Our two-night experience at Thurston House was super solid. Our room was clean, the location is exceptional and the service perfectly fine. Was it worth $140? Everything on the island is a bit overpriced and I have nothing to compare it to so....I don't know.
The Inn: Thurston House is perfectly situated near the crossroads of the island. The primary restaurants, shops, bars and historic sites are all within easy walking range. The public beach access is only about a mile away. There are multiple porches and decks to take advantage of rain or shine, very nice for relaxing, talking to the other guests or sharing a quiet moment with your lovely companion.
The Room: We stayed in the Widgeon, which was small and clean. The traffic flow was awkwardly tight between the bed and the television cabinet and the decor is not my style. The television was funny- you just don't see 10" screens anymore- but had cable. The bathroom was fairly standard but with an exceptionally loud fan and not so great water pressure. This is probably a common trait on the island. The Widgeon has a great private entrance off a nice little side deck that no one but us seemed to use. We kept our windows open and got the killer late September island breeze.
The Breakfast: served between 8:30 and 9:30 in the common house, breakfast was quite communal. The Inn was full during our weekend so there were 8 of us in the indoor dining room and 4 more on the front porch. The first morning I had an amazing sweet potato pancake that was delicious without butter or syrup, some bacon, sausage and a fried egg. Day two saw more traditional hash browns, biscuit and scrambled eggs with bacon and country ham. Everything was very good. Also, there was access to an extremely nice fig cake, coffee and tea.
The Hosts: we didn't really get to interact with Donna nor her mother very much but everyone was friendly and quite helpful when we had questions or issues.
The Vibe: relaxed and pleasant. The other guests that weekend were a surprising mix of young and old, gay and straight, liberal and conservative. Due to timing and circumstances we had limited interaction....
The Result: we would definitely stay here again but would probably go somewhere else first, just for variety.
Things to keep in mind about staying in Ocracoke: mosquitoes! Bikes are great for the island, does your B&B have them for you or will you bring your own or rent them ($20/day)? Ferry space is super limited so make your return reservations early if your plans allow it. read more