I was planning on ordering from this place and I needed to call to ask a simple question. I asked if they take orders for pick as I was in a rush, but the man rudely screamed over the phone "no we don't take pick up you need to come in," and then hung up. He was extremely rude and the tone in his voice made me change my mind right away. My family has ordered from here and it is extremely overpriced too. I would suggest changing their name to one star bagels. read more

Back in North Jersey, had to grab a nice bagel sandwich for breakfast. On a weekday over spring break you can actually move in here, haha. The guys here are quick and helpful and the bagels are great. Bacon, egg, and cheese is the most popular here, so I finally broke down and got one. It was excellent. The go to bagel spot in Teaneck area! Check it out. read more

Three Star Bagels - Taylor ham, egg and cheese on wheat. Great start to my morning! - Bagels Near Me - Teaneck, New Jersey

See all

The owner is incredibly rude. I walked into the store and went to the counter to order some hot food and he barked out that that's the wrong place to order food and other people were there first. I had ordered hot food at this counter several times before and thought that was the place to go. No one was standing there. The other area was where people were ordering bagels not hot food so I thought. I so taken aback by his rudeness that I walked out of the store and went to Teaneck Bagels instead. I was a bit shook up so I saw a white infinity Q 50 in front of the store and open the door and sat in it. I own a white infinity Q 50 that was parked two cars away. The owner came running out after me and started yelling that that wasn't my car. I explained that I own the same exact car and I had made a mistake. He called me stupid and a moron. I got into my car and drove away very upset. I will never step foot there ever again. read more

Best bagels EVER! My sister & husband have been going for years, I used to drive from Carteret in Middlesex County to Teaneck just to get a supply of bagels & cream cheese. Moved to Teaneck 6 yrs ago & it is dangerous because they are only 2 minutes away & I can get their yummy bagels, cream cheese or sandwiches anytime. We always get their everything bagel, sesame, plain, raisin, & their fantastic handmade cream cheese. We get them always, the older man is such a sweetheart & so is the rest of his staff. To those who wrote the older man was rude, FYI if you're rude or demanding or impatient the older man will hand it right back to you! If you are nice, polite & patient, you will receive the same, be rude, disrespectful you also will get the same! read more

The bagels here are all you need. The cream cheeses/egg salad and other things are a bit pricey. I usually pick up a few bagels at once to last me the week. They're made fresh everyday as the owner told me and they definitely feel and taste that way. A staple for an early morning bagel if you're in the area. read more

Amazing bagels & quick service . Highly recommend this if you want a solid breakfast. Was in a rush for work and to my first job with a full stomach read more

Absolutely the most disrespectful owner and staff. I would not recommend this place at all . You can't ask a simple request without getting attitude or getting kicked out. Thank god there's other bagel stores in town that are way better with their customer service and bagels. read more

I will give credit where it is do, the breakfast sandwiches here are very good. They do great work. The bagels are pretty good, but I can't get over the fact that the owner is so overwhelmingly rude. Whenever I go in he has a bad attitude to the point where I stopped going, which is a shame because the food is good. He charges extra money for egg sandwiches after 11:00. I paid $11 for a bacon egg and cheese on a bagel with a hasbrown. I hope the attitude of this place changes. read more

I love this place. I've tried tons of bagel spots and this one is definitely my favorite. They're not only nice but they do a great job. They're quick & efficient and give you the perfect amount. My favorite is always a Taylor ham, egg & cheese ! read more

I go for the Bobo sandwich. This thing must weight 2-3 lbs. ridiculously good. Seasoned perfectly. Great variety of delicious bagels and cream cheese spreads. read more

I really like their bagels, but over $10 for 2 with cream cheese, wow! Super expensive. Can't have that every day. Cream cheese is $18 a pound, they price it by the half pound $8.95 1/2lbs. Maybe the bacon egg and cheese is the better deal. read more

It is definitely a favorite local bagel spot especially on Sundays after morning church service. There is an old world charm in the store with dated price signs to the layout that isn't seen in newer bagel shops. I always tried different combinations of bagel with cheese cheese from their wide assortment. My friends have tried the bagel sandwiches and have been very pleased with it. You can see when they put freshly made bagels in the mornings as they stock their see through counters periodically. read more

I am a new customer and have spent about 25 dollars a day for the last three days between breakfast and coming back for lunch. This morning I got a bagel and iced coffee for my boss and I went to grab sugar and the older man came over from behind the counter to watch me and was staring at me and then walked over to me and made me put the sugar back. I took two of each packet, as I didn't know which one my boss likes. He told me three packets Max. I felt very uncomfortable and think that was stingy for him to do. Not happy with this experience and won't return now. Unfortunate that you have to come out from the back of the counter to watch customers take sugar. Never heard of or seen that in my life. read more

Food is amazing!! I always get a Bacon, egg and cheese on a roll. The service is great and everyone is really friendly. Highly recommend this place to anyone in the area looking for good breakfast food. read more

Good service. Have gone multiple times for large orders in the morning and everyone there is kind.

I won't be revisiting this restraint again. I went here with my girlfriend for some breakfast during our morning walk. We ordered a hot tea, nesquik, sausage egg and cheese, and Taylor ham and egg. My girlfriend asked the old man working there if there was any honey for her tea and he said he doesn't let customers have honey, all they do is make a mess. She then asked if he had any honey in the back. He gave the cup to the guys behind the counter who immediately started mocking her and they put about 1/4 of the cup of honey which was obnoxious. Mistake#2 they gave me a bacon egg and cheese instead of sausage egg and cheese. Fine, but the bacon was super fatty and greasy. Also the eggs were a little undercooked and slimy. My girlfriend said her sandwich was ok at best. I had hoped this would have been a good experience as its walking distance from my home, but I guess I'll have to walk a bit farther. read more

Two friends and I stopped here yesterday mid-day for a cup of coffee and were happy they had some tables to sit at so we could visit with one another. I sat at one of the tables (there was only one other table occupied and a couple others were available) while my friends were paying for their coffee. I was promptly told that we could only sit at the table for 10 minutes and if we wanted to sit for half an hour, we needed to spend $10. I didn't see any signs detailing this policy and thought the person (owner?) instructing me of this policy was rather unpleasant and unwelcoming, to say the least. I got up and informed my friends about the time limit and then stood near the door while they finished up their transactions. I was then instructed (by the same person) to move out of the way. At that point I had had enough and waited outside for my friends. The coffee was good but I have no intentions of ever patronizing this establishment again, given the disrespectful way I was treated. I work in customer service and if I ever treated a customer the way I was treated, I would be severely reprimanded and put on notice. I wanted to share my experience so others are aware of this potential rude behavior on the part of the shop's management. I guess they don't want to cultivate and grow their business! read more

I can't address the comments about the owner or the employees or the service, because I've only had these at work. Our office daily gets bagels from Three Star Bagels, and they are the best bagels ever. Fresh with a crisp outside that I can't even properly describe. You know like the muffin top is the best part of the muffin - well the outside of the bagels is just perfect, but you don't want to waste the insides! Maybe they are like a NY bagel? They are large, they taste great and they are highly satisfying. read more

The store is a typical old bagel shop that needs some cosmetic upgrades. I got a sesame bagel with cream cheese. The bagel was good enough---nothing special---definitely better than the cardboard I find near Princeton. The owner, a small old man with a bald head and mustache, was nice at first. However, on the way out, I mistakenly thought I could take one empty coffee cup. Holy crap!!!! That old man ran out from behind the counter like a bat out of hell and confronted me and my mon, freaking out about the cup, shaking his head and arms like a loon saying, "No, you can't take the cup!" It was pretty embarrassing for him to make himself look that chintzy. Yet another example of bad customer service. Sigh. read more

It is time to finally post this long overdue review. I've tried many bagel places in the city and from comparison I'd say Three Star is a worthy competitor. I've been back about 4 times now, but my boyfriend is from the area and has been coming to the place since he was a kid. The bagels are pretty good and would be considered 5 stars in Northern VA where I'm from, however they can't touch the ones from Boxcar Bagels in Bogota. I won't go on a rant about how good those are, but with that being said, will also make the claim that the breakfast sandwiches are better here (e.g. egg, cheese & _____ meat) at Three Star. The middle seems more packed, a bit saltier, and greasier (in a good way). This could just seem* that way as Boxcar's bagels are quite large, but that's just my opinion. The owner has always been really friendly and service is always quick. Highly recommended if you haven't tried this place yet it! read more

2 times I have been there and both times terrible attitude by owner One time we ordered coffee and he rudely came over and said this was not a place to sit and how long we would be there Second time he use same hands that he counted money with to scoop out my bagel and refused to serve me with gloves - cancelled my order and said he couldn't scoop my bagels with gloves! Very unhygienic place!!! Watch Id they use gloves while handling money and same on your food They also don't wear fresh gloves One set all the time I would be careful if they prepare your meal Angry owner as well read more

I cannot tell you how many Bacon Egg and Cheese on salt Bagels I have had in this store over the last decade or 2, and that's not counting all the bagels with cream cheese as well. GREAT BF Sandwiches, and they put a lot in their sandwiches too. Prices are good - been going there so long, most of the time the guys know what I am going to get as soon as I come in and its always Delicious. Owner is super friendly and is always willing to make your experience there be the best. read more

Three Star Bagels - Food Goodness - Bagels Near Me - Teaneck, New Jersey

See all

We love the bagels at Three Star. I have yet to find a bagel shop in the New York area that can match these bagels. We drive 25 miles to pick up a dozen and then freeze them. If your looking for the perfect bagel then this is the place! read more

Absolutely the best homemade bagels every. They make their own cream cheese and it's amazing..... the service is fantastic!!!!! They are so loving and welcoming. Humble and funny! Love eating there..... love their bagels and cream Cheese,... their coffee not so much but their egg, pumpernickel and their Rye bagel are my favorite read more

My daughter and I have been going to three star bagels for more than 10 years. Their bagels are made daily. They are soft and delicious. Cosmo, the owner and employees are very friendly. read more

Out here visiting from Miami, found this place on Yelp. Everything was grate from the service to the food. Got the BOBO bagel! Thinking of getting another one! read more

In Bergen County, theres a few places for bagels worth driving to - but this is my favorite. Nice non-kosher deli in the middle of kosherville, Teaneck. There is a large selection of deli meats and fresh lox and a daily roasted Turkey, hand cut (with your choice of white/dark meat) for your sandwich. The bialy here is by far the best on this side of the Hudson and is a personal favorite. Unfortunately i have had my order completely botched a few times - oddly enough my orders were multiplied IE 1 bagel = 3 bagels or 1 bobo = a bobo and a hobo (their names for breakfast sandwiches) and turkey sandwich. This is forgivable though and besides - if you want the best food and don't mind arguing here and there over "I JUST ORDERED A DAMN BAGEL WITH BUTTA" then your gold. Atleast you get a story to tell your coworkers. read more

Best bagels around. Nice amount of crisp, chewy and depth of any bagel locally. Free bagel on 1/2 dozen too. So fresh. The owner is always nice and accommodating on my visits. If I lived locally I'd visit more often. Highly recommended. read more

Delicious bagels. Perfect texture, flavor, and amount of toasting. Coming from the city, the prices are ridiculously great. Egg and cheese was done right. Absolutely no issues with service or attitude, everyone was quite pleasant. Coffee was just ok. Amazingly, the sundried tomato cream cheese was chock full of actual sundried tomatoes, not some gross pink colouring. read more

The reviews below about the rudeness of the owner are true. I went to Three Star Bagel today and simply inquired as to why an omelette with bacon home fries and toast, two bagels (one with nothing and the other with plain creams cheese) and two coffees cost $30. I've paid less at diners with actual waiters and service (including 25% tip). The owner began to yell at me, threatened to not give me my food (which he then gave me after I asked for my money back). As I was leaving he was screaming "go to Tik Tock, go to Tik Tock." Referring to Tik Tock diner. I've been going to Three Star for bagels for more than a decade. But I'll take the owners advice and I'll go to Tik Tock Diner in Hackensack, Hot Bagels, the Coffee Shop, or Bagel Twist in Teaneck, or Tenafly Diner in Tenafly. What I will never again do is walk into Three Star Bagels so that I can be overcharged and then yelled at by an angry and bitter owner. There are better options with better service, do not waste your money here. read more

Bagels my one and only true love in this world... i have many favorite bagles spots in teaneck well on cedar lane this is the spot... They make the bagles just the way it should be thick and chewy! They have a special buy a dozen and get two free .... gives you a chance to try the different types . I will save you from there muffins yuck blan uhhh dont remind me :) but seriously save your $2.00 The menu is great sandwich's and lox bagles etc Staff mexicans are nice the owner however... hes nice to people he chooses to be nice to?? Im not here to review on ppl but on the food. Enjoy the bagels the do have a sit down area. read more

Best place to get bagels. I always enjoy them here they are the best around. I don't know if its this area but this place is amazing. Been going here for years I'll definitely recommend this place. read more

Outrageously expensive. Bagel price of $1 is ok but everything else is way high from things top put on bagels to drinks out of the cooler. For example a drink for 2.75 costs 2.09 one block away in Stop and Shop and 1.99 a block away at CVS. read more

Very rude!!! Called from our office 1 block away for delivery, ordered 2 sandwiches told minimum was four, called back with an order for four and man that answered said he was to busy to take an order and hung up. Will never go back!!! Would give no star rating but yelp wont let you do that. read more

Extremely over-priced for anything other than a plain bagel with nothing on it . Customer service is hit or miss, mostly miss . It's a shame because the food isn't too bad . It's just not worth the prices they're charging . read more

The Owner is very rude and disrespectful to his customers. I have been a loyal customer for many years, unfortunately the owner has no appreciation for that. I made an order, there a was misunderstanding, as their menu and prices are very unclear. When I calmly explained that the order was not what I wanted, and asked to change the order to something else, the owner rudely interrupted stating "we don't make 2 dollar sandwiches here!" I never asked for a 2$ sandwich, I just wanted to change the incorrect order. He refused to help me and was extremely unprofessional. In addition, the bagels lately haven't been the freshest and clearly they do not take constructive criticism very well. Steer clear of this place, who needs such a headache first thing in the morning. read more

So lets start by saying that the bagels and food from here are generally pretty good, they give you quite a lot of spread. That being said you're gonna pay 3.50 for a bagel with cream cheese. The main problem I have here is the attitude of the younger worker, he is always rude to customers saying stupid things that he has no place saying. Word to the management you should find someone that actually understands that they're working in customer service and isn't rude & condescending to the customers. People will pay more for good service and good food, but bad service, combative service? I won't be back anytime soon. Bagel Twist is right down the street and they are ALWAYS nice, and significantly better priced. read more

Overpriced rude owners and staff make us go elsewhere. It's a shame because the bagels are actually good.

Three Star Bagels should really be five stars. I really love this place and haven't found any other places that compare. Cosmo, the owner, is a really nice guy who always seems happy to help customers. My wife and I love their bagels. read more

Love Three Star. Had it on my first real journey to the trip state area 6 years ago, then moved up 1.5 years later. It's friggin' bangin'. The bagels are huge and top notch. Top that with the in house cream cheese and you're off to a dandy start to your day. Who needs NYC? read more