After 10+ years of going there, the quality of food has gotten really bad. Tonight's meal ( cheesesteak) has been by far the worst yet and size has decreased considerably. I am sure I will not eat there anymore as there is a better shop just a little further down the road. You are who you hire!! read more

Went to Tony's last evening to try one of the pasta meals as opposed to the pizza which we typically order. We ordered an entree which comes with a salad and bread as well as an appetizer. The first thing that was served was the pasta...no appetizer or salad to be seen. 3/4 of the way the main dish the appetizer shows up! Never did get the salad. We refused the appetizer and it seemed like it was a big inconvenience to refund the price of the appetizer ($9.99 + tax) Finally the server brought me a $10 bill. I had to explain to her that it needed to have the tax added to the refund and again it seemed like a big inconvenience for her. I also noticed that there was not a glove or hair net worn by anyone (not even the kitchen staff.) kind of looked like they have a bunch of teens and early 20's running the place. read more

Hubby and I each ordered 2 slices. Our slices were Definitely different sizes For the same price. See pics.... Hubby odered an italian sub. It came out missing the cheese and the Capicolla....hubby took a few bites before he noticed. We showed the waitress and she said the Owner wanted to make him a new sub. She ended up bringing us out a 1/2 an italian sub that was hot (ewww) and wrapped in foil to go....we unwrapped it and it was HALF a sub! Totally comedic experience but waste of $30.00 and terrible food. read more

See all

We were in town for a few days and always looking for a good pizza and sub place being from New York. First night our pizza was so dry and crust so hard you could not bite into it, also ordered a chicken Caesar salad which chicken was over cooked or very old and filled with tendons, croutons extremely stale and no parm cheese for salad as it's supposed to come, I ask for cheese the young girl charged me and gives me mozzarella. Two nights later we tried again, pizza ordered with extra sauce and extra cheese so pizza came out normal. However you have to pay for two extra toppings just to get a regular amount of sauce and cheese it takes to make a regular cheese pie. Now I'm not exaggerating the meatball parm sub, the smallest amount of meat I have ever seen on and sub of my 40 years, literally I think one meatball sliced thin was the total amount on sub but meatball was slimy and a shit ton of fennel I really wasn't sure what this sub actually was. It definitely tasted more like a slimy sausage sub. I wonder how they continue to stay in business. Really shame on this business for skimming and scamming the hard working consumer to add a few dollars for their own selfish reasons. read more

Had a mixed experience with Tony's. I put in an order for pickup and the woman I spoke with on the phone was unfriendly and seemed rushed. I'm sure they were very busy but I am a paying customer... I had the eggplant parm and thought it was delicious. The side salad is extremely subpar, but the bread sticks were fantastic!! Super buttery and garlicky. My husband ordered the penne vodka and they gave us the completely wrong order, giving him instead a basic penne with marinara. Unfortunately we didn't realize until we were home and were starving so he ate it anyways. It was overall bland, and certainly not what we paid for. read more

Stopped in today for a quick lunch - I wish I hadn't. I ordered the lunch special of 2 slices of cheese and a coke. Posted price was $4.30 but that's for cash price, for using a card the price is different is unposted. When I walked in the restaurant there was one man ordering at the counter. He had just finished as I walked up but the girl at the counter wouldn't even acknowledge I was there, just moved on to looking at the soda fountain. I also noticed she had open sores on her arm and was working with food (cutting pizza) - really gross. After about a 4 minute wait to order the cook finally came to the front and asked what I wanted. The pizza had an ok flavor but was super greasy. Additionally my order was to go - instead of placing in a small box or something similar, slices were placed on a paper plate, stuffed in a paper bag, and stapled shut. Not sure if this is supposed to be a cost savings measure but sure looks terrible and cheap. Between the terrible service and the mediocre food I won't be returning to or recommending this place in the future. read more

I really like Tony's pizza. It's the thin, NY style pizza. Very good. They have very good subs, salads, pasta dishes and wings. The cheesesteak sub is very good. They have great specials daily. read more

I used to like this place but it has poor customer service. The female cashiers like to name call customers and that is just rude and very inappropriate. This is my first hand experience and why I do not buy here anymore, also wouldn't recommend them. Ps: had to put a 1 star because it doesn't let me share without it but if I could it would be 0 stars. read more

we walked in and ordered two large drinks, they were not busy so it should've been an easy in and out experience. But after we ordered, we stood off to the side of the counter to wait for our drinks. After 5 minutes had gone by, the girl working the register looked at the both of us like we had five heads. Another 5 minutes went by and she said "are you guys going to order or what?" With a very snappy tone. We told her that we were waiting on our drinks and she huffed and puffed and rolled her eyes before she got her drinks. do better. read more

Even for a Saturday, I'm surprised delivery was received 1 hr15 min. After placing order for 1.2 miles away and regular cheese pizza. Pizza tasted good although barely warm. Usually less than 45 minutes waiting time. read more

Didn't like it. The staff was unkempt and rude, barely acknowledging our presence beyond the bare minimum to take our order. The pizza was mediocre, better than frozen, but that's about it. Tip to the owner: Better hiring practices will serve you well. read more

I lived in the shadows of NYC for a year, worked in the city, and I found maybe ONE pizza shop that was as good as this spot. Perfect NY style slices, TONS of topping varieties. The meatball and sausage was perfect. Prices are very good too. I did the lunch special and added toppings on to it. Staff was super friendly. Only "negative" was no Mello Yello on tap despite having Coke products but they had it + orange Fanta in the bottle. read more

Best pizza around! Ample seating both inside and out. Food for my family took around 20-25 minutes and everything was delivered when it should be. Appetizers first, then later our meal. We even had them come to our table and ask us how things were and refilled our drinks. Do they all look like they work Olive Garden? No. can delivery times sometimes take awhile? Yes. When you order they typically tell you the amount of time to expect. If that is too long for you to wait order someplace else. The other place may be quicker but it won't have the taste of here. My biggest downside for the place is the bathrooms. Tiny bathroom with one toilet and a sink. Barely room to turn around. Impossible to take in a child needing assistance or changing. read more

The name is catchy, but doesnt live up to NY pizza. If you live in the northeast you know a name is just a name.... like here. We had a buffalo chicken pizza and an order of fried chicken. Buffalo chicken was heavy and saturated in hot sauce. Fried chicken was dry and over cooked (even the dark meat). Delivery was quick and food temperature was good but thats about the highlight of the meal. read more

We ordered mozzarella sticks, stromboli and pizza. The restaurant seating was very uncomfortable so we took the food to go. We were very disappointed; everything was very bland without flavor. We do not intend to return. read more

I've had the pizza here in the past...not bad but nothing to write home about. I stopped in another time for coffee and dessert while I was in Greencastle and was extremely disappointed. I ordered a cappuccino and tiramisu. My fiancé ordered a latte and cheesecake. We ordered everything for dine in and sat down at a booth. The drinks came out in styrofoam cups and both were absolutely terrible. I could only bear a couple sips of my cappuccino and threw the rest away. The tiramisu was a joke; unappealing consistency, tasted like cheap ingredients, and very doubtful It was homemade. The cheesecake was very dry and stale tasting, even if It was fresh, I don't think It would have been great...ok tasting maybe, but not what I'd expect from an Italian restaurant. I would have gotten better tasting drinks and treats at a hot dog stand then tony's. I seriously hope management can improve their coffee and dessert selections and presentations, or stop advertising It on their sign out front (that's what drew me in). What a complete embarrassment to the Italians to serve garbage like what I got. read more

Has to be the worlds smallest sub. For the same price I could have gone anywhere and had a better sub and probably x3 to x4 larger. Total rip off. read more

Tony's New York Pizza - $8.00 - Pizza Near Me - Greencastle, Pennsylvania

My favorite wings in town. The employees are nice other than one guy in the back he's a bit high strung. But they make it up with the food. Every time I've seen him they've been busy so it's understandable. Never been disappointed in here. read more

Good food if you have a lot of time on your hands. The service is ok, but it takes entirely too long to get your food. On more than one occasion, it took more than 45 minutes to get our food. Is it worth it??? Not really. The food is good, but not worth the extremely long wait. read more

The staff suck at this place. They get stressed and are rude to one another AND to the customer. Food is okay, but Tonys customer service is some of the worst I have ever experienced. Will not go back. read more

they were rude and almost forgot our drinks within 5 minutes and they were mean by stating "are you gonna order or what?"

Good pizza, thin crust and crispy. We had a plain cheese medium. Ate outside. Service was good.

Pizza is hit or miss. Sometimes it is cooked perfect and other times it's still raw and the dough is chewy. They also continue to use styrofoam containers where the hot oil of fries or sticks melts right through. So all you taste is cheap styrofoam. Use tinfoil or something. I'm leaning more towards brother's pizza right now read more

We have ordered from here before, and we've gotten home from picking it up to find that they've forgotten something. This time we called to ask for a refund for the item. Well, you would have thought we had asked for the moon! It was a $4 piece of cake that they forgot. First the girl who answered the phone seemed clueless. She put a manager on (after telling him our call was about *change*, not *cake*) who said they couldn't give refunds for online orders. This seemed ridiculous, so I asked for the general manager. I was given over to the owner Tony. First, he repeats the line that they can't do refunds on online orders. Then my husband talked to him and Tony proceeded to talk over, yell at, and ignore my husband. He actually told us that it was my husband's fault that our order was wrong! I called Menu Drive, the service that they use to do online orders, and Menu Drive confirmed that Tony's has the ability to do refunds for their online orders. Tony finally agreed to mail us a check back for the amount they stiffed us for. We'll see if it happens. Considering Tony's behavior and attitude when we spoke with him, I don't hold out much hope. It's a shame - some of their food was fairly decent, but we won't be going back there again. read more

I want to preface this with I am a California girl. So I am used to CA pizza. That said, I love this place and we come here every time we come to Greencastle to see family. We pretty much always get the lunch special and there is just something magical to me about the pizza. It is just right -- not too greasy or saucy or dry or.... anything. It is just plain delish! read more

Good pizza and subs. They always do a good job with pizza and subs. Sometimes the subs are lacking with the meat. Could use a little more meat and better quality of meat in the subs. But still good. The pizza is always awesome. Can't go wrong if you order their pizza. read more

We stopped here while traveling through town for a quick dinner. We ordered a large mushroom pizza. Service was fine, but the pizza was just ok. The crust was too thick and crisp/hard for my liking. Sauce, cheese and mushrooms were ok - standard pizza place toppings, nothing special. It was a hot day, and the air conditioning was struggling. read more

Never disappoints, pretty solid pizza and wings. Recommend getting it well done due to really thin crust.

Decent size menu but we chose to stick with the pizza. We ordered at the counter a white pizza which was way over priced and very small and took forever to make it to the table. It was extremely quiet and its a very cold decor. It echoed in there. Their sodas were expensive also. Husband will not go back, it was just a large disappointment. read more

Some of the best pizza around. Staff is always friendly and the food is hot. Price isn't too bad either. One of our favorite pizza restaurants. read more

Tryed them out for the first time yesterday first of all they are very pricey 10.00 for a bland steak and cheese hogie. The restaurant setup leaves a lot to be desired. Employees running around like chickens with their heads cut off. As far as the food goes it was so bland my steak and cheese tasted like it was missing something. I will give Tonys a 3/5 rating not good not horrible would i come back anytime soon probably not. read more

The calzone I ordered came out So good! I love the sauce they make a swell. Staff was friendly and they are opened a bit later then the norm :)) read more

My partner and I just left Tony's Pizza, a place we order from around once a week. We ordered two CHICKEN cheese steaks at the counter to dine in. The young man behind the counter brought us two regular cheesesteaks. I requested they make me a chicken cheesesteak as that is what I ordered but my partner reluctantly kept the beef so as to not waste food, not be too hard on the cook, and not cost the establishment we frequent often more money. The boss (I'm assuming the manager, dark hair in a blue shirt) insisted on checking the cameras and afterward came out front to announce that he can, in fact, hear us say "CHICKEN" and only then apologized for messing up our order. Slightly offended by the sequence of actions, we requested that the one regular cheesesteak be comped as we did not order it and he only kept it as a consideration to the employees. We were told he could not comp a half eaten cheese steak whether we ordered it or not and if we didn't want it we should have sent it back. He went back around the counter and proceeded to talk to his employees about how ridiculous of a request that was so loudly that we could hear him in the dining area. Extremely unprofessional, not good business practices, and I'm pretty bummed we will have to find another go-to place. read more

Top shelf pizza....probably some of the best I've had in the area. On the other hand. The absolute worst Calamari I've ever attempted to choke down. Tasted like it was cooked in last week's onion ring grease. Stick with the pizza and you'll be pleased! read more

Huge fan of this place. Very extensive menu, reasonable priced too. The pizza tastes like New York style pizza and the dinners are very filling. Had the baked ziti dinner and tastes homemade. A+ Tony read more

Very good freshly made pizza. Very busy on weekends but mostly great food for a reasonable price.

Tony's is always the "go to" for pizza in Greencastle. Great pizza and other italian specialties but I'd steer clear from the things like french fries and wings. It's a pizza shop so stick to the basics and you won't be disappointed read more

Tony's mussels are the best.. phenomenal. I get them every Sunday, and if I am out of town, I go through withdraw..and sloth man under me... where are you eating pizza ? On another planet? I have never had any other cheesy greatness that has touched my tastes buds that amazing. You can take your yelp review to Hogwarts and make it disappear. read more

In the past, my wife and I would frequent Tony's because we liked to sit on their porch on nice days. The other day, we walked in and immediately turned around and walked out when NONE of the employees, including those preparing the food, were wearing masks. They also were not utilizing their outdoor space. If they are not going to take measures to show they care about me as their customer, then I am no longer going to provide them with my business. My trust in them to prepare my food safely has been broken, and so even after pandemic, we will not be returning. Sad to see that in a time when good family owned businesses are going out of business due to no fault of their own, this family owned business is not doing their part to promote good practices in their industry. Instead, we went to Hardee's next door. Fully masked employees, socially distanced tables and plexiglass barriers. read more

Best pizza and cheese steaks I've ever had. Been coming here since I was a little girl, and it's still exactly the same ( in a good way).