Growing up, I always got the best pizza when I visited my grandmother in New Jersey. The first time I ordered a cheese pie at Tony's, I felt like I was back in NJ. Tony's makes the best NJ or NY style pizza in the area. read more

I tried the single lunch slice of pepperoni and the meatball parm sub. The sub was toasted well and crispy. Meatballs were good. Overall the sandwich was OK. Nothing special, though. The pizza slice was large and inexpensive (just under $3), very crispy, and wasn't that greasy (as pepperoni pizza sometime is). Good lunch place. read more

Stopped by when travelling through the area. The pizza was very good, and if I lived here I would come back. Everyone was friendly, but they lose a star because they had the chairs stacked 90 minutes before closing, that makes you feel a little unwelcome. read more

The thin slice NY pizzas are delicious but I'm not a big fan of their capri salad because the tomatoes were hard and had no flavor at all. If your looking for a good big size pizza for an affordable price, this is the place to go to or order from. read more

Great Pizza, Calzones, and breadsticks. The staff is courteous and expedite food quickly. The calzones and pizzas are made fresh and taste fresh and delicious! Great place for Pizza and Calzones. Highly recommend. read more

I agree with Johnny M.'s review completely. Quick, friendly service, good price and a good choice for NY style pizza. (On a side note: Once we ordered extra cheese, the second time we did not. Never could tell a difference in the amount of cheese - only difference was the price.) read more

I was passing through Hickory and looked on Yelp to find a good pizza joint. This place had good reviews so I checked it out. To my surprise, I quickly noticed that this restaurant is actually a chain that goes by other names. In Greensboro, it is Mario's Pizza. Same decor, uniforms, and pizza. This isn't a slight on the place . . . Mario's is one of my favorites in Greensboro. But if you've been to Mario's then you know what to expect with this place. Great "New York style" thin crust pizza. Don't get the Sicilian pizza. read more

Straight forward NYC style pizzeria. Great tasing dough, quality cheese. Delish. Family friendly. Highly recommend. They've got all sizes of pizzas to include a whopping 24" - mega giant. read more

Stop by Tony's pizza for the first time last week and it was awesome-the customer service is outstanding.The place is very clean and the food is delicious I will definitely be back. read more

Tony's pizza is quite good but suuuuuper greasy! I have never had to dab a napkin on my pizza till I ate there. This is a nice quick, simple and fast pizza experience for those days whe you are running around and don't feel like McD's read more

Tony's Pizza is one of the few pizza joints that really understands classic, New York style pizza. Being a native New Yorker, trust me, this is rare, especially in the Hickory area. At first, I thought the prices were a bit high, but when I saw the size of their slices, that all changed. Their "large" pizza puts Domino's "large" to shame. Is it a bit greasy? Sure, but that's because they use REAL cheese, not that over-processed, chemical-filled excuse for cheese used by the big chains. And to top it off, the staff at the counter is alway friendly. Try their freshly-made calzones. You won't be disappointed. read more

I'm used to great Italian pizza from Connecticut. The pizza wars near New Haven get mentioned on Food Network. Tony's is the next best thing to that pizza. Have never been disappointed. read more

Pizza is good and pizza by the slices are huge!!! Customer service was great! It's definitely worth trying! Ps- they have beer too! read more

Tony's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hickory, North Carolina

Best thin crust in Hickory and just a MONSTER size to boot!!!!!!

I`m from NYC, So i know good pizza !Tony`s in Hickory is the 2nd best pizza in North Carolina !the 1 ST is in Statesville ! but i wont name it here ! Tony`s in Hickory is the best Nyc Pizza ! Anywhere around Hickory ! read more

took my pop"s in late Jan, we enjoyed it. the pizza slice's we ordered were huge and deli sh. So worth the value...

Best pizza in Hickory by far - true NY style pizza! Meatball subs and cannoli are both excellent as well. read more

Now thatsa good pizza! The pizza is huge! And it tastes great! Go in for the slice or the whole pie. This NY style pizzeria is making it here in the south. read more

Tonys pizza and subs are authentic NY style. "I havn't had pizza this good since I moved from NY" read more

No delivery. Get off your fat can and get it yourself. Not only the best, but the least expensive. Now, three locations & Frankies at Granite Falls, South Bend Shopping Ctr. Get some now! Good old fashioned NY pizza. read more

Stopped by Tony's last night. We are new to the area and we usually have pizza on Friday nights. First of all we were impressed with the very friendly reception at the front counter. Nothing better than being greeted by a smiling face when you're in a place for the first time. Pizza was ready in 20 minutes and we were really happy with the quality, taste and the price. It will be our go to place on Fridays. Great place. read more

Real pizza finally! The big chain pizza's use mostly additives, chemicals and toxic oil products as ingredients, go on domino's website yourself and look at the ingredient list. Tony's is how pizza should be, the pizza dough is floor, yeast and a little salt, that's it, nothing more is added. Read the ingredient list for the big chain pizza's, look what you're feeding your kids. read more

I'm from the New Haven area, where pizza is the best in the country according to many national surveys. Always debatable, but still, I consider myself a connoisseur having grown up there in a large Italian neighborgood.. So I am very critical of the pizza around here, it just doesn't come anywhere near decent. Until I started going to Tony's, that is.......... there are 2 places in Catawba County that get high marks from me. Amalfi's in Conover, and Tony's on Catawba Valley Blvd. in Hickory. Great crust, nice and crispy outside and yeasty/chewy inside (as opposed to the majority I've had around here that taste like a baking powder dough and don't know what semolina flour is). Their sauce is perfect - I hate sweet sauce - and has actual garlic flavor to it, which is also a requirement to me. Not too much herb seasoning, just enough. Some places tend to overdo - sauce tastes like Prego from a jar - bleech. Not Tony's. Also, their mozzarella cheese is excellent and good quality, nice and stringy with some toothiness to it instead of the cheap mush combined with cheddar that I have had in other places. Their onions are perfectly dried ahead of time so they actually brown, they pepperoni is high quality and very tasty, and their oven does a nice char on the bottom. It's a half hour ride for me each way to pick up my order, but it's well worth it to get a real taste of home. Been there many times now, always a great pie. Tony's, Wooster Street would be proud of you. Don't ever change! Please thank the pizza chefs for me! read more

It can be hard to find good pizza in this area but Tony's is one of the best! If you like a large thin crust slice with grease dripping onto the plate than you might want to check out Tony's. read more

Best pizza in town, even my sister, a New Yorker, was impressed. Delicious crust on pizza. Good place to take the family or to grab a bite after the movies. read more

As a former NYer this is the closest you can get to NY style pizza. I've never had anything bad at Tony's. I love their sausage and spaghetti and their pizza. Customer service is excellent. You can't go wrong going to Tony's. read more