Great NY vibe with lots to look at while you eat. Great music while we here and it made feel even more authentic. The pizza is good and I recommend the double mushroom garlic slice$3.50.. very large slices! I'm a pretty big eater and two slices filled me up. Monday's are $1 Cream Ale beers (Rochester, NY) and they're good! If you stop in ask for Morgan, she's super nice and can help you out when choosing slices from the market counter. Tell her Tequila John says hello read more

See all

We ordered online for delivery. We got a half meatball and half cheese. OMG! I'm very partial to the cheese on this pizza! (Just like Al's). The sauce was just right, not too scarce and not drowning in it. The flavor was on point. The meatballs were flat but delicious. Why only 4 stars? The crust was thin but didn't have any flavor standing alone. It got kinda soggy, but the flavor of the cheese saved the meal . Maybe next time I'll get some garlic butter to dip the crust in. I'm definitely going to order from them again! read more

Staying nearby. Used Uber Eats to order garlic knots, pepperoni pizza, Caesar salad. Noted need for utensils, salad dressing on the side. Delivery to hotel. When opened up - no salad, no utensils. Garlic knots were dough balls sprinkled with mild seasoning - discarded, could not eat. Pizza discarded after 3 slices. read more

This pizza is worth the drive. And the garlic knots are my favorite. Too bad it's not in the same area we live in or it would be our regular haunt. read more

Both Female employees were very rude. Tuesdays have been deals on large cheese pizzas. Been getting it just for deal. The specials where written on the chalk board. They made me look like the bad guy in front of employees and customers. One claimed to be there for 8 months first time I seen her. Then saying that the cashier "stealing money from the store". Even though I use debit he never stole from me and doing his job. After her obnoxious attitude towards me I didn't want it and told her that I don't want it now. Then she was giving me attitude about that. Very disrespectful people working there lied to make her seem in the right. Will not go again if this employees work there. Being a certain type of female doesn't make you qualify for that position and they definitely are not. Work on your people skill and not your ego. Also If there where no specials why do people I work with tell me about beer specials they have on certain days. I know the specials been there for awhile. And I got my debit statements and possibly receipts to prove it. read more

These guys are great. Very welcoming and the was delicious. I like how the crust is crispy. Bathroom was clean too. This is the spot for when my buddies come into town read more

Tony Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

Pizza was great and smothered with pepperoni. Quick service , ready on time and easy to find.

New fav pizza place this side of the intercoastal. This fresh, relaxed, local late night joint has something for everyone from classic slices to the infamous Duval pie (a weird favorite that you have to try.) Pizza is cheesy, foldable (unless it has a bunch of toppings) and the crust is a nice balance. We've been here twice and each time everything has been perfect. Our favorite things thus far include the doughy-yet-crisp garlic knots woth that red sauce mmmm you want to take a dive in it, with the garlic knot as your floaty. That's how good it is. Our bartender/pizza expert Bri is on point every time. Very friendly, funny and freaking fantastic conversationalist. So whether you are perched alone at the pizza bar, or with someone--you'll always feel like you are having pizza woth a friend. There is room for a great time with a large group of friends or a family night, not much but we have seen them make it work. If I didn't have to watch my girlish figure I'd be here much more often haha Definitely worth every calorie! read more

See all

Just ordered a calzone and Caesar salad to go. Food was very delicious. I absolutely love this place. Seems like a nice locals' spot.

Nice quaint little place, but the food is nothing to write home about.... the food has Gourmet prices but it's not Gourmet tasting. We ordered a Philly Sub and an Italian sub. read more

Tony Pepperoni - philly sub - Pizza Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

See all

I have found my new favorite pizza place in the Jacksonville Beach area. The chicken bacon ranch pizza was amazing. The crust was crunchy and delicious, the chicken was juicy and seasoned all the way through. The meat lovers (which has three kinds of pepperoni) was very filling and one slice is probably enough to fill you up. The best part of all about both pizzas is that neither of them are drowned in grease. Truly a delicious solid pie. read more

See all

The first time I had them I fell in love. Yesterday when I ordered it definitely did not live up to the expectations from the first time. The mozzarella sticks had an old taste like they weren't made fresh. The Philly cheesesteak was hot but the directions were not followed on lite veggies. The pizza did not appear to be fresh either. Needless to say I'll give them another chance but not for a while. read more

Great food their chicken wings are the bomb their jalapeño poppers were great as well as the calzone I had old man I'll get it again I recommend these people are good read more

This place looks like an ordinary pizza spot but it's actually super upbeat and delicious! Price is fair but the food is definitely worth it! They have a bar and offer $1 can beer every Monday with $1 slice of pizza! You don't get to choose the beer but that's fine with me when it's only a $1. read more

My first time getting over to Tony Pepperoni's and Monday was a great day for it! $1.50 cheese slices and $1 Genny Cream Ale in a can... it's really hard to complain! Upon entering we were greeted by a super friendly hostess/waitress/bartender all around really friendly person. The atmosphere was actually really chill, multiple TV's showing sports, booth seating, small high top tables and a few places at the "pizza bar". Mostly families having dinner and lots of pick-up orders coming in to get their food. The bar area was full so after ordering at the counter I took a seat. Within a couple of minutes the pizza and a cold beer arrived. Again very friendly staff, and she was attending to everyone in the place! The pizza was pretty good. It was cooked very well with a bit of crisp to the crust that folded well and stood up to the "hold test". The sauce was a bit lacking in flavor and it overall did taste a bit salty. I will definitely come back as they have a nice looking menu for other items to try, but I want to try the pizza a few more times. I'm very tempted to give this place 4 stars for the overall experience, so I'll have to go back in a week or so and try again. If your in the Mayport area this should definitely be on your radar. read more

See all

Amazing! Our first time ordering to go, and they will be our go to from now on. Garlic knots, chicken parm, burger, and wings, all delicious! Can't wait to try the pizza!!! And it was delivered fast, hot and friendly! read more

As soon as you walk In huge menu on wall cool environment you can see the food being made and the smells are amazing. read more

See all

Delicious food!! Had their garlic knots and they were to die for. I'm from close to PA so I am a Pizza and Italian food snob and these were delicious! I'm already back a second time! read more

Pizza hits the spot! Cheese sticks never make it home, devoured on ride home. Veggie pizza is so good. We skip the olives add more shrooms, please. Dough so fresh, are got to pizza place for sure. read more

I visited this pizzeria twice before writing a review. I enjoyed the plain cheese pizza slice. It was large like a typical New York slice and the crust was just right. It was nice to be able to enjoy just a slice and not have to order a whole pizza pie. The next time I went, I tried the meat lovers slice. It was a little disappointing. There was a lot more grease and the crust as thinner and it was a little burnt after it was reheated. The lady that served me both times was pleasant. The strawberry melon drink was good, but the regular iced tea was watery. The restaurant is small, but cozy. This location has changed hands several times since it was part of the much larger pizzeria, years ago. I wish the new owners the best of luck. read more

See all

Overpriced pizzeria with crappy product on Mayport Road. The only reason I believe they are still in business is because they have no competition that delivers to Mayport other than chains (Dominos and Papa Johns). Many in Mayport settle for this expensive garbage pizza only due to a lack of alternatives. BRING QUALITY PIZZA TO MAYPORT read more

Excellent choice! Local pizza with delicious, inexpensive pizza along with cold beer and super friendly service! It was our first visit yet we will be back for more! Can't wait to try the other flavors ...love that you can order pizza by the slice so you can try new ones! read more

never will I order from this company again! Rude and sarcastic service! I asked to speak with a manager, and he said they do not have such a person. Never will I order again. read more

This review is based on a Yelp delivery order partnered with GrubHub. We ordered 3 items, a pizza, garlic knots and the buffalo chicken fries. Delivery was faster than expected but no napkins or utensils were provided. We were at a brewery and didn't have access to utensils. It was a pain. The pizza was excellent, but pricey. The garlic knots were amazing. The buffalo chicken fries were not good, and expensive, most of them were thrown away. I'd order again from here but skip the buffalo chicken fries. read more

Love their pizza and their garlic knots. Their legendary pepperoni includes three different Pepperoni's with cup and char style. When we moved to Atlantic Beach ( from across the ditch in Jacksonville) I tried out multiple popular Beach spots to see which pizza place I would enjoy the most and they are our main go-to especially for delivery or takeout. If you go in the restaurant they do have by the slice. read more

Tony Pepperoni - Cheese and legendary pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

See all

This is the best pizza and wings that I've had so far in Jacksonville! The hot sauce parm mix for the wings is the best!

I had wanted to try this place for a while now and finally got the chance. I needed to pickup the pizza and called so that it would be ready when I got there. I called from the corner of Atl/Hodges. I was put on hold until I pulled into the parking lot. Too late to try and call someone else. I was told 20 minutes, it was closer to 30. What I didn't catch was the sign on the counter than said I woudl be charged an extra 3% for using my debit card. And of course when I delivered the pizza to my niece in the hotel down the road, it was wrong. The pizza was edible, that's the best I can say about it. I won't be back. read more

Super great food and even better service! My daughter got the kids pizza meal, it was delicious! I got the Greek salad, I've had many Greek salads from a lot of different places..this one was honestly the best! Our waitress, I forget her name, I'm terrible with names, but she was so friendly and helpful! She helped me choose a good local beer they had on tap, it was a great choice, thank you to her! Can't wait to go back! read more

I think it tasted really good I live there marinara is chunky like it's fresh. However my wife states she was not fond of the cheese kn the pizza and calzone. read more

Great option for pizza, my husband LOVES the gyros! I gave it 4 stars because everything seems to be overly garlicky.. lol even asking for no extra garlic. read more

Great local pizza place and bar. Quirky, eclectic decor with open sitting. Daily specials and coupons. Friendly staff. Pizza is handmade and baked in a brick oven read more

See all

There are very few places that deliver on base at Mayport, so living here, our options are extremely limited when we want to order out for delivery. I have heard both good and bad things about Tony Pepperoni, but I wanted to satisfy my curiosity. So instead of ordering the usual Domino's last night, we called Tony Pepperoni and placed an order for a meatball sub with fries, a large pizza, and a 10 piece order of hot wings. I was honestly expecting our food to take such a long time, and be semi-cold. Surprisingly, they came in just an hour, and our food was hot. My sub nearly felt like it just came out of the oven. The sauce on the meatball sub & the pizza has a unique and sweet flavor. It has a great balance of zest and sweetness. However, I do feel like the pizza should have had a little bit more cheese on it for the price. Our family shared the pizza, and everyone approved. My husband ate the wings and said they were very delicious. On top of the awesome food, paying for delivery didn't break the bank for us. We are really looking forward to ordering again, and trying something new next time. I'm so happy that we've found a restaurant that delivers on base that's NOT the ordinary chain Papa John's/Domino's! read more

See all

I truly enjoyed this place. The prices are great. Friendly staff. I had the calzone. The dough was absolutely great. It was a very large portion enough for 2. Stuffed full with my toppings. Wonderful!! We ordered 2 slices of pizza that my boyfriend ate. He said they were really great and topped to perfection. We had the pizza fries appetizer. It was good but not sure I would order again. The place is small but quaint. My family will go back and I would let anyone know to give it a chance. read more

I got the Tony pepperoni pizza. The pepperonis are very good. The cheese and sauce also has great flavor. The dough/ crust needs some work though. It was hard as a rock and didn't have much flavor. read more

Great service right when you walk in pizza had great flavor and don't forget to try the garlic knots .sitting there felt like you were among friends go you won't be disappointed read more

Eggplant Parmigiana was all I craved my last month of pregnancy. I had been waiting to give in and I eventually called it in for delivery. Unfortunately it was burnt! Yes it was late in the evening, but still. Anyway, you may be wondering why there is a 4 star review then.. well a few weeks ago I gave it another try. I mentioned to the lady at the counter that the last time I ordered it, it was overly burnt. Well, she asked some information about when I ordered it and without even expecting this, I received a $2 discount. With that said, this one was not burnt and it was totally worth trying them again! I don't have a picture, when I crave eggplant parm, there's no time for photos ‍‍ read more

The pizza (meat lovers) was great, the garlic knots were a bit over cooked and in my opinion had way too much garlic. Overall a great experience with timely delivery. read more

First time trying! Great pizza! I I am from up north and this is good! Fast delivery too!

We're recently obsessed with this place! We've had the Philly cheesesteaks and white pizza which are both spectacular! Definitely recommend!

The pizza is fire, I built my own with the lunch special. However the wings are trash. I got salt and vinegar, the wildest of flavors, and my wings were bland. Gotta do better. read more