I will begin by saying, I prefer modern-upscale resorts, so this type of "resort" is not really up my alley. I worked in hotels for years, so I am used to providing and receiving round the clock service during stays.
THE GREAT:
The did a fantastic job with the walkway from unit to pier/beach (vegetation is beautiful), and area where boats are parked, is well kept. I really did enjoy the beach portion, as most beaches in the keys, have way too many rocks to enjoy, this one was pretty cleaned up. I like that they have a large float, for everyone to enjoy, as well as seating areas.
The view from pier and beach area is FANTASTIC. We caught the sunset, and it was incredible!
-Washer and dryer in each unit
-Ease of parking
-Docks for boat
-Near tons of restaurants, shopping area
-Fantastic view
-Affordable price (based on what family pays - not sure as I did not get details)
-beach/pool access
-ocean view units (2 our of 10)
-Wifi
THE NOT SO GREAT:
Topsiders Resort, is not a bad place, from what I got to experience. It just needs TONS of renovations. Renovations I assume are difficult to do, considering that every unit, is owned by 52 different people, leaving little to no room to work, while units are occupied.
With said, even their pool area needs major work. The hotel pool, looked very much like one you would find at a holiday inn (but worse). My daughter LOVES the pool, so i had no choice but to jump in. Pool was filthy, dead bugs were found in rim of the pool. The restrooms were unpleasant, and the dock, above pool, needs to be rebuilt. The entire pool area needs major work.
Now on to the units: There are only two that face the water, and I believe those can be rented ahead of time. Units seem as if they have not been renovated in years. My husbands family has been renting them for over 30 years (hence why we are visiting), and I was told, that not much has been done during time. Bathrooms and kitchen are extremely outdated. The blinds found through the unit, do not match, sort of like, fixed little by little, upon breaking. Carpet inside the room safe of an awful green color. Bedding and pieces of decor, all extremely outdated. Appliances are old.
This place would be so great, if they would invest and do a complete remodel. It seems to be working for management/owners, so I don't see changes taking place any time soon. Truth is, this local looks like it is used mainly by people who have boats, spend 90% of the time on the boats, and use the unit only for sleeping. Or perhaps people that think that "the outdated look" is all part of the keys concept. Which is kind of true, but I have visited large hotels in area, which make the "beach look" work! read more