One of my all time favorite pizza places, which is hard on Long Island where pizza is great to begin with! They have a shrimp slice I'm obsessed with, and a cheeseburger slice I was addicted to before I started trying to be more health conscious lol. But I love how all their specialty slices always look so fresh! I also love their little stuffed garlic bread thingies soo much, dipped in the sauce they give or plain. Service is exceptional. The guys are so friendly, down to earth, and attentive. Cutest little place, very welcoming for all read more

Tony's Pizza - Shrimp slice and stuffed garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Medford, New York

I've been coming to Tony's Pizza for as long as I can remember, and it truly is a Medford staple. If you've never been, you absolutely have to try their barbecue chicken pizza--it's one of a kind and only found here at Tony's. Of course, all of their other pies are fabulous too. I wish I had a picture to share with you, but I ate it so fast I forgot to take one. (Trust me, that says more than any photo could!) read more

See all

It's the bruschetta slice that does it for me here. It's literally the best I've had! If they throw some breaded chicken cutlets in there it would be the perfect chicken Milanese slice. The bruschetta is just amazing on it. The pizza in general is pretty good here. The guys that work here are also super nice. Can't go wrong with this classic pizzeria. Side note: their sister restaurant is La Margaritas in Medford which is also a solid spot. Delicious fried calamari. read more

Great pizza flavors! Clean and staff was very nice. Much better than nearby local pizza shops. Will return!

I've been going to Tony's pizza for years. I used to go to La Margherita pizza (same family) but this location is closer for me now. Every single pizza I ever received is PERFECT. I don't know what he does over there, but that sauce is to die for. You have to try it. My partner went to culinary school and his grandfather owned an Italian restaurant in Manhattan, and according to him, this is the real deal. You're welcome! :) read more

I ordered a large cheese pie for delivery and they brunt my pizza so bad it wasn't edible and still thought it was a good idea to send it. Dont order from here unless you like your pizza extra crispy. read more

Stopped in for lunch, as we were driving by. Appeared clean, but in need of an update. Around 2:30 on a Monday, it was fairly busy. Friendly counter staff. Decent amount of pizza options at the counter. My husband got a regular slice and a veal parmagiana hero. He enjoyed the slice with a nice crunch to the crust and not at all greasy. He also liked the Veal parmagiana hero, perfectly well done as he enjoys it. As I tasted the Veal, it was chopped into little bites, a generous portion, and flavorful. I had the deep dish regular slice. Again, it was not greasy at all, and the cheese pull was incredible. I bit into a nice, soft layer, and then the crispy crunch of the crust. I also tried a mozzarella stuffed garlic knot. Again, great cheese pull. The garlic was powder dusted on top and was a little burnt tasting, but still a solid knot. Overall, it was a good experience. read more

Tony's Pizza - Deep dish regular slice and mozzarella stuffed garlic knot - Pizza Near Me - Medford, New York

See all

Highly recommend! I have this place 5 stars, but let me explain why, I'm originally from NY but my 15 year old daughter isn't, we live in Florida now. She's heard me talk so much about NY pizza that I wanted to take her out to get good, greasy, NY pizza. We'll Tony's didn't disappoint in the taste at all, they let me down a bit in the grease department, , but the service was excellent and the pizza was damn good! My daughter enjoyed and raved about how much better the pizza is up there than back home, all I wanted from the experience. So I definitely recommend. Sorry I didn't get any pics but I can tell you we started with one slice but had to go back for another. read more

Tony's Pizza - One beautiful slice of cheese pizza! Oh and my daughters hand - Pizza Near Me - Medford, New York

This is a great pizzeria. This is a family owned business and it's definitely a gem that offers a wide variety of pizza variations and to be honest the food there is great. The service is great there if Luigi is there tell him Frank says hello. The ambiance is cozy. read more

Tony pizza is the best! The pizza is always amazing and the owners are the best! We use them every year for a school fundraiser and they are always more then accommodating. read more

Tonys is family run old-school pizza. A wide variety of food is available. It's hard to choose when at the counter. My advice is to stop off and try them all. The staff is friendly. I have seen the same faces forever. I've been going there since the late 80's highly advise trying the barbecue slice if that's your thing. Delicious and like no other. Thanks, Tony's pizza, for always being consistent all these years. read more

Tony's Pizza - Barbecue slice - Pizza Near Me - Medford, New York

See all

I found myself in Medford with much time to spare due to missing my train. Tony's was a find. Great food and good prices, too! Enjoyed a delicious meal, and the staff was so kind to let me sit for hours for my train. I highly recommend Tony's. read more

Recently ordered a catering package for my 30th birthday dinner party and it was amazing. The owner was super helpful! Food was hot, and delicious. He also threw in garlic knots and dinner rolls for free. My package included house salad, wings, sausage & peppers, meatballs, penne alla vodka and chicken francese. It was all perfect. read more

Yes, this place has been around for awhile. No, the quality is no longer good. The Grandma pizza is terrible, raw dough, had to throw it away. The specialty pizzas with add-ons were also just blah. There's plenty of competition in the area, and this one is just a dud not worth going to, even if you're hungry. read more

Hello all and welcome to the 8th episode of Ass or Gas. Today we're in Medford Long Island trying out Tony's pizza. Upon arrival you notice a giant sign that says "Tony's" a great way to let people know where the pizza is! When you get on the property you can smell the dough, and delicious sauce. My colleague is a huge fan of barbecue chicken pizza and told me I had to try it...so I did. At first I was a bit skeptical, but after my first bite my mouth was filled with sweet, salty and a hot combination of chicken and pizza. It was indeed a fantastic slice of pizza. Although there was one small issue...the crust. It was in my colleagues words "a medium level crust". If you're a crust type of person please advise. Otherwise it was great. In conclusion the pizza was dough, but had a crisp crunch. This meal was...GAS‼ read more

I was at Tony's Pizza last month when I flew up to Long Island to visit my dad. I remember the old Tony's Pizza that was next-door, are used to go there as a kid when pizza and a canna Coke was $.90. Things have changed but the pizza seems to be still popular as they're still in business and it's my father's favorite pizza joint in Medford. There's nothing like New York pizza. read more

My husband just picked up cheese and tomato pizza as a pure vegetarian and a religious manner, surprisingly there was a meat attached on the side Looks like they used same cutter for all pizzas. read more

Tony's Pizza - Sausage in vegetarian pizza - Pizza Near Me - Medford, New York

Was in the area and oh yes again I needed pizza. Decided to try Tonys, Had 2 slices sicilian. The service was excellent , And the staff friendly and helpful. The pizza was just ok, Nothing to write home about. read more

Tony's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Medford, New York

In my humble opinion, they make the gold standard of Grand Ma pies... Very nice people, Good food & Delivery I'm a fan. read more

Another 3-star, A-OK, pizza place. Slices here are generally pretty good, although I think they're smaller than the slices at nearby joints. There's always beer in the soda cooler, a sports game on the LCD TV, and the guy behind the counter is always so freakin friendly. I think it's owned by the same people that own La Margherita in Medford. There are coupons on the La Margherita website that can be used at Tony's Pizza. read more

Tony's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Medford, New York

Good service, great pizza! Been here many times and always am happy with my pizza. I haven't lived in LI in over 24 years, so finding a quality pizza place is a little more challenging for me. Whenever I'm home for a visit - I stop for pizza at Tony's and love it! read more

This pizza was delicious. Super thin crust just the way it should be!! Although we ordered from door dash and the cheese was on one side, it didn't effect the taste of how yummy it was. Reminds me of a pizza spot in farmingdale also Tony's pizza when I was growing up. We ordered 1/2 cheese 1/2 sausage pie. My new spot for sure!! Also was surprised to see the box says they are owned by La Margarita. read more

It's not New Haven ahbeetz but their "Grandma?" slice is damn good. The lemon chix slice was ok. I'd go here again if in the area.

I've eaten Tony's before on lunch break while in the area for work I've recently moved to the area and decided to order Tony's me and the wife ordered the deep dish pie. It was excellent just like I remember from the past this will be my regular pizza spot from now on. read more

Only delivers weekends but worth Granma pie the best and capresse salad my fav generous portions

Yesterday I called to make an order and the guy on the phone was rude and he was rushing me... I had to hang up the phone and call another pizzeria. read more

Actually really sad to leave this review. Grew up in the area and just moved back. I used to love getting pizza here and the staff is very nice. Unfortunately whoever was working tonight gave my fiancé and I burnt food. I was actually just in a car accident before on route 112 and we thought it would be easier to get take out from this place. What a poor day all the way through :( read more

Tony's Pizza - Chicken parm hero with badly burnt bread and chicken - Pizza Near Me - Medford, New York

See all

I live in the area and Tonys has been our go to pizza spot. Staff is always friendly and helpful. Always willing to make a fresh daily item even after they have sold out for the day. Panini sandwich is my fav. I have had several other menu items and have not been disappointed. The prices are fair and the food fresh ... Like I said this is our go to Pizza Joint in Medford. read more

I love Tony's Pizza! I found it when working in the area. My fav slice is the bruschetta! Food is fresh, staff friendly. Booths to eat in if you want to. I highly recommend! read more

Tony's Pizza - Bruschetta slice! - Pizza Near Me - Medford, New York

See all

Chucky cheese style pizza. Really low quality , worst Zepolie's I ever had. Terrible I would never go back

I ordered a chicken Marsala it smelled like they cooked it under their arm pit .. Bland no taste packed with mushrooms and soggy chicken cutlets just not what I expected from Tony's , I usually order pizza from here due to the fact I like margaritas pizza off rt 101 and today I decided to order something else besides pizza, bad move I guess read more

See all

Not from in town and just wanted some pizza for dinner so decided on Tony's pizza. I'm extremely happy with the how it was, great pizza, great service, and super happy crowd filling the small restaurant. The experience felt just as homey as being in my own house as the restaurant had gameshows on the TV with everyone playing along. Everyone that entered knew the guys behind the counter and all of them had personal conversations with the main cashier that felt so casual and comfortable. All in all a great experience that I would recommend to anyone looking for a quaint restaurant to eat pizza! read more

We recently ordered pickup from Tony's and I am seriously disappointed. We ordered one white pie and one pepperoni, when we went and picked it up they have us the wrong order. When we got home and realized the error we called and the girl on the phone was rude and told us if we wanted a new pizza we would have to return the wrong pizza and pick up a new one. But we would have to wait 20 minutes for them to make a new one. We did that and when we went to pick up they new one they were short with us and even charged us extra to get a speciality pie. I asked to speak with a manager and they told me nobody was there and I would have to call back a different day. By the time the pizza swap was over I had one white pizza I overpaid for and one cold pepperoni pizza (took an hour total to get things sorted out). The actual pizza is okay, nothing amazing, but this place is closest to my house. Fortunately there are 10 other pizza places on 112 and I will definitely be making the switch. It's a shame that some rude and inexperienced employees are going to cost Tony his customers. read more

They catered my girlfriends 40th Birthday. Wow the food was fantastic and they went above and beyond. I would highly recommend Tony's Pizza to everyone. read more

I must say . I love the pizza from Tony's he has the best pizza on long island. The Thin crust slice with lots of cheese and it melts in your mouth . yummy !! The staff is very nice and clean and always friendly . read more

Was my first time ordering anything besides a Chicken Marsala slice (bomb!) So I ordered their Stuffed Shells and a Salad. Seriously cheesy. Seriously delicious (if you love a cheesy saucy overload!) Salad was fresh and crisp and delish as well But oh em gee them stuffed shells was a flavor parade like Mardi Gras in New Orleans in my mouth!!! p.s. They Now Deliver Too!!! read more

My wife and I have been using Tony's Pizza for years now for all of our family parties. The food is excellent, portions are plentiful, the price is right and the quality is great. Luigi is so accommodating and helps me create a great menu every time. He even created simple catering packages that help me easily order based on my party size. Nothing like home style Italian cooking! (especially when I don't have to cook it) Looking forward to the next party! read more

Not a fan, pizza was not bad, but couldn't say I really enjoyed it. The shop itself matched the food experience as well. Whole place was very blah, but at least filled my gullet. read more

Probably my fave pizza spot... not all pizza is the same even in NY.. but I will keep coming back here .. love the crust

This place has really gone downhill. We have been ordering delivery from Tony's since my fiance and I moved into the area three years ago and up until recently had really enjoyed it. However, the last 4 times have changed that. Each time we ordered a side of sauce with our dozen garlic knots they've charged us for it and forgotten it. Even though I was a little mortified by doing it (I'm not much of a complainer but garlic knots without sauce are useless to me) I actually brought it up before hand saying, "Hey, no worries or anything but please remember the sauce, the last three times we've ordered it you guys forgot it." The person taking my order laughed a little said he was sorry and then added, as if he were noting it on the order "Remember the sauce." They forgot the sauce. To be fair, I called and complained and they did offer me a free dozen knots next time but I informed them that there wouldn't be a next time. It's a shame what's happened to this place. Good thing there's at least a dozen other pizza places on or around 112. I would suggest you go there. Even their far superior sister store La Mahgarita just a few miles away. read more