Great service, wonderful atmosphere, food is awesome,, love the pizza! Right in the center of Newton.

Quick service during lunch hours. The salads came out quick and the house dressing is good. They are working on the street but still an accessible entrance. read more

See all

I came in at 6:20 on a Wednesday. The restaurant was pretty empty so I was expecting a pretty quick meal. I remember in the past the hickory location had a buffet option the Newton one I came to did not. I got mozzarella sticks and a steak and cheese pizza. Value for price is pretty good but the taste is lacking It might just be the type of pizza I ordered but I love Philly cheesesteaks, the sauce doesn't really have any flavor and neither does the cheese. I got a ranch to dip it in and their ranch is the classic steakhouse homemade ranch that is so good. The mozzarella sticks were also not very flavorful. Also the meal took a while to come out, which I understand but I was hoping my cheese sticks would come out first. If I were to come back I'd order something else or go of the hickory location for the buffet read more

Geppeto's Pizza - Battered Mozzarella Sticks - Pizza Near Me - Newton, North Carolina

See all

Amazing selection of food on the menu. Great food service at Geppetos and knowledgeable staff. Wonderful room to enjoy your meal during the afternoon or evening read more

We grabbed a few pies to bring home. Solid pizza. The thin crust is cracker thin with crunchy crust. The sauce is on the sweeter side. For my taste, I'd like it a little less sweet and more crispy than crunchy, but definitely a solid pie. You won't be disappointed. read more

Saturday dinner 5:30pm, 6/9/24: First time patron and decided to try it based on the strong reviews. Took my MIL to get pizza and we like the atmosphere as we were seated. Quick service after ordering the Special pizza with a beer and white wine. I think this was likely our favorite restaurant pizza ever! That's saying a lot but it was well deserved. The crust was perfect, the sauce slightly sweet and the ingredients delicious! As we finished our meal we noticed the place was nearly full, so others must feel the same. Definitely will come back to try their pastas. Highly recommend read more

Got delivery both times and both times were really good! Wings were good salad was great Stromboli was to die for (get extra marinara on the side :)) read more

Geppeto's Pizza - Side salad with yummy honey mustard - Pizza Near Me - Newton, North Carolina

Great food. Asleyas taste fresh and hot. Attentive servers makes this please even better. The restaurant itself is clean and tidy. Reminds you of and older pizza parlor read more

There food has always been good but I do wish that they would bring back there pizza buffet which was one of my favorite things about the place but they have stopped it sadly there service has always been good and they've always been friendly. read more

Awesome service from a waitress that has been with Neil since place in opened since the 80's. Great place, great food, great service. Always feel at home. read more

I won't be back. The pizza crust is pre made and is terrible. Felt like I was at a Cici's pizza. Worst pizza I have ever had. ****Much better. Order of the menu so you don't risk old items on the all you can eat bar. read more

The food here is amazing! They have the best cauliflower crust and all the toppings are fresh and delicious! The staff is very friendly!

Great team and fast ordering and response Was disappointed when the food was missing two toppings. They did fix it for me read more

Now Geppeto's has delicious food anytime I want a salad or some lasagna or anything form Geppeto's I like

As for cleanliness it is ok.... food is good, i'm a sucker for desert pizza, and personally i think there's is the best.

Over priced for what it is. Ordered a large cheese and a small pepperoni. Got a large cheese and a small extra cheese for around $32. Staff isn't outgoing and friendly. The crust and sauce is too salty and generic. The extra cheese pizza wasn't too bad. read more

Had dinner at the Newton location and was very pleased. Pizza and lasagna were delicious! Will definitely be back!

We highly recommend this place. The food was delicious and hot when delivered. The delivery was prompt and accurate. The driver was extremely courteous. read more

Ordered the meatball sub. They're on the menu as homemade. I love a good meatball. I gave to say they are excellent and yes they are made in the restaurant daily. You can absolutely taste the freshness and quality. I will definitely order again. read more

Had takeout from Geppetos last night. Have enjoyed food here many times. It's always good, pizza, calzones, or salad. They are closed on Sundays post-Covid and the buffet is gone; losses! Love this place! read more

Wow. Super fantastic pizza!! First time trying Geppeto's and I wasn't at all disappointed. I opted for delivery and placed my order online (mobile phone). Delivery time was less than expected and less than promised (which is always a good thing). I got the "original" crust which I thought was a little thin for original but it was great. Very good flavor crust. Toppings were very fresh and tasty. I wish there were more of these in the Charlotte,NC area! read more

Pizza really isn't good, but the wings weren't bad. I'm giving 2 stars because the delivery was on time, friendly and again, the wings weren't bad. The pizza however was a huge disappointment. We probably would have enjoyed a frozen pizza from the grocery store better. If you are craving pizza, then go elsewhere...but if wings are your thing then this is a good bet read more

We wanted a different type of pizza other than our normal. We found this pizza place about 20 miles from us. We were very impressed with the amount of toppings that were used. This made our pizza really good. We had forgotten how good a pizza could be with lots of toppings. The crust used was also was to our liking. We will diffidently go back for another one. read more

Just had this for the first time a few months ago. The pizza was really good and the pasta was amazing! Good size for the price ! Definitely worth eating again! read more

Excellent pizza buffet at a reasonable price. Friendly staff. The buffet had a nice salad bar with a variety of toppings. With approximately 8 pizzas on the bar at any one time, I had plenty of options. Two dessert pizzas. Spaghetti with garlic bread sticks and a choice of meat sauce or plain sauce. I will definitely go back. read more

If I could give this location ZERO stars then I would. Made my order online, left a tip online, then waited for my order to arrive. When the delivery driver dropped the food off, i brought the food inside and noticed I was missing part of the order. I called the store immediately and they told me they were too busy to worry about me and I would have to talk to a manager. So I proceeded to look through the bags and noticed another part of the order was missing. The lady never put the manager on the phone and told me the rest of my order would be delivered within 30 minutes. Its been over an hour and I am still waiting on my food. Just go to giovannis, pizza hut, palermos or Amalfis. Geppettos obviously can't do business correctly and do not care about their customers. read more

Good pizza. The buffet is a great deal. Very good salad bar. Also you can request any pizza for the pizza buffet without issue. This is a frequent stop for our family. read more

This place is delicious. Salad, pizza, and spaghetti lunch buffet 11-2, and dinner buffet 5-830 at a reasonable price. Great service. Very attentive. read more

Just had delivery from here again and as always it was delicious. Our delivery person was on time and professional as well as the phone order taker. We visit the establishment as well as order in and we have never been disappointed. Thanks Gepptos for another wonderful meal. read more

Tristian always makes sure your order is right and thanks you for coming in.Very well mannered young man and pleasant to see at geppetos

We don't order out that often, but when I do order pizza, it's usually Geppeto's! The delivery man is nice and remembers his costumers! Every so often we eat inside the establishment. It's local, clean, and has a friendly staff. Their buffet is great for pizza, pasta, salad and dessert! read more

Very friendly staff, nice little buffet for lunch on a lazy Saturday. Reasonably priced, especially for the little ones. Pizza isn't anything to get super excited about, it's average. They have a nice lunch menu with lunch specials even on Saturdays too. May try out one of those the next time, but definitely someplace I could see returning too especially with my kids. My son has loved the chocolate chip pizza. Have never tried to the take out/delivery service, but the menu is quite nice, I will be taking a menu with me. read more

Another Newton, NC staple! If you grew up in the Newton-Conover area then you know all about Geppeto's. Many Friday nights before and after football games or during sleepovers with friends were spent either here or ordering from here. Now, our boys have grown to love this place. One of the best salad bars in our area. Love stopping by during lunch to fix a salad to go. And sometimes I even get a free sweet tea from one of the nice gals working the front desk. read more

These guys are the best, they always under promise but definitely over deliver on delivery times! The staff is always nice when you call, even if you are still trying to decide what to order. Never had an order come out wrong. Try them, you won't be disappointed! read more

Being disabled sometimes you get a taste for something you can't get.. I'd like to thank Geppetos for there prompt deliveries & there polite delivery drivers read more

I've fallen in love with Geppeto's thin crust pizza. The servers are very friendly, and the atmosphere is a little taste of Italy.