Just left with friends and not happy with the experience. Per our waitress the menu recently…read morechanged. I understand the need to change things up, but the menu offerings were not what we were looking forward to. Limited about of hand held offerings as well menu didn't lists sides clearly. Food was not as good as what we look forward to.

Incredible restaurant! The muscles were amazing, and the Indian food here was absolutely to die…read morefor. They had live music, the server Lauren was very kind and we will be here again.

Good local pub to get a beer and specialty pizza after work. The bar area has plenty of seats and…read moretv's .

Very good wings! We came here because of the wing reviews and are sure glad we did. The kitchen…read morestaff really gets into their late 90's and early 2000 music singing and having a good time cooking our great tasting food! First time here but will definitely be back. Highly recommend!

Really enjoyed everything about this place! We were visiting Gettysburg for a sporting event and…read morewanted something near the center of town. The atmosphere inside is unique and cozy. The service was fantastic. The food and drink were excellent. We will be back!

Would I eat here again or recommend it? Sure, but it def wouldn't be my 1st suggestion in…read moreGettysburg. Waitress and staff was very friendly and the building is old historic, pre-civil war years so that's super cool. Food is decent.

I highly recommend!!! Great food, great atmosphere and service…read more. I had my first date at Benny's July 13th of last year. Thanks for the great time. We are still together.

This establishment is in under new ownership. It is now called Hub Pub. Yesterday I ordered the…read morehomemade soup by Nikki, loaded potato, I can honestly say the texture was perfect. The taste was great and I had several people around me order it after I did. Kudos to you Nikki for you exemplary service.

What a wonderful Irish pub ambience! Lisa was a sweet down to earth host. She shared the…read morerestaurant regularly updates the menu. And, the food was absolutely delicious and portion was very generous.

Cozy, comfortable spot in the lower level. We shared the mussels. She had the Reuben and I road…read moretested the Dubliner. Both tasty. Nice staff. One less star for the $20 glass of domestic cab. Would return.

So last time I checked the year was 2022 and smoking was not allowed in bars, restaurants, etc…read more however, I think I time warped to 2007 when we were all ignorant fools who didn't realize that smoking caused cancer because everywhere I looked there was a person with a cigarette in their mouth. Hey at least my two beers only cost $7.50.

Drove 100 miles & payed for hotel room ( conveniently across the street from Pappy's ) to see…read moreWalker Road ( fucking AWESOME local band playing last night ... HIGHLY HIGHLY recommend ) and was totally surprised at what an awesome bar this is !!! From the totally professional and extremely friendly staff to the cleanliness of this place to the not weak and not overpriced drinks I was % 100 impressed !I you ever go to a place for the first time you instantly know your going to be a customer for life ? This is one of those places ! Enjoy !

Great staff, good drinks, amazing prices. Great local business for the downtown area.read more

Out of towners and looking for a cool dive bar. Read some great reviews so we stopped by! Not open…read moreat 11pm on a Friday night. Why?

The food was like a four stars the service was really nice…read more And there was no amenities

The food was excellent. I had the vegetarian chilli. Would have again. I asked without the…read morejalapeños. Our table had the pulled pork and chicken marsala with mashed red potatoes. We had a side salad. I loved the chicken and mashed potatoes. Dessert looked fantastic but I had leftovers and no room for dessert. Our server, Sara B Goode, was excellent from start to finish. Great service and fantastic personality. We also liked the decor and atmosphere. We had a corner table by the window. We will be back. Next time I hope to split dessert.

The food was great, the service was good, the prices weren't my favorite, but pretty reasonable for…read morethe area.

Ordered 4 days in advance. 10 Butter old bay and 10 garlic Parm. Normal crowd, fat little man…read moresitting at the end of the bar pretending to be the GM of the place and a dozen running around waiting on their SSI checks, selling an occasional rock to compensate their own addiction. Food use to be great. Gave the bartender $40. She gave me a $20 back, went got change gave me back a fist full of 1's. Took the $20 backgave me the wings. Left a generous tip. I knew something was wrong, but I looked at the crowd and decided my life was worth more than a discrepancy over a 20. Got home, 5 wings of each flavor. COLD AS A BONE. CHEWEY AS BUBBLEGUM. I can't explain my disappointment in the place. "The Cottage" is now a dive. Wings were to die for. Now, half the size they were and atmosphere is questionable. $40 for half an order of 10 wings, but I got away with my life. You lost a good customer.