While Tocqueville may not be quite as well-known as some places I consider its peers, it certainly doesn't fall short in any respect. Looking back at my evening here, there is nothing that I can criticize or attempt to form a complaint about; everything, from the moment I stepped in to the final few seconds when I had my coat politely held out for me to put back on, was nothing short of flawless.
My friend and I came to Tocqueville on a snowy Friday evening. We were greeted by the smiling hostess, had our coats checked in with ease, and were led into the main dining room, seated, and presented with menus. We barely touched them, though, as we'd decided beforehand to opt for Tocqueville's Signature Four Course Chef's Tasting Menu. It was, at least in my opinion, a wise decision and an option I would highly recommend for any future first-time visitors.
Our meal began with a myriad of amuse bouches. We were presented with goat cheese served in a crisp, paper thin shell; a ham croquette topped with mushroom; and a sliver of hamachi. The variety of textures and flavors in just these few bites led to even greater anticipation of our actual courses.
First - The Cato Farm Bloomsday Cheddar Salad. With its focus on seasonal and local ingredients, Tocqueville gave recognition to the farm in Connecticut which supplied its produce. A colorful salad composed of shaved fennel, friseé, and a slice of roasted pear, was drizzled with a hazelnut vinaigrette and topped with a slice of cheddar cheese and pine nuts. Although the friseé was a bit tricky to eat, the overall pairing of ingredients was spot-on. I absolutely loved the nuttiness and acidity from the hazelnut vinaigrette; and each of the components contributed something to the plate.
Second - Truffled Creamy Parmesan Grits with Sunny Side Up Country Egg. I couldn't recall if I'd ever had grits before, but if they can come even close to tasting like Tocqueville's, I would be tempted to have it every day. It was creamy, and the truffle and parmesan flavors melded together delightfully, the small bites of bacon serving a welcome surprise. Being able to break into the still-runny egg yolk sealed the deal.
Third - Seared Diver Scallops with Foie Gras. This was perhaps the dish I was looking forward to the most, and it didn't disappoint. I was presented with the largest scallop I have yet to encounter, and it was perfectly seared. The foie gras was a decadent piece of liver, smooth, and with none of the bitterness I have encountered in other (not as well prepared) variations. The cider vinegar gastrique was a smart addition, as the acidity cut through the richness of both of the scallop and foie gras. The mushroom and braised artichoke added some earthiness to each forkful, making for a surprisingly balanced, yet rich dish.
Fourth - The Signature Soufflé. It is with some embarrassment that I admit this was also my first soufflé. I am more than grateful it was at Tocqueville, however; in no other dessert have I encountered the range of textures present in this one. From the crisp, slightly crunchy outer shell to the still-molten interior, the chocolate soufflé was a delight to eat from start to finish. It was served with a side of raspberry sorbet, which was much appreciated break from the richness of the chocolate.
We ended the evening with a plate of petit fours, which weren't necessary as we were both completely satisfied by the end of our fourth course. Service throughout the evening was professional and warm, and was careful of being attentive, but not intrusive. While it's difficult to make frequent visits to Tocqueville, it's only to ensure that I don't get spoiled too easily. This is a place to come for special occasions or perhaps for those slightly-more-romantic dates. Yes, it is a splurge, but it's definitely worth the experience. read more