Awesome friendly service, unique pairings ! Our group went 2 years ago and still talk about it

This winery has a pickle and wine pairing, which is so unique! Definitely worth it! There are also some really interesting wines, like one made with hops and one that tastes like a margarita. The staff were all friendly and chatty, but not so much as to be annoying. The ambiance was fine, your typical wine tasting venue. I would definitely stop here again! read more

Toast Winery - Pickle and wine pairing - Wineries Near Me - Rock Stream, New York

Good variety of wines - per my husband, they have a good ice wine and I thought their reds were decent. Honestly the best part was the pickle pairing - some of the wines I wouldn't normally like (too sweet for me) but with the pickles they were pretty good! Also a good charcuterie board and the pretzels sticks were good. Definitely a recommended stop! read more

Toast Winery - Charcuterie, pickle pairing and pretzel sticks - Wineries Near Me - Rock Stream, New York

We did a pickle pairing was unique and different but also very good . Pickles we're good , wines were good too ! Service was good , everyone was very friendly . Great atmosphere, being rainy everyone was in good spirits. read more

See all

Pulled into this Winery on a whim a while back and am glad I did. I've come here 3 times this year (despite living 5 hours away) and have never had anything but a fun experience. Absolutely recommend to anyone doing the Seneca Lake wine trail or just in the area for fun. They have all sorts of options for Wine tastings - the basic version of sipping a few of their top choices, wine & cheese pairings, a "blindfolded" taste test, and even seasonal options like the Wine/Pickle pairing they do on Summer weekends. The staff are always super friendly and outgoing, and have something for everyone: reds, whites, sweet, dry, classic tastes, brand-new flavors (like their famous Margarita-tasting wine - yes, that's a real thing and yes it's exactly as tasty as it sounds), and also a few ciders and beers that are 100% worth a try as well. I had an ice-cream stout one day, and came back the next for some of their Hard Cider and the Pickle/wine pairing. Delicious. Clearly it's a popular spot especially on the weekend - they're one of the few wineries that's open until 6:00 pm, and they have an expanded space for large groups as well. Even so we've never had to wait for a table and are always served promptly. Can't wait to come back! read more

Toast Winery - Pickle-pairing Perfection - Wineries Near Me - Rock Stream, New York

See all

The wine here was excellent! I came all the way from Manhattan, New York, and was very pleased with this winery. The ambiance is very relaxing, and I loved the toasters against the wall, which adds a creative touch. There's also a tasting room in the back if you want to do that with a group of friends. Jayne was absolutely attentive and wonderful! I really enjoyed my time there because it felt welcoming, and they are very caring about their customers. Mike was also very friendly. All in all, a great experience! I will definitely be coming back again. read more

See all

Toast made my Winery list because of their pickle pairing. Wine is assigned a pickle to try and the staff explain what note pay attention to while trying them together. Well the wines were good, the pickles are what really made this a four star. We wound up purchasing two pickle jars bring home and I highly recommend the taco pickles. read more

We had a great time today at the Toast Winery. Everyone that works there is very attentive and friendly. 5 tastings for $8 is a pretty good deal. We enjoyed the wines that we tasted. I like sweet wines. I really liked the Bubbly Brindar (wine bubbly wine), and Celebration Red (tasted like awesome sangria). The Rita was ok. It was amazing that it tasted like a margarita without margarita ingredients. My husband liked his dry wines. I didn't pay attention to the names he really liked unfortunately because I was enjoying mine. We also got the smoked Gouda cheese which was amazing. The tangerine cider was really good too. Go check them out. They have lots of options. They also have some food options. read more

Toast Winery - Wineries Near Me - Rock Stream, New York

I'm a wine club member for the last year So many positives to mention Nice mix of dry and sweet wines Dog friendly Indoor outdoor seating Amazing charcuterie board Staff always have a smile on their face very helpful You will also find an excellent cider and few others on tap which they comarket read more

We were here looking for different wineries that we haven't tried and this place I do not remember. It has a cool logo of a flame and a winery called Toast can't be a bad thing. As I read about this winery before visiting, the owner has something in common such as me as a home wine maker, working in corporate america and working as a college professor. Wine is what relaxes me but it's a lot of hard work for sure, happy to see someone made this a dream and it's going well. We arrived inside sat at a table provided a list of wines to choose from in our tasting. Our waitress or waiter would come over and fill our glass up with a sample of our choice of wine that we wanted to try. The high falution was my favorite and purchased 3 bottles of this to go. This is a new favorite stop for us, especially how good the wine is. Cheers for a great first visit. We will be back. read more

See all

had a great tasting. very interesting conversation with the staff. love the white wines and the margarita wine! the ambiance was very welcoming and comfortable. love the bottle lights, the toasters and the wall art. Looking forward to going back to a pairing with the tasting. read more

Enjoyed this place a lot. The wine and popcorn flight was perfect! The staff were full of smiles, upbeat and friendly. Also, sampled the mulled wine. Loved it so much, bought their kit to make it at home. They have real time social media counters on the wall, it was fun to see them go up when a bunch of us started following them while we were there tasting. read more

See all

My husband and I stopped here for our last tasting of our annual FLX trip. We stopped by on a Monday around noon and were seated immediately at the bar. The menu is huge with dry, sweet, and bubbly wines. Interesting options were a Pet Nat Muscat Ottanel that was very interesting and good (my husband thought it tasted like "hard sprite" which is accurate, it had a bite to it and lots of lime), Bubbly Dry Riesling, and the barrel aged ice wine (it was smooth and not syrupy). Their watermelon sangria also sounded interesting, which is made with the Bubbly Dry Riesling, watermelon juice, and miscellaneous fruit. I'd also be interested in doing their black glass tasting, where you guess the wine. We weren't tempted to buy anything, but enjoyed our visit and will return in the future. read more

Toast Winery - Tasting menu (Aug 2023) - Wineries Near Me - Rock Stream, New York

See all

Love this winery! By far my favorite winery we stopped at. The staff was great. The wines were fantastic. They gave us cute little cupcakes as a treat also. Also the names of the wines ... so great. Add the ice wine to your tasting it was SO GOOD! Every wines were great, I would definitely go back! Don't skip Toast! read more

Toast Winery - Pure arrogance - Wineries Near Me - Rock Stream, New York

See all

Fabulous wines and staff with an amazing view! Dry White wines were my favorite with so many to choose from. Stop here and sip and sit. No rush in and out! read more

Super cool tasting room with friendly staff. The popcorn pairing was delicious. I don't have a favorite wine as all that were part of the flight were great. Like how attentive and knowledgeable the team was and they worked well together to serve all in the tasting room. read more

Great service. Very attentive staff. Dog friendly. Offered dog water bowls and dog treats. dogs allowed inside as well. Servers explained their offerings very well. Various cheese & warm pretzel sticks available for purchase. Good options for various tastes of wine. Spacious area. Lots of sitting including outside patio area. read more

Toast Winery - Dog friendly - Wineries Near Me - Rock Stream, New York

I will forever recommend ANY winery as long as the wine is chilled, service is friendly, and the view is amazing. This place has some kind of magic in a bottle called margarita wine (probably not the EXACT name, but you get it). I only bought two bottles. OMG what was I thinking??!! Now I'm 3 hours away in the midst of this hot summer and don't have anymore!! Get yourself a case if this is your thing and thank me later (or call me over and we'll share!!) Cheers!!! read more

We stopped during the Seneca Lake wine and chocolate tour. We were offered nonalcoholic, mulled cider drink that was delicious! The chocolate covered pretzels with the spicy Kick were enjoyed as well! read more

Toast Winery - Chocolate Covered Pretzel with a Toasty Kick - Wineries Near Me - Rock Stream, New York

What a hoot!! We had a tasting with popcorn and some mulled wine. Reminded me of my glogg days as a youngster. Hilarious t-shirts. Friendly and knowledgeable staff. read more

See all

Coolest wine pairing along the trolley line. The pickles were awesome! Our server was so nice as well. read more

Toast Winery - Wine pairing - Wineries Near Me - Rock Stream, New York

Bottle of Highfalutin on the patio. Very nice red. Pick four charcuterie was yummy and nicely done. Great setting, nice staff, enjoyable landing spot. read more

Toast Winery - Wineries Near Me - Rock Stream, New York

So we came as a group of 8. Then set 4 and 4 at a table. They refused to wait in us after being seated. We were told they can't serve a group of 8. Oh wait we were 2 groups of 4. read more

Very high quality rieslings and a delicious red blend. What we loved the most about this winery was the local cheese they sold as accoutrements. It truly enhanced the wine tasting experience. read more

Cameron was welcoming, attentive but not intrusive, knowledgeable and charming. This is a smaller winery but we had some good wines and really enjoyed it. Definitely glad we stopped in. read more

Wonderful service, great personalities and enjoyable wines. We recommend the mulled wine.

This place was great! Stopped here early on our trip and we were pleasantly surprised. We were taken care of by the owner who was extremely knowledgeable and pleasant. She spent a lot of time explaining the wine making process, how her wines were made, what they'd pair well with. You could tell she was passionate about her business. We loved chatting with her, getting recommendation about other places to check out, places to eat and drink some good wine. We'll definitely be back! read more

I will try to keep this short and sweet. I have been probably 4 times now, and will keep returning when I'm in the area. Yelp does a disservice to the new owners/winery by keeping the reviews for the previous one listed. The main draw for me, as it should be for anyone, is the wine. The choice to create various wines such as the petillant naturel and Zweigelt (and doing them justice) definitely has Toast at the front of the the pack for the region and likely the country once more recognized. The staff and owner are also just fantastic people. The tastings are always done well and done right. If I'm on the wine trail and I only get to get to hit one winery, this is it. read more

visited Toast Winery recently. The staff is so friendly and the wine is great. The pickle and wine pairing is so original and good. Wines are amazing read more

We were in the area working at Watkins Glen for a NASCAR race, Go Bowling at the Glen, and looked for a winery to go to that was open a little later for some tastings (they're open until 7pm on a Saturday!) and we couldn't help but to go here JUST because of the name! Apparently we aren't the only ones who do that... Not only is the staff super friendly and welcoming, but they also have a nice selection of clothing with "ass" or "pompous ass" quotes on them, and even one of those signs you can poke your head through for a fun photo of you as a woman with standing next to a donkey. Their "small" cheese platter makes you feel like you ordered a large by mistake. I really enjoyed it here for a quick stop. Unfortunately we were a bit exhausted from working in the sun all day, but if we ever venture out there again, I would definitely like to sit outside on their patio. read more

See all

Excellent! Music 3-6 some weekends! Amazing wines and hands down best Charcuterie tray! Make sure you 5qkw 4he time to stop!! read more

Toast Winery - My wine and cheese on Android there amazing finger lakes day! - Wineries Near Me - Rock Stream, New York

This was our second stop on our day of wineries. It was very generic looks like they are just starting out. We had to go just because of the name. Wine was ok we did end up buying a bottle of smart ass white. But the shirts and wine accessories were a big draw. We end up buying 2 shirts. Employee pouring wine was pretty blah and forgot to give my husband one of the tastings and just walked away. So we had to get her back and she seemed mad that we disturbed her from doing nothing. If they get there stuff together they could really have a good thing going. They need get some customer friendly funny wine pourers and have some fun with their product. read more

Toast Winery - Hubby in the tasting room - Wineries Near Me - Rock Stream, New York

Lovely winery, with new owners who took over the Pompous Ass wines and added several dry wines under the new Toast label. They have a good lineup of sweet and dry wines. Being a lover of dry wines, I especially loved their Dry Rosé and Cabernet Franc. read more

Toast Winery - Inside the winery - Wineries Near Me - Rock Stream, New York

Fun place. Good wine with snarky names. Knowledgable server. Cute merchandise and wine ice cream.

Excellent service and friendly bartender! Friendliest greeting as we walked in the door!

visited several winteries while visiting FLX, NY but Toast Winery was the best. Great tastings. Great food. Best staff....most personal. Mulled wine special was delicious. We were seated at the bar. Had live music during our visite to make it even better. read more

My wife and I had a wonderful time at this little winery. We were greeted warmly when we walked in on a beautiful Friday afternoon in early May, well before the main tourist time in the region. There was another couple at the bar and there were two women tending to the wine bar. We were given a menu of choices, and with the excellent suggestions of one of the bartenders (I apologize for not remembering her name), we made our choices. I am a big fan of big, woody dry wines and the Barrel Aged Dry Riesling at this vineyard is excellent. My wife and I made all different choices and we both got to try what the other chose. I am not a fan of "table reds" since, in my experience, they tend to be on the very sweet side. But this winery makes a blend called "Highfalutin" which is an excellent table red, sure to satisfy anyone that you serve it to. It is a blend of their Cabernet Franc (which is very, very good, by the way) and another red (I forget what it is). It is not too sweet, nor is it too dry. Perfect. The staff here was upbeat and friendly, informative and helpful. At some point another couple came in and the woman who had been helping us through the tasting was attending to them. The other woman stepped right in. Her name was Jayne and in the course of our conversation, we found out that she is the wife of the winemaker and they own the vineyard. We talked about their history and the winery and she even gave us what turned out to be an excellent recommendation for a nice anniversary dinner on the lake at Keuka. (By the way, Jayne, the lemon blueberry marscarpone cake was the best!) We truly enjoyed our time here with this crew. Despite our plan to return to the region to check out as many of the wineries as we can, I will return here again. This was a great experience. read more

I want to start by saying the young man who took care of our tasting was outstanding, I wish I had gotten his name. I love this place, we always make it a stop my only disappointment is they changed the name and logo from Pompous Ass to Toast. Not an interesting name.... Toast! The donkey was the draw!! Bring him back, I really miss him! ( nice wines though and great port for a reasonable price) read more

Group of friends and myself were doing wineries up and down Seneca Lake. We stopped because of the name. We wanted to see what it was like. The logo was super cute but that was the only thing we liked. The wines were nothing special. The tasting really got on my nerves. Instead of serving everyone their first wine then second wine then third. The lady went down the list and served each wine when someone had that wine. For our group everyone liked dry wines but myself. So I never got my first wine for 10 minutes. And my friends waited an additional 15 minutes for her to get to my wines. We were not very impressed. read more

Toast Winery - Wineries Near Me - Rock Stream, New York

See all

The wine really is mediocre compared to some of the other wineries in the area. I agree with other reviewers that the tasting felt very rushed, almost as if they couldn't get us out of there fast enough. Considering there was only one other couple tasting wine, I thought that was a little strange. They don't leave much time to talk about each wine individually and you almost feel awkward asking questions because they seem to pour the wine and then basically run away. To be honest they seem to be more hung up on their "kiss my ass" and "pompous ass" gimmicky merchandise than the quality and value of their wine. If you do go, I recommend trying the Riesling. Once again, compared to other wineries, I won't be traveling back to do another tasting. read more