$5 for a pretty large small cone with sprinkles. Not bad at all. The sprinkles were fresh... very crunchy and not waxy tasting at all. The vanilla was just that. Very vanilla &, for lack of a better word, boring. It wasn't watery nor was it creamy. It wasn't gross either. It was just there. They have lots of other options if soft serve isn't your thing. It was a nice day out so I sat on one of their many benches instead of my car. They even have picnic tables in case you need to put a banana split down. The lady who served me was nice and appreciated that tiny tip I left. And trust me, it was tiny. Sorry. It's all I had. Overall, a chill place to treat yourself. read more

See all

Very good ice cream . I had the tiramisu. The others had blueberry and chocolate- vanilla yogurt. All good. Next to the fudge shop.

I absolutely love this ice cream parlor! They have so many choices and the ice cream is the best around! I love that you can venmo them the money too. I have been a customer there since they opened and love that they are open most of the year! Try them you'll like them! read more

Gotta love a walk up window ice cream spot. They are fairly new to Flemington (like a few years old) but I love seeing the crowd on hot summer nights. Their ice cream is pretty wonderful and I am still searching for a flavor I don't love. The last trip included a scoop of tiramisu in a sugar cone and oh man, just so good. Loved that you could actually taste all of the tiramisu goodness mixed with creamy ice cream. It was a hot day and I could not have been happier. Can't wait for another trip and another flavor! read more

Thee Ice Cream Parlor - Tiramisu - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

Stumbled upon this place while driving to Old Hope, PA. The entire parlor looked inviting and gave a vintage vibe. Little did I know that I would discover a new favorite flavor for my sweet tooth midnight cravings. They didn't not have dine-in and it was only served through the windows. It was all home-made ice-creams. I saw another customer going through the menu and he said he is a frequent and his wife loved the "Black Raspberry Chunks" and I ended up tasting and it was a love-at-first-taste. Still I ended up getting a small sized Black Raspberry. The first spoon made me decide I would end up buying a pint for my home. The ice-cream was rich and still affordable at 3.75$ for a small. Every spoon was rich and creamy so that reminds us the quality of the dish. End of day I got a pint for $8. read more

Friendly and quick service on a busy Sunday afternoon. Yummy cherry vanilla ice cream with big bing cherries. My husband had black raspberry with chocolate chunks. Lots of specialty sundaes too read more

My mom and I decided to stop by Thee Ice Cream Parlor to try some homemade ice cream on our way back from shopping. We both got small sugar cones! I got the Vanilla Peanut butter which was good but nothing crazy. Then my mom got the Cappuccino Blast which was definitely more unique and very delicious. Every time I pass it there is always a line! So be prepared to wait in line, we waited almost 10 minutes. My only suggestion is to bring your own extra spoon because there is a 10 cent charge for an extra one... lol Would I go back again? Yes! Would I go out of my way to pick it up? No, but if im driving by I definitely would stop! read more

Thee Ice Cream Parlor - Cappuccino Blast - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

See all

Was looking for an old time ice cream parlor and had read a review that had this place highly rated. Unfortunately, they seemed to have closed off the dining area and only had takeout service. The ice cream itself was a little crystalline, lacking the nice creamy texture that we look for an ice cream. I tried the cappuccino flavored, which I could only describe as unusual. Very friendly service. read more

The ice cream is THE BEST!. Cherry vanilla has lots of real bing cherries in it. They offer many different types of cones so many delicious toppings. Don't pass it by. read more

nothings special . very sweet and artificial colors . I got the chocolate hazelnut that tasted like chocolate with chocolate syrop and brandy in it rather than any hazelnuts - nobody liked that flavor. The pricing was fair and staff very nice. read more

Home made ice cream tons of fans. Can't go wrong. Long hours too. I love sundaes but cones are great too

Great variety of ice cream flavors and the sundaes and shakes are excellent too. I wish they would open the indoor dining area but the ice cream is good enough that I can eat in my car and still be happy. read more

Old school ice cream parlor. Walk up window for ordering. There was a good amount of parking by the shop and at the adjacent fudge shop. We stopped in on a Sunday afternoon and it was very busy. We were glad to see that people were being good about social distancing and wearing masks at the counter. They have lots of ice cream options to choose from, and we went with vanilla soft serve, dipped in cherry magic shell, on sugar cones. Really nice quality. Delicious. Everyone enjoyed it. Nearly $15 for 3 cones seemed to be a bit steep. But we had a nice time nonetheless. Five stars. read more

Greatest sundaes and soft serve in the area! TICP has a really good selection of flavors, and a cute '50's vibe. Veronica and the rest of the staff are always smiling and it's amazing how they seem to remember what your favorite flavor is. Right now Peach is the way to go, but I think that's not going to be around much longer as a seasonal flavor. The owner Rachel works her tail off the keep the place spotless and running smoothly, and even somehow manages to stay pleasant in the face of skyrocketing supply costs, surly delivery drivers, and Complaining Karen's. I don't know how she does it - I'd be out of business or in jail, dealing with some of these crazies. For Pete's sake, it's ice cream, people... you're supposed to be happy! read more

Really really great ice cream, good vibes and atmosphere and loved the outdoor seating. Just a couple things they can work on: 1) could definitely use more flavor options. The ones they have are really good but there should be more of a variety. 2) a small pet peeve, but ice cream parlors shouldn't just put a scoop on top of a cone, they should fill the actual cone a bit as well. In general, I will absolutely come back. The sundae wall was great and the ice cream tasted fantastic. read more

See all

I got a chocolate ice cream it was so good I loved it really much you can't eat inside

Nice ice cream window stop but unfortunately the ice cream did not taste very fresh. There were ice chunks and texture was not rich or creamy. The flavors we tried were a bit too blah. Who knows-- Maybe it was an off day in March? read more

Always busy and its obvious why! Delicious icecream for a reasonable price. They offer so many flavors and toppings galore! My parents are fussy icecream eaters but they loved it! 100% a go to spot! read more

Thee Ice Cream Parlor - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

Very good ice cream. Rich and creamy. The vanilla peanut butter was really good. First time ever having that and I'll return for that alone. Service was fast and friendly. read more

See all

Not even one star worthy. The owner is incredibly rude and disrespectful. They surcharge 3.5% to buy their product too. That doesn't make clear business sense considering the average dollar spent using a Card vs cash is 3x higher. Why would anyone think turning away a customer who wants to buy product is the right decision regardless of the payment method. ? TICP isn't operating like they know how to run a business. If you want customers bake into your operating model. Bad business decisions and awful product. Do not give them a penny of your money. I was offering the owner advice, given I am 20 years in the business, and she swatted me away with venom and her ears plugged. read more

Great place for a savory ice cream! Consistently good and great service! Plenty of regular ice cream flavors complemented by seasonal ones. Prices are ok as well. read more

Thee Ice Cream Parlor is far superior to Polar Cub, hands down. Better parking, better ice cream. They have a wide variety of seasonal and year-round flavors. None of them are duds, but I gravitate toward the tiramisu. Service is very slow but it's worth the wait. read more

Delicious ice cream, quick and welcoming service and a great price. What more could you ask for?

Ice cream was ok, but sictomer service was terrible. One girl was in the back eating pretzels, rather than helping customers. One girl was talking to her boyfriend sitting at the counter, rather than helping customers. That left, one person helping customers are the window outside, and one girl helping customers inside. The girl who took my order ate gummy bears with her bare hands while making my Sunday. Also, some whipped cream fell off of my sunday onto the counter, and the same girl proceeded to use the spoon for my sunday to scoop it off of the counter, AND PUT IT BACK ON MY SUNDAY! It was disgusting... I won't be going back here. The customer service, attention to cleanliness, and lack of sanitary serving practices are the worst I've seen in a long time. read more

Ice cream cakes are outstanding! Always my go to for special occasion cakes! The presentation is beautiful and taste delicious

This place makes me laugh every time I drive by if. I recall my last visit where the teenage girl lost control of her he chocolate shake she was trying to mix under the mixing machine, and needless to say there was ice cream splatter on the wall, her hair and even a little on the ceiling. Exhausted, dazed and confused she finally gave us the shake, chocolate still dripping from her head, and hesitantly asked if that was all. I actually wanted a second shake but didn't have the heart to ask so I just got a cup of soft serve. Ice cream was good. read more

We stopped at the Ice cream Parlor for a snack after visiting Northlands. This is a good old fashioned ice cream shop with plenty of seating, and a wide selection of hard and soft serve. While it is not cheap, everything that we ordered was fresh and delicious. This is a recommended stop when your in the area. read more

This is chemical ice cream so if that's what you want then go here. Maybe requesting organic homemade ice cream will motivate people to create it? Hope so read more

Average ice cream and they use styrofoam. The location is a bit tough as there is really nothing around. The interior is kind of fun, with a '50s sort of feel. Service is not great - fast but the servers do not listen. Probably won't come back. read more

What an adorable ice cream joint that commits to a fun 1950s theme and also serves delectable treats! They offer a wide variety of hard & soft serve ice cream, any topping you could ask for (they even have wet walnuts - an old school topping your parents might murder for) and the staff is happy to provide you with a sample of their unique flavors. Their salted caramel screamed fall -- throw in a drizzle of legit old school hot fudge sauce, and I was in flavor country. They apparently to kids parties and had some fun Halloween cakes for sale, so there's definitely more here to check out. Next time I'm in town, we're definitely going out for dessert! read more

They did an amazing job hosting kids while we had an adult party at Cook to Order two doors down. The ice cream cakes are amazing and we love the owners. It is so nice to have an ice cream place that isn't a chain- Check out their Wednesday night movies on the lawn. They create summer memories. read more

Update: This place changed its hours on the page then tried to tell me I was wrong, omg! What a shitty practice. Google cache caught her in the lie!! Bye bye!!! read more

Best ice cream parlor this side of heaven...come all the way from Branchburg...if u r on weight watchers or any type of diet they have u covered and the customer service is 5 star!! read more

I banned this place after bringing my son and his friends for ice cream after a birthday party. After spending a significant amount of money on several ice creams, the kids were laughing and having fun (as kids should do). There were NO other customers in there at the time and the owner came out and meanly told the kids to keep it down. I did not appreciate her tone and was clear with her I didn't. She rudely told me to have them keep it down where I turned and said we would leave and never be back. Which I haven't. The kids were speaking in a normal voice and not running around or being disrespectful. She was clearly having a bad day and NO way to run a business or speak to a customer. If you want to have fun go elsewhere, it's frowned upon at this establishment!! read more

The best best customer service, best ice cream, cleanest bathrooms, low prices- awesome variety - Flemington hidden treasure!!!! read more

The product there is wonderful! The problem I had was with the owner who was speaking with another customer about how teenagers didn't deserve the same wages as young adults or adults. For.doing.the.same.job. I'm sure if it had been a conversation about women not deserving as the same wages as men, being a business owner, she would have been pretty upset. I will not be returning. read more

I thoroughly enjoyed Thee Ice Cream Parlor! Great flavors, good prices and most importantly, very friendly employees! The decor takes you back to early style Ice Cream stores! Love it! read more

I went here on a Saturday night around 5:30 PM and it was pretty crowded which is always a good sign. I ordered frozen yogurt with red velvet flavoring topped with rainbow sprinkles and my boyfriend ordered two scoops of hard ice cream with rainbow sprinkles. Our total was $10.65 which is was a little pricey in my opinion for the size. The hard ice cream was decent - coconut almond swirl and peanut butter. My red velvet didn't taste like anything red velvet but it tasted like a good vanilla soft serve. Overall- expensive but good ice cream. Not a place to frequent but for a special treat I'd go back. read more

Great local ice cream shop! The interior has a 50s diner feel. The outside seating is great to hang out with active children. It's conveniently located on 202. I believe they relocated to this new space about a year ago. read more

Excellent ice cream choices. Chocolate hazelnut and tiramisu are amazing. They have every ice cream topping you could want. read more

Thee Ice Cream Parlor - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

See all