Came to try the pizza so ordered grandma style and "new york style" pizzas. Service was slow and servers seem untrained. A lot of self service here where you're expected to order at the counter and find your own plates, cutlery, and water. New york style pizza is aspirational at best--false advertising at worst. Not sure what part of the thick hard crust was new york style but I wouldn't come back for it. The indoor seating is loud and you might end up having to share. read more

See all

The pizza and wings here are delicious. We ordered everything from the Ram, Patriot and the Phoenix. The crust was crispy and the dough was airy. I love how you can order Grandmas personal pizza or NYC style. You have the option of making it a cauliflower crust. There is plenty of seating for dine in customers. The ordering system was easy and I like how you can watch them make it. I loved the variety of ingredients here including ARs hot honey. Highly recommend coming here for lunch as well since they do offer some pizza by the slice options. read more

See all

The only place in town with grandma pizza! The Patriot was exceptional- sweet and spicy and the perfect size. They have a variety of menu options too, however, we always default to the grandma pizzas. Great location and ambience- delivery is quick, too! read more

The pizza here is incredible. We ordered takeout with some family in town and the service was fast and friendly. Definitely some of the best pizza we've had in the area! read more

This is becoming our go-to for cauliflower crusts. Their premade combinations work and are traditional enough to be appreciated by anyone. A sometimes inconsistent bake time for their oven can lead to over heavy char risk at times. Haven't quite figured out if that's the oven or just a time and usage issue. Their other pizza styles of dough seem popular with a lot of families and groups. So it's a continent spot that harkens back to a prior era of pizza parlor pop-through, complete with old and no-longer coin operated arcade game. Their outdoor space can be nice for downtown. read more

I ordered delivery and they don't go directly through a delivery platform so you have no idea when it will show up. Mine took over an hour. The pizza was just ok, I probably would order from Andy's or Anthony's over this restaurant. The toppings were generous but not cooked into the pizza and the pizza was a little too saucy. However the mozzarella sticks were good. read more

Good for lunchtime. We both enjoyed subs. The service was at register and table delivery.

The store is nice and was very clean. We ordered online and were able to get it at the estimated time. They were nice and quick with hand over. The pizza was very fresh and everyone was happy with how it tasted. Unfortunately no pictures because it was gone before I got one. read more

This is my 2nd visit and I can say I am going to keep on coming back for more. I tried their pizza a few weeks ago and loved it. I appreciate that they sell it by the slice. Some places you have to buy a pie. This time I decided to try their Turkey Reuben. I do have to say that it's actually a Turkey Rachel (difference being they use Coleslaw and not sauerkraut like a classic Reuben. ) It was delicious! I got a footlong, they do sell an 8 inch as well. I had leftovers and intend to eat it for dinner tomorrow. The staff are SO friendly and courteous. Cudos to them. I highly recommend this restaurant. They also accept Mason money (for those students out there) I tried to post a photo of the sandwich, but for some reason it isn't appearing. :( read more

Old Dominion Pizza - This was yummy! - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

5 stars for friendly service, clean and comfortable seating/dining, easy (free!) parking, fresh ingredients, consistent food, and speed/ease of ordering and dining. If you're looking for a quick slice, a fresh salad, or a cold beer ...this is a great pop in. Or for a sit down casual meal, it's a place that knows what it does and sticks to that. Love to see that! We stopped in for lunch between appointments, ordered off the menu and were able to comfortably order, eat, and get food packed up to go easily within our short timeframe. We got the "New York" style pizza but the Grandma style looked really good too. The slices on display had those great crispy cheese edges and the dough looked nice and puffy and light. As a New Yorker, I wouldn't call their "NY Style" pizza true NY but as a regular pizza, it was very good. The crust is too thick to be New York style, it has a thicker drier interior, with a crispy, airy crust. Didn't have that thin crust with the chewy interior like a true NY pizza BUT I was in VA, not NY so, I honestly don't expect it to be NY pizza. We loved the different sauce and customization options (had to stick to just cheese on this trip because of a picky kid) and happy to see a cauliflower crust option too. Overall very happy with our impromptu stop into this place for lunch and have it on our return list when we are back in the area! read more

See all

The pizza is so delicious! The crust is so tasty and the sauce and toppings taste so fresh! I also like to get fresh basil which is included upon request. Yum! read more

The garlic parm wings are the best! The service was great (shout out to Kaleb) and the food came out hot and fast :) The atmosphere is very welcoming and homey, I'll definitely be coming back again! read more

Nice smell of fresh pizza once inside! I like the pac man arcade inside that reminds me of when I grew up playing an arcade at a Pizza Hut. The pizza is just OK tho and not the best. I didn't try the NY style but the grandma style pizza wasn't that tasty in my opinion. The wings are pretty good. The fountain drinks are not your usual sodas, try the flavor. read more

Old Dominion Pizza - Free Pac-Man arcade! - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

See all

again, super affordable and nice people! crust was so soft but crispy i definitely enjoyed it more than last time. its right across the library so it serves as a great mid-study meal. read more

Old Dominion Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

Finally we found good pizza. We had pizza and the meatballs. So good. Delivery was prompt too!

Great pie! Got the Grandma's style for take out. Ingredients were fresh, crust was perfectly cooked, and taste of the pie was exactly what I was looking for in a Detroit-like style. Owner was very responsive to questions about ingredients too. read more

Another favorite pizza joint of mine. Lovely staff. Great location in downtown Fairfax that's enjoyable. Will be coming back!

Seemed lime a fast food pizza place...service was great, but the food was not too my liking. Thank You for the great service read more

Old Dominion Pizza - Order area... - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

Excellent experience! Pizza choices are difficult but can't go wrong- Wow the flavors are amazing!! We ordered wings & beer too, both were awesome Friendly service & they offer both inside (very clean) & outside dining! read more

Very good pizza. The gluten free options were outstanding. Highly recommend to anyone visiting the area.

Let me start with the pizza. It's average. Come in expecting average. Average pizza is still pretty damn good. Fairfax is a city deplete of pizza by the slice options. That alone gives Old Dominion an advantage. They offer both NY style and Grandma style pizza (crisp, square slices, resembling a blend of Chicago and Detroit styles). I ordered both options by the slice three times and it it has been consistently decent. Two out of three times the pizza, despite being reheated in the oven, was somewhat cold. If you have the time and appetite, ordering a full fresh pizza may be the better option. You can get a full Grandma Style pizza with cheese for only $8. On pizza alone this is a 3 star joint. But other elements of my experiences gave it a bump. Very friendly service, especially from the gentleman who I presume is the owner. A small but solid craft beer menu with all beers priced at $6. I believe I ordered Sour Monkey by Victory Brewing which is always solid (and at 9.5% abv is essentially two beers in one). It's also a nice, clean, spacious environment, something you don't always find in pizza places, especially in Fairfax. read more

Old Dominion Pizza - New York Style pizza and draft beer - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

This is one of my new favorites. While I'm going to have to do more analysis, the main thing that stands out is it's atmosphere. A lot of restaurants lack this. Here there's always something going on, whether by the oven, or out on the dining room floor. The employees are cheerful, polite, and welcoming. It seems a genuine spot. Crowds are mostly families, and although busy often, they'll get to you quick. What surprised me is how good "Grandmas Style" is. Absolutely delicious. Love their ingredients. There's no cutting corners, and prices are within reason. These thick pizzas with fresh toppings, and a cold draft beer hit the "proverbial happy zone." Will be back again soon, as tonight's grandma pizza was another tasty meal. read more

Old Dominion Pizza - a brick sidewalk with tables and umbrellas - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

See all

It's my first time trying their pizza and it is SO DELICIOUS! I love the deep dish pizza, and I added chili pepper, and it had the perfect amount of spice with meat and veggies! YUM! read more

My sister and I are pizza freaks! Normally, we do not like deep dish pizza, but instead of Old Dominion thin crust, we ordered the deep dish grandma style. We were blown away! Everything from the crust to the toppings to the flavor to the homemade sauce were on point.Taylor, our server was so nice and helpful. She suggested the roasted mushrooms and man they were delicious. We will definitely be back. Uh read more

This is our go-to place on pizza night! We love their pizza from the gluten free cauliflower crust to the grandma pizza...the pizza is great! We've also tried their wings, meatballs (also gluten free), and their steak & cheese which have all been good. We usually get take out, but have eaten there plenty of times and they have outstanding and friendly service over all. The restaurant itself feels like a fun & cozy neighborhood pizza joint! We love Old Dominion! read more

Came on a Friday night around 6PM expecting it to be busier, the restaurant was in actuality pretty busy but the counter staff were very attentive to clean and turn over tables, opted to sit at the "bar" counter area, a pretty nice setup for people watching The pizza on the scale of 1-10 (10 THE BEST PIZZA I HAD/ 1 call the police I've been robbed) 6/10 slightly above average Ordered The Patriot The wings are the reason I'm going to come back. They are the best wings in the area that I had in recent memory Ordered the Garlic Parmesan and Buffalo wings Overall will be in my family's rotation for dinner out PS There is a Pac-Man machine on free play with was nice read more

Old Dominion Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

Everyone has been saying we have to try ODP, so we finally picked some up. I now know why! This is some delicious pizza! I got the grandma style "the General" and cauliflower "the Knight". Both were great! ODP gives back to the community too and participates in fundraisers, which is excellent for the community. Service was fast and friendly too. Thanks for doing a military discount, you are good Americans. See you all again soon! read more

Very friendly staff and a cool throwback Pac Man machine! I loved that while I waited. The pizza was not very good. Sauce tasted like it was out of can. I ordered one slice each of pepperoni, cheese and green pepper, onion and mushroom. Again, not terrible, just not very good. Thanks for the friendly service and nice welcome. read more

We have been going to Old Dominion Pizza in Fairfax for over a year and have always enjoyed their fresh pizza, salads, and sandwiches. Today we were very disappointed to have ordered a cheese pizza NY style and it had the taste (and look) of Papa John's. Absolutely no taste in the tomato sauce. The cesar salad sauce was bland and just about one tablespoon to cover all the romaine lettuces. Needless to say and unfortunately, this will be our last visit. For the same price, Andy's pizza in Fairfax is much better. Sorry to all the locals that like Old Dominion but I grew up in NYC and if this restaurant was located there it would have a closed in less than a year. For the new folks wanting to try Old Dominion, please enter with caution. read more

Been here twice now and gotta say they have some great pizza. We didnt get too creative, just had the pepperoni and margherita pizzas. Will def be back. read more

I tried DoorDashing from them. When you order, it is a merchant-filled order. This means that if they mess up, you want to cancel, or want a refund, you have to go through them and not DoorDash. DoorDash just sets it up. They said they would have it delivered in a half hour, I didn't get it for 1.5 hours and it was not great enough to be worth the wait and frustration. read more

Discovered Old Dominion by chance. Went on a weekend evening near close and order two slices heated up. The pizza was OK - I would definitely stop by again if I was in the area. The staff were fantastic and super nice. It was late but they still took good care of us and we're very upbeat. It was pretty quiet (no loud music) which made it nice to eat and have a conversation. Definitely recommend giving it a try. There's also parking in a lot that's in the same building as the restaurant read more

See all

Grandma pizza is the best! We had the ram grandma style with homey ricotta-sweet but delish! Friends ordered the General grandma style (pictured) also delish. Great arancini balls and salad too. read more

Old Dominion Pizza - The General - only thing left to photo! - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

We came in for the restaurant week specials and had a great experience. We received plenty of food with leftovers and got to sit outside on the patio. It was a little bit confusing to find from the parking area, but we had a great time! We got salad, pizza, and wings and all were great. read more

The cavalier's garlic parmesan sauce could make me shed a tear. Pizza came out hot and fresh. A great pie!

Soft and crunchy pizza, service was fast, nice cozy spot to get a slice or get the whole pie not gonna break the bank. read more

Old Dominion Pizza - The saint - Pizza Near Me - Fairfax, Virginia

Service was quick and I was able to get a free cup of water bc of their Fountain service was out of order

Grandma's pizza is terrific -- with a balanced crunch and chewiness in the crust. The steak and cheese was very good too! Go try it!!

The food is awesome the staff is great there job the mangers are amazing good job Maggie and everyone.

So excited to have this gem close by! We have heard great things about this new pizza place and decided to give it a try tonight. It did not disappoint!! We ordered The Ram, The Phoenix, and plain cheese (for the kids) all NY style. We will be going back again soon to try more. The three we ordered were all phenomenal, can't wait to eat the leftovers! The service was most excellent. They saw my husband and I struggling with our kids and accommodated us in every way possible, including helping us move tables after we decided to sit outside. The have rotating draft beers for a reasonable price and bottles/can from mostly local breweries. They also have unique soda options and serve yourself water. Lastly, our family got a chocolate chip cookie and I'm not exaggerating, it was the best cookie I think I've ever had. Do not go there without trying one! Highly recommend this place! read more

See all