I'm a foodie from Boston & I really don't like to "food review" pizza because I'm NOT Dave Portnoy, but I have great taste buds so here goes: Tony's NY Pizza is amazingly delicious! I ate a slice of Meatlover's thin crust pizza on a full stomach & loved every bite! Near perfect pizza (I wanted to try a 2nd type but I was stuffed, huge pieces)! The atmosphere is great & the service is good & pretty fast. It's cafeteria style so no tipping "necessary". I think they did an awesome job so in went the "bill". If I lived in Manassas, this would be my "go to" pizza spot! read more

I wanted to share a quick story about the incredible kindness and inclusivity we experienced here recently. Going out to eat can sometimes be overwhelming for individuals with special needs. During a recent visit, my son became highly dysregulated while we were waiting. Instead of looking away or rushing us, the amazing staff completely stepped up to help. They immediately jumped into action to support him by: Offering quick food alternatives to help ease the wait time. Bringing out fresh pizza dough to use as a brilliant, hands-on sensory tool to help him calm down and ground himself. Seeing a local business not just accommodate, but truly understand and lean into sensory and special needs with such quick thinking and compassion means the world to our family. If you want to support a local business that genuinely cares about every single customer who walks through their door, please give them your business. They have earned our loyalty for life! read more

So I ordered food from Tony's in Oakton this evening, and I have to say that unfortunately it was not very good. This came as a surprise as the last time I ordered from them several months ago I had a much better experience. It looks like the quality has dropped in that time and I'll go into the details below. The order consisted of a chicken caesar salad, a 16" Tony's Special pizza and a Meat Lovers calzone. The salad was really not great. They are apparently now using croutons from a bag instead of making their own and the chicken was both underseasoned and overcooked. I'm not certain, but they may have changed the dressing as well, as it was not very good. Lastly, the garlic bread was stale. The pizza was also underwhelming - the crust had the consistency of something that you would get from a frozen pizza, bland and dry, similar to a cracker. The toppings were OK, and the sauce was fine, but a New York pizza has to have a quality crust, and this wasn't it. The calzone was fine - it was actually the best thing from the order. I don't know if this is a problem all the time or if I just had a singular bad experience, but it seems like they are trying to cut costs, at least with regard to the salad. I don't know if I will return, which is a shame as the people working there are very nice and the service in the past was always good. If I do, I'll update this review. read more

Located in the Twinbrooke Shopping Center, I love that Tony's Pizza offers pizza by the slice, making it easy to grab something quick. When you walk in, you're greeted by the friendly staff behind the counter and a display of nearly 20 different pies to choose from, which makes deciding a bit of a challenge--in a good way. Plenty of seating and a tv mounted on the wall. My top pick is the Pepperoni Bacon Focaccia pizza. The focaccia base is light and airy, and it's generously loaded with cheese, making each bite rich and satisfying. Will definitely be back to try other slices in the future. read more

See all

This is a super cool local pizza place! It's new to Twinbrooke. Very friendly service and spacious seating atmosphere and nice environment/ambiance. We ordered a slice of cheese and buffalo pizzas. As well as the garlic bread pizza. The cheese and garlic bread were FANTASTIC!!! Super crispy and toasty. Served with delicious hot marinara sauce. The buffalo was good... but some of the chicken in it was chewy and questionable. Overall a great place especially for pizza by the slice! read more

See all

Overpriced for soggy pizza. We ordered two larges for takeout, ate it when it was still piping hot, yet the toppings and cheese would not stay on the crust. I don't mind a floppy pizza, but not when everything is falling apart and the crust is soggy. Their Fair Lakes location is great, so this was disappointing. I do not recommend. read more

See all

This was my first visit to Tony's latest location in the Twinbrooks strip mall. The location is brand new and very clean, with a good number of seats for dining in. The staff were friendly and helpful. I had the chicken parm sub, which lived up to my high expectations from Tony's other locations. I didn't try them during this visit, but they had a very large selection of different pizza by the slice. I'm very happy to have this location open up close to my house. read more

Tony's NY Pizza - Vibe - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

See all

As a former New Yorker, pizza is a serious matter to me. This is the most authentic NYC-style pizza that I've had outside of Manhattan. I highly recommend! read more

Our neighborhood pizza place! Love single slice option. Like the pasta and calzones. Surprisingly a lot of seating in front and back. Glad it's here and hopefully to stay a long time! read more

See all

3.5 stars! Was happy to find a non-national chain pizza place near home. I had a half margherita/margherita special pizza. Great friendly service, it seems like a casual family owned spot. The pizza was pretty good. I always order margheritas the first time at a new pizza place to gauge the quality. Can't say this is the best pizza I've ever had but it is truly a solid option in NOVA. I will be back the next time I have a NY style pizza craving...which is pretty often. read more

Really good pizza - they have lots of different toppings so don't hesitate to ask for recommendations. Shout out to Patrick for the amazing hospitality every time! read more

There are several pizza tiers in the Nova area. In my opinion, Andy's Pizza and Frank Pepe's are the top two. Tony's is in the second tier with the likes of Mama Lucia's in Fair City Mall: rock solid. This is another new great addition to the Twinbrook shopping center. They do slices and have lots of options -- including a small bar area -- although we went with a couple of made to order pizzas. Both were very good as they really filled the meat lovers. We also ordered wings which may have been the crispiest I've ever had. Overall, we're really excited to have this place in Twinbrook and will definitely be back. read more

Tony's NY Pizza - Wings - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

See all

Pizza was good, we got a Tony's special and it was above average for this area, toppings were good and the extra sauce we asked for was in a small container on the side. We ordered for take out and it was ready on time. Restaurant was clean, bright and nice, it was a brutally cold night and there were several people eating there. The staff was very friendly and accommodating, overall a very good first impression of this relatively new place. We will be back. read more

2 stars for nice staff but this is the second strike for Tony's. The first strike was a pizza with the wrong topping combinatio, which they remade but I still had to drive back (20 mins) to pick it up. Strike two was an Italian sausage sub. I got no links of sausage, they use shredded meat that made the sandwich look like a really small cheese steak. I'd be really surprised if it had more than 3oz of meat, which was pretty tasteless under all that rubbery cheese. Not close to any thing I've gotten in NY. read more

Outstanding pizza- Tony's Special is! Friendly staff, consistently good pizza, perfect crusts.

This is not good pizza. I had been waiting to try it because it was so hyped. The crust is like cardboard. I would say the sauce is good - but that's the only thing good about it. So many people love this pizza but I am not a fan. read more

Definitely a solid NY Style pizza and possibly even better than the Fairlakes location. Only thing is my jaw got a workout chewing the bread. Not sure if the dough sat too long or if the mixture was off but otherwise, the flavor and temperature was great. Spaghetti with marina was decent. I called an ordered over the phone and told 30-40 minutes. Walked in at the 40 minute mark and walked out 3 minutes later with my order. Much smoother than opening week. Inside was not as big as the Fairlakes location but definitely comfortable to dine in. Give it a shot. read more

Tony's NY Pizza - Outside entrance - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

I love Tony's New York Style pizza. My only regret is I can only eat two large pieces before I'm full. It has the ambiance of a typical neighborhood pizza place ... nothing spectacular but clean with a friendly staff. As a single person, I really like that you can order by the piece. You order your pizza at the counter (15-20 different options). They reheat it and deliver it hot and cheesy to your table. Beer and wine are also available. I've been going to the FairOaks location for over 15 years. This was my first visit to this location. I was not disappointed ... great pizza in a friendly atmosphere. I'll be back. read more

The pizza is authentic. Subs and pasta dishes are excellent. For us, it is more of a takeout place. Great service at the takeout counter!

For over 20 years I have been going to the different "Tony's NY pizza" locations in Northern Virginia. The mostly new staff were accommodating but need additional training on menu items. Didn't know that Entrees came with bread and salad. We sent the Lasagne back - it had no flavor. Just plain ground beef with bland tomato sauce. The Chicken Marsala: Chicken was tender, however it was all cutup mixed in with the fettuccine and had parmesan cheese on top. The taste of Marsala was very faint. The pizza: toppings were fine but the taste of the dough was like cardboard. Had never experienced that at other locations. Sfogliatella was fine as at other locations. read more

Amazing pizza!!! And you can get it by the slice!!! Cheeks fleek McHugh retro haik if there's your 85 characters. It discourages people from the review. Nice job Yelp executive morons read more

Great place highly recommend great pizza. Sausage roll was excellent. Customer service was great. read more

Tony's NY Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

See all

Really good pizza, the Sicilian slices are really good too! Highly recommend for some of the best pizza in NoVa

Delicious. Very friendly and helpful staff members. Clean premises. I am required to enter a verbose comment - everything was amazing. Wonderful. Best dining experience. read more

$8 pizza with tip. Waited over 20 minutes, size of the pizza shown in picture. Not going back ever. read more

Tony's NY Pizza - $8 pizza, waited 20 minutes for it and size.....never going back - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

ordered two slices and a calzone, counter person removed calzone from oven and threw it in microwave to heat up calzone to temp . Asked staff member why he microwaved food. Fresh quality cooking does not align with microwaving food for service , let alone pizza and calzones. will not return. read more

Great selection of good pizza by the slice. Clean seating area and good service. Crust is good and crispy.

Tony's NY Pizza is simply THE BEST NY PIZZA IN VIRGINIA!!! My father is from Queens and Tony's is the only place he will eat. I am so excited for their new Twinbrook location closer to their home. Tony's is an easy 10 stars! read more

Ok, I went to Tony's NY Pizza at Twinbrooke. The pizza was phenomenal! An unwritten pizza rule is to always get cheese (no toppings) at a place that makes really good NY style pizza so that you can better taste the signature sauce and crust. Notice how nice and orange the cheese piece looks. That's what you want: a perfect mixture of sauce and cheese. I ordered it well done which made it super crispy on the bottom and perfect (not burnt) on the top. This will be my new go-to in an area (Burke) that is in desperate need of good places to eat. read more

Tony's NY Pizza - Cheese and Margherita slices. - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

See all

We really really want to like Tony's and we're super excited to have one open down the street in twin brook. But the three times we have ordered from this location it's been experience has been the worst. They never have our order ready and just give a lot excuses " we lost your order" "we dropped your pizza and need make a new one" and last night my wife waited for over an hour for our food and it pretty ruined the start of our Halloween. Sadly we don't think we will ever return. read more

A NOVA staple! One of the best and one of my go-tos. Food is amazing and you can even buy dough if you want to make the pizza at home! Quick service. Feels like a ny pizza shop in the suburbs. Love it. read more

So add 4 more pieces to this and that's what u get . For 10 bucks . After being on hold with Tony's for 10 minute as soon as i got home . I was offered $5 off my next Tony's pizza order. Seriously? Am I supposed to share this appetizer or no? I'm disappointed to say the least. read more

Tony's NY Pizza - $10.00 Zucchini sticks - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

We just love Tony's Pizza. Always an incredibly fascinating smorgasbord of pizza choices to pick from to satisfy most anyone, and then there's the delectable deserts. The atmosphere is comfortably upscale and relaxing, and then there's the cozy, warm and inviting tables and chairs topped with nice lighting for dine out eating outside their door. The service is always professional and the customer service is top notch. read more

their pizza isn't great, i think the sauce is too sweet or something. their subs are okay. the customer service sucks. they are disorganized. they didnt tell me my food was ready and it sat for like 15 minutes until i finally asked. read more

The Sicilian Veggie pizza was inedible. The crust was so overdone and hard that we had to throw it out. We had it once before and it was good. Called to tell them so they could evaluate and fix. The women said too bad and did not care. Embarrassing as we had guests. read more

We thought the thin crust pizza was amazing. Tasted just like New York pizza. The sauce was perfect, not too sweet or spicy. We'll be back for sure! read more

Perfection! The food, wine and service were fantastic and Lorenzo is a great host. He helped us select wine, and made sure we enjoyed our meals. This by far the best gluten free pizza! Looking forward to another great meal at Tony's NY Pizza. read more

We called in our order at 5:00 and were told it would be ready at 5:30. We arrived on time. When we traveled the 1 mile to our house, our pizzas were barely lukewarm, the pasta was cold, and the "hot" Italian sub had never touched any kind of heat yet had been placed in a specialized container to keep it "warm". When I returned the next day to report the poor service I was told there was no manager there to talk to. I tried the following day as was told the manager was in a meeting. I left my name and number and was assured I would get a call. No call but I got the message loud and clear. WE REALLY DON'T CARE. read more

Good pizza in a rather stark, fast food establishment. The Puzza is definitely worth it, especially since it is so fairly priced.

Got a slice of white pizza and a slice of plain. Both were excellent. This is the best NY style pizza in NOVA.