As our last day of visiting wineries along Seneca Lake unfolded, we found ourselves reflecting on…read morehow much the region is evolving. Earlier in the day, when we were at Penguin Bay, our server Sharon had shared some fascinating updates about wineries in the area changing hands. One of the biggest surprises? Bagley Winery, one of the oldest wineries along Seneca Lake, which had been operating since 1980, had sold their 40-acre farm in Hector.
We had visited Bagley Winery in the past, but at the time, the wines just weren't quite to our liking--a reminder that every harvest is different, and winemaking is always evolving. But as we were driving to our next stop, we suddenly spotted the sign and had a moment of realization:
"Hold on, that used to be Bagley's. Let's stop!"
That spontaneous decision turned out to be one of the best surprises of the trip.
Exploring the New Offerings
Walking into the tasting room, there was an immediate sense of something fresh and different. While the space felt familiar, the wines had taken on a completely new personality under the new ownership. Instead of diving straight into full pours, we sampled a small tasting of different wines to get a feel for their style and direction before deciding on what we wanted.
Here's what they had to offer:
White & Rosé Wines
1 2023 Sunny Side White Blend - Bright and lively, featuring notes of tangerine, apricot, and grapefruit.
2 2023 Grace Riesling - A classic Finger Lakes Riesling with flavors of red apple, lime, and bright acidity.
3 2023 Viva Riesling - An intriguing take on Riesling, infused with ginger, lavender, and lime zest for a more aromatic and complex profile.
4 2023 Chardonnay - Pear, floral, and mineral-driven, offering a beautiful balance between fruit and structure.
5 2023 Rosé of Cabernet Franc - Fresh and vibrant, with flavors of strawberries and a medium body that made for an easy-drinking, summer-friendly wine.
Red Wines
6 2023 Cabernet Franc - Classic red cherry, raspberry, and cedar notes, capturing the signature earthy and fruit-forward character of Finger Lakes Cabernet Franc.
7 2023 Sunny Side Red Blend - A soft yet structured blend with red plum, cigar box, and soft tannins, offering depth and an incredibly smooth finish.
Sparkling Wines & Pet-Nat
8 2023 Pet-Nat - A naturally sparkling wine that was fresh, fizzy, and bursting with crisp apple flavors.
9 N/V Sparkling Chardonnay - A slightly sweeter sparkling option with notes of pear, vanilla, and a creamy mouthfeel.
What Stood Out & What We Took Home
As we worked through the tasting, we were really impressed. The wines were refreshing, crisp, and perfectly dry--just the way we like them. Each one felt thoughtfully crafted, capturing the best qualities of the grapes while maintaining a clean, balanced profile.
While all the wines were well-made and enjoyable, one in particular stood out:
2023 Sunny Side Red Blend - This was my absolute favorite, with its rich red plum notes, subtle spice from the cigar box aroma, and velvety-soft tannins. It had that perfect combination of depth and drinkability, making it a wine I knew I wanted to open and enjoy at home. So, naturally, we purchased a bottle to go!
A Deeper Connection to Their Story
After the visit, I took some time to read more about the new owners--and I was truly impressed with how quickly they got the winery up and running with their own lineup of wines. Ria and Michael, the new owners, bring a wealth of experience and industry knowledge, which was evident in the quality of the wines.
One fun personal discovery? Ria and I actually have something in common! She teaches Viticulture and Enology, while I teach Computer Science--very different fields, yet we both share a deep appreciation for winemaking. I've always had a passion for enology, so it was great to learn about someone who is both an educator and deeply involved in the winemaking world.
Final Thoughts - A Winery Worth Revisiting
This stop turned out to be a terrific experience, and I'm already looking forward to coming back in the warmer months. I'd love to see how the winery continues to evolve under its new ownership, and of course, enjoy another glass of Sunny Side Red Blend while sitting outside, soaking in the lake views.
If you're visiting Seneca Lake, make sure to stop here--especially if you love dry, crisp wines with fresh, balanced flavors. It's exciting to see a historic property get a fresh new start, and based on what we tasted, the future is looking very bright for this winery.
Cheers to unexpected stops and discovering something new!