My partner and I were in the area and looking for something quick to eat. The choice was between here and the bagel shop next door, and the scent was just so much more enticing here. They have tons of pizza options, but we opted for their hot oven specialties, specifically their Meat Calzone (pepperoni, sausage, and cheese) and their Rustica (ham, salami, sausage, cheese, eggs, spinach, and broccoli). Note that they do charge a 3% credit card fee, so I would recommend either paying cash or a credit card that has 5% for dining. This is in a shopping center of a much larger shopping area, so there was plenty of parking. We opted to dine in and there was plenty of seating as well - booth and tables. You get a number and can grab drinks, condiments, seasonings, and utensils. The bathroom was decent and everything overall was clean. Once they dropped off our food, my partner and I dug in. Both came with marinara dipping sauce, although I felt like the Rustica could have been better paired with a white sauce. Regardless both tasted good and were filling. I was surprised by the Rustica as it seemed like the love child of a calzone and a pizza - pizza shape with calzone crust. With the ingredients, it reminded me more of a quiche. I liked how much more balanced it was - nice mix of protein and vegetables.and wouldn't mind coming back to try more of their menu. read more

Tonys NY Pizza - Meat Calzone and Rustica - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

Tony's pizza in fair lakes has changed their steak and cheese to a much lesser sub. Hardly any steak and the rolls have also changed. Very disappointing to hear this is not the only place that is doing this. Less meat and more money. read more

Tony's has a broad menu with so many delicious pizza and sub options! It is a little pricey but still affordable. The service is ok - but my sandwich took 20 minutes to come out... the tasty grilled chicken sub made it worth it though. The melty cheese with the banana peppers on the soft toasted bread paired perfectly with the chicken. Any pizza you get here will be worth it and so good. Nice ambiance that reminds me of a New York pizza diner. read more

Tonys NY Pizza - Soda Counter - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

See all

Several staff greeted us as soon as we walked in the door. Very friendly and helpful! We had the: Pepperoni Pizza with Banana Peppers on one half. It's delicious and perfectly cooked. Lasagna with Garden Salad with House Italian Dressing and Garlic Bread. The Lasagna is flavorful with the right amounts of noodles, cheese and meat sauce. It's also a good serving size, especially, since it comes with the side salad and bread. The Owner remembers us and stopped by the table to ask how we are doing and if we are happy with everything. He is always very nice and checks on his guests! The restaurant is always very clean. read more

See all

Went to grab a late night snack/dinner. This is the one spot our family always go to. It is near the house and it could be a quick stop. Service was great, once you order, you get a number and the pizza will be brought to the table if you dine in. Besides pizza, they also have other things on the menu but we come here for pizza. We get the supreme pizza and margherita pizza. Food comes out fairly quick and everything tasted so good, crust is not too thick and it is crispy. It id not too big so usually 2 slices would be ideal for a normal meal. They are most likely will be busy on the weekends and at night time so come accordingly. They have tables and booths. read more

Tonys NY Pizza - Supreme Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

Amazing NY style pizza! The pizza crust was some of the best - crispy and thin, and not soggy at all. The toppings held on nicely, too. The white Hawaiian was great, and I will definitely try their other slices. Service was quick and the ambiance was easy-going and casual. I will be returning! read more

Tonys NY Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

See all

Tony's NY pizza is exactly as advertised, and it hits the spot when you're craving that easy New York slice. The Greek salad was fresh and generously covered in red onions, while the veggie calzone had sooo much cheese. Not as many veggies as I would have liked but still a good experience. The staff behind the counter was lovely and helpful. The restaurant was a little cold from folks coming and going, but the booths were comfortable for our party size. read more

Tonys NY Pizza - Veggie calzone - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

See all

Great food, service was outstanding and the atmosphere was fantastic. I highly recommend this place for everyone who loves pizza and subs. read more

See all

Came here after ages . Love their pizza's . Ordered two slices . Margareta pizza and Artichoke pizza . Both thin crust loved the flavor and taste . Enjoyed our lunch . read more

See all

I swear they used to have a better white pizza. The artichoke watered down the pizza and flavor. Ok better than most but it has lost its flavor and edge. read more

A wonderful spot with a lot of choices, definitely try this spot. Really clean, friendly. read more

Tonys NY Pizza - Bar of pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

My son and I visited for the first time in years earlier this week. We both had a slice of pepperoni and cheese pizza and we both gave our food a 10 out of 10. The people we met at the store were polite and professional. We'll visit more frequently in the future read more

Delicious food! Family run restaurant and my favorite pizza place ever! Pizza is amazing and the service is great too.

Went here early on a Friday night and it was hopping! We've been to other locations and this did not disappoint. The pizza is authentic NYC style and comes out hot a delicious. Also, it's still a bargain. We got 4 slices and a fountain drink to share for $22-hard to beat that these days. read more

Tonys NY Pizza - Cheese slice and Pepperoni and Sausage Slice - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

Been coming here at 11 to 11:30 for the past several months daily and they burnt a slice of pizza that was just pulled out onto the counter. Sad that they couldn't even offer me a new slice! read more

Tonys NY Pizza - Pepperoni sausage and bacon pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

Being from New Jersey, there are only 2 places I go for pie and Tony's is my first choice. They're so good that I drive from Dumfries to get it then eat it like warm by the time I get home. As close to a NY NJ pie you can get in NORVA. Perfectly baked from fresh dough. Their mootz is delicious with just enough saltiness and their toppings especially their sausage is the best. I wish they'd open in Woodbridge.....I'd get a pie a week instead of a quarter. read more

It's not bad, a bit overpriced probably.. same with their pizza, at about $ 5.00 per slice! Oh well!! read more

Tonys NY Pizza - Half sub is $ 9.00 & whole sub is $ 13.00. Half sub is between 6" to 6.5" - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

See all

Awesome Pizza! Great taste, amazing flavor, overall spectacular. Highly recommend this to anyone who enjoys Pizza.

We've been coming to Tony's for thin crust, New York style pizza for decades. At first, it was the crust and sauce: super thin and a tasty tomato basil that is not sweet. The flavors just shine. At first, we would go to eat in so the pizza was brought out hot and melty with a long mozzarella pull. Delicious! Tony's is one of the few places that still employs the local kids in the Summer and on weekends. It's a real sense of community that makes a welcoming atmosphere. But recently, we've gotten too busy to eat in, so we'd get takeout, often with a greek salad (yum!). The pizza just didn't seem to taste the same by the time we got it home, ate the salad and dug into the pizza. But we found a solution that is as good as eat-in: the website offers a half-baked pie. It's the same thin crust and sauce but now with a controllable point where it comes out of the oven. We can enjoy the salad and pop the pie in at 550 F for 3-4 mins. The pizza is just as hot and melty as with the eat in option. Excellent development. read more

If you're looking for a great pizza spot that's both family-friendly and delicious, this is the place to go! The pizza was great but the best part... it was toddler-approved! My newly 2YR old devoured TWO slices (which is not normal). The restaurant is family-owned, and you can tell they care. It was also super clean, which is a big plus for dining out. We will certainly be back! read more

Tonys NY Pizza - Specialty Slice (bacon and pineapple) - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

Decent pizza. Classic ny style was tasty & well made. Sicilian style (full pie - Tony Special) was "doughy".... I'll pass on it next read more

My husband and I got pizza and mozzarella sticks here and it was not good. The pizza tasted like it has been sitting out all day and not fresh at all. The mozzarella sticks had very little cheese in them. Very unhappy been coming here for years. We will be sticking to Ciros in the future. read more

This experience was genuinely so disappointing and frustrating. My family has ordered from Tony's many times through Grubhub and never had an issue until now. However, tonight two different things in our order were wrong, and what made it worse was how we were treated when we called to get it resolved. First, my mom ordered a stromboli. She specifically chose it because the pictures on Tony's Grubhub showed the stromboli as the usual log-shaped kind. That's what she was craving and why she ordered it. But instead she got something shaped like a crescent, basically a calzone. When we called to ask about it, the assistant manager Zach didn't even apologize. He just told us the pictures online were wrong and that they don't make strombolis like that anymore. He essentially said it wasn't their fault if the picture was outdated. That's misleading and honestly ridiculous to say that's not the restaurant's responsibility when it's their own menu and images. Then came the bigger issue. I have chronic health issues and specific dietary needs. The only thing I ever order from Tony's is the gluten free penne pasta with tomato sauce and grilled chicken. It's the only dish I know that won't trigger my symptoms. On Grubhub, there's no option to add chicken directly, so I always write "please add grilled chicken" in the special instructions box. Every other time they've either added it or called us to confirm and charge us for it. But this time, they didn't call whatsoever. They didn't try. They just taped a note to the container that said "sorry we couldn't put the chicken because Grubhub didn't charge you for it." So I ended up with just gluten free pasta and tomato sauce, which I never would've ordered by itself. When we called the restaurant to explain, Zach again blamed us. He told us we should've ordered something that already comes with chicken. He clearly didn't understand or didn't care that this is the only dish I can safely eat. He didn't offer a solution or show any concern. He even said we should've called the restaurant directly instead of using Grubhub, which makes no sense since they offer their menu through Grubhub and clearly expect people to use it. Then he cut us off by saying the restaurant was too busy and told us he was going to hang up. There was no apology. No care. Just defensiveness and blame. My mom even said directly to him that his customer service was incredibly rude and unhelpful and that we felt like we were being blamed instead of listened to. She was completely right. This wasn't just a mistake with an order. This was a business showing they do not care about their customers, and especially not customers with dietary restrictions who rely on the food being correct. I'm honestly hurt and angry because when you live with chronic illness, safe food is already limited and it's exhausting having to fight just to be taken seriously when something goes wrong. I don't think we will be ordering from here again. read more

Tonys NY Pizza - The taped note they put on my pasta order. - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

Our go to pizza spot! The pizza and wings are both very consistent. Pizza has a good undercarriage with a nice quantity of toppings. The wings are crispy and the hot sauce is spicy and good! read more

$50+ for pizza and it was cold! We ordered two pizzas to arrive at a certain time, they came 30 minutes early, and they were cold. VERY disappointed in ordering from the restaurant. What is the point of having a time schedule if you can't even get close to the requested time? With tax, delivery fee and tip, this order came to $60 and no one wanted to eat this pizza. What a waste. read more

I went here on a whim. I was pleasantly surprised! The cheese steak was the best I've had around Northern VA. The pizza reminded of back home (Connecticut). They also have a GREAT lunch special. (Photo attached) I will definitely be returning to try more of their food! read more

See all

Went to this place a few times now, used to always go to pomodoro in Fairfax town center, (they closed) ... I am so glad I found this Place it is always so nice and clean and the food and service are excellent!! Their steak and cheese is !! One of the best I have had! I love their pizza!! Love to come just by myself and order a whole pie and have the rest for the next day. The people that work there are always so attentive and very pleasant! I definitely will keep coming back! Definitely recommend read more

Tonys NY Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

See all

As a former New Yorker, you know I'm a total snob with pizza. In this area, this is the closest to NY you'll find. It is our go-to when we are craving an authentic NY style pizza with its thin crust profile and ratio of cheese/sauce. I had to deduct a star for this past visit, though. I ordered through their website and asked that it be cooked Well Done with light sauce. It's how my kids like their pizza, and they've got autism so they're super particular about texture. I've attached a photo of the "well done/light sauce" pizza, which looked 100% identical to the second one I ordered with no special requests to preparation. It really wasn't well done at all, and my kids frustratingly wouldn't even touch it. Tony's, really wish you'd look at the special prep requests from your website when you fulfill an order! read more

Tonys NY Pizza - Waiting for takeout before the big snow - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

See all

I've been a long time fan of Tony's. Their pizza never disappoints. Some people argue it's the closest thing to New York pizza. We ordered the Tony's special and margherita special pizza- both delicious. We also ordered mozzarella sticks- yum. We ordered via door dash and it showed up in 30 minutes. Will order again! read more

See all

This was ordered over the phone and picked up..... Our food was piping hot. Kudos given on the Cheesesteak subs, place in a container, not squished or soggy. Pizza was delicious as well, even reheated for left overs. Nicely done ! read more

See all

Great pizza Surprises everyone I serve it too. These guys make great pie..love the crust My favorite is the veggie read more

Love love love Tonys. Been supporting this family owned business ever since they have been open. The food is amazing from the pizzas to the subs to the pastas. You will not be disappointed with anything you order. The fresh made tomato sauce is delicious. My favorites are: white pizza, meatball sub read more

See all

Beware of their gluten-free menu! I have celiac disease and ordered the chicken parm gluten-free pizza, which sounded delicious. The chicken was breaded and fried and not gluten-free. I assumed if they're advertising that they have a gluten-free menu, they were familiar with those restrictions. I would not trust eating here as a gluten-free customer. Dealing with the management was a whole other disappointing issue. read more

Kids got their food. They were almost done eating when I felt the need to ask about my salad 15 min behind. Got my salad, but it had no dressing. Had to walk up to the counter again to ask. Felt pretty neglected and wasn't worth the dining out experience I wanted for myself eating out and not having to cook for once. Food was meh. read more

The pizza is bland no matter which one you choose. The marinara sauce is just heated up tomato with no seasoning. Anything you order will take forever to come out. Even though the place is empty and there are a lot of workers. Also over priced. Won't be back. read more

I have been coming here since 2006 and I have to say it is the BEST NY style pizza I have had in this area HANDS DOWN!! The owner, Giovani, is such a gentleman and he just makes you feel as though you are a part of his Italian family! When you are a regular, he knows you by name and always greets you with a warm and big smile! It can get quite busy on certain days, but you can always find a table. This time, we opted for takeout. Their pizza is always piping hot and SUPER DELICIOUS!! What makes it is the incredible NY style crispy delicious thin crust and the awesome tomato sauce that is NOT sweet at all, but has a nice tangy garlic flavor!! The topping are super fresh and amazingly delicious!! we ordered the margarita special and a small garden salad with grilled chicken, and they are not skimpy on the toppings whatsoever!! This is definitely a staple, and we will keep coming back for years and years to come!! The staff has always been so friendly and always go out of their way to be very accommodating to all of our needs! The restaurant is very open with lots of windows and nice views. Definitely one of our favorites for dine in or take out!! read more

Tonys NY Pizza - Wonderfully delicious margarita special pizza!! - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

See all

Im a regular. Im here on average once a week for lunch. They have excellent lunch deals.

The best pizza place in Fairfax, hands down. Everything I've ordered from here has been excellent. I've gotten all manners of pizza, steak and cheese subs, salads, mozzarella sticks, garlic bread, I've had it all! Tony's is a classic and will always be my top choice for dinner! read more

Probably no if you want it within an-hour! But the pizza is sooo yummy! So I guess I need more characters....

It may not look like much, but this pepperoni pizza slice from Tony's NY pizza in Fair Lakes was really good! The crust was the perfect balance of crunchy and chewy and the sauce was flavorful and delicious! I look forward to eating there again soon when I'm in the area! read more

Tonys NY Pizza - Pepperoni Slice - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia