go back to try the rest of their menu. read more

Tostimo's - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seabrook, New Hampshire

See all

No more Italian sandwiches, so I stopped going. The pizza sauce is also a deal breaker for me.

Too bad they won't let u do half n half calzones... they are so good, the chicken parm is stuffed, meatball ricotta so tasty and buffalo chix so good too.. prices cheaper than competition when compared by size .. Seabrook keep the spot, it feeds us well read more

See all

Not worth your time or money. First sub was $16 - tiny tiny tiny. They even used bagged marinara sauce; the fake spice was overwhelming. Wasn't even remotely full or satisfies. Contemplating getting a second sub. Not worth it. Go to market basket and get a sub there. Not. Good. All for the show. They think they're fancy but falling flat. $13 for a junior roast beef. Don't fall for that trap either. Nikos for beef only. read more

Only thing I can say is that Tostimos has amazing roast beef. Every time I am in The area I have to go. Today i went with my son we Had the roast beef and it was Phenomenal as usual warm pink and perfectly cooked and tasty. BBQ sauce was warm and the bun was superbly toasted. My son suggested we try the chicken fingers as he said they are home made. Got the buffalo chicken fingers and they were amazing , supper fresh and real chicken,not that processed garbage. The buffalo Sauce was delicious. Can not say enough about this place. Keep up the good work. Staff was amazing and friendly as usual. Thanks Can not wait to try your Portsmouth location. Jim R. read more

I've been having roast beef sandwiches for about 30 years and this place is consistently the best I have ever had if you like, medium rare, no cold beef or anything brown and overcooked. It is literally perfect every time. read more

Tostimo's - Pizza Near Me - Seabrook, New Hampshire

Food was tasty but delivery charge was $6.99 plus $5 tip for Door Dash, who apparently they use for delivery. Pizza arrived cold, sandwich was wet and soggy. Delivery time was pushed back several times arriving 25 minutes laterrhan original time. Id recommended getting takeout as Door Dash was horrible and not disclosed as their delivery method read more

Got a margarita pizza and it was delicious. Service was great.and the place was clean and organized.

Have been 3 times now and this is hands down the best roast beef I've had in a long time - I feel like it's a destination spot as I come here anytime I'm in the area - the beef is perfectly rare and shaved properly, huge portion and James River BBQ finishes these masterpieces off - fries are legit as well - the owner and staff have always been great and proud of their products and it shows - can't wait to go back read more

The chicken Parm samwich they use provolone??? Must be New England treat but I'm working here from NY and that's not even close to a Chicken Parm. And they sprinkle a ton of parsley and I think grated cheese! Not Italian ........ read more

First time going here and will absolutely be going back. Unreal burger and salad for a small plaza pizzeria

Tostimo's opened last month in the former Olympia Diner/Sal's Pizza space at Southgate Plaza in Seabrook. They offer roast beef sandwiches, pizza (slices and whole pies), pizza calzones, hot & cold subs, wraps, burgers, salads, pasta, rice bowls, kabobs, steak tips, gyros, chicken fingers, bagged chips, baklava, and Coke products in the cooler. The place is order at the counter or online ordering. The place has ample table seating in the bright dining area with TVs on the walls. I stopped by Tostimo's for takeout recently. I ordered a 3-Way Super Beef Sandwich ($10.75 plus tax) and a Fettuccine with Chicken Cutlet ($11 plus tax) at the counter. My number was called 10 minutes later and my food was all set and bagged. I enjoyed my food back at my office. The 3-Way Super Beef had lots of shaved rare roast beef, a spicy BBQ sauce, mayo, American cheese slice on a toasted soft onion roll. This is what tasty roast beef sandwich should be. The pasta dish was packed in a round plastic bowl really good; topped with a tender breaded fried chicken cutlet smothered in plenty of thick marinara sauce, good flavor. The slice of baked cheese bread with the pasta was fantastic. I can't wait to try out some more things from here! read more

Good solid food with friendly service. Can't ask for much more! We would definitely go back when in the area.

Yesterday I ordered a large cheese pizza for delivery. After waiting 40 minutes I called and was told the pizza wasn't picked up yet and there's nothing they do can about it they can't contact drivers. You shouldn't be offering delivery for 7 dollars when you have no way of knowing the food will be picked up. Complete waste of time. read more

We ordered food and soda, they never delivered the soda. Called they said they couldn't fix it unless we went there to pick it up. They fixed it food tased good other than the wings that were pink. read more

My meatballs were old and really inedible ...my husbands sandwich was also thrown in the trash .. maybe a bad day but i'm not going back !

Walked in on a Saturday at 1:45 p.m. and tried to order a Big Beef and was told they had no more roast beef. So from 11:00 am open to 1:45 pm they ran out of Roast Beef! Then, as we were walking out and the person behind the counter said to a customer waiting that was in front of us, I guess your lucky you got the last one, like throwing it our faces that we got nothing. read more

Went here on my way to Hampton beach omg I honestly might drive the 30 minutes up here just to get another roast beef this place was super good read more

Really good pizza. We ordered a large meat lovers and a large cheese for takeout. I got a text when the order was ready - super convenient! It's a good crust. It's not too doughy or too thin. The sauce and toppings all stayed on. We'd be back the next time we're in town! read more

Tostimo's - Meat lovers - Pizza Near Me - Seabrook, New Hampshire

See all

First time here, I got a slice of cheese and a crispy chicken bacon ranch wrap. WOW!!! Excellent flavors and everything tastes fresh! Nice to have fresh great tasting food, I'll definitely be coming here again and again. 5/5 read more

Large portions and good flavor. Casual and good for kids. Good location with easy parking- close to groceries and TJ Maxx. We would go again. read more

Things I like... - delicious food - reasonable prices - friendly staff - clean restaurant with plenty of seating Things I don't like... - charged a hidden fee for using a credit card. Showed in receipt but I didn't see any mention of it prior to purchase. Also, a point of confusion. The restaurant main sign said Tostimos. But the credit card receipt and the small street sign said Nostimos. read more

Alright... I grew up in the North Shore and know great roast beef sandwich shops and the crown had always been in my opinion Billy's in Melrose. Folks will say Nicks in Beverly Liberty Bell in Stoneham but I'm here to tell you the Crown has just been passed to Tostimo's in Seabrook for the Best Roast Beef Sandwich I've Ever had. Congratulations Team! I'll be back! read more

Tostimo's - Supa Roast Beast cheese sauce mayo.... Incredible - Pizza Near Me - Seabrook, New Hampshire

If you have an out of state zip code and try to order over the phone, this company will not except your debit or charge card. After 4 attempts our food had to be picked up in person. I can only guess how many customers they lose because of this. read more

Everything is delicious here! I LOVED the Veggie Pizza and we also enjoyed the roast beef sandwich and wings!

If you are seeking fressh quality food and a friendly atmosphere Tostimos in Seabrook NH is the place to go. The ricotta and meatball pizza was superb! The crust was cooked perfectly and the meatballs were flavorful. The chicken parm dinner with ziti was quite the hit. Tender crispy chicken accompanied by pasta cooked just perfectly with a luscious red sauce. Large portions and a friendly atmosphere. We were extremely pleased and will be returning to sample more scrumptious dishes. read more

Quick hit: Excellent, and I mean tasty Chicken Caesar Wrap. Perfection. I would add that customer service was a little weak, could have made my visit better w/ a sincere 'hello' or welcome and 'thank you, thanks for stopping in'. read more

I like sliced beef better than shredded usually. However, the beef was great. For a side, the Greek fries were amazing. Clean inside. Friendly staff. Great service. Would come back! read more

Love all the food I've eaten there so far! Love the delivery service. Very spacious restaurant !

The 3-Way Roast Beef sandwich was outstanding! Very clean place. Family run. Nice people.

Best chicken and rice bowl in town. The man who served it to me remembered my name and order a week later and purchased me a drink at the bar, truly exceptional customer service. 10/10 read more

Great pizza. Best in the area. Subs are great too. Nice clean restaurant Reasonable prices Looking forward to going back

Wow!! This place does not disappoint. Best Greek salad dressing I've ever had. Love the chicken kabob salad with added feta. Did I say the feta cheese is incredible? My other half had the super beef which is also a fast fave. Haven't tried the pizza but it smells oh sooo good. If you haven't tried this place, you should!! read more

Got takeout. Order was ready quickly. food was hot, good portions, rice bowl was great as was roast beef. Will go again

I ordered the Ckn Caesar wrap (warm chicken was fantastic). My other half had the ckn kabob sub - he really enjoyed it. Will come back again read more