This is my favorite restaurant so far in Lancaster. Customer service is great here!! I've ordered from the DoorDash app and now I live only 5 minutes away!!! Everything I have add is amazing. Tonight I ordered a Rachel sandwich with fries and a pickle. Honestly, it's the best Rachel I've ever had!!! Last time I ordered the Steak, steak , steak pizza and it was the best quality steak I've ever had on a pizza. Food both times was fast, hot and delicious. Everyone I encountered was super friendly and welcoming and I will be back sooner than later. Thank you for the great service!!! read more

See all

I've been here a couple times years ago with coworkers during lunchtime and decided to come by with friend today to check it out myself. Always remember the food was really good. Today, same thing, the food was really good. My friend ordered the macaroni and cheese with pork belly, I tasted the mac and it was delicious! I ordered a bacon, egg burger, asked for it to be cooked well, no pink, and it arrived with lots of pink. Instead of sending it back, I just ate half and brought the rest to go so I can cook and eat it later. Our waiter was great, I forget his name though, nice guy. So, when I arrived at 11:15am there was only one other couple seated. I walked in and said hello to the waitress (think her name was Sally), she gave me a very dry hello, I told her I was waiting for someone, she said they weren't there yet, sat me down for two, said something else but it was under her breath, I couldn't hear her, didn't feel very welcomed but it's okay. Our table had crumbs on it, my menu had crumbs on it. I was disappointed but honestly, I just wanted to have a good brunch with my friend so I cleaned it myself. I finally had a moment to take in the decor and it made me feel a little uneasy as I noticed a Hindu Buddha head, some scary dolls, sculptures and some weird decor going on, goats everywhere except one wall that had monkeys on it. Goats and monkeys are fine, just saying it was weird Whatever. Lol That's fine and all but it's just not my thing. read more

We had a very mixed experience here. The staff and prices and pretzels were excellent! We ordered their berber pizza and it was really really bad. The spice level was off the charts and it tasted very earthy but not in a good way. The waitress and manager were kind enough to comp another pizza for us so we ordered the goat cheese and fig pizza. But it came with Bleu cheese. We had waited for so long for the first pizza that by the time we got to the second it had been well over an hour we took it home. When we got to eating the pizza and discovered it was Bleu instead of goat I was out and had cereal for dinner. I can't stand bleu cheese and never would have ordered it. I was very disappointed because the pizza was not cheap and to be unable to eat basically any of it was very frustrating. I can't say for sure we'd come back again. read more

See all

I stopped by this restaurant for the first time and was pleasantly surprised! The menu features all the American classics such as pizza, sandwiches, fish fry. I was feeling a little adventurous. I normally get either a cheese or pepperoni pizza but I ordered the Berbere Pizza and it was absolutely delicious. The roasted chicken paired perfectly with their award-winning Berbere wing sauce--spicy, flavorful, and well-balanced. The caramelized onions and garlic added a rich depth while the goat cheese and mozzarella made every bite creamy and satisfying. The spinach gave it a nice fresh touch. It was one of the most flavorful pizzas I've had in a while. I'm already planning to come back and try more from the menu! Our waitress was lovely and came by pretty often. You can also bring your four-legged friends and sit on the patio. read more

The Yelling Goat - Bars Near Me - Lancaster, New York

DELICIOUS food!! I had a short rib sandwich on homemade bread. Husband had the wings which he really enjoyed. Service was a little slow, but the food more than made up for it! Will be back. read more

The Yelling Goat - Bars Near Me - Lancaster, New York

Have never had a bad meal here. It is a bit more on the $$$ side but the food quality and serving sizes make it much more reasonable. I love their berbere spice based dishes, especially the wings. They added great M-Thu happy hour specials and Tuesday is wing night! Check out the wings. I believe they are top 10 in Buffalo!!! read more

See all

It's a cute restaurant and I liked the wooden tables. We had a reservation and were seated promptly. We were put in the bar area and it was very loud. Our server came promptly and did a good job. There were a lot of good choices on the menu. I asked his advice on a meal choice and he mentioned the short ribs which I ordered. They came with mashed potatoes and a salad. We also got bread and a dipping oil which we usually prefer over butter but didn't care for this one. I don't like that I got my meal before my salad so didn't really eat it. It was field greens which I don't care for anyway. The short ribs were good but not tender but I liked the gravy on them. My husband got the huge prime rib which was good but not tender at all. I just don't think the food was worth the price but willing to give it another chance in the future. read more

See all

Been here a few times over the years. Always great. Had the Cuban today. I'm a huge Cuban fan and this was definitely top 5. Plenty of ham and pork, flavorful swiss cheese, a great pickle layer, and properly used yellow mustard and not honey or Dijon like some places. read more

The Yelling Goat - Cuban - Bars Near Me - Lancaster, New York

Delicious and flavorful burger. Definitely a must try. The atmosphere is perfect, not too loud where you have to yell to your friends and not to quiet either. Friendly staff with attention to great service. read more

The Yelling Goat - Bacon and Bacon Egg Burger - Bars Near Me - Lancaster, New York

See all

Sat at the bar and was greeted quickly by friendly staff. Started with the bourbon BBQ wings -- large, meaty, and coated in a phenomenal sauce. If you like extra crispy wings, I'd recommend asking for them that way. For dinner, I had the steak and goat cheese calzone, and wow -- this thing could easily feed three or more people! They let me know upfront it would take a little longer to bake, which I appreciated. Totally worth the wait -- loaded with plenty of tender steak and creamy goat cheese. Also tried the pork belly pizza, which was fantastic. Each slice had thick, melt-in-your-mouth pieces of pork belly -- rich, flavorful, and perfectly cooked. We went on a weekday night, so it wasn't too busy, but I've been here when it's packed and the service is always consistently good. Bonus points for the outdoor patio still being open -- and it's dog-friendly! Highly recommend for great food, generous portions, and a relaxed atmosphere. read more

This review is mixed because we had mixed feelings when we left. With that said, to start off on a really strong note, the wings we got were fabulous. The perfect mix of crispy on the outside and tender, juicy meat on the inside. My husband and I both agreed that we will definitely bring friends there for wings sometime. The second aspect that was amazing was our server, and I believe her name was Abriana. She was so helpful and attentive. They even had a large event going on which she was serving for and never let that keep her from her other tables. She truly was so sweet and did a great job. As far as the entrees, this is where we felt a little let down. We both ordered the pork belly burger and it just didn't meet our expectations. The burger itself was ok but we assumed the pork would be on the burger rather than on the side. It was just hard to eat and the flavor/texture of the pork was dry and underwhelming for both of us. We felt that it could have been better considering how good our other meals there have been. We still very much love the yelling goat and chalk it up to one dish that just isn't our favorite. In general, it's a great local fav and worth a try! read more

See all

We were a group of 4 for dinner. I ordered the broiled fish fry. It was accompanied by fries, macaroni salad and coleslaw. A very nice meal with excellent service. The atmosphere was nice and conducive to conversation. My friend had the duck that he raved about. A very nice dinner. We will r read more

See all

First time here, what a great establishment! The place was packed but we had made reservations since it was a Friday night Our friends joined us for dinner. The waitress was wonderful! I had the bunless burger and my husband had the fish fry. Our friends also had a bunless burger and a duck entrée - everything was delicious! We started out with the spinach artichoke Dip, which was absolutely amazing! We met the Owner's son, Collin, who is now running the place as the original owners have now taking a much needed, and deserved retirement. I absolutely love that they are Dog Friendly on their outdoor patio and I will have to bring my dogs. We met an adorable dog named cupcake. Highly recommend read more

See all

Absolutely wonderful experience here all the way around and I would be happy to come back! We came in on Cinco de Mayo and for reference, they had a special menu in addition to their usual with drinks, apps, and entrees. First, they automatically bring out nice and fluffy bread with a balsamic dipping oil. They will offer you more if you like but one basket was enough for us. I had a hard time deciding what to eat as the menu was very big and I like almost everything. I settled on the country fried steak as u haven't had it in many years. It comes with the gravy and mashed potatoes and then you can pick one additional side. I chose the vegetable of the day which was steamed broccoli. Everything was fantastic. Even the gravy was nice and flavorful (I've definitely experienced bland gravy and this was NOT) and had the perfect consistency. The mashed potatoes were amazing and had some garlic to it. Even the steamed broccoli was perfectly cooked with some olive oil to just the right tenderness. In addition to all this, it was enough good to bring home an entire second meal. All staff members were nice. Our waitress was attentive and we never had an empty drink or had to wonder where she or our food was. I look forward to another visit here soon! read more

See all

Pizza was amazing! It was worth the hour drive! Friendly bartenders and a great environment. read more

The Yelling Goat - Deep dish pizza - Bars Near Me - Lancaster, New York

We went on a Friday eve, the restaurant and bar were busy as expected but we were seated for our reservation on time. The vibe is farm chic. We sat in the main dining room, service was decent. The only thing that affected the vibe was the constant slamming of the kitchen door every time the staff entered or exited the kitchen. I ordered the steak salad, portion was huge, steak was cooked to my liking. I got ranch instead of horseradish dressing. read more

See all

Prices are a little higher than places nearby, but as Long as they continue to use good quality ingredients, I am okay with that. The Mac and cheese.... Absolutely phenomenal. You can get away with the medium. You do not need the large. It doesn't reheat at home as good (oil). Of course everything is better fresh :-) Please let the cooks know that no pink does not mean cook allll the moisture out. It was so overcooked, or held under a warming light, my egg on top was completely cooked through so no runny egg to assist with the overcooked burger. Let me be clear... an overcooked burger and egg is not the fault of the waitress!! Besides that... everyone's mess were fantastic. My friend got a pizza.. that thing looked FANTASTIC and with all the stuff on top of it, the dough did not buckle. Gordon Ramsey would approve. Don't sleep on the milkshakes. Under $9 and great! Alcohol from the bar- I do not drink, not a fan, My friend ordered a mixed drink and said it tasted very watery. I took a sip because if anyone could taste it, it would be me... she wasn't lying. Maybe the base mix was too watery but the whole drink was pretty watered down. Our waitress was fantastic. The drink or the burger was not her fault. Would come back for her. read more

2nd visit here. The first was with a large group (my book club,) and the food and service were outstanding. This time, just hubs and me, our weekly date night. Wednesday evening, good-sized crowd. We didn't wait for a table, but I noticed there weren't many open seats at the bar. The food and service were top-notch, the menu is HUGE. Expect to need some extra time to make a decision, cause you'll be telling the server you need a few more minutes. read more

See all

The restaurant, bar and staff are great! The food is always good and consistent. They are always super busy so what do that tell u about the food? I am Celiac and they have some gluten free options and havent be disappointed here at all. Go and enjoy. U won't be disappointed. read more

The Yelling Goat earns five stars in every category. The host and hostess who greet you when you first walk in, the servers, the bartender who bids you good night, the staff here create a very welcoming environment. Our waitress Shelley was there whenever we needed anything, she was pleasant, she got our order correct and despite the place being packed, the wait time was very reasonable. The ambience at this restaurant is fun, and compels you to walk around to see what's in the next corner. There are amusing knickknacks and conversation starters wherever you turn. Gotta love the vintage Zoltar machine when you first walk in! Now let's get down to it. The food. The corned beef is excellent. Someone at this restaurant truly knows how to select, season, prepare, cut and serve corned beef. Enthusiasts know that if you cut the corned beef the wrong way, it is tough as shoe leather but if you cut it just right, across the grain, it melts in your mouth. I grew up on the corned beef of Manhattan, the Bronx, the metro New York area and during my travels, I have found only a handful of places throughout the country that meet those standards. Yelling Goat is on that short list. The corned beef is not piled up as high on the sandwich as at some of the other places, but it's piled high enough to make an absolutely and thoroughly enjoyable sandwich. The seeded rye bread is fresh and delicious. Served of course with a pickle on the side. My wife's burger came rare - as ordered - which was much appreciated. It was a large burger and very tasty. Their wine list is limited, but adequate. My wife had a glass of Malbec which complemented her beautiful burger perfectly. As soon as we sat down, our waitress brought over a basket of bread and nice dipping oil with balsamic vinegar. The stuffed hot banana peppers were a nice appetizer for the table. If the place wasn't so packed with people, I would have sought out to shake the hand of whoever prepared and cut the corned beef. Five well earned stars. read more

See all

This place has the biggest menu of all the fun things . Lots of comfort food , everything from pizza to yummy entrees . The drinks are all amazing , and so many . Service was good too ! Big inside so plenty big seating and not loud at all . read more

The service was good. The food was OK. I got sliders with fries. My White Russian was good and the food was subpar. The only flavor to the burgers was what they put on them. The fries tasted like the oil was a little bit old. My final take is good service and atmosphere, a little pricey ($17 for salad?), menu is a bit too much and all over the place. read more

As promised, an updated review based on last week's visit after attending a matinee at the Lancaster Opera House. I really wish I could award more stars, but... For what it's worth, my dining companions all were raving about their meals, but I was not as impressed. Our server Maddy was great. She was obviously very busy, but still was attentive and went above and beyond when one member of our party recalled the 20% offer in our theater program. Once we presented our playbills and clipped out the ad, the deduction helped what I thought were fairly high prices compared to other places I've been recently. I haven't paid $9.95 for a glass of wine in quite some time, and $17.95 for a reuben was a tad steep as well. But my biggest issue? If you're a vegetarian and want a sandwich after 4 pm, you're s*!t outta luck. No grilled cheese, no portabello sandwich. So I was pretty much stuck with ordering my usual meatless reuben. Meh. Yelling Goat, I truly want to love you as much as my friends do, but you gotta show me some love in return, okay? read more

The yelling Goat Is a warm quaint with very friendly professional staff, yummy food and great pizza.

They got a nice selection of draft beers not too many so it becomes hard to choose ! Four of us all got the Ruben sandwich , ( it was highly recommend by our son). you got your choice of fries or onion ring so the wife and I got one of each. The meat was very tender chunks of fresh cooked, delicious, good amount of meat and sauerkraut , it melted I. Your mouth fantastic! The onion rings were very good and crispy! The fries were Ok. Service was good and the place is simple and comfortable!, read more

My boyfriend and I came here for a late dinner after a sip and shop event in the village of Lancaster. We sat at the bar. The staff was friendly and helpful. I went with the bun less burger. It was a burger served on a portabella mushroom with greens and tomatoes. It also came with fries. The burger was delicious. I would recommend this dish. My boyfriend had a burger and enjoyed his as well. This will probably be one of our hang outs, so more updates and reviews to come. read more

The Yelling Goat - Bunless burger - Bars Near Me - Lancaster, New York

We ordered in and decided to go back to one of our favorite local places. Yelling Goat is always good. I typically always get the chicken fried steak but seeing as it was lunch, I opted for the burger. This cheeseburger is a masterpiece of culinary artistry, with a juicy and perfectly cooked beef patty that is HUGE. The cheese is melted to perfection, and the toppings are fresh and flavorful, including crispy lettuce, and tangy pickles. The bun is soft and fresh, with just the right amount of toasted crispness on the outside. Overall, if you are a fan of cheeseburgers, this one is definitely worth trying. My wife got the chimi pizza and it was so good! I was a little hesitant at first but the flavor on this is incredible. Next time we're getting a large. YG is always a good time and we've never had a bad meal from here. We're definitely keeping them on our shortlist for go-to spots near home. read more

See all

Had a corned beef sandwich on rye. The corned beef was so tender and flavorful. The rye was great too. Our server was very nice. It was a very good meal. read more

We asked the bartender for some recommendations and he was extremely knowledgeable about the menu and even the history and background of the flavors and how they fit with each other. I also hear that they have a cheese connoisseur working in the kitchen! Baked Brie 10/10 Melted cheese is always awesome. Not a huge fan of nuts, but the cherry walnut pesto kinda made this dish. Creaminess from the cheese, nuttiness and a pop of flavor from the pesto, and a crunch from the toasted bread. Truffle Burger 8/10 Added goat cheese. These burgers are huge! Asked for medium rare, was cooked perfectly. Very juicy. The truffle you could smell from a mile away. Was amazing. Pink inside. Goat cheese went great with the truffle to add to that umami flavor. The only suggestion would be maybe to season the meat a bit more with salt/pepper/ maybe garlic too. read more

See all

LOVE the food and service here, but the vibe stinks when you walk in. John Tesh or Enya playing at 10% volume every time I'm there. What's up with that? Zoltar is the only thing I can ever hear. Dump Zoltar, and play some good music (70s, 80s) that appeal to your audience. Something with a beat. read more

The Yelling Goat - Beef on weck w/cheddar - Bars Near Me - Lancaster, New York

See all

Great food...... Great service.... nice atmosphere. Will definitely be a regular place for dinner. Can't wait to try the berbere wings and a calzone. Already planning my next visit!! read more

See all

Went here for my brother-in-law's birthday. The restaurant was busy for a Tuesday night, which was awesome to see. We had a drink at the bar, and then sat down for dinner. The food was amazing and everyone raved about their dinners. I had the Mac and cheese and can honestly say it's the best I've had at a restaurant. We truly enjoyed ourselves and will be back. read more

Goats and Wing Kings have a lot in common. First, goats and the Wing Kings of Castle each have four stomachs. Second, they are both herd animals and will become depressed if kept without their companions. And finally, counter to the dominant stereotype about being willing to eat anything, goats and Wing Kings are very picky eaters. Unfortunately for the Yelling Goat, the Wing Kings pickiness will become apparent in this review. Location/service: 4.5 / 5 Lots to like here. Fantastic patio and a great beer menu. Our server, Trish, was very attentive and seemed genuinely interested in ensuring we were enjoying ourselves. The complimentary bread bowl was a great touch and left us very excited for what was to come. Presentation: 3 / 5 Plated in a pile, presentation was just okay and they made a common (and costly) mistake of omitting celery. We don't focus much on dipping sauce but it's time; While we usually reward any attempt at uniqueness, replacing bleu cheese with a watery, salty, mystery concoction called "goat sauce" was not helpful to their score. Meat: 3 / 5 Too large with bones jutting out (that's what she said). "Wait, isn't more meat better," you ask? Not necessarily; keep reading. Cook: 5 / 10 Chewy and gummy. A deadly adjective combination. Regular readers know we prefer a healthy crisp to our wings and these didn't have it. A few flavors even seemed a bit undercooked. Really tough to properly cook an oversized wing. Standard Wing: 10 / 15 The medium had some potential but hard to get past 'chewy, gummy and undercooked' so they were pretty forgettable. Imagine getting your favorite take out pizzeria wing and letting them sit in the car too long. Specialty: 6.5 / 10 We were excited to try the Berbere (Ethiopian spice) and they were pretty good - actually had a good crisp -- but the flavor was basically regular Cajun with a different name. The Southwestern were just okay and the BB&B were just Southwestern. Honey Dijon built on the 'chewy' and 'gummy' attributes by adding 'slimy' and 'gross'. Yelling Goat was definitely not the Yelling G.O.A.T. As a result, you'll find them on the waiver wire. Overall score: 32 / 50 read more

The Yelling Goat - Bars Near Me - Lancaster, New York

Hands down the best Ruben I have ever had!!!! Stopped on a whim and will definitely be back!! After talking with the super friendly bartender, we learned that 90 percent of the menu is made in house including 5 different red sauces, pizza crust and home made bread!!! I had a simple house salad to start with crumble blue cheese and Italian dressing and it was amazing. The Ruben came with fries and it was like eating fair food!! They were so good and had flaky salt that gave depth to the taste! Y'all need to hit this place up!!! read more

The Yelling Goat - Best Ruben ever!!!!! - Bars Near Me - Lancaster, New York

Food and service were both excellent. Ambiance was good. Very loud in the dining room. Definitely a bar and beer crowd. Food came out quickly and was very good. read more

Ordered the roast beef on kimo, what I received was a cheap hamburger roll with 3 kimoweck seeds and shaved roast beef cold cut meat Not going back read more

The food was very good. We had a pizza that was different from the regular cheese and pepperoni. Loved it! Tons of beer choices.

I went to the Yelling Goat with a close friend for my Birthday. We had a server named Ava. She immediately made us feel welcome and was very informative about the choices. The food was perfect, the atmosphere perfect, and the drinks were perfect. Ava understood exactly what we wanted and was available throughout the evening. I would recommend anyone to go to this restaurant , the food, and the server Ava made it all an excellent birthday visit there. We will be back read more

I have no idea why it has taken me so long to visit this establishment. I started with the sliced fresh/fried mozz "rounds" in their marinara. Lightly breaded, all four set on a nice scoop of the marinara. I really liked the thin crust pizza. Flank steak was nice and tender. The fresh cup of pico was the perfect topper. Palate took a beating because of the temp. Well worth linking off the bubble later. Got three pieces for snack later! Lucky me!! I'll be back!!! read more

The Yelling Goat - The Mexico Pizza - Bars Near Me - Lancaster, New York

See all

Fantastic food. Generous portions. Can be loud. The menu is varied. And I highly recommend anything with the corned beef. Best I have ever had. read more