I pass this place multiple times a week and finally stopped for a slice of pepperoni pie. It was placed in the oven to be warmed and came out relatively quickly. The slice was hot and delicious. I want to come back and try more options because their menu was huge and had tons of yummy looking food. read more

Tony Pepperoni - Pepperoni slice - Pizza Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

I will never return here. The first time we came, the whole experience felt off. We practically had to beg someone to take our order, the staff was weird and rude, and the music was so loud we couldn't even hear each other. We decided to give them a second chance what a waste. We ordered ONE pizza and were told it would be ready in 30 minutes. We showed up after 30 minutes and then had to wait ANOTHER 30 minutes for it. And once again, the staff was rude. Two chances, two bad experiences. There definitely won't be a third. read more

Food is awesome, coldest beer in town!!! Staff is friendly and attentive. If you haven't tried them you should.

Unsafe, Aggressive Staff and Incorrect Orders Avoid this establishment if you value your peace of mind and physical safety. I paid a $114.00 bill for a phone order here, only to discover the food was the wrong size. When I pointed this out to the cashier, a kitchen worker named "Anthony" began screaming aggressive insults from the back, shouting that "people are always looking for free food"--even though my transaction was already completed. The situation escalated dramatically when a second worker wearing a ski mask came out of the kitchen to physically interject himself into the conflict. I felt so unsafe and threatened by their hostile behavior that I abandoned the counter immediately, leaving behind a $5.00 partial cash tip I had already laid down because I didn't want to risk reaching back over the counter. Deplorable customer service, hidden credit card upcharges, and a genuinely dangerous environment. Management needs to answer for this immediately. read more

Tony Pepperoni - Receipt - Pizza Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

Wow is all I can say! We were having drinks down then street and got hungry, so we decided to see what was close. This little pizzeria was open and we went in. What friendly staff and owners! They told us about their specials, what was good on the menu and to let us know if they had any questions. They had a wide variety of appetizers, pizzas, calzones, and desserts! We got a cheese and a pepperoni pizzas! Medium crust that was just right. We also got the mozzarella sticks and the fried ravioli. That fried ravioli was probably the best I've ever had! They have a small bar and about a handful of tables that you can hang out or take it to go. This is a little far from my house, but I will definitely make the drive to come up there. read more

this is my first time trying this restaurant moved to the area. Chicken is not fried so the skin is flabby, i got the Parmesan garlic, but it is basically naked wings because all the Parmesan is sitting at the bottom of the container. The spicy ranch taste like nothing. The only thing that had salt and it was the french fries. Philly cheese was dry. They added no sauce.. The pizza was oily. I will not be back. read more

Tony Pepperoni - Parmesan wings nothing but oil and flappy - Pizza Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

I drive for Uber Eats and was assigned to pick up an order that included a pizza and spaghetti. When I arrived, I was informed that the pizza had not yet been placed in the oven. I was also told that the cooks would not be making the spaghetti. Initially, no explanation was given, but I was later told they simply "didn't feel like making it." The employee working the counter appeared frustrated and was left trying to deal with a situation that was not her fault. When I spoke directly with the cooks to get clarification, they essentially told me to leave. As a delivery driver, I understand that delays and mistakes happen. However, refusing to prepare part of a customer's order because employees don't feel like making it is completely unacceptable. I advised them that I would be reporting the incident to Uber Eats. Management should be aware of how customers, delivery drivers, and front-counter staff are being affected by this type of behavior. The cooks involved demonstrated a level of professionalism that falls far below what should be expected in a restaurant. read more

This is an amazing hidden treasure!! I can't say enough !! Pizza was perfect Staff was amazing. The cheese is the BEST!! read more

I was going to rate three stars, if it isn't for the waitress being rude. Food was great, facility was clean but the service we received was bad all because who else but a young entitled, unprofessional server. read more

We had the fried ravioli appetizer with marina and ranch. It was very good and we would order it again. For pizza we ordered BBQ Chicken and Tony Pepperoni. Both were very good, with right amount of sauce and toppings. Our server was Sarah and you can tell she loves her job. We will be back for sure. read more

First off, the food was amazing. The pizza's were picture perfect like some lil old Italian grandma placed each topping. They were hot, juicy and glorious. That being said, the only downside is ordering online and having to go through a 3rd party. It was an experience total but totally worth it! This is a lil hole-in-the wall, Mayport gem. read more

I ordered a B.Y.O (Build your own) Pizza. I was attempting to replicate a pizza from another restaurant (it had Pepperoni, Hot Honey, Ricotta, and Basil) The pizza was average a bit too greasy for me to fully enjoy. Ricotta cheese wasn't as prevalent in overall flavor, but the honey did pair perfectly with the pepperoni cups. read more

Tony Pepperoni - B.Y.O Pizza: Pepperoni cups, Basil, Hot Honey and Ricotta - Pizza Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

See all

Refused to make my order AFTER I paid. Refused to give refund. I did NOT get my food and lost my money, see proof below. . Lady working was incredibly rude and yelling at the kitchen. Literally told us to " GO F YOURSELF". She preceded to freak out and yell at me and then kick me out ordering me to leave without food or a refund. This lady should not be working in any customer service job. I was extremely kind and said if they can't make the food or give a refund, then I can just contact them tomorrow and find someone who can help; not a big deal. However, she handled it terribly and screamed at me instead. I think she must have been on something because she completely freaked out. This is the worst customer service I've ever seen. Will be contacting the owners as soon as possible. read more

Tony Pepperoni - Took a picture to prove that they received the order through Uber Eats. - Pizza Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

So far we've had the pizza (if you like legit NY style pizza, this is it!), the calzones, and jalapeño poppers. Everything is delicious! The service is always great and quick. Pro points for delivering on base! We love to come here for the food and chill/laid back vibes. Definitely one of my favorite places in Jax. read more

Tony Pepperoni - Supreme calzone - Pizza Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

We tried the pizza about a year ago and have not been back. It was just okay tasting, basic pizza. I expected more from the reviews. The bartender was serving food and had chipped nail polish on. The bartender slightly flirted with my husband as we waited for our pizza. It had cool decorations inside. read more

Don't order delivery or pickup from this place if you want your food the same day. They could care less about their mobile order customers. The staff is rude and acts like they don't want to be there. I assume this a management issue. read more

I have lived down the street for 3 years and never stopped in. Why I have no idea. Pepperoni Pizza was delicious. Service was great and beers at the picnic table while waiting perfect! I will be back! read more

Tony Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

This is the 3rd time I've ever been here and the lady name Brooke was fantastic... she was great!! Food was great also..definitely will come back again. read more

This place was disappointing from beginning to end. Poor service, high prices, gross pizza, loud music. If you're looking for a rave at 4pm this your place.... The pepperoni pizza we got had undercooked cheese, no flavor in the sauce and a doughy yet burnt crust. Music was blaring techno and the man at the counter was rude, unaccommodating and just plain rude rolling his eyes multiple times. There is one single bathroom for everyone in the restaurant if you like to squat in men's pee this restaurant if for you. ( but remember gender neutral is 2023 apparently painted nails are too) Followed by a broken paper towel dispenser, broken soap dispenser and feces in the toilet, and just dirty in general just keep driving I'll do you a favor papa John's is only a short distance away. Did not ask us on the phone when we ordered, and were given attitude when we asked to sit down to eat it there "it's already in a box" We were In the area from out of town -camping- craving pizza, and looked up the best reviewed places. We would have rather gone to domino's across the street, at least you know what you're getting. You're getting a crappy edible pizza . Neither of us could finish 2 pieces of Tony's Perpperoni. Surprised this place is still in business, perhaps the music gets everyone in a trace and the pizza is out of this 1 star for the pepperoncinis because zero wasn't an option. They made my pizza a little bit soggier. But I cannot blame them, because it was unsalvageable anyways. Will feed the rest to wild raccoons because none of my friend will eat it. read more

Tony Pepperoni - Legendary Tony Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

Love this place!!! Garlic garlic garlic. Get a Za and garlic knots every time I visit my daughter

I search for food in my area, its located at near Publix . I thought perfect I am already here. It looked great I tried the 3 types of pepperoni pizza. It was just how do I say it, small! Ok so I am thinking good things come in small packages. I was wrong it was just Meh! They should remove the 2 thin types of pepperoni, and just use the thick one it was flavorful. Crust average but the cook was perfect for the pie. It's OK, it's not great. read more

Tony Pepperoni - Meh - Pizza Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

We have not reviewed this spot in awhile but it is at the top of our delivery pizza places. OK, so I admit, it's because we can get loaded cheese fries and pizza. Hello? How sinful and delicious is that combo? We normally order cheese fries, bacon on the side, and a half cheese/ half pepperoni pizza. I don't eat meat but hubby does. It's delicious and more than enough. Tonight we added the Cajun ranch wings for him and he said they were really good and he knows good wings. Pizzas, fries. Sandwiches, salads, etc. It's all good food! We do delivery and it's usually 30-45 minutes through Door Dash. Check them out! read more

See all

Tony's never disappoints! Everything I've ever tried has always been delicious and friendly genuine staff.

Liked pizza so far in the Jacksonville. Good size, generous toppings and well as the crust

Another absolutely horrible delivery service from this place. Second time I've given them a chance in two months. A simple Buffalo calzone was ordered both times. First time they never sent it with the rest of the order and wouldn't send out the correct order. Tonight they sent a frigging pepperoni calzone that we waited over an hour for. Don't waste your time or money with this place. read more

Tony Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

The service makes you feel at home, very welcoming. The food was amazing! Their burgers are the best around! Highly recommend you try their Jalapeño Burger. Loved it! Will be going back regularly. read more

Tony Pepperoni - Jalapeño Burger. Food quality is fantastic - Pizza Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

First time eating here and I can say I was completely satisfied! Ordered the Buffalo chicken calzone (carry out) Def was jammed packed with chicken and cheese. The dipping sauce which I'm assuming is the same used inside the calzone was tasty. My mind was blown by the size of the calzone, def got every penny worth! Side note the menu did say enough for me and my momma, wasn't a lie! Highly recommend. read more

Tony Pepperoni - Buffalo Chicken Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

The ingredients definitely has changed! People in the front are on something or drunk, disrespectful and constantly cussing. The lighting is bright , pizza came soggy and cheese slipped right off. Chicken was served raw, the subs are good but you want a good pizza at a pizza joint. read more

The new owners are a joke. This place used to be great and now they suck. They can't even sauce wings properly. Asked for hot wings, they added about one droplet of hot sauce to them and were disrespectful enough to send that out to a customer. And their new coleslaw tastes like they wait until it's gone bad for them to serve it with the duval pizza read more

Small place busy with locals. Pizza was good a little too crunchy crust. Sauce appears to be home made. The Garlic knots were the best! Kids drew on paper plates and they are stapled to the walls (kids loved it) read more

See all

A friend of my was a big fan of Tony Pepperoni so after some drinks we decided the easiest thing to do was our some delivery pizza. I will say the delivery didn't take too long because next thing you know we had pizza. She had ordered the "Legendary" Tony Pepperoni pizza "16 inches. I will say I didn't know that was a thing. I thought we ordered a regulars pepperoni pizza so when I saw it had 3 different types of pepperoni (including my favorite the spicy little ones that curl up.) The only thing I wasn't a fan of was that I looked more pizza a little more on the over cooked side. Like the cheese completely melted into the pizza but that's just me. I can always just ask for it to be more well done next time. We also did get 2 orders of Garlic Knots which were great. Perfectly soft, buttery ,with the perfect amount of garlic and parmesan. The marinara for dipping was also delicious. For sure another heavy hitter in the Mayport/Beachside pizza restaurants. read more

Tony Pepperoni - Garlic Knots - Pizza Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

See all

Afternoon trip for lunch. It is a small, quant, clean local place. I have to say I was quite disappointed because I wanted to order the caprese salad only to told that they have not had that item in years! So I went with antipasto instead. It was a Togo order, So I cannot speak for the ambiance, but they had a small bar where a few were chatting and sipping. I saw folks munching on garlic knots , they are supposedly good, but I will leave that review for others. The salad was very good. Lots of toppings, big enough to split. The pizza had a good flavor. My slice was a little crunchy, but I will say I ordered only a slice from the counter and was reheated. I'm sure a fresh pie would be very tasty. Pretty decent, I would return and order a fresh pie! read more

Tony Pepperoni - Pepperoni special - Pizza Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

See all

The pizza is awesome but now I am gluten-free. So I am no longer a customer. It's sad so many great pizzerias don't offer gf options like cauliflower crust or gf crust or pizza bowls. read more

How have I never been here before. I've seen it multiple times- they have an awesome mural on the side of their building and are right off Mayport road. Same Shopping center as Dunkin Donuts. The garlic parmesan wings- so freaking good. Dripping with butter, seasonings and cheese. Perfect amount of crunch. I ordered 5, wish I had gotten 20. Will 100% be back just for these. Build your own pizza- less than $10 for an 8 slice pizza, 12 inches I think. Prefect crust, perfect sauce, perfect taste. I will 100% be back for these. Let's just say I loved the food and can't believe it took me so long to try it! Ate too quick to take pics. read more

This place is the best. Super fast delivery, great appetizers and pizza. love ya Tony!

Excellent customer service, best "pie crust and sauce, calzones are outta this world " I've had since I've been in Jacksonville for eight months (yes 8!!) Portions Are MORE than generous when you walk in you get that *cheers* "NORM" feeling every single time!!! These guys definitely appreciate their patrons. It shows in their work for their food, and when you walk in the door each and every time!!!! You guys will surely be missed !!! {Nothing better than walking in, and your bartenders knitting a beanie, remembers your name, remembers the order before after AND the credit card number before you!!! Ah yes that's why they have HAPPY repeat customers} read more

I have eaten here a few times now - even today a year apart from the last time and Tony Pepperoni didn't let me down! It's usually a battle for me here because I can't decide whether to get two slices or one. Their pizza slices are large can usually satisfy for dinner with a salad. This was my choice today. My pizza slice was the Super. This is a deluxe with pepperoni, sausage, green pepper, onion, black olives, and extra cheese. I could have missed a topping here, but don't hold it against me! The extra cheese covered it up :) I also had their smaller size house salad (which is adequate in size for any customer) with balsamic dressing. I loved that it had cheese and banana peppers on it! The only thing I missed today was that the Duval pizza slices weren't offered, but still overall, I had a happy eating experience. Service and atmosphere at Tony Pepperoni is upbeat! Lively country music fills the seating area and it's a pretty good stream they use here! Not the greatest fan of country music, but I enjoyed the selections today. They have one of the most cheerful servers I've experienced in JAX at Tony Pepperoni. My shame for not getting her name! I'll post it on the rebound review when I go back there. But I'll give her credit, she actively serves the customers, checks up on them regularly, all with a smile that makes your day better! I like Tony Pepperoni! Even like the name so much I avoid just calling it Tony's :) But it's a grade A ma and pa shop that has the appearance of what a classic pizza store should look like - with age and a cash register that goes back to the 1800s! It's what makes the ma and pa shop band special! Give it a try sometime! Recommendation: MED HIGH read more

See all

Got it to go and the pizza was hot and fresh and satisfied the hubby's craving. We love to support local. If you haven't been, go check them out. Their wings are good too! read more

Tony Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

See all

Pizza came out looking hot tasty and fairly quick which is the good. The bad is this place was over loaded with screaming kids. If you want quiet and relaxing this not the place. Guy working the front never came back to the table to refill drinks and he was basically solo running the bar counter area and taking everyones orders. Need seriously an assistant as he was obviously trying. As I was trying this place the first time with a Groupon they automatically add a 18% gratuity. Not worth that given no refills etc... Inside area is very small maybe 6 tables. Place needs some fine tuning. read more

Tony Pepperoni - Menu on the wall. - Pizza Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

See all

Under new ownership New lighting is to bright Music is awful Regular customers say their usual items don't taste the same Non-family crowd People have walked out when the usual server was not there. read more