OK, so I have given 5 stars to a few other pizza places during my time on Yelp but HEAR ME, THIS ONE IS DEFINITELY THE BEST I've had in SC and among the best including NY/NJ pizza places. We had a plain pie with double sauce and double cheese and it was very impressive. The sauce was among the most flavorful that I've had anywhere and the cheese was as good as anywhere I've ever been. Dela Ventura's, also in Simpsonville, has similarly good cheese but the sauce and crust at Slice of Brooklyn was much better (not that Della Ventura was bad...it was good!) The owner, Mike, just added house made pasta to his menu and I happened to be there while it was being prepared....looked great! The here-say is that the guy who made pasta at Jianna in downtown Greenville is now making the pasta for Mike. If so, I'm going to have a weight problem between the pizza and the pasta. The space is nice and can accommodate a good number of people and the location, in downtown Simpsonville, is very walkable with lots of interesting small businesses nearby. Stop by and try a slice and see if I'm right. You won't be sorry!! read more

The Slice - Mother loves her Peroni while waiting for her pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Simpsonville, South Carolina

I don't get the hype about this place. The pizza was like any generic "NY-style" pizza shop. It wasn't bad, but nothing special. They added a lot of meat toppings but hardly any cheese even though we ordered (and paid $4 for) extra cheese. The house salad was $5 for romaine lettuce then a handful of shredded mozzarella, some sliced cucumber, and 2 wedges of tomato. It was basically all just lettuce. The house red wine vinaigrette dressing has very little flavor, just tasted like olive oil. It does have a cool atmosphere and our server was super nice. I just think this was way too expensive for mediocre pizza. read more

Yum yum yummmmmmm. Moved close to this place a couple months ago and finally got around to trying it. What captured my attention was the garlic rolls posted on a GVL eats page so we RAN here. Unfortunately they were out of garlic rolls and the pasta I wanted to try "vodka made me do it" so I tried the ziti instead. Not my favorite. The cheese to sauce ratio just wasn't my cup of tea, and that's okay! Because their pizza was absolutely delicious. Closest to NY PIZZA we have had since moving to SC. my boyfriend had the chicken wings and he realllly enjoyed them. for now until I can try their garlic rolls. Look forward to coming back read more

See all

New York style pizza. We had the Arancini appetizer and Hawaiian pizza. I had a Peroni on tap which I highly recommend as it's a taste of Italy in a glass! The Arancini were good. I have to say that I was a little disappointed in the Hawaiian pizza. Only a third of it had any sauce and no spices. I expect basil at a minimum but like rosemary for flavor. They did have Oregano and a few other spices on the table. I just thought the pizza was bland until you got to the third with the sauce. Hence why it's 4 and not 5 stars. I'll try again to see if it is just the Hawaiian made that way or all of the pies. read more

Fantastic! Now my favorite pizza in the simpsonville area. Crust is actually a new york style crust, many claim to be new york style but this actually is a ny style crust for a change. So good, but keep in mind this 5 star is based on pizza in the area Large cities like NY STL ATL etc this would be a 3 star pizza. Since I don't live in a big city anymore all that matters is this pizza vs area pizza and compared to this area this is a fantastic pizza! read more

See all

For me and how I like my pizza this is about as good as it gets. Perfect New York style pizza with toppings that are fresh. It's on Simpsonville's main street which is a nice little "side" of Greenville. This is a pretty typical Italian/New York Italian/New York Pizza menu and restaurant. Anyway, we got fries as an appetizer. They were perfect crispy fries. Exactly what you want with pizza (pizza and fries are a thing for me). Oh man the pizza was good. We had a pepperoni and mushroom pizza. It was the perfect New York style. I'm talking crispy on the bottom with a lite crispy crust with a good chew. Mushrooms were fresh (I hate canned mushrooms) and the pepperoni/cheese was top notch. I don't want to bore with going on and on about how good this is, but it really is. I highly recommend it and it's probably in my top three for pizza I've ever had. There's nothing I would change about it. read more

See all

Good food, and service. We enjoy coming back to this restaurant. They have gluten free pizza as well. It does get crowded.

Food looks awesome in their pics! It comes out and does not taste good. No sense of flavor which is a shame. Pizza was very watery for some reason. Pasta dish was def not worthy. I will still come back for 1 or 2 things if around the area but left not impressed. Service was average. Top deck needs to have an option for those who don't want 90 degree sun baking you and the food at the same time. Would love to see actual garlic bread not just knots as well. Def have high hopes to see this nice place hit a home run for us who can't find a quality Italian place. read more

Excellent pizza by the slice! Tastes like New York pizza! Great and friendly service!

The Slice has the best food! The Vodka made me do it is to die for! I get it every time I go!

Fresh & piping hot food, always! Their pizza is the real deal, and is definitely #NewYorkLegit

This restaurant has continued to impress me in their short time in Simpsonville . Between the fantastic menu options, attention to detail of their staff, and great selection in both food and drink. We will continue to support this place. read more

Today a friend and I went to the slice for lunch. The place was nearly empty as it was only 11:30 in the morning. The waitress told us they only had one 2 top table and we had to sit at it. It was right by the hallway leading to the restrooms and the open door that the manager sat in was 2 feet away from us, and he was in there. I asked if we could sit at one of the other empty tables and she said oh no those are just for four Tops and more. So I said if we have to sit here, can the manager at least close the door because it felt like he was sitting at the table with us. She went to ask him and he refused. At that point, I decided that they were not interested in our business and we left and went to Shortsfields in Simpsonville and had the most amazing service ever . Needless to say, I will never go to the slice again. read more

The pizza started out as a 4star but after I found a hair in the chicken bacon ranch, it quickly went to a 2 star- only for the garlic knots. And yes the hair was baked in there not left by anyone in my party. read more

The Slice - Hair in food. - Pizza Near Me - Simpsonville, South Carolina

We stopped here before a family walk to Cedar Falls Park. What a little gem in the heart of Simpsonville. Pair with a beer and some ice cream for the kids and you have a sweet little family day in town. The pizzas are huge. The prices blow the other NY pizzerias out of the water. The toppings tasted fresh and delicious. The owners wear many hats as most small business owners do. They may come off rude, but they is hardly the case. They are taking orders, hopping over to the pizza line, serving and doing with hustle and love. After the rush dies down, and they're able to breathe they make their rounds to the customers to see how they are enjoying it all. Then a customer walks in, a regular customer, and the owner shouts out a bit of banter with him and they share a laugh. It's all refreshing to watch. They love their customers and they love sharing their food with their customers. We cannot wait to come back and share a slice and maybe a laugh. read more

I have lived in the biggest pizza cities in the US. Chicago, Detroit, NYC and Philly. All have their own versions and all good in their own way. The Slice is the closest to NY pizza I have found in the Carolinas. Great crust, super fresh and high quality ingredients make this a great pie! The arancini is also top notch. We will definitely be back to try other options. read more

One bite...every one knows the rules...excellent NY Style pizza!!! Crust that is thin yet crispy, flavorful...sooo goood!!! And the customer service is exceptional as well!! Do yourself a favor and stop! You can get a whole pie or just a slice...or if you're feeling noodles, they have those too! read more

Absolutely delicious! We got a large pepperoni with ricotta and a Caesar salad, so simple but some so well! I just moved to the area and was brought here first by friends so when I got here I had to bring my mom! We will definitely be bacon read more

Was an enjoyable experience the pizza was very tasty and the price was good. Would recommend lunch or dinner at the Slice!

Tried it once, haven't went back to expensive, and lacked flavor. I did mention the lack of flavor of the pizza to the waitress and was not surprised of the staffs response (deer in the headlights). They were not ready for the facts or the truth. read more

This is the best pizza in Greenville. Just reopened after renovating. Only a couple tables at the moment as they finish the other half of the building. read more

The Slice - Pepperoni Pizza slices - Pizza Near Me - Simpsonville, South Carolina

We tried takeout tonight. Almost 40 dollars for a three topping pizza. Got home and it is so burnt it is inedible. read more

The Slice - pizza - Pizza Near Me - Simpsonville, South Carolina

See all

Very simply. Outrageously delicious pizza. Dont Miss the Italian salad for 4. So good!!! read more

See all

Great wings. Very attentive bartender. Lots of energy at this place. Can't wait for the rooftop seating to open!

Below par pizza. Was raw in the middle. Did take out so didn't find out until we were home. Disappointing $30 pizza.

The Slice is consistently delicious. Every time we eat here we have amazing food and love to try new things. Can't wait for the rooftop seating to open too! Try The Slice - I guarantee you will not be disappointed! read more

See all

Native New Yorker here. Cannot recommend The Slice more. Their cheese pizza is as authentic as you can get. The chicken Parmesan sandwich is a sight to behold. Two chicken filets were overflowing out of the sesame seed bread. Want more? You are in for an amazing surprise ordering the Vodka-made-me-do-it plate. read more

Great pizza!! Very active, tough to get a table but is definitely worth the wait. Mozzella sticks are the best in the Greenville area!! read more

From Long Island NY this place is Fire I eat here at least once a week. Food is always excellent and the staff is always friendly.

The pasta is really good. It's nice on the rooftop when the weather is good. Gets crowded quickly but usually the wait isn't too long.

Pizza totally burnt!! Must have been cooked my a four year old!! Was Take Out i totally feel Taken. Im bringing the rest back tomorrow read more

The Slice - A pizza cooked by a four year old!! Thursday night March 14th - Pizza Near Me - Simpsonville, South Carolina

deeply mediocre. - tried two different types of submarine sandwich and a barely better than Little Caesars level pizza between three people - we didn't even finish half our meals - it's heartburn city and tons of flies if you sit outside - clearly the only reason people are eating here is because it's on the main drag in a tiny town but if you don't live within a three minute drive don't bother read more

We LOVE slice! The pizza is always fresh & delicious. The location is fantastic. Their garlic knots are massive- you could have 2 of them and be done with your meal it's so cute inside from the booths to the silverware. read more

Pizza is always on point, but the wings are absolutely delicious! We get the meat ball and ricotta pie and the pepperoni. We can't wait to try a few more and enjoy once the upstairs area opens up. Great place to bring the family on a weeknight. If you're going on the weekend , you'll have to find parking and walk there because there's going to be a wait. read more

The chicken wings were delicious. We sat at the bar and had chicken wings and four different flavors. The bartender was so nice to us and the restaurant had great vibes. The customer service was superb! There was a special on the chicken wings because of the football season so we enjoyed ourselves the lemonade was free refills too, you gotta check out the slice read more

Great pizza. Last week we stayed at bar while waiting for pizza. Great attentive staff and atmosphere. Still took pizza home to eat. Next time we will stay and eat there. read more

Delicious NewYork style pizza! I love the thin crust. They serve individual slices too which is a plus!

We love The Slice and could probably be considered "regulars" here! My husband and son love the pizza... well cooked and a great crust and toppings! I love the garlic Parmesan wings - extra crispy (well done). And you won't have to worry about vampires after eating lol! My husband also loves the Mango Habanero wings... a good amount of kick to them but very flavorful! Great experience all around! read more

Really good food, fair prices, nicely decorated and good atmosphere. Our server was friendly and accommodating, the food came out in a reasonable time and we really enjoyed our time at the restaurant. We will definitely be back and highly recommend this business. read more

First time guest. Got a large extra cheese and pepperoni pizza. It was perfect. Looking forward to going again. Service was also spot on. Star came and checked on us multiple times. It's a fun place in downtown Simpsonville. read more